The Pierogi Burgers At This Ohio Restaurant Have Locals Raving Nonstop
In Fairview Park, Gunselman’s Tavern has created a dish that keeps diners talking long after the last bite.
Their pierogi burgers combine comfort and creativity in a way that feels both indulgent and unforgettable.
Crispy, cheesy, and packed with flavor, each bite is a playful twist on classic favorites.
Locals line up for the experience, proving that inventive cooking can turn a simple meal into a beloved destination everyone wants to return to.
A Cleveland Icon Since 1936
Henry Gunselman took over this joint decades ago, transforming it into a neighborhood treasure that’s survived wars, recessions, and countless food trends.
Walking through those doors feels like stepping into Cleveland history itself.
Generations of families have gathered here, celebrating everything from Little League victories to golden anniversaries.
The walls practically whisper stories of first dates, business deals, and Friday night traditions that span nearly 90 years of delicious memories.
Four Partners Brought It Back to Life
David Grace, Joe McDonough, Scott Eppler, and John Caine saw potential where others saw a fading relic. Their revival mission wasn’t just about profits but preserving a piece of Cleveland soul.
Under their leadership, the burger program exploded onto Cleveland’s food scene like fireworks on the Fourth of July.
Major awards started rolling in, proving that passion and quality ingredients can turn any tavern into a destination worth the drive across town.
Fresh-Ground Patties With a Secret Blend
Foster’s Meats supplies a custom blend mixing brisket, short rib, and chuck that creates burger magic in every bite.
Forget frozen hockey pucks from corporate chains; these patties get ground fresh and packed with flavor.
Brisket adds richness, short rib brings buttery tenderness, and chuck provides that classic beefy punch everyone craves.
When these three cuts unite, you get a juicy masterpiece that doesn’t need fancy toppings to shine, though the pierogi situation certainly doesn’t hurt.
Pierogies Are the Star Attraction
The Pierogi Lady’s creations have become Gunselman’s calling card, transforming ordinary burgers into Cleveland culinary legends.
During Cleveland Pierogi Week, this place practically becomes pierogi headquarters, with lines stretching out the door.
These aren’t just any dumplings slapped on a bun as an afterthought.
Each pierogi gets grilled to golden perfection, creating crispy edges that contrast beautifully with pillowy potato filling, making every bite an adventure in texture and taste.
The Pierogi Lady Cheeseburger Pierogi
Somebody asked, “What if we put a cheeseburger inside a pierogi?” and Gunselman’s answered with this mind-bending creation.
Potato dough wraps around seasoned ground beef, melted cheese, grilled onions, sharp cheddar, and their signature Gunny sauce.
It’s basically inception for comfort food lovers, where Polish tradition meets American burger obsession in the most delicious way possible.
One bite delivers multiple flavor dimensions that’ll have your taste buds doing backflips while questioning everything they thought they knew about fusion cuisine.
Easy to Find and No Reservation Hassles
Located at 21490 Lorain Road in Fairview Park, Gunselman’s keeps things refreshingly simple with both dine-in and carry-out options.
No pretentious reservation systems or snooty hostesses judging your sneakers here. Just show up hungry and ready to experience Cleveland burger greatness without the fuss.
The no-reservation policy means everyone gets equal access to pierogi burger heaven, whether you’re a regular or a first-timer who heard about this place from your cousin’s neighbor’s coworker.
A Quirky Seven-Sided Building With History
Built in 1920, this seven-sided brick oddity stands out like a geometric puzzle piece dropped into suburban Cleveland.
That original mahogany bartop has witnessed nearly a century of celebrations, commiserations, and cold beers sliding across its polished surface.
Architecture nerds and history buffs love this place as much as burger fanatics do.
The building’s unusual shape creates cozy corners perfect for devouring award-winning burgers while soaking in authentic old-school tavern vibes you simply can’t replicate in modern cookie-cutter restaurants.