The 8 Colorado Bakeries Worth Visiting for Fresh Thanksgiving Pies
One pie shop owner took over his business just ten days before Thanksgiving. He had to learn the recipes on the fly, right in the middle of the busiest pie week of the year.
I love that kind of trial by fire.
That same shop now bakes an estimated 10,000 to 15,000 pies a year. Another bakery on this list offers 84 kinds of pie.
That feels less like a menu and more like a friendly dare.
In Colorado, Thanksgiving pie is serious business. Order deadlines sneak up fast, pickup days get busy, and one great crust can rescue an entire meal.
So I started hunting for the bakeries that deserve a spot on your holiday plans. A couple sit in mountain towns, a few hide in busy suburbs, and one lives inside an old grain mill.
Which one is closest to your table?
1. Colorado Cherry Company at Lyons
Cherries in the name, cherries in the crust, and cherries on your Thanksgiving table if you plan well. The foothill town of Lyons is home to this charming stop for scratch-made sweet and savory pies.
The cherry pie is the obvious star, and for good reason. Expect a rustic look, a sweet-tart filling, and a flaky crust with plenty of buttery edges.
Fruit fans have more to choose from this time of year. Holiday options have included caramel apple, classic apple, cherry, and mixed berry pies.
Here’s a clever trick for busy hosts. Some pies come frozen and ready to take home and bake yourself, so your kitchen smells amazing on the big day.
Need something savory before dessert? The menu also lists chicken pot pie, bison chili, and hand pies that travel well.
Shelves hold local jams, honey, cherry juice, and peach cider for your gathering. You could grab a pie, a jar of jam, and a few hostess gifts in one quick stop.
Weekend afternoons tend to be the busiest stretch here. A weekday visit could make your pie run a lot calmer.
The shop is generally listed as opening at 9 AM daily, although published closing times vary, so confirm the hours before visiting. Free parking, both in a lot and on the street, keeps things simple.
Lyons makes a pretty drive any time in fall. Pie just gives you an excellent excuse to go.
Address: 12311 N St Vrain Dr, Lyons, CO 80540
2. You Need Pie! Diner
Eighty-four varieties of pie is not a menu so much as a lifestyle choice. That’s the lineup at this retro 1950s-style diner in Estes Park.
Honestly, the name says it best. Shopping for one pie here could turn into a long, happy debate with yourself.
Cream pies earn plenty of attention, especially the chocolate cream versions. Coconut cream, German chocolate, and chocolate silk also appear on the menu.
Fruit lovers have options too, like strawberry rhubarb. Some cream pies come with an old-school crumble crust, which gives them a fun homemade feel.
For Thanksgiving, the diner takes holiday pie orders with pickup set for November 25. Placing your order early is a smart move with that many choices on the line.
Whole pies come in individual and full sizes. A small pie is perfect if you’re feeding two, or if you just want a personal dessert nobody else can touch.
The kitchen serves made-from-scratch comfort food beyond dessert. Biscuits and gravy is one menu highlight, so breakfast before your pie pickup is totally reasonable.
New owners took over in May 2025 and remodeled the dining room. They also expanded the menu while keeping that playful 1950s spirit.
Dogs are welcome at the diner’s outdoor pet-friendly tables, making it a convenient stop for road trippers traveling with pets. Your pup can tag along while you choose between chocolate and strawberry rhubarb.
Address: 509 Big Thompson Ave, Estes Park, CO 80517
3. Ginger and Baker
A grain mill from 1905 now spends its days making pie, which feels like a pretty great retirement plan. The owners renovated the historic Fort Collins building, and it opened as Ginger and Baker in 2017.
The Baker part of the name nods to their original dream of opening a pie shop. That dream grew into a full food hub with a cafe, a coffee bar, a market, and a teaching kitchen.
Pie still holds a starring role, though. The scratch-made lineup has included double-crust apple, quadruple coconut cream, and chocolate explosion pie.
That quadruple coconut cream pie deserves a moment. Four layers of coconut in one slice sounds like the perfect closing act for a heavy holiday dinner.
Holiday menus have featured apple cranberry pie, a fun twist for your Thanksgiving table. Savory pies show up too, including chicken pot pie and a veggie pot pie.
You can grab a slice at the coffee bar if you can’t wait for the holiday. Consider it quality control before you commit to a whole pie.
The building also has a glass-enclosed rooftop patio and a dog-friendly patio. It’s an easy spot to linger with family visiting from out of town.
The complex is closed on Mondays and open Tuesday through Sunday. Free parking nearby makes your pie pickup a little easier.
Address: 359 Linden St, Fort Collins, CO 80524
4. The Pie Maker Bakery
When the bakery’s name is The Pie Maker, it had better deliver on pie. In Cortez, down in southwest Colorado, this little shop clearly takes that job seriously.
Everything starts from scratch here, from pies to pastries. You’ll also find bagel sandwiches and nitro cold brew coffee if you need fuel for holiday errands.
Pecan pie gets special praise, and that’s great news for Thanksgiving. A rich pecan pie is basically the guest everyone hopes shows up.
Fruit pies round out the selection for folks who want something lighter. Pairing a pecan pie with a fruit pie keeps both camps at your table happy.
Plan on grabbing your order to go. The shop offers takeout, in-store pickup, and curbside pickup, but no dine-in seating.
Curbside pickup is a real gift during the busy holiday week. You can stay in your car, keep the kids buckled, and still score a fresh pie.
The shop sits on North Harrison Street with free street parking nearby. That makes it an easy quick stop on your way to family dinner.
Cortez is also a handy base for exploring the Four Corners region. If you’re spending the holiday out this way, a local pie fits right in with the trip.
Call ahead or check online before you head over, especially near Thanksgiving. Popular pies tend to go fast this time of year.
Address: 17 N Harrison St, Cortez, CO 81321
5. Granny Scott’s Pie Shop
Ten days before Thanksgiving in 1998, a new owner took over this shop and had to learn pie-making fast. Talk about a trial run with zero room for error.
He clearly figured it out. The shop now bakes an estimated 10,000 to 15,000 pies a year, and Thanksgiving is its biggest tradition.
During the holiday rush, the team bakes thousands of pies. That effort uses well over a ton of apples and hundreds of pounds of butter.
The daily selection includes more than 25 homemade pies. Holiday favorites include pumpkin, pecan, caramel apple, double cherry, and peach.
Cream pie fans can look for chocolate, coconut, and banana cream. Pumpkin cheesecake is another tempting option if your family likes a little twist.
The shop first opened in November 1994. The Granny Scott name stuck around from the original owner simply because it was catchy.
Hungry while you shop? Home-style sandwiches, soups, and ice cream are also on offer, with some seating inside.
Holiday hours change around Thanksgiving, often with a short morning window on the holiday itself. The shop has typically closed the day after Thanksgiving, so plan around that.
Weekday hours run from 7:30 AM to 8 PM, and Saturdays start at 8 AM. Sundays are closed, so don’t count on a last-minute Sunday stop.
Address: 3333 S Wadsworth Blvd # C107, Lakewood, CO 80227
6. Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery
Say the name three times fast, then reward yourself with a slice of Dutch apple pie. This mom-and-pop bakery in Colorado Springs adds a European spin to holiday baking.
Apple pie is the big Thanksgiving recommendation here. The Dutch apple version gives your table a little something different from the usual lattice top.
Cherry pie also earns high marks, along with a beautifully presented coconut cream pie. Pumpkin and pecan pies have been part of holiday orders too.
Want to try something new? Look for vlaai, a traditional Dutch fruit pie with a soft, bready base.
Pre-ordering is the smart move for the holiday. Orders placed a week ahead have been ready to pick up the day before Thanksgiving.
The bakery case goes far beyond pie. You’ll spot cinnamon rolls, chocolate croissants, almond tea cake, cannoli, and napoleons.
Oliebollen, a Dutch fried dough treat, also appears on the menu. It could make a fun breakfast surprise for houseguests on Thanksgiving morning.
Shelves stock Dutch grocery items, so you can grab a few specialty snacks while you’re there. Espresso drinks are available if your pie run needs a caffeine boost.
The bakery opens at 6:30 AM on weekdays and closes Sundays. Friday and Saturday mornings tend to be the busiest stretch.
Address: 610 E Fillmore St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907
7. Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St.
Pie-making has run through this family for four generations, with roots going back to 1929. That’s a lot of practice before your Thanksgiving dessert even hits the oven.
The Tennyson Street shop in Denver keeps both sweet and savory fans happy. Fruit pies, hand pies, and quiche all share the spotlight.
For the holiday, the pumpkin pie is a crowd favorite. It features a creamy pumpkin filling in a shortbread cookie crust, topped with cinnamon whipped cream.
The roasted pecan pie uses amber honey and maple syrup. It also sits in a shortbread cookie crust, which sounds like a very good idea.
Then there’s the Thanksgiving pot pie, a full holiday dinner tucked under a crust. Peppered turkey, gravy, green beans, and cranberry sauce get topped with garlicky mashed potatoes.
That one could save the day for a small gathering. You might even skip roasting a whole turkey altogether.
Pre-orders open ahead of the holiday, and they’re the way to go. The day before Thanksgiving can bring a line, so ordering early saves you time.
Hand pies like cherry and mixed berry make easy snacks for the drive home. Key lime and French silk pies also appear for folks who skip pumpkin.
A second shop sits on East Alameda Avenue, and a holiday pop-up has appeared in Littleton. Colorado pie lovers have options.
Address: 4000 Tennyson St Ste 100, Denver, CO 80212
8. Rheinlander Bakery
Strudel lovers, your Thanksgiving dessert table just got a German upgrade. This longtime family-owned bakery sits in Olde Town Arvada.
The cases hold a big spread of European cakes, pastries, cookies, and coffee cakes. Pies are part of the lineup too, along with sweet and savory pastries.
Dietary needs get serious attention here. Gluten-free, sugar-free, dairy-free, and vegan options all show up on the menu.
That’s a big help if your holiday guest list includes different diets. A dairy-free pumpkin pie mousse has been one of the options for folks avoiding dairy.
Thanksgiving pickup runs the day before the holiday, and it’s well organized. Pre-ordering lets you breeze in, grab your pies, and head home.
The shop is takeout only, with no dine-in seating. There’s also no public restroom, so plan your stop with that in mind.
Strudel makes a fun side dessert next to a classic pie. Sticky buns could also handle breakfast while the turkey roasts.
Olde Town Arvada is a pleasant area for a short stroll. You can pair your pie pickup with a quick walk around the historic district.
The bakery opens at 8 AM daily, including Sundays. Sunday mornings tend to be the busiest, so a weekday stop may be quieter.
Free parking is available in a lot and on the street. It’s a sweet way to wrap up your Colorado pie tour.
Address: 5721 Olde Wadsworth Blvd, Arvada, CO 80002