12 Minnesota Supper Clubs That Stay Booked Solid All Weekend
Minnesota knows how to do dinner right, and nowhere is that more obvious than at the state’s legendary supper clubs.
These aren’t just restaurants, they’re time capsules serving up perfectly aged steaks, relish trays that could feed a small army, and Old Fashioneds strong enough to make your grandpa proud.
Weekend reservations at these spots disappear faster than hotdish at a church potluck, and for good reason: they’ve mastered the art of making every meal feel like a celebration.
1. J.D. Hoyt’s Supper Club
Right in the heart of downtown Minneapolis, this gem brings old-school glamour to the modern city scene. The moment you walk through those doors at 301 North Washington Ave, you’re transported back to when dinner meant something special—not just fuel between meetings.
Steaks here are cut thick and cooked to absolute perfection, with a char that would make any grill master weep with joy. The relish tray arrives like a work of art, and the bartenders mix drinks with the precision of scientists and the soul of poets.
Weekends see every table filled with everyone from anniversary couples to business moguls celebrating big deals. The waitstaff knows regulars by name and treat first-timers like old friends, creating an atmosphere that’s both sophisticated and genuinely warm.
2. Jensen’s Supper Club
Located at 3840 Sibley Memorial Hwy in Eagan, Jensen’s has been feeding hungry Minnesotans since way back when bell-bottoms were cool the first time around. This family-owned treasure treats every guest like they’re coming home for Sunday dinner, just with better steaks and no one asking about your report card.
The prime rib practically melts on your tongue, and the walleye is so fresh you’d swear it was swimming that morning. Their signature drink pack enough punch to help you forget about Monday morning, at least until Sunday night.
Booking a table here on Friday or Saturday requires planning ahead like you’re launching a space mission. Locals know to call weeks in advance, because once word gets out about their specials, those phone lines light up faster than a Christmas tree.
3. Phil’s Tara Hideaway
Tucked away at 15021 60th St N in the Stillwater/Oak Park Heights area, Phil’s lives up to its name as the ultimate hideaway. This place feels like stumbling upon your rich uncle’s secret cabin, if that uncle happened to be an amazing chef with impeccable taste in décor.
The menu reads like a greatest hits album of supper club classics, with each dish prepared like it’s competing for a Grammy. Their twice-baked potatoes are legendary, fluffy clouds of carbohydrate heaven that deserve their own fan club.
Weekend reservations vanish quicker than snow in April, with couples seeking romantic escapes and friend groups celebrating life’s big moments. The intimate atmosphere makes everyone feel like they’re in on a delicious secret, which honestly, they kind of are.
4. Fisher’s Club
Perched on the shores of Middle Spunk Lake at 425 1st St NW in Avon, Fisher’s Club offers views that compete with the food for your attention—and somehow, both win. Getting a window seat here on a Saturday night is like winning the lottery, except the prize is walleye and a sunset instead of cash.
The restaurant specializes in whatever’s fresh from the lake, prepared with techniques passed down through generations of Minnesota cooks who understood that simple done right beats fancy done wrong. Their fish fry Fridays are the stuff of local legend, drawing crowds from counties away.
Regulars know to book their summer weekend spots in early spring, treating their reservation confirmations like golden tickets. The combination of exceptional food, friendly service, and those million-dollar lake views creates magic that can’t be replicated.
5. Weiderholt’s Supper Club
Out at 14535 240th St E in Hastings, Weiderholt’s represents everything right about Minnesota’s supper club tradition. This family operation has been serving up happiness on plates since before your parents were dodging curfews, and they’ve perfected their craft to an art form.
The menu features cuts of beef so tender they practically cut themselves, accompanied by sides that taste like grandma’s recipes got a professional upgrade. Their salad bar isn’t just an afterthought—it’s a destination within the destination, loaded with fresh vegetables and homemade dressings that could convert a carnivore.
Weekend warriors from the Twin Cities make the drive out here regularly, treating it like a pilgrimage to the temple of good eating. Smart diners call ahead by Wednesday if they want any hope of snagging a Saturday spot, because this place fills up faster than gossip spreads in a small town.
6. Bar Harbor Supper Club
Way up at 8164 Interlachen Rd in Lake Shore, Bar Harbor serves as the perfect excuse for a mini vacation disguised as dinner. This northwoods beauty combines cabin coziness with culinary excellence, creating an experience that feeds both stomach and soul.
The chefs here understand that up-north dining means generous portions of comfort food elevated to gourmet status. Their signature dishes feature local ingredients prepared with creativity and respect, resulting in flavors that make you understand why people drive hours for a meal.
Summer weekends require reservation calls made with military precision, as vacationers and locals alike compete for tables. The restaurant’s location near popular lakes means it’s often the celebratory endpoint for successful fishing trips, where the catch of the day meets the chef’s special in perfect harmony.
7. Norway Ridge Supper Club
Sitting pretty at 34757 Co. Rd. 39 in Pequot Lakes, Norway Ridge brings a touch of Scandinavian charm to Minnesota’s supper club scene. The name isn’t just for show—this place embraces its Nordic roots while serving up American classics with a subtle European twist.
Steaks here are seasoned and cooked with the kind of attention usually reserved for crown jewels, while the seafood options showcase the kitchen’s versatility. The atmosphere strikes that perfect balance between fancy enough for special occasions and comfortable enough that you won’t feel weird ordering a second dessert.
Lakes area visitors treat Norway Ridge like a required stop on their vacation itinerary, right up there with fishing and complaining about mosquitoes. Getting a reservation during peak summer or fall color season requires calling so far ahead you might need to check next year’s calendar.
8. Gary’s Supper Club
Down at 20790 Keokuk Ave S in Lakeville, Gary’s has built a reputation that extends far beyond its suburban location. This isn’t some cookie-cutter chain pretending to be special—it’s the real deal, serving authentic supper club experiences that honor tradition while staying fresh.
The kitchen turns out consistently excellent food that keeps customers coming back week after week, year after year. From perfectly crusted walleye to steaks that could convert vegetarians, every menu item receives the same careful attention to quality and flavor.
Local families celebrate everything from graduations to promotions here, creating memories around tables that have hosted countless special moments. Weekend availability disappears quickly, with regulars knowing to book their favorite tables weeks in advance or risk disappointment.
9. The Narrows Saloon & Supper Club
Sitting at 3380 Shoreline Dr in Navarre, The Narrows is the kind of supper-club-meets-lakeside-saloon that Minnesotans treat like a second home. With live music drifting through the dining room and the smell of sizzling steak in the air, the place manages to stay both laid-back and special at the same time.
The menu leans into true supper-club comfort — walleye, prime rib, hearty pastas, and perfectly crispy fish fry plates that have earned loyal fans across the west metro. Strong Old Fashioneds, generous portions, and lake-life nostalgia seal the deal.
Come Friday and Saturday evenings, The Narrows fills up fast with everyone from boaters coming off Lake Minnetonka to locals celebrating the end of the workweek. If you want a table near the stage or windows, booking ahead is more of a requirement than a suggestion.
10. Ranchero Supper Club
Way out at 4452 40th St W in Webster, Ranchero Supper Club proves that great food is worth the drive. This western-themed gem combines frontier hospitality with culinary skills that would impress even the toughest cattle baron, serving up meals that stick to your ribs in the best possible way.
The steaks here are cut thick and cooked over flames that add that perfect smoky char, while the sides taste like they came from a ranch cook who actually cares. Portions are generous enough to fuel a day of hard work, though most diners are just fueling their drive home.
Weekend crowds include everyone from local farmers to Twin Cities escapees seeking authentic dining experiences away from urban bustle. Smart planners call ahead early in the week, knowing that word-of-mouth keeps this place packed tighter than a rodeo arena on championship night.
11. The Creekside Supper Club
Nestled at 4820 Chicago Ave in Minneapolis, Creekside brings supper club tradition to the neighborhood level, proving you don’t need to leave the city for an authentic experience. This local favorite treats regulars like family and newcomers like regulars-in-training, creating a welcoming vibe that pairs perfectly with exceptional food.
The kitchen focuses on classic preparations done right, without unnecessary fuss or pretension. Each dish showcases quality ingredients treated with respect, resulting in flavors that comfort and satisfy without trying too hard to impress.
Neighborhood residents guard their weekend reservations jealously, having learned through experience that showing up without one means disappointment. The intimate size means limited seating, which only adds to the appeal for those lucky enough to snag a table during prime dining hours.
12. Porterhouse Steak & Seafood Supper Club
Located at 11211 205th St W in Lakeville, Porterhouse delivers classic supper-club flavors in a warm, old-school setting that feels tailor-made for celebrations.
From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the aroma of sizzling steaks and buttery seafood that instantly sets the tone for the night.
The menu hits every supper-club expectation: thick-cut prime rib, perfectly charred steaks, seafood dinners that rival coastal restaurants, and sides that arrive in portions so generous they practically need their own ZIP code.
Weekends here are a full-house affair, with families, date-night couples, and longtime regulars turning the dining room into a lively community gathering place.
If you don’t reserve ahead, expect to spend some quality time with the bar, but most people don’t mind when the drinks are this good.