12 Akron, Ohio Pizza Spots That Are Surprisingly Affordable And Good
I love a good pizza night, but choosing where to order in Akron can be surprisingly difficult.
There are so many neighborhood pizzerias around the city that sticking to the same familiar place almost feels like missing out.
I’ve always been curious about the smaller shops, especially those that have kept locals coming back for decades.
Sometimes the most interesting finds are the places people recommend without even having to think about it.
And while looking into Akron’s pizza scene, I came across a few surprises.
A personal cheese pizza for around $4? That’s certainly enough to catch my attention, although a good deal means much more when the pizza itself delivers.
What I find especially interesting is how much personality these local places bring to their menus.
Some have perfected their signature crusts, while others aren’t afraid to experiment with something different.
These 12 Akron, Ohio pizza spots are worth exploring, and a few might even challenge your usual favorites.
The hardest part could be deciding which one gets your first order.
1. Fiesta Pizza And Chicken, Akron
Some places sell pizza, and some places sell memories with a side of chicken.
Fiesta Pizza and Chicken in Akron has been feeding the Goodyear Heights neighborhood since 1963. That is more than six decades of dough tossing, which is honestly longer than most of my kitchen pans have survived.
The family behind the counter keeps things simple and steady. You get classic pizzas with a reliable crust, crispy fried chicken, and the famous JoJo potatoes.
Those thick, seasoned wedges are a Northeast Ohio thing, and Fiesta does them right.
My move here is a family-sized combo. It covers pizza, chicken, and JoJos in one box, so nobody at home argues about dinner.
Keep an eye on the rotating daily specials, too. They change during the week and often stretch your dollars further than you might expect.
Takeout is the main event here, so call ahead on busy nights. Friday evenings bring a steady line of hungry neighbors who clearly know the drill.
Fiesta proves that a good recipe never needs a makeover, just a hungry crowd.
Address: 1860 Newton St, Akron, OH 44305
2. Guiseppe’s Pizza, Akron
Four dollars. That is the price of a 6-inch cheese pizza at Guiseppe’s Pizza in Akron, and yes, I double-checked.
Tucked into the Portage Lakes area, this family-owned spot is a budget champion. A 9-inch pizza costs about $7.50, and a 12-inch runs around $12.50.
The crust is thin and crisp, the kind that snaps a little when you fold a slice. Toppings are piled on with a generous hand, so even the small sizes feel filling.
I love the 6-inch for a solo lunch. It is personal pizza without the personal debt.
The specialty combinations are worth a look if you want something beyond pepperoni. Ask the staff what is popular, because the regulars clearly have favorites.
Families can mix sizes, too. Kids get their own tiny pie, and the adults split a bigger one with more adventurous toppings.
After a summer afternoon by the lakes, few things beat a warm box from this place. Guiseppe’s turns pocket change into a pizza party, and I am here for every cheesy cent of it.
Address: 14 E Caston Rd, Akron, OH 44319
3. Rasicci’s Pizza, Akron
Forty years is a long time to keep an oven warm. Rasicci’s Pizza has done it with style.
This neighborhood shop in Akron serves traditional pizzas, deep-dish varieties, chicken, and JoJo potatoes. It feels like the kind of place your uncle swears by, and for once, your uncle is right.
The prices are refreshingly honest. A small cheese pizza is listed at $8, and a large is $12 on the direct-order menu.
I went for the small deep dish on my first visit. It arrived thick, soft inside, and golden on the bottom, with cheese stretching off every slice.
Deep dish usually costs a pretty penny, so this felt like a small victory. My second visit ended with chicken and JoJos joining the party.
Ordering directly from the shop is the smart play. You see the real prices and support a local business at the same time.
The staff keeps things quick and friendly, even during the dinner rush. Rasicci’s is proof that four decades of practice really does make pizza close to perfect.
Address: 513 E Cuyahoga Falls Ave, Akron, OH 44310
4. Talamo’s Pizza, Akron
Kenmore Boulevard has character, and Talamo’s Pizza fits right in.
This casual Akron pizzeria makes its dough fresh, and you can taste the difference in every chewy bite. The toppings land heavy, which is exactly how I like them.
Cheese pizzas start around $10.28, a fair price for a pie this filling. The real savings, though, hide in the weekday specials.
I stopped by on a Tuesday and nearly cheered at the deals. Pizza-and-chicken packages make feeding a whole crew much less stressful on your budget.
Specialty pizzas are on the menu for anyone feeling bold. I tried one loaded with meats, and I needed a short nap afterward.
The vibe is relaxed and neighborly. Nobody rushes you, and the staff seems happy to explain the combos if you look confused, like I did.
A tip from me to you: check the specials before you order. The best value often shows up on certain days, and planning ahead pays off.
Talamo’s keeps Kenmore well fed, one fresh crust at a time, and I plan to keep showing up hungry.
Address: 1195 Kenmore Blvd, Akron, OH 44314
5. San Marino Italian Restaurant, Akron
Grandma-style cooking does not usually come with a twelve-dollar price tag. San Marino Italian Restaurant breaks that rule happily.
Located in the Ellet neighborhood of Akron, this family-owned spot serves homemade-style Italian food. The portions are generous enough to guarantee leftovers.
Pizza lovers will find a small cheese pie for $9 and a large for $12 on the direct-order menu. For a sit-down Italian restaurant, those numbers made me blink twice.
The sauce has a warm, slightly sweet flavor. It tastes like someone has been making it the same way for years and sees no reason to change.
Calzones deserve a shout too. Mine arrived puffy and golden, packed with cheese that escaped the moment I cut in.
Specialty pizzas add more choices if plain cheese feels too tame. I suggest bringing a friend so you can split two and try more.
The atmosphere is comfortable and unfussy, perfect for a weeknight dinner. Kids, grandparents, and picky eaters all seem to find something.
San Marino makes Ellet smell like a Sunday supper every single day of the week.
Address: 3071 Albrecht Ave, Akron, OH 44312
6. Pizza 77 On Main, Akron
Lunch breaks are short, and downtown prices can be steep. Pizza 77 On Main solves both problems nicely.
This downtown Akron takeout spot advertises a two-slice daily special for just $5. I tested it on a busy workday and was back at my desk with time to spare.
The slices are big and foldable, with a crust that holds up to toppings. It is the kind of quick meal that actually keeps you full until dinner.
Beyond slices, the menu offers traditional pizzas and creative specialty combinations. Some of the combos sound wild, but the ones I tried worked surprisingly well.
Chicken and JoJo meals are on the menu too. Pair them with a pizza for an evening feast that feels very Akron.
Ordering online is easy and saves you standing around. The staff moves fast, which matters when your stomach is growling louder than traffic.
A friend from South Carolina tagged along once and asked if all Akron lunches were this cheap. Sadly, no, but this one sure is.
Pizza 77 turns a five-dollar bill into the best part of a Tuesday.
Address: 374 S Main St, Akron, OH 44311
7. DeCheco’s Pizzeria, Akron
White pizza fans, gather around. DeCheco’s Pizzeria has something you need to try.
This family-owned shop in the Firestone Park area of Akron is known for its Famous White Pizza. It skips the red sauce and leans into rich, creamy, garlicky goodness.
I ordered it out of curiosity and finished it out of pure loyalty. The dough is freshly made, soft inside and lightly crisp outside.
Prices are reasonable for the quality. A 9-inch cheese pizza costs $10, a 12-inch is $15, and a 14-inch runs about $17.
The specialty pies get creative with toppings. They cost a bit more, but the 9-inch size makes testing new flavors easy on your wallet.
My advice is to start small with the white pizza. Once you are hooked, size up next time and share with someone you trust.
The neighborhood setting gives it a homey, local feel. Families come and go, and the staff often greets regulars by name.
DeCheco’s reminds me that sometimes the best pizza decision is skipping the tomato sauce completely.
Address: 2075 S Main St, Akron, OH 44301
8. Pizza Bella, Akron
Late-night cravings deserve respect. Pizza Bella treats them like VIP guests.
This small neighborhood pizzeria on East Avenue in Akron stays open later than many shops. That alone has saved more than one of my hungry evenings.
The pizzas come generously topped, with crusts that stay crisp from first bite to last. Even reheated the next morning, they held up better than I expected.
Chicken-and-JoJo combinations are a big hit here. The chicken is flavorful and crunchy, and the JoJos soak up every bit of seasoning.
Portions are hefty, so one order can easily stretch across two meals. That is how a reasonable price turns into a fantastic deal.
Service is friendly and quick. The folks behind the counter seem genuinely happy to see you, even near closing time.
I recommend calling ahead if you are picking up late. It keeps the wait short and gets that box into your hands faster.
Akron locals clearly know about this place, judging by the steady flow of pickups. Pizza Bella is the friend who still answers the door after everyone else has gone to bed.
Address: 2473 East Ave, Akron, OH 44314
9. Regina’s Pizza, Akron
Handmade dough has a certain bounce to it. Regina’s Pizza has mastered that bounce.
This longtime family-owned pizzeria in Akron sticks to traditional Italian-American recipes. The dough is made by hand, and the sauce is cooked in-house.
You can taste the care right away. The sauce is bright and savory, and the cheese melts into it without drowning anything.
Toppings are generous without being sloppy. Every slice I grabbed held together, which is a small miracle with this much pepperoni.
Do not skip the meatball sandwich. It is a classic for a reason, stuffed with tender meatballs and plenty of sauce.
Many locals say Regina’s beats the big chains on value. After comparing my receipt to a chain order from last month, I agree.
The atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed. It is the type of place where kids stare at the oven like it is a magic show.
Stop by when you want pizza that tastes like someone actually cares. Regina’s serves tradition by the slice, and tradition never tasted so reasonably priced.
Address: 2160 East Ave, Akron, OH 44314
10. Galluch’s Pizza, Akron
Strombolis rarely get enough love. At Galluch’s Pizza, they finally get the spotlight.
This family-owned shop sits on Manchester Road in southern Akron. It offers traditional pizzas, specialty combinations, strombolis, and hearty salads.
My stromboli arrived golden and tightly rolled, with meat and cheese in every bite. It was so filling that I saved half for lunch the next day.
The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying. Toppings are generous, and the crust has a nice balance of chew and crunch.
Salads here are not an afterthought, either. They are big enough to share and fresh enough to make you feel slightly virtuous next to your pizza.
Prices stay generally reasonable, making Galluch’s a smart alternative to big chains. You also get that neighborhood feel no chain can copy.
The shop itself is simple and no-nonsense. Nobody is trying to impress you with fancy decor, just with good food.
If you live south of downtown, keep this number saved in your phone. Galluch’s is the kind of reliable that turns first-time customers into weekly regulars.
Address: 5949 Manchester Rd, Akron, OH 44319
11. Parasson’s Italian Restaurant, Akron
Caramelized cheese edges are my weakness. Parasson’s Italian Restaurant knows exactly how to exploit it.
This longstanding Akron restaurant is famous for its pan pizzas. The cheese runs all the way to the edge and bakes into a golden, crispy crown.
Those crunchy corners are the best part. I caught myself eating the crust first, which has never happened before in my life.
A personal pizza is listed around $10.79 through online ordering. For something this distinctive, the price feels like a steal.
The inside of the crust stays soft and airy. That contrast with the crispy edge makes every bite interesting.
Parasson’s has been around long enough to build a devoted following. Families have been ordering here for years, and many swear nothing else compares.
Try it once with plain cheese to appreciate the crust. Then experiment with toppings on your next visit.
I told a buddy in South Carolina about these edges, and he now asks for photos every time I order. Parasson’s makes pizza crust the main character, and honestly, it deserves the role.
Address: 959 E Waterloo Rd, Akron, OH 44306
12. Totally Baked Pizza, Akron
Creativity runs wild at this downtown stop. Totally Baked Pizza treats toppings like an art supply box.
Located on North High Street in Akron, this pizzeria specializes in distinctive specialty pies. The menu is eclectic, playful, and a little unpredictable in the best way.
Build-your-own pizzas start around $11.80 on a delivery-platform menu. That gives you full control over your masterpiece without blowing your budget.
If decisions stress you out, a classic cheese pizza is always there. It is simple, melty, and dependable.
The specialty combinations are where things get fun. I tried one with toppings I would never pair at home, and it completely won me over.
Fresh ingredients make a real difference here. Veggies taste crisp, and the meats are flavorful without being greasy.
Downtown workers and late visitors both seem to love it. The location makes it easy to grab a pie after a show or a stroll.
Bring an open mind and maybe a friend who likes to share. Totally Baked is the perfect final stop on this tour, proving Akron pizza can be cheap, cheerful, and totally creative.
Address: 18 N High St, Akron, OH 44308