These 8 Colorado Bakeries Could Save Your Thanksgiving Dessert Table

One Colorado pie shop bakes thousands of pies for Thanksgiving. The holiday rush there uses well over a ton of apples and hundreds of pounds of butter.

I honestly can’t picture that much butter in one room.

That shop isn’t alone in taking pie season seriously. Across Colorado, bakers are filling cases with cherry, pecan, pumpkin, coconut cream, and flavors you might never try at home.

One spot sits among fruit orchards. Another bakes inside a historic mill.

I love the idea of letting someone else handle the crust this year. Your oven is already busy with the turkey.

Your patience is probably busy with your relatives.

So why not hand dessert to the pros? The trick is knowing where to look before the pre-order lists fill up.

And a few of these spots might tempt you into buying two pies instead of one.

1. Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery

A bakery that sells both cherry pie and Dutch groceries deserves a spot on your holiday radar. This mom-and-pop shop in Colorado Springs mixes gourmet desserts with a little taste of the Netherlands.

Start with the display case, because it’s the main event here. You’ll spot coconut torte, Boston cream pie, and coconut pastry lined up like a sweet parade.

Pie fans have plenty to love too. The Dutch Apple pie and Cherry pie are two of the shop’s big stars.

Coconut lovers should also look for the coconut cream pie. It’s known for high quality and a pretty presentation that would look great on any table.

Not sure pie is enough? The bakery also offers a wide range of cakes, cookies, and pastries.

That variety helps when your family can’t agree on one dessert. Grab a pie for the classic crowd and a cake for the rebels.

Espresso and coffee are on the menu as well. Cinnamon rolls make a smart pick for Thanksgiving morning, before the real cooking starts.

Timing matters at this spot. It opens early on weekdays and Saturdays, but it closes on Sundays.

Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays tend to be the busiest stretches. Plan ahead during holiday week so you aren’t stuck staring at an empty shelf.

While you’re there, peek at the Dutch grocery items. A few treats from the shelves could make a fun addition to your snack table.

Address: 610 E Fillmore St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907

2. The Pie Shop-Palisade Pies

Orchards on every side make this roadside pie stand feel like dessert grew right out of the ground. Palisade sits in Western Colorado’s fruit country, and this shop leans into that sweet location.

Homemade fruit pies are the heart of the menu. You’ll find flaky crusts and crumb toppings that beg for a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Peach pie is a natural choice in a town famous for peaches. Strawberry rhubarb has its own fan club too, if you want something tart.

Baked goods here use local sources, which feels just right for an orchard setting. Your Thanksgiving pie basically comes with a hometown story.

Here’s a fun twist for your shopping list. The shop also sells carrot cake, and it has earned some serious praise.

Shelves hold more than sweets as well. Look for canned fruits and veggies, relishes, salsa, queso, and homemade pork sausage.

That means you could grab dessert and appetizers in one quick stop. Relish trays count as cooking, right?

Coffee is available too, along with cookies. Sit inside or take a seat outdoors and enjoy the orchard views.

The shop opens daily from morning until late afternoon. Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds, while Wednesdays tend to be calmer.

If you’re driving through the Grand Valley before the holiday, this is an easy detour. Just leave room in the car for extra jars.

Address: 3415 C 1/2 Rd, Palisade, CO 81526

3. Colorado Cherry Company at Lyons

Cherries are right there in the name, so you already know what to grab first. This Lyons bakery sits in the foothills of Northern Colorado, on the way toward Estes Park.

Rustic cherry pies are the star of the show. The cherries hit a sweet and tart balance, wrapped in a flaky, buttery crust.

Apple pie is another strong fruit choice. Having both on the table covers the classic fans nicely.

Savory pies deserve a mention, especially for leftover-weary days after Thanksgiving. The shop makes chicken pot pie, bison pies, and even a mushroom veggie pot pie.

Hand pies are also on the menu. They’re great for guests who want a little taste without committing to a full slice.

Everything here leans scratch-made, with sweet and savory options side by side. Bison chili shows up too, which makes a fine lunch stop.

Don’t skip the shelves. Local jams line up alongside the pies, and a jar could brighten your holiday rolls.

Coffee is ready if you need a boost for the drive. The shop opens every day, with later hours on Fridays and Saturdays.

Weekend afternoons get busy, so a weekday visit might be smoother. Wednesday evenings tend to be the quietest time.

Picking up a cherry pie in a mountain-town bakery just feels right in November. Your guests will probably ask where it came from.

Address: 12311 N St Vrain Dr, Lyons, CO 80540

4. Ginger and Baker

Grain once moved through this Fort Collins building, and now pie dough does. Ginger and Baker fills a historic mill with a pie bakery, an American cafe, and a dog-friendly patio.

Head downstairs for the bakery counter. That’s where the pies wait, looking ready for their big holiday moment.

Cherry pie is a favorite here. It pairs nicely with a cup of black coffee if you stay for a slice.

Coconut fans should look for the coconut pie with its flaky crust. It’s a fresh change from the usual pumpkin parade.

Want a meal while you shop? The cafe serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, including chicken pot pie.

Homemade jam over biscuits is another tasty reason to linger. The building itself adds to the fun, with a fireplace and rooftop seating.

The menu also includes full vegan and vegetarian options. That’s handy when your guest list has different needs.

Catering is available too, so you can think beyond dessert. Ask about bigger orders before the holiday rush hits.

Hours run from morning to evening, Tuesday through Sunday. Mondays are closed, so plan around that.

Friday and Saturday evenings bring the crowds. A Tuesday or Wednesday morning visit should feel a lot calmer.

Bringing a pie from a century-old mill feels like a great story for the table. You’ll have dessert and a conversation starter in one box.

Address: 359 Linden St, Fort Collins, CO 80524

5. Shamane’s Bakery

This Boulder bakery offers freshly baked bread, savory dishes, pies, and sweets.

That focus pays off during the holidays. Families come back for these pies year after year as part of their seasonal traditions.

Chocolate pecan pie gives the classic a richer spin. If your table needs pecan, this one checks the box and then some.

Sour cherry pie brings a tangy contrast to heavy holiday plates. It’s a smart pick when guests are stuffed but still curious.

Then there’s the chocolate mousse pie, also called the s’mores pie. Kids and grown-ups alike will likely circle that one.

The shop also makes custom cakes, mini fruit tarts, and cupcakes. Lemon rose petal cake and mango tres leches add even more variety.

Savory items show up too. Quiches and pot pies could help with breakfast before the big meal.

Monkey bread is another fun find. It would make a sweet treat for a slow holiday morning.

Hours are short, so pay attention. The bakery is open Tuesday through Saturday and closes in the afternoon.

Mondays and Sundays are closed. Weekday mornings stay busy, so ordering early is your best move.

Coffee is on hand if you need fuel for errands. Grab a cup while you pick up your pies.

Address: 2825 Wilderness Pl #800, Boulder, CO 80301

6. Granny Scott’s Pie Shop

Thousands of pies leave this Lakewood shop around Thanksgiving. The team uses well over a ton of apples and hundreds of pounds of butter for the season.

That’s not a typo, and yes, that’s a lot of crust. Over 25 housemade pies star at this quaint storefront.

Pecan pie is a big holiday hit. Caramel apple and Dutch apple are popular picks for apple lovers too.

Craving something creamy? Banana cream pie comes loaded with fresh bananas, vanilla pudding, and mountains of whipped cream.

Cherry almond pie is another standout. Pair it with blueberry cheese or blackberry for a table with real variety.

With so many choices, you can match a pie to each guest. Uncle Steve gets pecan, and Grandma gets her cream pie.

The shop isn’t only about dessert. Sandwiches and salads are on the menu, plus coffee and a few seats.

That makes a quick lunch stop easy during holiday errands. You can eat now and carry pie home later.

Hours run Monday through Saturday, with evenings open until 8 PM. Sundays are closed.

Thanksgiving week will be busy at a place baking thousands of pies. Order early so your favorite flavor is waiting for you.

Plan for a little extra fridge space too. Cream pies need a cool home before the big meal starts.

Address: 3333 S Wadsworth Blvd # C107, Lakewood, CO 80227

7. Clint’s Bakery & Coffee House

Ice cream upstairs and pie downstairs sounds like a Breckenridge dream. Clint’s sits right on Main Street in the Summit County mountains.

Pies share the spotlight with cakes, cookies, croissants, and bagels. It’s a true small-town bakery with something for most cravings.

Apple blackberry pie offers a fun twist on the usual apple. The berries add a pop of color to your dessert spread.

Pecan pie is also on the menu for classic fans. For a sweeter spin, try the chocolate chip pecan pie.

Cake lovers have options too. Red velvet cake and cupcakes, including funfetti, round out the case.

Heading up for a mountain Thanksgiving? This shop could save you from baking at high altitude.

That’s a real bonus, since baking up high can be tricky. Let the local pros handle it.

Breakfast eats and sandwiches make it a solid stop before hitting the slopes. Coffee helps with chilly mornings.

Upstairs, ice cream and waffle cones wait. Yes, ice cream in the mountains in November still counts as smart.

Dogs are allowed inside, which is handy for traveling families. Your pup can tag along for the pie run.

The bakery opens daily from 7 AM to 8 PM. Saturdays draw the biggest crowds, so a weekday stop may be easier.

Address: 131 S Main St, Breckenridge, CO 80424

8. Colorado Marketplace and Bakery

High country baking takes skill, and this Silverthorne shop handles it with pies, cakes, and treats. It’s a charming local bakery known for custom cakes and fresh breakfast items.

Pie is part of the lineup here. Pair one with a cake for a dessert table that covers every sweet tooth.

Custom cakes are a specialty. That’s perfect if your Thanksgiving doubles as a birthday or family celebration.

The bakery has handled big events too. Ordering a cake and pie together is a simple way to solve dessert in one stop.

Goods here are handmade with local sourcing in mind. Meals are prepared with care, not tossed together.

Hungry while you pick up your order? Breakfast burritos and sandwiches make easy fuel.

Coffee is on the menu as well. You can sip while you wait for your boxes.

In-store shopping adds another reason to browse. You might find a treat for the drive home.

Hours run daily from 7 AM to 3 PM. That means early birds have the advantage.

Weekends are busiest, especially Saturday and Sunday mornings. Tuesday mornings tend to be much quieter.

Silverthorne sits along a busy mountain route in Colorado. It’s an easy stop if your holiday trip heads toward Summit County.

Grab dessert, grab coffee, and get back to the cabin. Your guests will think you planned everything perfectly.

Address: 325 Blue River Pkwy Ste 110, Silverthorne, CO 80498