10 Pennsylvania All-You-Can-Eat Pizza Buffets That Locals Secretly Love
Pennsylvania’s hidden food gems include some seriously mouthwatering pizza buffets that locals guard like treasure maps.
Growing up in the Keystone State, I spent countless family nights piling my plate high with slices of cheesy goodness.
These all-you-can-eat pizza paradises offer everything from traditional pepperoni to wild specialty pies that’ll make your taste buds dance – all without emptying your wallet.
1. Cicis Pizza’s Mountain Of Mozzarella
Last Tuesday, I stumbled into Cicis after a brutal workday and nearly wept at the sight of their endless pizza paradise. The aroma hit me like a delicious tidal wave!
Their buffet features over 15 different pizza varieties simultaneously, from classic pepperoni to their famous mac and cheese pizza that makes my inner child squeal with delight. The cinnamon rolls alone are worth the trip – gooey, warm, and perfectly sweet.
Families pack this place on weekends, but weekday lunch hours remain the hidden sweet spot for maximum pizza enjoyment with minimal wait times. Pro tip: Their garlic breadsticks dipped in marinara create a flavor combination that haunts my dreams in the best possible way.
2. Infinito’s Pizza Buffet’s Legendary Lunch Rush
My college years wouldn’t have been the same without Infinito’s Pizza Buffet saving my hungry student budget countless times. Their hand-tossed crusts achieve that magical balance between crispy exterior and chewy interior that pizza connoisseurs dream about.
What makes Infinito’s special isn’t just quantity – it’s quality. Every 15 minutes, fresh pizzas emerge from their stone ovens, ensuring you’ll never settle for lukewarm slices. Their buffalo chicken pizza has a cult following among locals who swear by its perfect spice-to-ranch ratio.
Located near Penn State, this place fills with students during term time, but savvy locals know to visit during semester breaks. Fun fact: Their house-made ranch dressing recipe hasn’t changed in 22 years because it’s absolutely perfect.
3. Royal Buffet And Grill’s Pizza Paradise
Royal Buffet completely shattered my expectations the first time my family dragged me there. “Chinese buffet with pizza?” I scoffed. Boy, was I wrong!
This culinary chameleon somehow masters both Asian cuisine AND Italian-American pizza classics. Their thin-crust pepperoni achieves that perfect grease-to-crunch ratio that makes you reach for just one more slice… five times in a row. The dessert pizza sprinkled with cinnamon sugar provides the perfect sweet finale.
Weekday dinner hours see local families flocking here for the value – kids under 10 eat at half price. While most folks load up on General Tso’s chicken, the real treasures lie in the pizza section where they experiment with unexpected toppings like teriyaki chicken that somehow totally works.
4. Brick & Brew’s Bottomless Pizza Sundays
My brother-in-law introduced me to Brick & Brew’s Sunday pizza extravaganza, and now it’s our monthly tradition. This gastropub transforms into pizza heaven every Sunday from 11-3, offering unlimited wood-fired pies alongside craft beer flights.
Unlike typical buffets, servers bring fresh, piping-hot pizzas directly to your table – no heat lamps or buffet lines here! Their prosciutto and fig pizza with honey drizzle creates a sweet-savory masterpiece that’s worth every calorie. The rustic brick interior with exposed beams creates the perfect atmosphere for serious pizza indulgence.
Reservations are practically essential, as locals have caught on to this weekend treasure. The $18.99 price tag might seem steep until you realize it includes unlimited specialty pizzas that would cost $16-20 each if ordered individually.
5. Pizza Time Saloon’s Wild West Pizza Rodeo
Saddle up for the most unique pizza experience in Pennsylvania! My first visit to Pizza Time Saloon left me speechless – where else can you eat unlimited pizza while sitting in a wagon-wheel booth under cowboy memorabilia?
Their buffet features Western-themed creations like the “Buckaroo BBQ” and “Cowpoke Supreme” alongside traditional favorites. Country music twangs through the speakers while servers in cowboy hats keep the pizza flowing. Kids go crazy for the mechanical bull (yes, really) that runs on weekends.
Located in rural Lancaster County, this hidden gem draws farmers and tourists alike. The homemade ranch dressing contains a secret blend of herbs that locals speculate about endlessly. Don’t miss their cactus-shaped breadsticks – oddly shaped but impossibly addictive.
6. Shady Maple Smorgasbord’s Pizza Corner Phenomenon
Everyone knows Shady Maple for its massive Pennsylvania Dutch buffet, but locals head straight to the often-overlooked pizza corner that’s become legendary in its own right. My grandmother still talks about their Dutch-inspired pizza with sweet Lebanon bologna and maple syrup drizzle!
While tourists load up on fried chicken and shoofly pie, regulars make strategic trips to the pizza station where fresh pies emerge every few minutes. Their breakfast pizza during morning hours features scrambled eggs, bacon, and maple syrup that somehow works perfectly together. The pizza dough reportedly uses the same starter as their famous breads.
Tuesday nights feature the most pizza varieties – sometimes up to 12 different options simultaneously. For the ultimate experience, alternate between pizza slices and their famous ice cream bar for a sweet-savory dance your taste buds won’t forget.
7. Miller’s Smorgasbord’s Secret Pizza Hideaway
Tucked in a corner of this famous Lancaster County buffet lies a pizza station that changed my definition of Pennsylvania comfort food. Last summer, I watched in amazement as an Amish pizza master hand-tossed dough with mesmerizing precision!
Miller’s blends traditional Amish cooking techniques with Italian pizza traditions, creating uniquely Pennsylvania hybrids. Their chicken pot pie pizza combines two comfort foods into one mind-blowing creation that locals line up for. The sourdough crust has a distinctive tang that comes from a 75-year-old starter passed down through generations.
The buffet rotates specialty pizzas daily, with Wednesday’s scrapple and apple pizza drawing both curious tourists and devoted locals. Arrive before 5pm to beat the dinner rush and score the freshest slices. Their pizza corner feels like a delicious secret club that tourists rarely discover.
8. Pizza Hut Buffet’s Nostalgic Noontime Feast
Sometimes nothing beats the classics. My weekly lunch date with my retired dad always takes us to the Pizza Hut buffet in Allentown where the red cups and checkered tablecloths transport us straight back to 1992.
While chain restaurants often get overlooked, locals know this particular location offers the best lunch deal in the Lehigh Valley. Their pan pizza crust achieves that perfect buttery crispness that’s nearly impossible to recreate at home. The salad bar features surprisingly fresh ingredients, making you feel slightly virtuous before demolishing your sixth slice.
Weekday lunch hours see a mix of construction workers, office employees, and savvy retirees getting maximum value. Pro tip: Their stuffed crust pizza only appears on the buffet between 12:15-12:45, so time your visit accordingly if you’re a cheese-filled-edge enthusiast like me.
9. Stevi B’s Pizza Buffet’s Family-Friendly Feast
My nephew’s birthday party at Stevi B’s converted our entire family into loyal fans of this under-the-radar chain. The moment you walk in, the carnival-like atmosphere and pizza aroma create an instant mood boost!
Their buffet caters brilliantly to picky eaters with specialized sections for adventurous and traditional palates alike. The macaroni and cheese pizza sounds bizarre but tastes like childhood dreams come true. Their dessert pizzas – particularly the apple pie version with streusel topping – deserve their own fan club.
Tuesday nights offer the best value with their “Family Night” discount that locals religiously attend. The game room adjacent to the dining area keeps kids entertained between pizza rounds. Their pizza dough is made fresh daily on-site, and you can absolutely taste the difference from frozen alternatives.
10. Cicis Game-Room Location On Lancaster Covered Bridge Drive
My teenagers actually volunteer to join family dinner when we mention this particular Cicis location. The Lancaster Covered Bridge Drive spot combines unlimited pizza with an arcade that rivals dedicated gaming centers!
Beyond the standard Cicis offerings, this location experiments with Pennsylvania-inspired specials like the Philly Cheesesteak pizza that perfectly captures the beloved sandwich in pizza form. The pasta bar provides carb-loading alternatives when you need a brief pizza break. Their stuffed breadsticks with spinach and cheese make a perfect pizza companion.
Weekends get packed with birthday parties, so Wednesday evenings provide the sweet spot for maximum enjoyment. The game cards loaded with every $25 food purchase make this an incredible value for families. Local high school sports teams celebrate here after games, creating a community atmosphere that keeps people coming back.