These Ohio Buffet Spots Where The All-You-Can-Eat Comfort Food Tastes Like Home
Ohio knows comfort food like grandma knows her secret recipes.
From Amish country classics to international feasts, the Buckeye State serves up buffets that fill both your plate and your heart.
Whether you’re craving homestyle mashed potatoes or adventurous sushi rolls, these spots deliver endless options that’ll make you loosen your belt and ask for seconds (or thirds, we won’t judge).
1. Der Dutchman – Plain City
Rolling into Plain City hungry? Buckle up, because Der Dutchman is about to rock your taste buds with authentic Amish cooking that’ll transport you straight to grandma’s kitchen.
This legendary buffet spreads out mountains of fried chicken so crispy it could win awards, creamy mashed potatoes that melt on your tongue, and noodles that taste like they were hand-rolled with love (because they probably were).
The homemade bread arrives warm enough to melt butter instantly, and don’t even get us started on the pie selection—it’s basically a dessert wonderland.
Families flock here for good reason: portions are generous, flavors are authentic, and the atmosphere wraps around you like a warm quilt.
Located at 445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064, this spot proves that simple, honest cooking never goes out of style.
2. The Barn Restaurant – Smithville
Forget fancy city restaurants—The Barn Restaurant in Smithville delivers country cooking so good you’ll want to write home about it (or at least post it on Instagram).
Nestled at 877 W Main St, Smithville, OH 44677, this beloved establishment serves up buffet spreads that celebrate Ohio’s agricultural heritage.
Think tender roast beef, buttery corn, green beans cooked just right, and enough variety to satisfy even the pickiest eaters in your crew.
The salad bar alone could be a meal, loaded with fresh vegetables and homemade dressings that put store-bought bottles to shame.
What makes this place special isn’t just the food—it’s the genuine hospitality that makes strangers feel like neighbors.
Kids love the relaxed vibe, adults appreciate the quality, and everyone leaves with satisfied smiles and probably a few extra pounds.
3. Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery – Sugarcreek
Sugarcreek’s Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery combines two magical words: unlimited food AND fresh-baked goodies. Talk about winning the lottery!
Located at 1343 Old Route 39 NE, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, this gem sits right in the heart of Ohio’s Amish country, serving traditional recipes passed down through generations.
The buffet rotates seasonal favorites, so you might find ham loaf one visit and chicken and dumplings the next—both equally delicious and equally addictive.
Their bakery section tempts visitors with cinnamon rolls bigger than your fist and cookies that crumble perfectly with every bite.
Tourists and locals alike pack this place during peak hours, creating a buzzing energy that somehow adds to the meal’s enjoyment.
Pro tip: save room for dessert, because those pies aren’t just decoration—they’re edible masterpieces that deserve their own food group.
4. Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen – Mount Hope
Mrs. Yoder doesn’t mess around when it comes to feeding hungry folks, and her kitchen at 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660 proves it daily.
This no-frills buffet focuses on what really matters: soul-satisfying food made the old-fashioned way.
Broasted chicken practically falls off the bone, stuffing tastes like Thanksgiving every day, and the vegetable sides actually make you want to eat your greens (miracle alert!).
Everything comes seasoned perfectly—not too bland, not too salty, just right in that Goldilocks zone of deliciousness.
The restaurant’s simple decor keeps attention where it belongs: on your overflowing plate.
Prices stay reasonable despite the generous portions, making this a smart choice for families watching their budget without sacrificing quality.
Friendly servers keep drinks filled and smile like they actually enjoy their jobs, which somehow makes everything taste even better.
5. The Feast Buffet – Columbus
Columbus’s Feast Buffet at 171 E Campus View Blvd, Columbus, OH 43235 takes the concept of variety and cranks it up to eleven.
Walking through the doors feels like entering a culinary theme park where every station offers new adventures.
Craving Chinese? They’ve got it. Want Italian? Right this way. Seafood calling your name?
Say hello to the crab legs and shrimp.
The rotating selections mean you could visit weekly and never experience the exact same meal twice, which keeps things exciting for regulars and newbies alike.
Quality matches quantity here, with chefs preparing fresh batches throughout service to ensure nothing sits too long under heat lamps.
Families appreciate the kid-friendly options alongside adult favorites, meaning everyone from toddlers to grandparents finds something to love.
The spacious layout prevents that cramped feeling some buffets create during busy hours.
6. Tokyo Grill Sushi & Hibachi Buffet – Columbus (Polaris Area)
Sushi lovers, rejoice! Tokyo Grill at 8748 Lyra Dr, Columbus, OH 43240 delivers Japanese cuisine in unlimited quantities that’ll make your chopstick-wielding heart sing.
Fresh sushi rolls rotate constantly, ensuring you’re not gambling with yesterday’s fish (nobody wants that adventure).
The hibachi section lets you customize stir-fry combinations while watching skilled cooks work their wok magic, flipping ingredients with impressive flair.
Beyond raw fish and grilled meats, you’ll find teriyaki chicken, tempura vegetables, fried rice, and enough Asian-inspired dishes to keep your taste buds guessing.
Located in the bustling Polaris area, this spot attracts diverse crowds who appreciate authentic flavors without authentic wait times.
The all-you-can-eat format encourages experimentation—try that weird-looking roll! Sample unfamiliar sauces!
Worst case, you just grab something else from the endless options available.
7. The City Buffet – Columbus
Need proof that Columbus takes buffets seriously? The City Buffet at 2285 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229 presents its case deliciously.
This expansive operation covers multiple cuisines under one roof, creating a mini United Nations of flavor.
American classics share space with Chinese favorites, Italian pastas, Mexican options, and seafood selections that would make coastal restaurants jealous.
The dessert bar deserves special mention, featuring cakes, cookies, puddings, and ice cream that turn every meal into a celebration.
What sets this place apart is consistency—visit on Tuesday or Saturday, and quality remains reliable. Attentive staff clear plates quickly, keeping tables tidy despite the constant food traffic.
Reasonable pricing makes this a go-to spot for groups with varying tastes, since everyone can customize their experience.
Parking is plentiful, which matters more than you’d think when hunger strikes hard.
8. Golden Corral – Multiple Ohio Cities
Golden Corral at 5329 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228 represents the reliable friend who always shows up when you need them—predictable, comforting, and never disappointing.
This national chain earns its reputation through sheer variety and value.
The carving station serves up juicy roasts sliced to order, while the fried chicken competes with grandma’s recipe (we won’t tell her).
Vegetables, starches, salads, soups, and breads cover the basics before you even reach the legendary chocolate fountain that makes kids (and adults) lose their minds with excitement.
Multiple Ohio locations mean you’re never far from a Golden Corral fix, and the standardized menu ensures you know exactly what awaits.
Prices stay budget-friendly, especially for families with growing teenagers who eat like competitive athletes.
Sure, it’s not fancy, but sometimes you just want dependable comfort food without surprises.
9. Sakura Buffet – Elyria
Elyria’s Sakura Buffet at 1635 W River Rd N, Elyria, OH 44035 blooms with flavor options that’ll make your decision-making skills work overtime.
Japanese and Chinese cuisines blend seamlessly across the buffet stations, offering everything from delicate sushi to hearty lo mein.
The hibachi grill cooks fresh proteins to order, ensuring hot, customized meals rather than lukewarm steam-table casualties.
Seafood lovers appreciate the selection that goes beyond basic offerings, while landlubbers find plenty of chicken, beef, and pork options prepared multiple ways.
The restaurant maintains high cleanliness standards, with staff constantly monitoring and refreshing food stations.
Prices stay competitive for the area, making this a popular choice for family dinners and casual dates alike.
The spacious layout prevents that sardine-can feeling even during peak hours, and ample parking makes access easy.
Dessert includes both Asian specialties and familiar American sweets, ending meals on sweet notes.