13 Cheap But Delicious Ohio Pizzerias Perfect For Family Night
Getting everyone to agree on dinner can be surprisingly difficult.
Someone wants pepperoni, someone insists on plain cheese, and I’m usually the one wondering how a simple pizza night became so complicated.
Then there’s the bill, which can get a little uncomfortable once everyone starts adding their favorite extras.
That’s why I appreciate Ohio pizzerias that offer genuinely good food without making a family dinner feel like a major expense.
Of course, cheap pizza isn’t much of a bargain if nobody enjoys eating it. I’d rather find a neighborhood spot that gets the basics right and offers enough food to satisfy everyone at the table.
Fortunately, Ohio has quite a few places that understand the assignment. Some offer family bundles that make ordering easier, while others have weekly specials worth remembering when dinner plans come around.
And if your family has an unusually big appetite, one pizzeria on this list serves a massive 30-inch pie.
At that point, the biggest challenge might be figuring out how to fit the box in your car.
1. Olde Town Pizza House, Amherst
Some pizza places feel like they have been waiting for your family to show up. Olde Town Pizza House has been doing exactly that in Amherst since 1986.
My kids are picky, but the menu here makes everyone happy. You can choose traditional, thin-crust, or deep-dish pizza, so nobody has to settle.
The 12-slice family-size cheese pizza starts at $17. That is a lot of slices for the price, and it leaves room in the budget for extras.
Little eaters get their own spotlight with mini pizzas on the children’s menu starting at $6. My youngest treats hers like a personal trophy.
Do not leave without trying the signature Woogie Bears. They are a local favorite, and they vanish from the table faster than you can ask for a second helping.
Homemade soups and calzones round out the menu for anyone craving something different. The dining room is casual and relaxed, so a little noise from the kids is no big deal.
Families here have been sharing pies for nearly four decades, and you can feel that history in the friendly service.
Plan on bringing a big appetite and leaving with a box of leftovers.
Address: 195 Cleveland Ave, Amherst, OH 44001
2. Pizza Dive, Beavercreek
Tuesday is the best night of the week, and I will defend that opinion forever. My reason has a name, and it is Pizza Dive in Beavercreek.
The Tuesday buy-one-get-one promotion lets you purchase a pizza at regular menu price and get a cheese pizza of the same size free. The deal applies to dine-in and carryout orders, making it a sweet option for a family that eats like a hungry football team.
The slices here are New York-style and generously sized. You can fold them in half like a true pizza pro, and the crust still holds strong.
Freshly prepared dough makes a real difference. You can taste it in every chewy, golden bite.
Creative specialty pies keep things interesting for adventurous eaters. My son tries a new one every visit, and he has not been disappointed yet.
The restaurant has also been known for its Wednesday all-you-can-eat buffet. However, the owners announced a pause after July 1, 2026, so confirm whether it has returned before making plans around it.
My tip is to take advantage of the Tuesday deal when you need to feed a group. Bring stretchy pants and an empty stomach.
Leaving here hungry is basically impossible, and believe me, my
3. Nick’s Restaurant And Pizza, Lancaster
Back in 1977, a family opened a restaurant in Lancaster and started tossing dough. Nick’s Restaurant and Pizza is still family-operated today, and that personal touch shows.
The thin-crust pizza is the star here. It has that crisp, light bite that lets you sneak in one more slice without feeling stuffed.
A 14-inch one-topping pizza costs $17.25 on the regular menu. Rotating specials can save you even more, so I always ask what is running before I order.
Not everyone in my family wants pizza every single time. Luckily, Nick’s also serves sandwiches and hearty American favorites, which keeps the grumbling to a minimum.
The seating is comfortable, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. It feels like a spot where regulars know each other by name.
My husband likes to grab a specialty pie while the kids split a plain one. Everybody wins, and the bill stays reasonable.
A place does not last over 45 years by accident. Good food and kind service are the real secret recipe here.
Save room, because that thin crust is sneaky and the slices keep calling your name.
Address: 702 W Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130
4. LaRosa’s Pizza Hyde Park, Cincinnati
Ask any Cincinnati native about pizza, and the name LaRosa’s will pop up fast. The Hyde Park location keeps that hometown tradition going strong.
Signature family-recipe pies are what made this brand famous. The sauce has a sweet, cozy flavor that tastes like it came from somebody’s grandma.
Wednesday is the magic day for parents. Kids aged 10 and younger can get a one-topping kids pizza meal with a drink and dessert for $6.49.
That promotion is for dine-in customers, so plan to sit down and stay a while. Honestly, the comfortable booths make that an easy choice.
My daughter always picks pepperoni, then spends the whole meal talking about dessert. That little treat at the end is a guaranteed smile.
Grown-ups have plenty of options, too. Italian dishes sit right alongside the pizza, so you can switch things up if you want pasta.
The vibe is friendly and relaxed, which helps when you have wiggly little ones in tow. Nobody blinks at a dropped crayon here.
Cincinnati takes its comfort food seriously, and this spot serves it with a slice of local pride.
Address: 2684 Madison Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45208
5. Pizza Twist, West Chester Township
Curry on a pizza sounded wild to me at first. Then I took one bite at Pizza Twist, and my whole family changed its tune.
This West Chester Township spot serves traditional pizzas plus creative Indian-inspired flavors. Think paneer, tikka masala, and tandoori toppings on a warm, cheesy crust.
The advertised family deal includes two large three-topping pizzas for $33.99. That gives you room to order one classic pie and one bold pie, which is perfect for mixed crowds.
My kids stuck with pepperoni the first time. By the second visit, they were stealing slices of tikka masala from my side of the table.
Vegetarian and plant-based selections are another big plus. If someone in your family skips meat, they will still have plenty of tasty choices.
A friend visiting from South Carolina tried the tandoori pizza with me and asked for the menu to take home. That is high praise from a fellow pizza lover.
Family night does not have to be predictable. Sometimes a fun new flavor makes it more memorable.
Come with an open mind, and this place will put a fresh spin on pizza night.
Address: 4747 Tylersville Rd, West Chester Township, OH 45011
6. J-Cups Pizza, Toledo
Thirty inches of pizza is not a meal. It is an event, and J-Cups Pizza in Toledo knows how to throw one.
The famous Gigantor pizza measures a whopping 30 inches across. The first time I brought one home, my kids just stared at it like it was a pizza spaceship.
Big parties love it, but regular family nights have great options, too. A large three-topping pizza is on special for $14.
The $38.99 family package might be my favorite deal on this list. It comes with two pizzas, cheese bread, and a two-liter soft drink.
Imaginative specialty combinations keep things exciting. You can stay simple with cheese or go big with creative topping mixes that surprise your taste buds.
J-Cups is a fantastic pick for takeout nights. I like to grab the family package, set up a movie, and let everyone dig in on the couch.
Just measure your car seat before ordering the Gigantor. Trust me, it is a real puzzle to get it home.
Toledo families have a big secret here, and it is only getting bigger with every order.
Address: 4843 N Detroit Avenue, Toledo, OH 43612
7. Ron’s Pizza, Dayton
Crunch matters. At Ron’s Pizza in Dayton, the thin crust snaps just right, and that sound is music to my ears.
This longstanding local favorite feels like a true neighborhood pizza shop. It has been feeding Dayton-area families for years, and people keep coming back.
The crispy thin-crust pizza is the main attraction. Toppings spread all the way to the edge, so even the corner pieces feel special.
One advertised special includes a 13-inch one-topping pizza with two bottled soft drinks for $17.50. That makes a simple, affordable dinner for a smaller family or a parent date night with the kids.
Specials rotate, so the restaurant asks customers to confirm which promotion is available. I always call ahead to check, and the staff is happy to help.
Baked sandwiches and pasta are also on the menu. My husband orders a sandwich almost every time, then still sneaks a slice from my plate.
Old-school pizza shops like this one have a charm that never fades. Simple food, done well, is hard to beat.
Ron’s keeps things crispy, classic, and kind to the family budget.
Address: 5562 N Springboro Pike, Dayton, OH 45449
8. Zavarelli’s Pizza Shop, Canton
Fridays in Canton come with a delicious reward. Zavarelli’s Pizza Shop turns the end of the week into a pizza party.
The published menu lists two large one-topping pizzas for $22 on Fridays. For a busy family, that deal is a total lifesaver after a long week of school and work.
Toppings here are generous, so you never have to hunt for your pepperoni. Every slice feels loaded and satisfying.
Specialty combinations give you even more choices. I like to mix one classic with one specialty pie so everybody gets a little variety.
Here is a fun twist for hungry crews. Zavarelli’s offers pizza-and-chicken combinations, which is perfect when your family cannot agree on dinner.
Subs and chicken dinners are available, too. My nephew orders chicken every time, and nobody tries to change his mind.
Hosting a birthday or a team party? Larger sheet pizzas make feeding a big group easy without breaking the bank.
This established pizzeria knows what local families want. Big flavor, fair prices, and plenty to go around never go out of style.
Friday nights in Canton just taste better here.
Address: 2817 Lincoln St E, Canton, OH 44707
9. Regina’s Pizza, Akron
Handmade dough and homemade sauce are a winning pair. Regina’s Pizza in Akron has built its reputation on both.
This neighborhood institution serves traditional Italian flavors that feel comforting and familiar. The sauce has a rich taste that reminds me of Sunday dinners at my aunt’s house.
Size options make planning easy. A 12-inch large pizza starts at $14.75, and an 18-inch jumbo pizza starts at $22.
That jumbo pie is my go-to for family nights. It feeds my crew of five with a few slices left for lunch the next day.
Do not skip the garlic cheese bread. It arrives warm and gooey, and it usually disappears before the pizza even gets cut.
Sandwiches and pasta are also on the menu, so picky eaters have backup options. My niece loves the pasta and calls it her fancy dinner.
The pies here are substantial, which means real value for your money. You get a lot of food without the stress of a giant bill.
Akron has many pizza choices, but Regina’s keeps earning a spot on our family calendar.
Address: 2160 East Ave, Akron, OH 44314
10. Papa Joe’s Pizza, Columbus
Monday blues have a cure on the west side of Columbus. Papa Joe’s Pizza sells a large one-topping pizza for just $10.99 on Mondays.
That deal alone made me a fan. Still, the rest of the menu sealed the friendship.
Thin-crust pizza here comes out crispy and golden. It is the kind of slice you can eat with one hand while juggling a toddler with the other.
The $30 family special is a real crowd-pleaser. It includes two large one-topping pizzas, two Richboy subs, and a two-liter soft drink.
Those Richboy subs are hearty and filling. My husband claims one every time before the kids can even reach the bag.
Wings and casual Italian-American favorites also fill the menu. That variety helps on nights when one family member suddenly declares they are tired of pizza.
Budget-friendly takeout is the main strength here. I grab my order, head home, and dinner is ready without any dishes to wash.
Families watching their spending will love how far a few dollars stretch at this friendly shop.
Address: 2970 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204
11. Angelina’s Villa, Columbus
Three pizzas for one low price sounds like a math problem I can happily solve. Angelina’s Villa in Columbus makes the answer delicious.
On Fridays and Saturdays, you can order three 14-inch one-topping pizzas for $34.99. That is perfect for sleepovers, game nights, or a house full of hungry cousins.
Sunday has its own special, too. Two large one-topping pizzas cost $23.99, which makes a relaxing end to the weekend.
The classic thin-crust pizza is crisp and tasty. Cut into squares, it is easy for little hands to grab a piece.
Italian subs and wings add more choices to the table. My son is a wing fanatic, so he always adds an order to our pizza haul.
Family-friendly combinations make ordering simple. You do not have to piece together a meal one item at a time.
This longstanding neighborhood pizzeria shines for convenient takeout. I call ahead, pick it up on the way home, and everyone is eating within minutes.
Weekend plans in our house usually start with one question. Is it an Angelina’s night yet?
Address: 5450 E Livingston Avenue, Columbus, OH 43232
12. Plus 1 Pizza, Athens
Down in southeastern Ohio, Athens has a pizza spot with a name that makes me smile. Plus 1 Pizza always seems to have room for one more guest at the table.
Homemade dough and family recipes are at the heart of this business. You can taste the care in the soft, flavorful crust.
Online ordering unlocks a nice deal at the Athens location. Two large one-topping pizzas cost $22.99.
Another offer is perfect for bigger appetites. A large Super Supreme pizza and a large two-topping pizza come together for $26.99.
That Super Supreme is loaded with toppings. My oldest calls it the everything pizza, and he means that as a big compliment.
Traditional toppings keep things simple for kids who like plain and familiar flavors. Nobody has to pick off mystery veggies here.
If you are visiting Athens for a college tour or a weekend trip, this is an easy stop. It feeds the whole crew without draining the travel budget.
Fresh, homemade, and friendly to your wallet, this spot adds a happy plus to any family night.
Address: 600 E State Street, Athens, OH 45701
13. Italian Garden, Akron
Potato medallions deserve more fame. Italian Garden in Akron serves them in a combo that has become my family’s secret weapon.
The online menu lists a small one-topping pizza with six wings and potato medallions for $19.99. It is a tidy little feast for a small family or a cozy night in.
Bigger crowds have a deal, too. You can grab two large pizzas for $22, which keeps dinner costs nice and manageable.
Traditional and specialty pies fill the menu. I usually stick with a classic, but my brother swears by trying a new specialty each time.
Wings and sandwiches join the lineup along with other Italian-American dishes. Picky eaters and adventurous eaters can share one order without a fight.
The vibe is casual, which suits busy families just fine. Come as you are, even if you are still wearing soccer cleats.
Those potato medallions are crispy on the outside and soft inside. The kids fight over the last one like it is a gold medal.
Ending this list in Akron feels right, because good pizza and fair prices are a perfect way to wrap up family night.
Address: 1730 Goodyear Boulevard, Akron, OH 44305