These Ohio Pie Shops Bake The Kind Of Slices That Bring Back Sunday Mornings
There is something about pie that makes a Sunday morning feel complete. Maybe it is the flaky crust that crumbles just right, or the way a single slice can turn a simple breakfast into a celebration.
Ohio has a deep love for pie, and small bakeries across the state have been perfecting their recipes for decades, turning out fruit pies, cream pies and savory options that taste like home.
From family run shops in Amish country to neighborhood bakeries in bustling cities, these places bake slices that remind you why dessert never needs to wait until after dinner.
I have spent more time than I care to admit chasing down the best pie in Ohio, and this list is the delicious result of that research.
1. Just Pies, Westerville
Stepping into Just Pies, I felt a very clear message in the air: this place exists for crust and filling, nothing else. The shop is small and focused, with cases full of fruit pies, cream pies and even savory options, all made from scratch every day.
On my last visit, I watched a steady stream of regulars walk in, call the staff by name and leave, balancing whole pies like prized trophies. The menu rotates with the seasons, but there is always a classic apple, a silk smooth chocolate and at least one showy cream pie crowned with a serious cloud of whipped topping.
If you are the type who believes breakfast can be a slice of cherry, this shop quietly agrees and hands you a fork.
Address: Just Pies, 736 Northfield Rd Ste 1, Westerville, OH 43082.
2. Mama Jo Homestyle Pies, Amherst
The first time I pulled into the parking lot at Mama Jo Homestyle Pies, the sign alone already felt promising. Inside, the glass cases full of whole pies and generous slices made it pretty clear why this family business has been baking in Lorain County for decades.
I remember standing in line trying to act decisive while my brain quietly argued over lemon meringue, apple crumb and a cream pie that looked almost too perfect to disturb. Locals grab holiday orders here, but on random Tuesdays, the place still hums with people treating themselves to a slice and a coffee.
The fillings lean comforting rather than flashy, with flaky crusts that hold together just long enough for a clean bite. It is the kind of pie that reminds you why dessert never really needs a trend.
Address: Mama Jo Homestyle Pies, 1969 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001.
3. Gray House Pies, Westlake
Walking into Gray House Pies, I had the sudden urge to cancel any remaining plans for the day and focus on pastry research. This cozy Westlake bakery stacks its menu with serious fruit pies, rich custard pies and even savory pot pies, all made with a from scratch philosophy that shows up in every flaky edge.
On my visit, I watched someone pick up an entire box labeled simply assorted, which feels like the bravest and smartest option here. The staff talks about ingredients the way some people talk about sports statistics, and the boards often list seasonal flavors that disappear quickly.
Whether you go for a classic apple or something more adventurous, the slices are sturdy, deeply flavored and unapologetically generous. This is not a place that believes in dainty portions.
Address: Gray House Pies, 26075 Detroit Rd, Westlake, OH 44145.
4. Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery, Hartville
I did not fully understand the phrase save room for pie until I visited Hartville Kitchen and mistakenly treated the main course like the main event. The restaurant is known for its homestyle entrees, but the bakery is where dessert people quietly lose their composure.
Rows of cream pies, fruit pies and seasonal specials line the cases, each one looking like it came straight from a very confident church potluck. People order whole pies here for holidays, but by the slice traffic on a normal afternoon is just as intense.
I finally settled on a banana cream slice that somehow balanced rich filling with a crust that stayed crisp until the last bite. Walking out with a boxed whole pie for later felt less like indulgence and more like basic preparation.
Address: Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery, 1015 Edison St NW, Hartville, OH 44632.
5. Rood, Lakewood
The night I first walked into Rood in Lakewood, the dessert case immediately hijacked my plans for a light meal. This stylish neighborhood spot used to lean even harder into the pie part of its name, and those roots still show in a rotating cast of beautifully plated slices.
I remember staring at a menu where seasonal fruit pies shared space with decadent chocolate creations and tarts that felt almost too artistic to disturb. People around me were happily turning dinner into a pie centric experience, ordering multiple slices for the table and passing plates around with serious focus.
The flavors are creative without losing that cozy, fork scraping the plate satisfaction that makes pie feel familiar. It is the kind of place where dessert never feels like an afterthought.
Address: Rood, 17001 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107.
6. The BonBonerie, Cincinnati
The first time I stepped into The BonBonerie, I felt slightly underdressed for how elegant the pastry cases looked. Famous for cakes and a charming tearoom, this Cincinnati classic also turns out pies that could easily steal the spotlight on any dessert table.
I remember gravitating toward a lemony slice that somehow managed to taste bright, buttery and perfectly balanced all at once. Around me, customers were ordering pies to go while trying not to get distracted by tortes, tarts and other temptations lined up nearby.
Everything here is made by hand, from the crusts to the fillings, and the result is a pie that feels both nostalgic and special enough for big celebrations. If you are the type who brings dessert to earn instant hero status, this place makes it very easy.
Address: The BonBonerie, 2030 Madison Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45208.
7. The Fork and Pie Bakery, Newtown
My first visit to The Fork and Pie Bakery started with a simple plan to just look and ended with both hands full of boxes. This small shop near Newtown specializes in from scratch pies that lean comforting, carefully crafted and completely worth a detour off the main route.
Inside, the vibe is relaxed and neighborly, the kind of place where the staff is happy to talk you through every flavor in the case. One day it might be blueberry crumb and chocolate cream, another day chicken pot pie and seasonal fruit combinations that sound simple but taste deeply thought out.
The crusts hold everything together without getting tough, and the fillings stay on the generous side of the spectrum. It all feels very sincere, in the best way.
Address: The Fork and Pie Bakery, 6836 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45244.
8. Luna Bakery & Cafe, Cleveland Heights
I wandered into Luna Bakery & Cafe on a cold morning, fully planning to order only coffee, and then saw the pastry case. Known for its tarts, cakes and quiche, this Cleveland Heights favorite also turns out pies that can quietly become the main reason for your visit.
The crusts tend to be delicate and buttery, supporting fillings that showcase seasonal fruit and carefully balanced flavors. I watched one regular order a slice to eat there and a whole pie to take home, which felt like a very smart life strategy.
With its bright interior and steady flow of locals, Luna feels less like a grab and go stop and more like a place where you linger over dessert and conversation. The pie just happens to be good enough to hold its own beside everything else in the case.
Address: Luna Bakery & Cafe, 2482 Fairmount Blvd, Cleveland Heights, OH 44106.
9. Bakery Unlimited, Toledo
The morning I arrived at Bakery Unlimited in Toledo, the smell of butter and sugar had already drifted into the parking lot. Inside, the displays are packed with breads, donuts and cakes, but the pies deserve just as much attention as the rest of the lineup.
I remember standing in front of a row of fruit and cream pies that looked ready for every holiday at once. The staff moves quickly, boxing up whole pies for advance orders while still sliding generous slices across the counter for walk in customers who clearly know what they want.
Crusts here are sturdy yet tender, and the fillings lean toward classic flavors done very well rather than complicated experiments. It feels like the kind of place that quietly keeps family traditions running on schedule.
Address: Bakery Unlimited, 4427 Secor Rd, Toledo, OH 43623.
10. Amish Door Restaurant & Bakery, Wilmot
Driving up to Amish Door in Wilmot, I realized this is not just a restaurant, it is a whole little village with a serious soft spot for baked goods. Inside the main restaurant, the bakery case shines with pies that pair perfectly with hearty, country style meals.
During my visit, I watched families finish plates of comfort food and then immediately start negotiating which pies to take home. Fruit pies with golden crusts share space with cream pies that look ready for birthday level celebrations, and staff members pack them up like they have done this a thousand times.
The setting feels peaceful, and there is something very grounding about ending a slow meal with a slice of pie that tastes both familiar and carefully made. This is Sunday dessert energy any day of the week.
Address: Amish Door Restaurant & Bakery, 1210 Winesburg St, Wilmot, OH 44689.
11. Miles Farmers Market, Solon
On my first trip to Miles Farmers Market, I thought I was just stopping for produce and left with a trunk that looked like a dessert mission. This Solon landmark has an in store bakery that takes pies extremely seriously, turning out fruit and cream versions that share shelf space with breads and pastries.
I remember spotting their Fruits of the Forest pie and realizing that someone here clearly enjoys going all in on flavor combinations. Customers were lining up to order holiday pies ahead of time while still snagging slices for immediate enjoyment, which seems like the only logical approach.
The whole place feels busy and practical, but the bakery case adds a warm, nostalgic note to the experience. It is very hard to walk out without at least one box under your arm.
Address: Miles Farmers Market, 28560 Miles Rd, Solon, OH 44139.
12. Theo’s Restaurant, Cambridge
The first time I sat down at Theo’s in downtown Cambridge, I thought I was here for a casual diner style meal. Then I saw the legendary mile high pies glide past on their way to another table, and my priorities rearranged themselves instantly.
Theo’s has been around for generations, serving classic comfort food, but the pies are the detail everyone remembers. Tall slices topped with generous meringue or whipped cream arrive at the table with enough height to partially block your view of whoever is sitting across from you.
Flavors range from bright lemon to rich chocolate and fruit options that feel tailor made for Sunday dessert. It is the kind of place where just one slice quickly turns into planning your next visit before you even leave.
Address: Theo’s Restaurant, 632 Wheeling Ave, Cambridge, OH 43725.
13. Troyer’s Home Pantry, Apple Creek
Pulling up to Troyer’s Home Pantry in Apple Creek, I immediately got the sense that locals were not exaggerating when they called this their go to pie stop. The bakery focuses on cream pies, fruit pies and other sweets that lean very traditional in the best possible way.
Inside, the cases feel wonderfully crowded with full size pies and slices that do not skimp on filling. Strawberry, rhubarb, cream and seasonal fruit options share space with cinnamon rolls and breads, so pie lovers have serious decisions to make at the counter.
I remember watching a customer order several pies just to freeze, which sounded suspiciously like code for late night dessert insurance. Everything tastes homemade in a way that feels personal rather than polished.
Address: Troyer’s Home Pantry, 668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606.
14. White House Fruit Farm, Canfield
My first visit to White House Fruit Farm started as a simple fall outing and turned into a full bakery expedition. This working farm near Canfield is famous for its donuts, but their bakery also turns out pies that could easily headline any holiday spread.
Inside the market, you will find an entire section dedicated to pies baked daily, with flavors like apple, cherry, peach and more elaborate combinations appearing throughout the year. Half pies are available for smaller households, which I personally interpret as permission to buy two different flavors at once.
The mix of farm setting and warm bakery smells makes every slice taste a little extra comforting. It is the kind of place where dessert shopping becomes an outing all by itself.
Address: White House Fruit Farm, 9249 State Route 62, Canfield, OH 44406.
15. Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen, Middlefield
When I walked into Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen in Middlefield, the first thing that caught my eye was not the dining room; it was the bakery case. Pies, cookies and breads fill the shelves, but the pies are the quiet stars that draw people from across northeast Ohio.
I remember seeing peach, berry and cream pies lined up with that slightly rustic look that usually signals real butter and family recipes. Diners finish generous plates of noodles, meats and sides, then circle back to the bakery to claim their dessert for later.
Everything feels deeply rooted in tradition, from the flavors to the way slices are cut, just a little on the hearty side. This is the sort of place where saving room becomes a very strategic part of the meal.
Address: Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen, 14743 North State St, Middlefield, OH 44062.
16. Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery, Plain City
The first time I visited Der Dutchman in Plain City, I thought the buffet and comfort food would be the main story. Then I saw the bakery section, full of whole pies, fry pies and slices that looked like they belonged in every family photo album.
In the bakery, double crusted fruit pies sit beside coconut cream and seasonal creations that regulars order by the box, especially around holidays. Staff members talk about strawberry pie and other favorites with the ease of people who pack a lot of dessert into every week.
The atmosphere is friendly and unhurried, making it easy to linger a little too long in front of the pie case while you think. Somehow, a whole pie usually leaves the building with you.
Address: Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery, 445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064.