12 Coastal New York Oceanfront Steakhouses Where The Skyline Meets The Shore
You’ve had steak in Manhattan, undoubtedly. You’ve probably enjoyed a meal with an impressive view. But have you ever savored a prime cut of beef, perfectly grilled, while the ocean breeze tousles your hair and the New York skyline paints a dramatic masterpiece on the horizon?
This isn’t a pipe dream; it’s a reality along Coastal New York. We’ve scoured the shoreline to bring you 12 exceptional oceanfront steakhouses that beautifully marry metropolitan sophistication with serene seaside charm.
Prepare to redefine your ultimate dining destination, where luxury meets the lull of the waves, and every meal is an unforgettable vista.
1. Louie’s Prime Steak & Seafood: Port Washington’s Century-Old Gem
Perched on the edge of Manhasset Bay, Louie’s Prime has been serving up exceptional dining experiences since 1905. Recently refreshed but maintaining its historic charm, this North Shore institution offers USDA Prime dry-aged steaks that rival Manhattan’s finest steakhouses.
The true magic happens on their waterfront deck, where diners can savor perfectly charred ribeyes while gazing at both the tranquil bay waters and the distant Manhattan skyline. The contrast of old-world service with contemporary culinary techniques creates a timeless appeal.
Regulars recommend timing your reservation to catch the sunset, when the fading light transforms the water into a canvas of gold and crimson hues that complement the rich flavors on your plate.
2. Mill Pond Steak & Seafood: Centerport’s Picturesque Waterside Haven
Stunning sunset views over Mill Pond make this Centerport treasure a local favorite for special occasions. The restaurant’s name tells you exactly what to expect: premium cuts of beef and fresh seafood served in an elegant waterside dining room.
Floor-to-ceiling windows ensure every table enjoys the serene pond views that stretch toward Long Island Sound. The menu balances classic steakhouse fare with creative seasonal offerings, making each visit feel both familiar and fresh.
Regulars rave about the bone-in filet, perfectly seared and served with a view that transforms throughout your meal as daylight fades into a romantic evening ambiance. The cozy fireplace adds warmth to winter dining, while summer brings the option of outdoor seating.
3. Castaways: Port Jefferson’s Harbor-Front Treasure
Sailors and steak lovers alike flock to Castaways, where the bustling Port Jefferson Harbor provides a dynamic backdrop for hearty meals. This unpretentious gem sits right on the village waterfront, offering prime views of bobbing boats and harbor activities.
I discovered this place during a sailing trip last summer when we docked nearby, following our noses to the aroma of grilling steaks. The juicy steak frites became our post-sailing tradition, perfectly complementing tales of our day on the water.
While seafood features prominently on the menu, beef enthusiasts won’t be disappointed by the quality cuts and generous portions. The casual maritime atmosphere makes even a weeknight dinner feel like a mini-vacation, especially when enjoyed with their signature drinks as the harbor lights begin to twinkle.
4. Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar’s Huntington Harbor Elegance
Sophistication meets waterfront charm at Prime, a standout in Huntington’s dining scene. The restaurant’s Harbor Club seating area offers unobstructed views of the water, creating a backdrop that elevates the already impressive dining experience.
Classic steakhouse cuts receive meticulous attention here, with dry-aging and precise temperature control ensuring each steak achieves its full flavor potential. The sommelier-curated drink list features perfect pairings for every protein on your plate.
Beyond beef, Prime offers seafood towers that showcase the freshest catches from local waters. The contrast between the restaurant’s sophisticated interior and the natural beauty just outside creates a compelling dining atmosphere that balances luxury with Long Island’s coastal character.
5. The LakeHouse: Bay Shore’s South Bay Culinary Landmark
The gentle lapping of Great South Bay waters creates a soothing soundtrack at The LakeHouse, where deck seating puts diners practically on top of the water. This Bay Shore favorite has mastered the art of relaxed waterfront luxury, with a menu that respects both land and sea.
Arriving for my anniversary dinner last year, we were greeted with champagne and seated at a prime waterside table. The sunset painted the bay pink while we enjoyed perfectly prepared bone-in chops that rivaled any Manhattan steakhouse.
The steakhouse mains include thoughtful touches that elevate classic preparations without overwhelming the quality of the meat. Seasonal vegetables from nearby farms complement the proteins, creating a truly local dining experience that captures Long Island’s agricultural and maritime heritage.
6. Salted. On The Harbor: Northport’s Modern Waterfront Marvel
Contemporary design meets harbor-front charm at this Northport hotspot where floor-to-ceiling windows frame postcard-worthy views. The sleek, minimalist interior allows the natural beauty of Northport Harbor to take center stage while providing a sophisticated backdrop for exceptional meals.
The menu balances tradition and innovation, with sliced steak dishes that incorporate unexpected flavor combinations. Their signature steak is served with a coffee-infused reduction that brings out the beef’s natural sweetness while adding complex depth.
Even on stormy days, Salted offers drama and comfort as waves crash outside while you stay warm and dry in the modern dining room. The bartenders craft drinks that complement both the menu and the maritime setting, making even a simple drink feel like a special occasion.
7. Harbor Crab Co.: Patchogue’s Lively Riverside Retreat
Energy flows through Harbor Crab Co., where the Patchogue River provides both scenery and fresh seafood. This sprawling dockside establishment balances serious steak offerings with a fun, festive atmosphere that draws crowds year-round.
Live music often fills the air on weekends, creating a party-like environment that contrasts with the typically formal steakhouse experience. Despite the casual vibe, the kitchen takes its steaks seriously, offering quality cuts cooked precisely to order.
My brother’s bachelor party found its perfect venue here last spring when we wanted great food without stuffiness. We feasted on ribeyes while watching boats cruise by, then stayed for hours enjoying the band and waterfront breeze. The combination of quality food, waterside tables, and entertainment makes this a unique entry in New York’s steakhouse scene.
8. Scarpetta Beach At Gurney’s: Montauk’s Oceanfront Italian Steakhouse
Luxury reaches new heights at Scarpetta Beach, where fine Italian cuisine meets premium steaks against the dramatic backdrop of Montauk’s coastline. Part of the exclusive Gurney’s resort, this oceanfront establishment offers uninterrupted Atlantic views that stretch to the horizon.
While seafood dominates much of the menu, steak enthusiasts praise the short-rib offerings and specialty beef dishes that incorporate Italian influences. The floor-to-ceiling windows ensure diners never miss a moment of the ocean’s ever-changing beauty.
White tablecloths and attentive service create a refined atmosphere that matches the stunning setting. The restaurant’s location at the very edge of Long Island gives diners the sensation of dining on a luxury liner, with nothing but open water beyond their table.
9. Mavericks Montauk: Fort Pond’s Surf-And-Turf Paradise
Local character infuses every aspect of Mavericks, from the laid-back surfer vibe to the locally sourced beef that stars on their surf-and-turf menu. Nestled beside Fort Pond with distant views toward Montauk Harbor, this restaurant captures the essence of the East End.
The commitment to local producers shines through in steaks from nearby farms, prepared with a simplicity that lets quality speak for itself. Rustic wooden tables and nautical decor create a casual atmosphere that feels authentically Montauk.
Summer evenings bring spectacular sunsets over Fort Pond, visible from nearly every table. The seasonal menu adapts to available ingredients, ensuring peak freshness whether you’re ordering from land or sea. Unlike more formal steakhouses, Mavericks welcomes sandy feet and windblown hair from a day at the beach.
10. Ocean Club Montauk: Yacht Club Luxury With Panoramic Views
Nautical elegance defines the Ocean Club, where the prestigious Montauk Yacht Club setting creates an atmosphere of refined maritime luxury. Sweeping ocean vistas greet diners through expansive windows, while the menu balances seafood freshness with steakhouse tradition.
The restaurant’s design incorporates yacht-inspired elements that pay homage to its location without feeling kitschy. White-jacketed servers deliver steakhouse classics with the precision of a well-crewed vessel.
I celebrated finishing my novel here last fall, treating myself to their perfectly aged New York strip while watching sailboats glide across the harbor. The experience combined the satisfaction of achievement with culinary excellence. Their steakhouse-style entrées receive the same attention as the seafood offerings, ensuring beef lovers aren’t overlooked at this oceanfront establishment.
11. The Restaurant At Barons Cove: Sag Harbor’s Historic Waterfront Gem
Literary history meets culinary excellence at Barons Cove, where famous authors once gathered in this storied Sag Harbor location. The harborfront restaurant now serves classic American fare with an emphasis on quality steaks and fresh seafood, all enjoyed with unobstructed harbor views.
The dining room’s nautical-chic design creates a sophisticated yet comfortable atmosphere that honors Sag Harbor’s maritime heritage. Large windows frame the harbor scene, where yachts and sailboats create a constantly changing tableau.
The surf and turf options showcase the kitchen’s versatility, with perfectly prepared filet mignon and lobster representing the best of land and sea. Weekend brunches are particularly popular, when morning light dances across the harbor waters and makes the mimosas sparkle alongside steak and eggs.
12. The Wharf Bar & Grill: Rockaway’s Casual Beachside Steak Sanctuary
Sandy footprints and salty air set the scene at The Wharf, where Jamaica Bay provides a stunning backdrop for casual waterfront dining. Unlike the formal steakhouses of Manhattan, this Rockaway favorite embraces a laid-back beach vibe while still taking its steak sandwiches and grilled cuts seriously.
Wooden deck seating puts diners right over the water, creating an immersive experience where the bay becomes part of your meal. The menu features approachable steak options that satisfy cravings without pretension or formality.
Sunset transforms this casual eatery into a magical spot where golden light bathes everything in warmth. The retro beach atmosphere feels like a throwback to simpler times, making this an authentic slice of New York coastal culture where quality food meets spectacular waterfront views without any unnecessary fuss.