These 14 Ohio Pizzerias Are Serving Slices Worth The Drive This February
February in Ohio means cold nights, cozy dinners, and the perfect excuse to hunt down a hot, cheesy slice of pizza. The state has quietly built a reputation for exceptional pizzerias that go way beyond the standard chain offerings.
From Cleveland to Cincinnati, Columbus to Dayton, passionate pizza makers are crafting pies with creative toppings, perfectly charred crusts, and sauce that makes you want to lick the plate. Whether you prefer thin and crispy, thick and fluffy, or something in between, Ohio delivers.
This month, treat yourself to a pizza road trip across the state and discover why locals are willing to drive across town for these particular slices. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.
1. IL Rione Pizzeria, Cleveland
Authentic Neapolitan pizza is hard to find outside of Naples, but this Cleveland spot gets it right every single time. The dough ferments for days, creating those signature airy bubbles and a crust that chars beautifully in their scorching hot oven.
Each pie arrives at your table with San Marzano tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil that smells like summer even in the heart of winter. The Margherita is simple perfection, but adventurous eaters should try the Diavola with spicy salami.
The casual atmosphere makes it perfect for families, date nights, or solo pizza missions. Service is friendly without being pushy, and they know their stuff when it comes to recommendations.
Located in the Detroit Shoreway neighborhood, this pizzeria brings a slice of Italy to Ohio. The interior feels warm and inviting, with exposed brick and soft lighting that makes everyone look good.
You might need to wait for a table on weekends, but the pizza is absolutely worth it. February is actually a great time to visit since the crowds thin out a bit after the holiday rush.
Address: 1303 W 65th St, Cleveland, Ohio.
2. Angelo’s Pizza, Lakewood
Since 1958, this family-run institution has been serving up square-cut slices that define Cleveland-style pizza. The crust hits that perfect balance between crispy bottom and chewy middle, with edges that get delightfully crunchy.
Their sauce has a slight sweetness that pairs beautifully with quality pepperoni that cups and crisps in the oven. The cheese blend melts into gooey perfection, stretching from plate to mouth in those satisfying cheese pulls we all love.
What makes this place special is the consistency. They have been making pizza the same way for over six decades, and they are not about to change now.
The dining room has that old-school pizzeria vibe with red checkered tablecloths and family photos on the walls. Kids are welcome, and the staff treats regulars like extended family.
Their large pizza feeds a crowd without breaking the bank, making it perfect for game nights or family gatherings. February means comfort food, and comfort food means Angelo’s for thousands of Lakewood residents.
The location on Madison Avenue makes it easy to grab a pie on your way home. Parking can be tricky during peak hours, so plan accordingly.
Address: 13715 Madison Ave, Lakewood, Ohio.
3. Mama Santa’s Restaurant & Pizzeria, Cleveland
Cleveland’s Little Italy neighborhood is home to this beloved pizzeria that feels like eating at your Italian grandmother’s house. The recipes have been passed down through generations, and you can taste the love in every bite.
Their pizza comes loaded with toppings that actually stay on the slice instead of sliding off. The sausage is seasoned perfectly, the mushrooms are fresh, and the green peppers add just the right crunch.
Beyond pizza, their menu offers classic Italian dishes that make choosing difficult. But on a cold February evening, a hot pizza pie with a side of garlic knots is hard to beat.
The restaurant has been a neighborhood fixture for years, attracting students from nearby universities and families who have been coming here for decades. The walls are covered with photos and memorabilia that tell the story of Little Italy.
Service is warm and efficient, with servers who remember your name and your usual order. They make you feel like part of the family from the moment you walk in.
The portions are generous, so come hungry or plan to take home leftovers. Their pizza reheats beautifully, making breakfast pizza a legitimate option the next morning.
Address: 12301 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, Ohio.
4. Dewey’s Pizza – Clifton, Cincinnati
Creative toppings meet perfectly blistered crust at this Cincinnati favorite in the trendy Clifton neighborhood. Their menu reads like a pizza lover’s dream journal, with combinations you never knew you needed.
The Edgar Allan Poe pizza, topped with olive oil, mozzarella, fontina, mushrooms, whole roasted garlic, kalamata olives, and goat cheese with tomatoes and parsley added after baking, sounds complex but tastes incredible. For purists, their Margherita showcases quality ingredients without any fuss.
They take their crust seriously, using a sourdough starter that adds complexity and tang. The result is a chewy, flavorful base that holds up to even the heaviest toppings.
The Clifton location buzzes with energy, filled with university students, young professionals, and families all united by their love of good pizza. The modern industrial decor creates a hip atmosphere without feeling pretentious.
Their commitment to fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible shows in the bright flavors. Even the simplest pizzas taste vibrant and alive.
February brings seasonal specials that incorporate winter vegetables in unexpected ways. The staff knows the menu inside and out and can guide you toward your perfect pie.
Parking near the University of Cincinnati campus can be challenging, but the pizza makes the hunt worthwhile.
Address: 265 Hosea Avenue, Cincinnati, Ohio.
5. Taglio – OTR, Cincinnati
Roman-style pizza by the slice brings something different to Cincinnati’s Over-the-Rhine neighborhood. The rectangular slices are cut with scissors and sold by weight, just like in Rome.
The crust is lighter and airier than typical pizza, with a focaccia-like texture that soaks up flavor without getting soggy. Toppings change daily based on what is fresh and seasonal.
You might find potato and rosemary one day, mortadella and pistachio the next. The variety keeps regulars coming back to see what creative combinations the kitchen has dreamed up.
The modern, minimalist space feels European and cool, with an open kitchen where you can watch the pizza makers at work. Counter service keeps things casual and quick.
This is perfect for a fast lunch or a light dinner when you want quality without committing to a full sit-down meal. Grab a couple of slices, maybe a simple salad, and enjoy.
The OTR location puts you in the heart of one of Cincinnati’s most vibrant neighborhoods. Make an evening of it by exploring the surrounding shops and galleries.
February might be cold, but the warm, pillowy pizza will heat you right up from the inside out.
Address: 56 E 12th St, Cincinnati, Ohio.
6. Hounddog’s Pizza, Columbus
Quirky meets delicious at this Columbus institution near the Ohio State University campus. The pizza is thick, hearty, and loaded with toppings that would make lesser crusts crumble.
Their Howlin’ Hound pizza brings serious heat with pepperoni, sausage, banana peppers, and hot sauce baked right in. If you prefer something milder, the Smokin’ Joes with barbecue chicken hits all the right notes.
What sets this place apart is the crust, which is thick enough to support massive amounts of toppings but never feels heavy or doughy. They have perfected the ratio of crispy exterior to soft interior.
The atmosphere is pure college town, with mismatched furniture, local art on the walls, and a laid-back vibe that welcomes everyone. Late-night hours make it a favorite spot for night owls and students pulling all-nighters.
Their vegetarian and vegan options are actually good, not just afterthoughts. The Vegan Stoner with vegan cheese, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers proves plant-based pizza can satisfy.
Service is casual and friendly, with staff who seem genuinely happy to be there. The music is always good, and the energy is infectious.
February in Columbus means bundling up, and this pizza provides the perfect reward for braving the cold.
Address: 2657 N High St, Columbus, Ohio.
7. Adriatico’s Pizza, Columbus
New York-style slices the size of your head have made this Columbus spot legendary since 1988. The thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of grease is exactly what pizza should be.
Each slice is massive, making their prices incredibly reasonable for the amount of food you get. Two slices and you are full, three slices and you might need a nap.
The cheese is perfectly browned with those little crispy spots that add texture and flavor. Their sauce is tangy and bright, cutting through the richness of the cheese.
Located near campus, the place fills up with students, but locals know it is worth fighting the crowds. The energy is always high, with people coming and going at all hours.
Late-night service makes it a popular stop after concerts, games, or just a night out exploring Columbus. Nothing tastes better at midnight than a hot slice of pizza.
The interior is basic and functional, because the pizza is the star here. No fancy decor needed when you are serving slices this good.
They also offer whole pies if you are feeding a group, but the by-the-slice option is perfect for solo diners.
Address: 1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, Ohio.
8. Terita’s Pizza, Columbus
Family-owned and operated since 1973, this Columbus pizzeria has been perfecting their recipe for over five decades. The result is a consistently excellent pizza that keeps generations of families coming back.
Their sausage is made in-house with a secret spice blend that adds depth without overwhelming heat. Combined with their slightly sweet sauce and quality mozzarella, it creates pizza perfection.
The crust strikes that ideal balance that is so hard to achieve. Crispy enough to hold its shape, soft enough to bite through easily, with a subtle yeast flavor that makes you want another slice.
The dining room has a classic pizzeria feel with booths, tables, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes everyone comfortable. Kids are not just tolerated but genuinely welcomed.
Their lunch specials offer incredible value, making it easy to enjoy quality pizza without spending a fortune. Dinner crowds can be heavy, especially on weekends, so calling ahead is smart.
Located on Cleveland Avenue, it serves a diverse neighborhood that appreciates good food at fair prices. The staff treats everyone like regulars, even on your first visit.
February might be slow for some restaurants, but Terita’s stays busy because locals know where to find comfort food that actually comforts.
Address: 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, Ohio.
9. Rubino’s Pizza, Bexley
This Bexley institution has been serving the community since 1954, making it one of the oldest pizzerias in central Ohio. Their thin crust pizza is a local favorite that has stood the test of time.
The pepperoni curls up into little cups that hold pools of flavorful oil, adding both visual appeal and taste. Their cheese blend melts perfectly, never separating or getting greasy.
What makes Rubino’s special is their dedication to doing things the right way, even when shortcuts would be easier. They make their dough fresh daily and never compromise on ingredient quality.
The restaurant has that comfortable neighborhood feel where everyone knows everyone. Regulars have their favorite tables, and the staff remembers how you like your pizza.
Their square-cut style makes sharing easy, though you might not want to share once you taste it. Each piece is the perfect size for one or two bites, depending on your enthusiasm.
Located in charming Bexley, the pizzeria draws from surrounding neighborhoods but maintains a loyal local following. The parking lot fills up quickly during dinner rush, proving their continued popularity.
Address: 2643 E Main St, Bexley, Ohio.
10. Old Scratch Pizza – Dayton
Wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pizza has found a devoted following at this Dayton hotspot. The round pies feature a thin, airy crust with puffy edges where the dough blisters and chars into crisp, chewy perfection.
The sauce goes directly on the dough with the cheese on top, so each bite delivers a balanced mix of tangy tomato, creamy mozzarella, and crisp-edged crust that makes sense once you experience it.
Their toppings are creative without being weird, walking that fine line between adventurous and accessible. The pepperoni and pickled jalapeno combination sounds strange but tastes incredible.
The industrial-chic space with exposed brick and Edison bulbs creates a modern atmosphere that feels both trendy and comfortable. The open kitchen lets you watch your pizza being assembled and baked.
Service is knowledgeable and enthusiastic, with staff who clearly love the product they are serving. They are happy to explain their wood-fired pizza style to newcomers and make recommendations.
Located on South Patterson Boulevard, the pizzeria has helped revitalize its neighborhood. The surrounding area offers other interesting spots to explore before or after your meal.
February means you can actually get a table without a long wait, though weekends still fill up fast. The warm, cheesy pizza is perfect comfort food for cold Ohio evenings.
Address: 812 S Patterson Blvd, Dayton, Ohio.
11. Marion’s Piazza, Dayton
Dayton-style pizza is a real thing, and this local chain has been perfecting it since 1965. The ultra-thin crust gets cut into squares, with every piece offering a different ratio of crust to toppings.
Their sauce is slightly sweet with a hint of oregano, creating a flavor profile that defines the region. The cheese goes all the way to the edges, ensuring every bite includes that crucial dairy component.
What locals love most is the consistency across all locations and over decades of operation. Your pizza tastes the same whether you ordered it in 1975 or 2025.
The Shroyer Road location offers plenty of seating and a comfortable family atmosphere. The decor might not be fancy, but it is clean and welcoming with that classic pizzeria charm.
Their party-cut style makes sharing easy and gives everyone access to both edge pieces and center pieces. Some people fight over the corners, others prefer the middle squares.
The menu extends beyond pizza to include salads, sandwiches, and pasta, but pizza is clearly the main attraction. Their large pizza feeds a crowd without requiring a second mortgage.
Address: 711 Shroyer Rd, Dayton, Ohio.
12. Home Slice Pizza, Toledo
Downtown Toledo has found its pizza champion in this spot serving massive New York-style slices. The crust is thin and pliable, perfect for that classic fold-and-eat technique that makes New York pizza so portable.
Each slice is huge, easily matching anything you would find in Manhattan or Brooklyn. The cheese is generously applied and melts into a gooey blanket that stretches impressively.
Their sauce strikes the right balance between sweet and tangy, with enough seasoning to be interesting without overwhelming the other flavors. Simple ingredients prepared well always beat complicated recipes done poorly.
The downtown location makes it perfect for a quick lunch during the work week or a post-event dinner. The casual counter service keeps things moving quickly even when busy.
Their by-the-slice option means solo diners can enjoy fresh pizza without committing to a whole pie. Of course, whole pizzas are available for groups or people with serious appetites.
The interior is simple and functional with a few tables and counter seating. Most people grab their slices and go, but eating in gives you a front-row seat to the pizza-making action.
February in Toledo can be brutally cold, making hot pizza an essential survival tool. The location on South St Clair Street is easy to find and worth seeking out.
Address: 28 S St Clair St, Toledo, Ohio.
13. Avalon Downtown Pizzeria, Youngstown
Youngstown’s downtown revival includes this pizzeria bringing quality pies to Federal Street. The focus on fresh ingredients and careful preparation shows in every bite.
Their crust is hand-tossed and baked to order, creating that perfect texture that is crispy outside and tender inside. The dough has a slight tang from proper fermentation, adding complexity to even simple pizzas.
Toppings are fresh and generous without being overwhelming. The vegetable pizzas actually taste like vegetables, not just delivery vehicles for cheese and sauce.
The downtown location puts you in the heart of Youngstown’s ongoing renaissance. The dining room is modern and clean with an open kitchen concept that lets you watch your pizza being made.
Service is friendly and attentive, with staff who take pride in their product. They are happy to customize pizzas to accommodate dietary restrictions or personal preferences.
Their lunch specials offer great value for downtown workers, while dinner service attracts couples and families looking for quality food in a comfortable setting. The pace is relaxed without being slow.
Address: 17 W Federal St, Youngstown, Ohio.
14. Avalanche Pizza, Athens
College towns need great pizza, and Athens delivers with this popular spot on East State Street. The pizzas are loaded with toppings and built on a crust that can handle the weight.
Their specialty pizzas feature creative combinations that appeal to adventurous eaters, while classic options satisfy traditionalists. The BBQ chicken pizza has a devoted following among students and locals alike.
What makes this place special is the generous portions at reasonable prices. College budgets appreciate the value, but the quality keeps everyone coming back.
The atmosphere is casual and lively, especially during the school year when Ohio University students pack the place. The energy is contagious, and the staff keeps things running smoothly even during rushes.
Their late-night hours make them a favorite destination after studying, concerts, or just hanging out. Nothing beats hot pizza at midnight when you are young and hungry.
The location near campus means parking can be challenging, but the pizza is worth a short walk. The surrounding area offers other entertainment options, making it easy to spend an evening in Athens.
February brings a slight lull between semesters, offering the perfect opportunity to enjoy their pizza without fighting student crowds. The locals reclaim their favorite pizzeria, if only temporarily.
Address: 329 E State St, Athens, Ohio.