6 Illinois Italian Delis Where Giardiniera And Hand-Sliced Mortadella Taste Like The Old Neighborhood

A giardiniera recipe that hasn’t changed since the 1950s is still being made in Illinois. The peppers are still cut and packed by hand.

I love that kind of stubborn devotion.

That jar of spicy pickled vegetables is a small clue to something bigger. Across the state, a handful of family delis still slice mortadella to order and stack subs the way grandparents remember them.

Some of these counters have been at it for decades. One traces its roots back more than 80 years.

These aren’t fancy places with big signs and long menus. They’re grocery shelves, deli cases, and paper-wrapped sandwiches built on old habits.

The kind of spot where a sub tastes like a Saturday errand from childhood.

I rounded up six that keep the old neighborhood alive, from the city to the suburbs and beyond. Which one sits closest to your kitchen table?

1. J.P. Graziano Grocery

J.P. Graziano Grocery
© J.P. Graziano Grocery

Hand-cut peppers, a recipe from the 1950s, and a family name on the door since 1937. That’s the kind of resume you don’t argue with.

J.P. Graziano Grocery has called Chicago’s Randolph Street home for generations.

It’s a fourth-generation family business, and that history shows up in the way the place still runs.

The sub shop opened in 2006 to show off the products the family had sold for decades. Meats get sliced fresh to order for each sandwich, so your mortadella isn’t sitting around waiting for you.

Speaking of mortadella, the Italian sub stacks imported mortadella with hot capicola, Genoa salami, hard salami, and provolone. The bread brings a crunchy outside and a soft middle, which is exactly what a loaded sub needs.

Then there’s the house giardiniera. The peppers are still hand-cut and hand-packed, following that same family recipe from the 1950s.

Spice fans tend to lean toward the Mr. G with hot peppers. The dressings on these sandwiches earn plenty of praise too, and the cannoli makes a strong case for a sweet finish.

Plan ahead before you go, because the hours are quirky. The shop is closed Mondays, Thursdays, and Sundays, with lunch service on Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday.

Friday and Saturday also bring evening hours. Weekday afternoons get busy, so an early arrival can save you some waiting.

Honestly, it’s a sandwich lesson in Illinois food history, and you get to eat the homework.

Address: 901 W Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60607

2. Bari Foods

Bari Foods
© Bari Foods

Three feet of Italian sub. Yes, you read that right, and yes, it’s on the menu.

Bari Foods sits on Grand Avenue in Chicago, a stretch long tied to the city’s Italian community. It’s a compact grocery with a deli counter in the back, and that’s where the real action happens.

The subs come loaded with freshly sliced mortadella, capicola, and salami. Top-grade cheese and the homemade giardiniera finish the job with a little crunch and heat.

Not in a cold cut mood? The Italian beef sub has its own loyal following, and the beef and sausage combo doubles down nicely.

Meatball subs and Italian sausage subs round out the hot side of the counter. There’s even a focaccia sandwich if someone in your crew skips meat.

Those three-foot versions of the Italian sub and sausage sub make this a smart stop before a family party. Picture walking into a graduation with one of those under your arm.

Grab a side of macaroni salad and a bag of Deep River chips while you’re there. Prices stay reasonable, which matters when you’re feeding a few hungry people.

Keep in mind this is a takeout kind of place, and there’s no restroom. It opens at 8 AM most days, with shorter hours on Sunday.

The shelves feel like an old corner grocer, the sandwiches feel like a reward, and the whole trip feels pleasantly Chicago.

Address: 1120 W Grand Ave #1, Chicago, IL 60642

3. Alpine Food Shop

Alpine Food Shop
© Alpine Food Shop

Some sandwiches change with the times. The Alpine sub, by most accounts, has politely refused.

People who grew up near Alpine Food Shop in the 1970s and 1980s say the signature sub tastes the same today. That’s a pretty big compliment for any deli.

The shop sits on North Avenue in Elmwood Park, a western suburb with deep Italian-American roots. It’s a small, quaint spot built around cold-cut submarine sandwiches and other Italian deli favorites.

The house sub is the headliner. Expect layers of deli-sliced mortadella and cold cuts, with hot giardiniera bringing the zip.

Fans call the Alpine a must-have Chicago-area experience. Considering how many subs this region produces, that’s high praise from a tough crowd.

Don’t skip the potato salad. It’s the side that keeps coming up next to the sub, and it makes a fine partner for a lunch on the go.

Hours are worth a quick check before you drive over. The shop is closed Mondays, opens 10 AM to 4 PM Tuesday through Saturday, and closes at 2 PM on Sunday.

Friday and Saturday afternoons get busiest. A Tuesday morning visit is usually the calm window.

Free street parking makes it an easy stop. Bring the grandparents, and let them tell you what this block looked like back in the day.

Address: 7538 W North Ave, Elmwood Park, IL 60707

4. Ambrosino’s Italian Market & Deli

Ambrosino's Italian Market & Deli
© Ambrosino’s Italian Market & Deli

Little Italy took a road trip to the southwest suburbs and decided to stay. At least, that’s how Ambrosino’s feels.

This family-owned market in Frankfort has roots stretching back about 70 years. The store looks like a classic Italian deli you’d expect to find in the city’s old Taylor Street area.

Shelves hold imported cheeses, pastas, spices, and real pasta sauce. If you’ve been hunting for a hard-to-find Italian ingredient, this is a good place to start looking.

Behind the counter, the made-to-order subs are the big draw. They come piled with hand-sliced imported mortadella and Italian meats, plus giardiniera peppers.

Hot food gets plenty of love too. The sweet Italian sausage and homemade lasagna are local favorites, and cold pasta salads make easy sides.

Save room for the homemade cannoli. It’s the kind of dessert that ends up in a white box headed to Grandma’s house.

Here’s a practical note for planning. Ambrosino’s doesn’t offer dine-in, so think picnic, car lunch, or kitchen table at home.

A free parking lot makes the stop simple, which is a welcome change from city sandwich runs. Most visits run quick, perfect for errand days.

For Illinois families south of the city, it’s a nice reminder you don’t need to fight downtown traffic for a proper sub.

Address: 20495 LaGrange Rd, Frankfort, IL 60423

5. Rubino’s Italian Imports Inc.

Rubino's Italian Imports Inc.
© Rubino’s Italian Imports Inc.

Neatly wrapped carryouts and carefully arranged shelves might not sound thrilling. Then you see the deli case at Rubino’s.

This Tinley Park market runs as a traditional family Italian grocery with a full-service deli counter. Sliced mortadella, specialty salumi, and spicy giardiniera all share the spotlight.

The housemade lineup goes well beyond sandwiches. You’ll find meats, cheeses, pastas, salads, and desserts, along with lasagna that draws its own fans.

Italian sausage is a standout here, and the hot version gets special attention. Olives and Italian salads also earn a spot in many shopping bags.

For plenty of shoppers, those flavors bring back memories of family kitchens. Grandparents rolling pasta, dads making Sunday sauce, that sort of thing.

Rubino’s also offers a bakery and prepared foods. The produce is a highlight too, so dinner ingredients can come home right alongside lunch.

Timing helps. The market is closed Mondays, open 9 AM to 6 PM Tuesday through Saturday, and wraps up at 3 PM on Sunday.

Weekend mornings and afternoons tend to be busiest. On-site parking keeps things easy, though there’s no restroom, so plan accordingly with little ones.

It’s a great Illinois pick for a family dinner fix. Grab a sub for now and a tray of lasagna for later, and everyone wins.

Address: 16635 Oak Park Ave, Tinley Park, IL 60477

6. DiTullio’s Italian Market & Cafe

DiTullio's Italian Market & Cafe
© DiTullio’s Italian Market & Cafe

Fresh Italian lunch meat in Rockford? Plenty of folks call it an unexpected find, and that’s half the fun.

DiTullio’s Italian Market and Cafe sits on East State Street in northern Illinois. It blends a deli counter, grocery cases, and a relaxed cafe into one easygoing stop.

The kitchen slices imported Italian lunch meats and cured salumi, including mortadella. Those meats land on specialty subs with classic peppers and giardiniera.

DiTullio’s Italian Sub is the signature order, built with high-quality meats. The panini are known for their good looks, and the house dressing has a devoted following.

Plant-based eaters aren’t left out. A vegan veggie panini sits on the menu, which makes mixed-diet lunches easier.

Unlike several delis on this list, you can actually sit down here. There’s seating inside plus outdoor seating when the weather cooperates.

Coffee is another bonus, and it’s well regarded. Shelves also stock olive oil, cheese, and spices for your own kitchen experiments.

The cafe keeps lunch-friendly hours. It’s open 11 AM to 3 PM on weekdays, opens at 10 AM Saturday, and closes Sundays.

Parking is usually plentiful, with a free lot and free street spots. That’s a pleasant surprise if you’re used to circling city blocks.

A quiet lunch, a cured meat haul, and a strong coffee. Not a bad reason to point the car toward Rockford.

Address: 2207 E State St, Rockford, IL 61104