12 New Hampshire Pizza Spots That Locals Say Blow The Chains Away
If you’re craving pizza in New Hampshire, the chain spots usually leave you wanting more. Locals know the places where the pizza actually hits the spot, with fresh ingredients, perfectly melted cheese, and crusts that aren’t soggy or too hard.
These are the restaurants people go to again and again, the ones that feel like they’re part of the neighborhood. Everyone seems to have a favorite, whether it’s a slice you can’t stop eating or a pie that’s just right every time.
1. Tilton House Of Pizza, Tilton
Walk into this spot and you’ll feel right at home. The menu goes way beyond pizza, but locals keep coming back for those perfectly baked pies with generous toppings.
Families have been ordering from here for years because the portions are big and the prices don’t break the bank. You can tell they care about what they serve.
The crust has just the right amount of chew, and they don’t skimp on the cheese. Whether you grab a slice or order a whole pie, you’re getting quality that beats any chain by a mile.
2. Alley Cat Pizzeria, Manchester
This place brings a fresh vibe to Manchester’s pizza options. The owners focus on creative combinations that surprise you without being weird for the sake of it.
Their dough gets made fresh every day, and you can taste the difference. People rave about the sauce, which has a nice balance of sweet and tangy.
The atmosphere feels casual but put together, perfect for a quick lunch or dinner with friends. They’ve built a solid reputation by sticking to quality ingredients and not cutting corners on anything they serve.
3. 900 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria, Manchester
Real Neapolitan pizza means cooking at extremely high temperatures, and this place does it right. The result is a thin, slightly charred crust with a soft, airy edge that’s completely different from typical American pizza.
They follow traditional Italian methods, so expect simple toppings that let the quality shine through. Fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and good olive oil make all the difference.
It’s not your standard thick slice, but once you try it, you’ll understand why people get so excited about authentic Neapolitan style.
4. Constantly Pizza, Concord
The name says it all. This spot keeps turning out consistent, reliable pizza that hits the spot every single time.
Locals appreciate that they can count on the same great taste whether they order on a Tuesday or a Saturday night. The staff knows their regulars by name, which tells you something about the kind of place this is.
Their specialty pizzas offer interesting flavor combinations, but the classic cheese and pepperoni remain top sellers. Everything tastes fresh, the service is friendly, and you never feel rushed when picking up your order.
5. La Festa Brick & Brew, Dover
Brick ovens create a special kind of heat that makes pizza crusts crispy on the outside and tender inside. This Dover spot has mastered that technique beautifully.
The menu leans Italian, so you’re getting recipes with real heritage behind them. People love the slightly smoky flavor that comes from the brick oven cooking method.
It’s become a go-to for special occasions and regular weeknight dinners alike. The portions are generous, and the ingredients taste like they came straight from a market, not a warehouse.
6. The Community Oven, Hampton
This Hampton favorite lives up to its name by bringing people together over really good food. The pizza here has that homemade quality that reminds you of Sunday dinners.
They use local ingredients whenever possible, which makes a noticeable difference in flavor. Regulars swear by their white pizzas and creative seasonal options.
The space feels welcoming, like you’re eating at a friend’s house rather than just another restaurant. You can tell the owners put thought into every detail, from the menu to the atmosphere.
7. Flatbread Company, Portsmouth
Wood-fired ovens and organic ingredients set this Portsmouth location apart from typical pizza places. The flatbreads come out with beautifully blistered crusts and toppings that taste incredibly fresh.
They support local farms and use nitrate-free meats, which health-conscious diners really appreciate. The menu changes with the seasons to take advantage of what’s available.
It’s a lively spot with an open kitchen where you can watch your pizza being made. Families and couples both find it comfortable, and the quality never wavers.
8. Espresso Pizza, Nashua
Despite the name, pizza is definitely the star here. This Nashua spot has been feeding families for years with reliable, tasty pies that everyone enjoys.
The crust strikes a nice balance between crispy and chewy, and they’re generous with toppings. You can order specialty combinations or build your own exactly how you like it.
Service is quick and friendly, making it perfect for those nights when you need dinner sorted fast. Locals know they can count on Espresso Pizza for consistent quality without the chain restaurant feel.
9. Athens Pizza & Family Restaurant, Keene
Greek-style pizza has its own character, with a thicker, slightly oily crust that gets wonderfully crispy on the bottom. Athens does this style justice while offering plenty of other options too.
The family restaurant atmosphere means everyone feels welcome, from kids to grandparents. They’ve been serving Keene for years, building trust through consistency.
Beyond pizza, their Greek specialties are worth trying, but regulars often stick with what they know best. The portions are filling and the prices stay reasonable, which keeps people coming back regularly.
10. Amicci’s Italian Pizza, Keene
Another Keene favorite, Amicci’s takes the Italian approach seriously. Their recipes lean traditional, with attention paid to getting the fundamentals right before adding any creative twists.
The sauce has that slow-cooked taste that only comes from taking your time with good tomatoes and herbs. Cheese gets layered properly so every bite has the right amount.
People who know pizza can tell when someone cares about their craft, and Amicci’s clearly does. It’s become a trusted spot for both quick meals and special orders for gatherings.
11. Pizza Barn, Center Ossipee
The name might sound quirky, but the pizza here is seriously good. Located in Center Ossipee, this place has become a destination for folks exploring the Lakes Region.
They’ve nailed the recipe for a satisfying pie that hits all the right notes. The casual, barn-inspired setting adds to the charm without feeling gimmicky.
Locals bring out-of-town guests here because they know it’ll impress. Whether you’re stopping by after a day on the lake or just passing through, Pizza Barn delivers quality that surprises first-timers.
12. Laconia House Of Pizza, Laconia
This Laconia staple has earned its reputation through years of serving the community well. The menu is extensive, but pizza remains the main attraction for good reason.
They use quality ingredients and prepare everything fresh, which you can taste in every slice. The staff treats customers like neighbors, creating that comfortable local spot feeling.
Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you know what you’re getting. Consistency matters, and Laconia House of Pizza has it down to a science without losing the personal touch that makes it special.