This Classic Pennsylvania Diner Serves A Reuben Sandwich You Can’t Miss
Some cravings do not whisper, they practically grab you by the sleeve and point you toward a diner booth.
Nazareth Diner in Pennsylvania is made for that kind of moment, classic, welcoming, and ready to turn an ordinary day into a full-on comfort food win.
Pull into Nazareth, step inside, and you get that familiar diner rhythm right away, steady conversation, warm plates moving fast, and the kind of menu that feels like an old friend.
Then there is the Reuben, the star that refuses to be background noise.
A great one is all about the balance, hearty, tangy, and stacked just right, with flavors that hit in layers instead of chaos.
Order it and you can almost feel the table go quiet for a second after the first bite, because that is what happens when something simple is done really well.
Add a side, sip something cold, and suddenly the day feels less complicated.
Personal rule, if a diner is known for a Reuben, I am not debating it. Hand it over, extra napkins included, and consider my plans happily derailed.
Open Every Single Hour of Every Single Day
Most diners claim they’re always open, but Nazareth Diner at 581 S Broad St actually delivers on that promise. Every day of the week, all 24 hours, you can walk in and order from the full menu.
Whether you’re craving pancakes at 4 a.m. or a burger at midnight, the kitchen never closes. Regulars love this about the place because life doesn’t run on a 9-to-5 schedule, and neither should good food.
Travelers passing through the area have discovered this gem after long drives, finding comfort in hot meals when everywhere else has locked their doors.
The staff welcomes late-night guests with the same warmth they show during breakfast rush.
One customer even mentioned stopping by on New Year’s Eve and being greeted with smiles and the entire menu available.
That kind of consistency builds loyalty, and it’s clear this diner values every customer no matter when hunger strikes.
The Reuben Sandwich That Built a Reputation
Corned beef piled high, melted Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing all pressed between slices of perfectly griddled rye bread.
That’s the Reuben at Nazareth Diner, and it’s not just good, it’s the kind of sandwich people drive out of their way to eat.
The meat is tender and flavorful, never dry or overly salty like some versions you find elsewhere. Every bite delivers that perfect balance of savory, tangy, and rich flavors that make a Reuben memorable.
Locals have been ordering this sandwich for years, and many say it’s the best they’ve ever had. The bread gets toasted just right, with a slight crunch on the outside and soft warmth on the inside.
Paired with crispy fries or a side of coleslaw, this sandwich turns a simple lunch into something worth celebrating.
A Salad Bar That Actually Impresses
Walking into Nazareth Diner and seeing the salad bar might surprise you. This isn’t some sad collection of wilted lettuce and store-bought dressing.
The bar features house-made salads including red potato salad, barley and tomato salad, multiple pasta salads, and fresh vegetables.
Customers rave about the variety and freshness, with one reviewer calling the potato salad the best they’d tried.
Kalamata olives, fresh fruit, and different greens give you plenty of options to build exactly the salad you want. Many entrees come with salad bar access included, which adds serious value to your meal.
The salads are prepared in-house, and you can taste the difference compared to mass-produced options.
Even people who don’t normally get excited about salad bars have mentioned this one specifically in their reviews.
It’s a throwback to classic diners from decades past, done right with quality ingredients and care.
Breakfast Served Around the Clock
Pancakes at dinnertime? Eggs Benedict at 3 a.m.?
Absolutely, because breakfast never stops at this diner. The all-day breakfast menu means you can satisfy those morning food cravings whenever they hit.
Customers frequently mention the breakfast offerings in reviews, highlighting everything from fluffy pancakes to perfectly cooked eggs.
One guest raved about the Nutella pancakes with bananas, calling them exquisite and delicious. Another praised the eggs Benedict and egg casserole as part of an excellent overall experience.
Home fries get mentioned often, cooked crispy and seasoned well. The breakfast portions are generous without being wasteful, and the quality stays consistent whether you order at dawn or midnight.
For travelers and shift workers who need a real breakfast when most places only offer lunch menus, this flexibility makes all the difference.
The kitchen treats breakfast with the same care and attention regardless of what time appears on the clock.
Location That’s Easy to Find and Access
Finding Nazareth Diner couldn’t be simpler. Situated at 581 S Broad St in Nazareth, PA 18064, the diner sits right on a main road with excellent visibility.
The large parking lot means you’ll never circle endlessly looking for a spot, even during busy meal times.
Out-of-town visitors appreciate how accessible the location is, especially when traveling through the Lehigh Valley area.
Several reviews mention the convenience of the location, with one couple noting they discovered it while house hunting in the area during a snowstorm.
Another guest praised it as the best post-ski meal near Blue Mountain, better than overpriced slope food.
The diner serves as a reliable landmark for locals giving directions, and GPS finds it without any confusion. Free parking, easy highway access, and a building you can’t miss make getting there stress-free.
Whether you’re a regular or visiting for the first time, you’ll have no trouble pulling in and finding your way inside.
Atmosphere That Feels Like the 1970s (In a Good Way)
Step inside and you’ll immediately notice the throwback vibe. The decor channels authentic 1970s diner style without feeling dated or tacky.
Roomy booths, plenty of table seating, and even bar seating give you options depending on your mood.
One reviewer described it as having a throwback atmosphere that enhances the dining experience rather than distracting from it.
The ceiling features a beautiful mural with hands and flags from many nations, symbolizing diversity and community. Multiple dining rooms provide space so the diner never feels cramped, even when busy.
The renovation maintained the classic diner feel while updating things to feel clean and welcoming. Customers describe the atmosphere as cozy, warm, and family-friendly.
The counter area adds another dimension for those who want a seat with their meal.
Everything from the lighting to the booth upholstery contributes to that comfortable, nostalgic feeling that makes you want to settle in and stay awhile.
A Menu So Big You’ll Need Time to Decide
The menu at Nazareth Diner spans multiple pages and covers just about every comfort food category imaginable.
Breakfast items, burgers, sandwiches, dinner entrees, appetizers, and desserts all compete for your attention.
Some customers mention feeling overwhelmed by the choices, but in the best possible way. You could visit weekly for months and still not try everything.
The variety means groups with different tastes can all find something they’ll enjoy. One person can order breakfast while another gets a burger, and someone else tackles a dinner entree.
Popular items include the tuna sandwich, chicken parmesan, philly burger, haddock, and chicken pot pie. French onion soup gets mentioned as a favorite, along with rice pudding for dessert.
The kitchen handles the extensive menu without sacrificing quality, which isn’t easy.
Whether you’re in the mood for something light or a hearty meal, the menu delivers options that actually sound appealing rather than just filling space.
Servers Who Make You Feel Like Family
Good food matters, but service can make or break a dining experience. Nazareth Diner employs servers who genuinely seem to care about their customers.
Multiple reviews mention specific servers by name, praising friendliness and attentiveness during meals and late nights. One customer said a server went above and beyond, deserving ten stars if possible.
Another reviewer wrote about Tanya making their experience memorable, even accommodating an off-menu request with a smile.
The staff creates a family vibe that makes both regulars and first-timers feel welcome.
Servers offer suggestions, answer questions patiently, and check in without hovering. One guest mentioned staff warmly welcoming every late-night customer on New Year’s Eve with genuine friendliness.
Of course, experiences vary and some reviews mention less attentive service, but the overwhelming majority praise the staff’s kindness and professionalism.
When servers remember your usual order or greet you by name, dining out becomes about more than just food.
Portions That Actually Satisfy Without Waste
Nobody likes leaving a restaurant still hungry, and that’s not a problem here. Nazareth Diner serves portions that fill you up without being so excessive that half your meal ends up in a takeout box.
One reviewer described plates filled to the brim, giving you plenty of food for your money. The breakfast plates come loaded with eggs, meat, and sides that constitute a real meal.
Burgers arrive with generous sides, and dinner entrees include enough protein and accompaniments to satisfy even big appetites.
The chicken basket should have four pieces according to the menu, and customers notice when it doesn’t.
Sandwiches like the Reuben are stacked high with quality ingredients rather than being skimpy. Pricing is often described as moderate in reviews, meaning you get good value for what you pay for most meals.
Compared to overpriced resort food nearby, this diner offers substantially better portions and quality at reasonable prices, making it a smart choice for locals and visitors alike.
Three Decades of Serving the Community
Nazareth Diner has been a fixture in the community for over 30 years, according to longtime customers. That kind of longevity doesn’t happen by accident.
One reviewer mentioned visiting for three decades and watching the place evolve while maintaining its core identity.
The diner stayed open during COVID when many restaurants closed, showing commitment to serving the community even during difficult times.
The ownership appears invested in the business, with at least one customer mentioning meeting the owner and finding him friendly and welcoming.
Recent renovations updated the space while respecting the classic diner aesthetic people love. Locals consider it a reliable spot for celebrations, casual meals, and late-night cravings.
The diner has become part of the area’s identity, the kind of place people mention when describing their town to others.
Building that kind of reputation requires consistency, quality, and genuine care about the food and customers.
Three decades later, Nazareth Diner continues earning its place in the community one meal at a time.