13 Ohio All-You-Can-Eat Buffets Where Desserts Steal The Spotlight
Ohio buffets have a sneaky way of convincing me I’m “just browsing,” only for me to end up balancing a plate that’s suspiciously heavy on pie. I’ve learned the hard way that the smartest move is pacing myself, because the real grand finale always waits under those glass dessert domes.
These spots understand something important: nobody brags about the green beans, but everyone remembers the slice that made them pause mid-bite. From Amish kitchens to colorful fusion counters, the sweet selections here don’t whisper for attention, they confidently steal it.
If you’ve ever promised yourself “just one small slice,” Ohio is ready to test your willpower. These buffets prove dessert isn’t the ending but the reason you showed up in the first place.
1. Berlin Farmstead Restaurant, Berlin
Tucked into the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country, this family-run spot serves up comfort food with a side of genuine hospitality that’ll make you feel right at home.
The dessert spread here is nothing short of legendary. Homemade pies line the counter in flavors that change with the seasons, from classic apple crumb to creamy coconut cream.
Fresh-baked cookies sit alongside cakes so moist they practically melt on your tongue. The shoofly pie alone is worth the drive, with its gooey molasses filling and crumbly topping that tastes like childhood memories.
What really sets this place apart is the authenticity. Everything is made from scratch using traditional Amish recipes passed down through generations.
The soft-serve ice cream station lets you pile on toppings until your cone looks more like a sculpture. Families pack the dining room during weekend lunch rushes, and for good reason.
The all-you-can-eat format means you can sample every single dessert without feeling guilty. By the time you leave, you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even reached your car.
Address: 4757 Township Rd 366, Berlin, OH 44610
2. Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery, Walnut Creek
Walking into this Walnut Creek establishment feels like stepping into your grandmother’s kitchen, assuming she happened to be an incredible baker with unlimited counter space.
The buffet here stretches impressively long, but everyone knows the real action happens at the dessert end. Broasted chicken and mashed potatoes are fine, but those towering cream pies demand your attention.
Peanut butter pie topped with chocolate shavings sits next to cherry crumb and banana cream varieties that could win state fair ribbons. The cinnamon rolls are bigger than your fist and drizzled with icing that’s sweet without being cloying.
During peak hours, the staff constantly replenishes the dessert station because items disappear that quickly. The soft-serve machine offers vanilla and chocolate swirl options, plus a toppings bar with everything from crushed Oreos to hot fudge.
What makes this buffet special is the bakery attached to the restaurant. They bake everything on-site daily, so nothing tastes stale or mass-produced.
The apple dumplings are particularly noteworthy, served warm with a buttery sauce that pools around them perfectly. You’ll want to loosen your belt before tackling the dessert section.
Address: 4967 Walnut St, Walnut Creek, OH 44687
3. Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery, Sugarcreek
Sugarcreek’s answer to dessert heaven operates out of a charming building that looks exactly like what you’d expect from Ohio Amish Country.
The buffet line moves quickly during lunch, but most folks slow down considerably once they reach the sweets. Layers upon layers of cake varieties tempt you from glass-domed stands.
German chocolate cake competes for attention with red velvet and carrot cake so dense with cream cheese frosting it could qualify as its own food group. The fruit pies change based on what’s in season, meaning summer brings fresh strawberry-rhubarb while fall delivers pumpkin perfection.
Puddings and custards fill small bowls for those who prefer creamy over cakey. The bread pudding deserves special mention, studded with raisins and drowned in vanilla sauce.
Kids make a beeline for the soft-serve station, while adults tend to hover near the pie selection, debating whether to try one slice or three. The brownie bites are dangerously addictive, fudgy in the center with slightly crisp edges.
Staff members keep the dessert area immaculately clean and fully stocked. Even on busy Saturdays, you’ll never find an empty tray for long.
Address: 1343 Old Route 39 NE, Sugarcreek, OH 44681
4. Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery, Plain City
Plain City might not sound exciting, but this Der Dutchman location proves that great desserts can emerge from anywhere.
The buffet setup here feels more spacious than some other locations, giving you plenty of room to contemplate your sweet choices. Pies dominate the landscape, with meringue-topped options towering high enough to catch your eye from across the room.
Lemon meringue balances tart and sweet perfectly, while coconut cream delivers tropical vibes even in the middle of winter. The pecan pie is loaded with nuts and comes drizzled with caramel that adds extra richness.
Cookies are piled high on platters, including snickerdoodles, chocolate chip, and oatmeal raisin varieties that actually taste good. The cake selection rotates, but you can usually count on finding chocolate, white, and some kind of fruit-based option.
What really shines here is the attention to presentation. Desserts aren’t just dumped onto trays but arranged attractively with garnishes and proper spacing.
The soft-serve machine works flawlessly, producing perfectly swirled cones that hold their shape. Families appreciate the kid-friendly atmosphere, while couples enjoy the quieter weekday lunch crowds.
Every visit feels like a special occasion when dessert looks this good.
Address: 445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
5. Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery, Bellville
Bellville’s Der Dutchman sits along a scenic route that makes the drive part of the experience, though the desserts alone justify the trip.
This location has perfected the art of fruit cobblers, serving them warm with crispy golden tops that crackle under your spoon. Peach cobbler appears during summer months, while apple takes over when autumn arrives.
The pie selection mirrors other Der Dutchman locations but somehow tastes even better here. Maybe it’s the small-town charm or the fact that bakers seem to put extra love into each creation.
Chocolate lovers gravitate toward the triple-layer chocolate cake, which features three distinct types of chocolate in perfect harmony. The strawberry shortcake uses actual biscuits instead of sponge cake, topped with fresh berries and real whipped cream.
Pudding parfaits layered in clear cups show off their colorful stripes, making them almost too pretty to eat. The butterscotch version tastes like liquid comfort.
During holiday seasons, special desserts appear that you won’t find any other time of year. Pumpkin roll at Thanksgiving and peppermint bark brownies around Christmas keep regulars coming back.
The soft-serve ice cream here runs extra cold and creamy, perfect for topping warm pie slices.
Address: 720 State Route 97 W, Bellville, OH 44813
6. Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen, Mount Hope
The most beloved buffet in Mount Hope operates with the kind of warmth that makes strangers feel like family members showing up for Sunday dinner.
Mrs. Yoder’s has built a reputation on generous portions and authentic Amish cooking, but the dessert spread is where things get truly memorable. Pies here come in varieties you won’t find at chain restaurants.
Sour cream raisin pie might sound unusual, but one bite converts skeptics into believers. The custard is silky smooth with plump raisins throughout and a flaky crust that shatters perfectly.
Chocolate peanut butter pie delivers exactly what its name promises, with layers so rich you’ll need a glass of cold water nearby. The fruit pies use real fruit filling, not the gelatinous stuff from cans.
Cakes sit on elevated stands, showcasing everything from classic yellow cake with chocolate frosting to more adventurous options like pineapple upside-down cake. The carrot cake comes loaded with walnuts and topped with cream cheese frosting applied with a generous hand.
Rice pudding and tapioca appear in serving bowls for those who prefer something lighter. The bread pudding here rivals any you’ve tasted, served warm with a bourbon sauce that’s family-friendly but full of flavor.
Address: 8101 State Route 241, Mount Hope, OH 44660
7. Golden Corral Buffet & Grill, Whitehall
Chain restaurants often get dismissed, but this Whitehall location takes its dessert game seriously enough to compete with standalone bakeries.
The chocolate wonderfall fountain becomes the centerpiece of the dessert area, with strawberries, marshmallows, and cookies waiting to be dipped. Kids treat it like a attraction, but adults secretly love it just as much.
Soft-serve machines offer vanilla, chocolate, and swirl options, but the real fun comes from the toppings bar. Crushed candy bars, gummy bears, sprinkles, hot fudge, caramel sauce, and whipped cream let you build sundaes that would cost fifteen dollars at an ice cream shop.
The bakery section rotates daily, featuring everything from brownies and blondies to decorated sugar cookies. Carrot cake, German chocolate cake, and red velvet appear regularly, all moist and generously frosted.
Cotton candy gets spun fresh throughout the day, adding a carnival atmosphere to the dining room. The banana pudding tastes homemade despite the restaurant’s size, layered with vanilla wafers that soften just right.
What makes this spot work is the constant replenishment. Desserts never sit long enough to dry out or get stale.
Staff members keep everything looking fresh and appealing, even during the dinner rush.
Address: 4750 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213
8. Golden Corral Buffet & Grill, Toledo
Toledo’s Golden Corral brings the same dessert enthusiasm as other locations but adds its own local flair to the experience.
The dessert bar here stretches impressively long, giving you almost too many choices to process. Pies include classics like apple and cherry alongside more unique options that change weekly.
Key lime pie makes regular appearances, tart and creamy with a graham cracker crust that stays crisp. The pecan pie comes loaded with nuts and just sweet enough without crossing into candy territory.
Cookies are baked throughout the day, so you can often snag them while they’re still warm. Chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and sugar cookies all make appearances, along with seasonal varieties during holidays.
The soft-serve station here runs smoothly, rarely breaking down even during peak hours. Building your own sundae becomes an art form when you have access to a dozen different toppings.
Cake varieties rotate but always include at least one chocolate option and one fruity choice. The strawberry cake with cream cheese frosting tastes lighter than it looks, perfect for finishing a heavy meal.
Brownies and lemon bars sit on separate trays, offering handheld options for those who want dessert without committing to a full plate. Everything stays fresh because turnover happens quickly.
Address: 5730 Opportunity Dr, Toledo, OH 43612
9. Kumo Japanese Seafood Buffet, Parma
Kumo brings Asian-inspired sweets to the buffet scene, offering desserts that feel refreshingly different from typical American options.
The dessert section here looks like an art installation, with colorful mochi balls arranged by flavor and small cakes decorated with precision. Green tea ice cream sits alongside more familiar vanilla and chocolate varieties.
Mochi comes in strawberry, mango, and red bean flavors, each one chewy and sweet with ice cream centers. If you’ve never tried mochi before, this buffet offers the perfect low-risk introduction.
Fruit tarts feature fresh kiwi, strawberries, and mandarin oranges arranged in geometric patterns on custard bases. They taste lighter than American pies, perfect for cleansing your palate after sushi and seafood.
Small cakes appear in individual portions, making it easy to sample multiple flavors without waste. Matcha cake offers earthy sweetness, while black sesame cake delivers nutty richness that surprises first-timers.
The soft-serve machine here dispenses green tea and vanilla flavors that swirl together beautifully. Toppings include mochi bits, fruit sauces, and crushed cookies.
What sets Kumo apart is the presentation. Desserts are arranged with the same care as the sushi, making the buffet feel upscale despite the casual pricing.
Every visit introduces you to something new and delicious.
Address: 1975 Snow Rd, Parma, OH 44134
10. Supreme Buffet Sushi & Hibachi, Columbus
Columbus diners flock to this spot for the sushi and hibachi, but the dessert selection keeps them coming back week after week.
The buffet layout puts desserts right near the exit, ensuring you can’t miss them even if you wanted to. Small cakes in paper cups make portion control easy while letting you try multiple flavors.
Chocolate mousse cups are rich and airy, topped with chocolate shavings that add texture. Cheesecake bites come in plain, strawberry, and chocolate varieties, all creamy with graham cracker bases.
Soft-serve ice cream flows from dual machines, one dispensing vanilla and chocolate while the other offers green tea and strawberry. The flavor combinations you can create are nearly endless.
Fresh fruit appears throughout the dessert area, including watermelon, pineapple, and cantaloupe cut into neat cubes. It provides a refreshing option between richer sweets.
Cookies and brownies sit on trays near the ice cream station, perfect for crumbling over your sundae. The fortune cookies are fresher than most, still crisp enough to snap cleanly.
Gelatin desserts wobble in individual cups, flavored with everything from orange to lychee. They’re fun and light, ideal for kids or anyone who wants something sweet without feeling stuffed.
The variety here ensures everyone finds something they love.
Address: 1323 W St James Lutheran Ln, Columbus, OH 43228
11. Tokyo Grill Sushi & Hibachi Buffet, Columbus
Another Columbus entry proves the city takes its buffet desserts seriously, with Tokyo Grill offering an impressive sweet spread that rivals the savory options.
The dessert area here feels more spacious than some competitors, giving you room to browse without bumping elbows with other diners. Small cakes are arranged by type, making it easy to spot your favorites.
Tiramisu cups deliver coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream in perfect ratios. The green tea tiramisu offers a unique twist that tastes surprisingly good.
Soft-serve machines here run extra cold, producing ice cream with ideal texture that doesn’t melt into soup before you reach your table. Green tea, vanilla, chocolate, and mango flavors rotate throughout the week.
Fruit tarts are restocked constantly, ensuring the fruit stays fresh and the custard doesn’t develop a skin. Strawberry, kiwi, and blueberry versions all taste bright and clean.
Mochi selection includes more exotic flavors like lychee and passion fruit alongside traditional options. Each one is perfectly chewy with creamy centers.
Cookies and brownies provide familiar comfort for those not adventurous enough to try Asian sweets. The chocolate chip cookies taste homemade, with gooey centers and crispy edges.
Whether you prefer traditional American desserts or want to explore Asian options, this buffet delivers both with equal skill.
Address: 8491 Sancus Blvd, Columbus, OH 43240
12. Kintaro All You Can Eat Sushi & Hot Pot, Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s Kintaro elevates the buffet experience with a focus on quality that extends from the hot pot to the dessert station.
The sweets here look almost too pretty to eat, arranged with the precision of a high-end bakery. Small cakes come in flavors that change seasonally, keeping the menu fresh and interesting.
Matcha cheesecake combines earthy green tea with tangy cream cheese in a way that shouldn’t work but absolutely does. The texture is silky smooth, melting on your tongue instantly.
Mochi balls are made in-house daily, resulting in fresher texture than most buffets offer. Flavors include traditional red bean, modern mango, and unexpected black sesame.
The soft-serve station dispenses premium ice cream that tastes richer than typical buffet offerings. Toppings include fresh fruit, mochi pieces, and Asian candy bits.
Fruit displays feature exotic options like dragon fruit and lychee alongside familiar strawberries and grapes. Everything is cut perfectly and stays fresh throughout service.
What makes Kintaro special is the commitment to quality over quantity. The dessert selection isn’t the largest, but every item tastes exceptional.
You’ll leave satisfied without feeling overstuffed.
The presentation alone makes you want to photograph your plate before digging in. This is buffet dining for people who appreciate the finer details.
Address: 7325 Northcliff Ave, Brooklyn, OH 44144
13. Hibachi Sushi Supreme Buffet, Warren
Finally, Warren’s premier Asian buffet saves some of its best offerings for the dessert section, where East meets West in delicious harmony.
The layout here puts desserts front and center, impossible to miss as you enter the dining area. It’s strategic placement that ensures everyone at least considers ending their meal with something sweet.
Soft-serve machines offer four flavors simultaneously, including the standard vanilla and chocolate plus green tea and strawberry. The swirl combinations you can create are limited only by your imagination.
Small cakes are portioned perfectly for sampling multiple varieties without commitment. Red velvet, carrot cake, and chocolate mousse cake all make regular appearances, each one moist and properly frosted.
Mochi comes in a rainbow of colors, each hue representing a different flavor. The texture is consistently chewy without being tough, with ice cream centers that stay frozen until you bite through.
Fresh fruit is cut into fun shapes, making healthy choices feel more exciting. Pineapple flowers and watermelon stars appeal to kids and adults equally.
Cookies and brownies provide familiar comfort, while Asian desserts like egg tarts and sesame balls offer adventure for the curious. The variety ensures every family member finds multiple options they enjoy.
It’s this balance that keeps locals returning week after week.
Address: 4379 Mahoning Ave NW, Warren, OH 44483