10 Wisconsin Supper Clubs Still Serving The Same Beloved Classics
Wisconsin supper clubs are a delicious slice of tradition, where recipes have stood the test of time and plates are filled with comforting classics.
From perfectly cooked steaks to creamy pastas and homemade pies, these spots serve meals that feel like a warm welcome.
Locals keep coming back for the familiar flavors, the friendly atmosphere, and the sense of nostalgia each visit brings. Every supper club is a celebration of timeless taste and community.
1. Five O’Clock Steakhouse — Milwaukee, WI
Step inside this 1946 gem and you’ll feel like you’ve crashed a Rat Pack reunion. The leather booths, dim lighting, and tuxedoed servers create an atmosphere so classic it hurts.
Their bone-in ribeye has been making carnivores weep with joy for over 75 years, cooked to absolute perfection every single time.
The old-fashioned cocktails pack enough punch to make you forget what year it is, which honestly adds to the whole time-travel vibe of this place.
2. The Packing House — Milwaukee, WI
Built inside an actual 1888 meatpacking facility, this place takes “farm to table” to a whole new level of literal. Exposed brick walls and industrial beams remind you this building has serious history baked into every corner.
Their prime rib practically melts off the bone, served with all the traditional fixings that make supper club dinners legendary.
Weekend reservations book up faster than Packers tickets, so plan ahead or prepare to wait with a brandy old-fashioned at the bar.
3. Toby’s Supper Club — Madison, WI
Nothing says Wisconsin like a supper club overlooking a peaceful lake, and Toby’s delivers that postcard-perfect experience since 1962.
Sunset dinners here hit differently when you’re watching the sky turn pink over the water while cutting into a perfectly seasoned steak.
Their famous relish tray comes loaded with pickles, cheese, and all the crunchy vegetables your heart desires.
The Friday fish fry draws crowds so massive you’d think they were giving away free beer and cheese curds.
4. Kavanaugh’s Esquire Club — Madison, WI
Since 1961, this family-owned treasure has been serving up nostalgia with a side of perfectly grilled beef. Walking through the doors feels like visiting your coolest aunt’s house if she happened to run an upscale restaurant.
The prime rib here is legendary enough to have its own fan club, seasoned with a secret blend that’s probably guarded better than state secrets.
Their salad bar stretches longer than a Wisconsin winter, offering everything from classic iceberg to fancy fixings you didn’t know belonged on lettuce.
5. Black Otter Supper Club — Hortonville, WI
Tucked away in small-town Wisconsin since 1965, Black Otter proves you don’t need a big city address to serve world-class comfort food.
Their steaks arrive sizzling hot, cooked exactly how you ordered them, which apparently is harder than rocket science at some places.
The homemade soups rotate daily and taste like your grandmother’s secret recipes, assuming your grandmother was an absolute culinary genius.
Their casual, friendly vibe makes first-timers feel like regulars who just forgot they’d been there before.
6. Lehman’s Supper Club — Rice Lake, WI
Operating since 1930, Lehman’s has been feeding hungry Wisconsinites longer than most of us have been alive. Their broasted chicken is so crispy and juicy it should probably be illegal in at least twelve states.
Generations of families have celebrated birthdays, anniversaries, and random Tuesdays within these walls, creating memories between bites of perfectly cooked comfort food.
The portions here are Wisconsin-sized, meaning you’ll definitely need a to-go box and possibly a forklift to get back to your car afterward.
7. Pinewood Supper Club — Mosinee, WI
Pinewood has been a central Wisconsin staple since the 1940s, serving up classic supper club fare that never goes out of style.
Their Friday fish fry brings in crowds from three counties over, all chasing that perfectly beer-battered cod.
The salad bar here is a thing of beauty, offering enough variety to satisfy even the pickiest eaters in your group.
Their signature brandy old-fashioneds are mixed strong enough to make you believe you can actually dance, which the small dance floor encourages on weekends.
8. White Stag Inn — Rhinelander, WI
Way up in the Northwoods since 1967, White Stag Inn serves hearty meals perfect for refueling after a day of fishing or snowmobiling.
Their steaks are thick enough to use as doorstops, cooked over an open flame that adds incredible smoky flavor.
The rustic cabin atmosphere complete with mounted deer heads makes you feel like you’re dining in the world’s fanciest hunting lodge.
Their homemade desserts are so good you’ll save room even after demolishing a massive steak dinner, which takes serious commitment.
9. Golden Mast Inn — Okauchee Lake, WI
Perched right on Okauchee Lake since 1967, Golden Mast offers stunning water views that make every meal feel like a special occasion.
Their German-inspired menu features schnitzel so authentic you’ll swear you just flew to Bavaria without leaving Wisconsin.
Summer sunset dinners on the patio are basically mandatory if you live within a hundred miles of this place.
The extensive wine list and craft cocktail menu prove this supper club keeps one foot in tradition while the other stays firmly planted in modern excellence.
10. Donny’s Glidden Lodge Restaurant — Sturgeon Bay, WI
Nestled in Door County since 1929, Donny’s has been serving up supper club classics longer than your grandparents have been telling the same stories.
Their whitefish is caught fresh from Lake Michigan, breaded and fried to golden perfection that tourists dream about all year.
The cozy lodge atmosphere complete with stone fireplace makes winter visits especially magical, like dining inside a snow globe.
Their cherry pie, made with locally grown Door County cherries, is the perfect sweet ending to any meal here.