12 Pennsylvania Amish Grocery Stores Beloved For Their Homemade Culinary Treats
Rolling farmland and rich traditions define the state, and nowhere is that heritage more delicious than inside an Amish grocery store in Pennsylvania.
Walk through the door and you are greeted by the warm scent of fresh baked bread, cinnamon kissed pies cooling on racks, and jars of preserves lined up like edible jewels.
Call it homemade heaven, a pantry full of tradition, a taste of simple living done right.
Wooden shelves hold hand rolled noodles, creamy cheeses, and baked goods crafted with time honored care. Shopping here feels different from the usual supermarket rush.
Conversations are unhurried, ingredients are familiar, and recipes have been perfected over generations. Pennsylvania charm shines through every loaf and every jar.
First time I visited one of these stores, I told myself I would grab a pie and head out.
Instead, I left with a basket full of treats and the comforting feeling that some of the best flavors still come from kitchens where quality always comes first.
1. The Markets at Shrewsbury, PA
Stepping through the doors at 12025 Susquehanna Trail South in Glen Rock feels like entering a treasure trove of handcrafted goodness.
Vendors from various Amish and Mennonite communities gather here to sell their specialties, creating a vibrant marketplace atmosphere where you can chat directly with the people who bake, pickle, and preserve everything on display.
Fresh pretzels emerge from ovens throughout the day, filling the air with a yeasty warmth that makes it impossible to leave empty-handed.
Shelves overflow with jars of chow-chow, apple butter, and pickled vegetables in every imaginable variety.
I once bought a loaf of cinnamon raisin bread here that disappeared within hours of getting home.
The deli counter serves hearty sandwiches piled high with meats sliced to order, while the bulk foods section offers everything from spices to candy by the pound.
Located conveniently off Route 851, this market draws both locals and travelers seeking authentic Pennsylvania Dutch flavors in a welcoming, no-frills setting.
2. Bristol Amish Market, PA
Positioned at 498 Green Lane in Bristol, this market brings Lancaster County traditions to Bucks County shoppers every Friday and Saturday.
Multiple vendors operate individual stalls under one roof, each specializing in different homemade products that showcase the diversity of Amish culinary skills.
Bakery stands tempt visitors with shoofly pie, whoopie pies, and dinner rolls that practically beg to be torn apart while still warm.
Meat counters display fresh cuts alongside homemade sausages and bacon cured using old-world methods.
The cheese selection rivals any specialty shop, with blocks of sharp cheddar and creamy spreads made on Amish farms.
I always grab a container of their chicken corn soup when I visit because it tastes exactly like the version my Pennsylvania grandmother used to make.
Fresh produce arrives weekly from family farms, ensuring seasonal variety throughout the year.
The market’s location near Philadelphia makes it accessible for city dwellers craving a countryside shopping experience without the long drive.
3. Westtown Amish Market, PA
Situated at 1165 Wilmington Pike in West Chester, this market operates on a schedule that keeps regulars coming back like clockwork.
Open Thursday through Saturday, it draws crowds who know that arriving early means first pick of the freshly baked goods and specialty items that sell out quickly.
The butcher counter offers custom cuts prepared while you wait, along with house-made scrapple that locals swear by for weekend breakfasts.
Baked goods range from simple white bread to elaborate fruit pies topped with lattice crusts that look almost too pretty to eat.
Bulk bins line entire aisles, letting shoppers stock up on baking supplies, dried fruits, nuts, and grains at prices that make sense for families.
The prepared foods section saves dinner on busy weeknights with ready-to-heat options like stuffed peppers and pot pie filling.
Chester County residents appreciate having this authentic market so close to home, eliminating the need to trek to Lancaster for genuine Amish products and that personal touch missing from chain grocery stores.
4. Peight’s Country Store, PA
Hidden away at 136 Peight Store Lane in Belleville, this family-run establishment sits in the heart of Big Valley, home to one of Pennsylvania’s most traditional Amish communities.
The journey to get here winds through farmland dotted with buggies and laundry flapping on clotheslines, setting the stage for an authentic shopping experience.
Inside, the store maintains an old-fashioned general store vibe with creaky wooden floors and shelves packed floor to ceiling.
Their deli serves sandwiches made with meats smoked on-site, creating flavors you simply cannot replicate with store-bought ingredients.
Bulk foods dominate one entire section, offering everything from soup mixes to baking chocolate at prices that seem frozen in time.
I particularly love their selection of locally made noodles, which come in wider varieties than I knew existed.
The store also carries hardware, fabric, and household goods, functioning as a true community hub where neighbors catch up while shopping.
Visiting Peight’s feels like stepping back several decades to when shopping meant knowing the person behind the counter by name.
5. Centerville Bulk Foods, PA
Located at 3501 Scenic Road in Gordonville, this no-nonsense bulk foods specialist caters to serious home cooks and bakers who appreciate quality ingredients at fair prices.
The store’s layout prioritizes function over flash, with clearly labeled bins and helpful staff who actually know their products.
Baking enthusiasts find everything needed for scratch cooking, from specialty flours to hard-to-find ingredients like citric acid and cream of tartar.
The spice selection puts supermarket offerings to shame, with fresh ground options that actually smell potent when you open the containers.
Dried fruits, nuts, and trail mix components let you create custom blends instead of settling for pre-mixed versions loaded with fillers.
Every third visit, I stock up on their coconut oil and pure maple syrup because the prices make bulk buying worthwhile.
The store also carries natural cleaning products, vitamins, and supplements alongside food items.
Gordonville’s location in the heart of Lancaster County means you can easily combine a shopping trip here with visits to nearby farms and attractions along the scenic backroads.
6. Esh’s Grocery & Deli, PA
Just down the road at 3732 East Newport Road in Gordonville, this family-owned spot combines grocery shopping with made-to-order deli service that keeps the lunch crowd happy.
The Esh family runs a tight operation where freshness and customer service take priority over everything else.
Their deli counter churns out sandwiches built on homemade rolls that put chain sub shops to shame.
Roast beef gets sliced thick, cheese comes in generous portions, and vegetables actually taste like they were picked recently.
The grocery section stocks all the Amish staples including canned goods, baking supplies, and locally produced items you won’t find elsewhere.
I stumbled upon their homemade granola during one visit and now keep a bag in my pantry at all times because it beats any store-bought version.
Prepared salads like macaroni and potato varieties make perfect picnic additions or quick side dishes.
The store maintains reasonable hours throughout the week, making it convenient for both tourists passing through and local families doing regular shopping in this bustling Amish community hub.
7. Miller’s Natural Foods, PA
Located at 2888 Miller Lane in Bird-in-Hand in Lancaster, this store takes a different approach by focusing on natural and organic products alongside traditional Amish goods.
Health-conscious shoppers appreciate finding clean-label items in a setting that still maintains that authentic country market charm.
Organic produce arrives fresh from local farms committed to sustainable growing practices. The selection changes with the seasons, ensuring you’re eating what grows naturally in Pennsylvania at any given time.
Supplements, vitamins, and natural remedies line dedicated shelves for those seeking alternatives to conventional options.
The store also carries grass-fed meats, free-range eggs, and dairy products from cows raised without antibiotics or hormones.
I appreciate their commitment to transparency about sourcing, with signs explaining where products come from and how they’re produced.
Bulk bins offer organic grains, beans, and nuts for shoppers wanting to avoid packaging waste.
The bakery section still delivers traditional treats but also accommodates dietary restrictions with gluten-free and sugar-free options.
Bird-in-Hand’s very tourist-friendly village location makes this an easy stop while exploring Lancaster County’s attractions.
8. Bird-in-Hand Farmers Market, PA
Operating at 2710 Old Philadelphia Pike in Bird-in-Hand in Lancaster, this market buzzes with activity on Fridays and Saturdays when vendors set up stalls overflowing with farm-fresh products.
The building houses multiple independent sellers, creating a festival atmosphere where shopping becomes entertainment.
Fresh produce vendors compete to offer the best tomatoes, corn, and seasonal fruits picked at peak ripeness.
Bakery stalls display pies, cakes, and cookies that showcase different family recipes and baking styles.
The meat and cheese sections feature products made by various Amish families, giving shoppers a wider selection than single-vendor markets.
I once spent an hour just sampling different cheese varieties before making my selections, and the vendors never rushed me.
Prepared food stands serve hot meals perfect for lunch, from barbecue to traditional Pennsylvania Dutch dishes. Crafts and handmade items add non-food shopping opportunities, making this a one-stop destination.
The market’s reputation draws visitors from across the region, so arriving early ensures better parking and first access to limited-quantity items that sell out fast.
9. Shady Maple Farm Market, PA
Standing at 1324 Main Street in East Earl, this sprawling complex includes not just a market but also a famous smorgasbord restaurant that draws tour buses from neighboring states.
The farm market section alone could occupy an entire afternoon with its vast selection of products.
Freshly baked goods emerge from ovens throughout the day, with sticky buns that have achieved legendary status among regular customers.
The produce section resembles a small farmers market indoors, with seasonal fruits and vegetables displayed in attractive arrangements.
Bulk foods take up significant floor space, offering everything from baking ingredients to snacks in quantities that make sense for large families.
The meat counter provides custom butchering services alongside pre-packaged options, all sourced from local farms.
During my last visit, I watched them grind fresh hamburger to order, something you rarely see anymore.
The gift shop area sells Pennsylvania Dutch souvenirs, cookbooks, and specialty food items perfect for taking home or shipping to friends.
Ample parking accommodates the crowds that flock here, especially during peak tourist season when the market becomes a must-visit Lancaster County destination.
10. Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe, PA
Situated at 4040 Old Philadelphia Pike in Gordonville, this working dairy farm lets visitors experience where their food actually comes from while enjoying some of the freshest dairy products available.
The Lapp family welcomes guests to visit the farm setting and see contented cows before sampling the results.
Ice cream made from milk produced right on the farm comes in classic and creative flavors that change seasonally.
The texture differs from commercial brands because of the higher butterfat content and minimal processing time between cow and cone.
The cafe serves light meals, sandwiches, and baked goods that pair perfectly with their signature milkshakes.
Fresh milk, cream, butter, and cheese are available for purchase, all produced on-site using traditional methods.
I bring my kids here specifically because they can connect their food to actual animals and farming, something increasingly rare in our modern world.
The creamery also keeps things simple, making it a family destination beyond just shopping, with seating for a quick treat.
Gordonville’s location provides easy access from major routes while maintaining that rural farm atmosphere that defines authentic Amish country experiences.
11. Hershey’s Farm Market, PA
Found at 959 South Octorara Trail in Parkesburg, this market serves the western edge of Pennsylvania Dutch Country with the same quality products found deeper in Amish territory.
The Hershey family (no relation to the chocolate company) has operated this stand for generations, building a loyal customer base through consistency and fair dealing.
Seasonal produce dominates during growing months, with corn, tomatoes, and melons that actually taste like something because they’re picked ripe instead of shipped green.
The canning and preserving section offers jars of everything from bread-and-butter pickles to pepper relish made using old family recipes.
Baked goods appear fresh daily, with pies that sell out by early afternoon on weekends. Their pumpkin whoopie pies have become my fall tradition, marking the season change better than any calendar.
The market also stocks local honey, maple syrup, and other artisan products from neighboring farms.
Parkesburg’s location near the Chester County border makes this a convenient stop for shoppers coming from Philadelphia or Delaware who want authentic Amish products without driving all the way to Lancaster, proving that quality handmade goods exist throughout Pennsylvania’s countryside.
12. Green Dragon Farmers Market & Auction, PA
Operating at 955 North State Street in Ephrata every Friday, this legendary market and auction combines food shopping with livestock sales and flea market finds in a chaotic, wonderful explosion of rural commerce.
Arriving early means witnessing the auction action before settling into serious shopping mode.
Food vendors occupy permanent stalls and temporary tables, selling everything from fresh produce to complete meals served hot.
The variety exceeds most markets because of the sheer number of sellers competing for attention.
Baked goods come from dozens of different Amish families, each bringing their own specialties and secret recipes.
The meat and cheese selection spans multiple vendors, letting you compare products and prices before committing.
I love the competitive atmosphere here because it keeps quality high and prices reasonable as vendors work to attract repeat customers.
Beyond food, you’ll find tools, furniture, plants, and random treasures that make browsing an adventure. The outdoor setting adds to the authentic farmers market experience, though weather can impact your visit.
Green Dragon represents old-school market culture where bargaining is expected and relationships matter more than transactions, preserving traditions that have defined Pennsylvania commerce for centuries.