The 10 Best Pennsylvania Pizzerias To Grab A Slice Near Holiday Markets

One pizza on this list comes topped like a campfire dessert, with s’mores where the pepperoni usually goes.

It’s sold less than a mile from a Christkindlmarkt that pulls in holiday shoppers from all over.

Another shop sits just two blocks from a Christmas village. A third stands right next to a historic market that hosts festive vendor pop-ups.

I love how close the cheese is to the cocoa. Holiday markets across Pennsylvania are packed with ornaments, crafts, twinkle lights, and plenty of cold fingers.

Shopping makes people hungry, and a slice is the easiest meal to carry between booths. So I started wondering which pizzerias sit closest to the festive action.

I can’t imagine a better reward after a chilly lap around the stalls. Which would you grab first, a classic cheese slice or the dessert pie?

1. Joe’s Pizza Philly

Joe's Pizza Philly
© Joe’s Pizza Philly

Arugula, feta, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze sound like a salad’s dream. Here, they land on a pizza slice instead.

Joe’s Pizza Philly sits at 122 S 16th St in Center City. That puts you about two blocks from LOVE Park and Dilworth Park at City Hall.

Those parks host Christmas Village in Philadelphia and the Made in Philadelphia Holiday Market. So your slice break is only a short stroll from the booths.

Slices come with all kinds of toppings, and hoagies share the menu too. It’s a busy lunch spot, so plan around the noon rush if you can.

Ordering happens at the counter, which keeps things quick between shopping laps. The space has three seating areas, so you can actually sit and rest your feet.

Plant-based eaters get a full vegan menu here, plus a full vegetarian one. A Caesar salad also gets plenty of love if you want something green on the side.

Kids have their own menu, which helps when tiny shoppers start fading. Tuesday and Thursday daytime hours tend to be calmer than Friday lunch or Sunday afternoon.

Hours run until 8:30 PM Monday through Saturday and 7 PM on Sunday. Grab your slice early and beat the evening market crowd.

Address: 122 S 16th St, Philadelphia, PA 19102

2. Brooklyn Pizza, The Shops at Liberty Place

Brooklyn Pizza, The Shops at Liberty Place
© Brooklyn Pizza – The Shops at Liberty Place

Shopping mall food courts don’t usually make pizza lists. This counter inside The Shops at Liberty Place earns its spot with New York-style thin-crust slices.

Brooklyn Pizza is less than 0.2 miles from LOVE Park’s Christmas Village. That’s about a four-minute walk, short enough to keep your hot drink from cooling.

Combo deals are the big draw here. A popular pairing gets you two slices of any variety plus a fountain drink.

Being indoors is a real bonus on a frosty December afternoon. You can thaw out, refuel, and head back to the market feeling human again.

Service happens at the counter, so there’s no waiting around for a server. Takeout and delivery are options too if you’d rather eat somewhere else.

Families will find it easy to manage with kids in tow. The casual food court setting means a little holiday chaos fits right in.

Timing matters, since the shop keeps mall-style hours. It’s open 10 AM to 7 PM Monday through Saturday and noon to 6 PM on Sunday.

Parking nearby can be tough in Center City. Walking over from the market is your smartest move anyway.

Address: 1625 Chestnut St Ste F3, Philadelphia, PA 19103

3. Lehigh Pizza

Lehigh Pizza
© Lehigh Pizza

S’mores on a pizza sounds like a dare. Lehigh Pizza in Bethlehem actually puts it on the menu.

The corner shop sits at 13 W 3rd St in South Bethlehem. Head about 0.8 miles down 3rd Street and you reach SteelStacks, home of Christkindlmarkt Bethlehem.

Slices here are big and fairly priced, and they’re known for a soft, fluffy crust. The sauce leans sweet, which pairs nicely with chilly air.

The menu goes well past plain cheese. You’ll spot taco pizza, pulled pork BBQ pizza, calzones, wings, and a Cuban sandwich.

Craving something hearty after hours of browsing? A California cheeseburger or a chicken bacon ranch option can handle that job.

Vegan and vegetarian diners get full menus here. That makes it an easy pick for a mixed group of market buddies.

The space is small but clean, with seating for a quick sit-down. High chairs and a kids’ menu help families too.

Late hours are a big perk for Pennsylvania night owls. It stays open until 11 PM Monday through Thursday and midnight on Friday and Saturday.

Sunday hours run noon to 10 PM, with the kitchen closing 15 minutes before the restaurant. Free parking is usually easy to find nearby.

Address: 13 W 3rd St, Bethlehem, PA 18015

4. Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza

Anna's Brick Oven Pizza
© Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza

A brick oven is a pretty good friend to have in December. Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza bakes its pies in one, about 0.7 miles from PNC Plaza at SteelStacks.

That plaza hosts Bethlehem’s annual Christkindlmarkt. So you can trade ornament browsing for garlic rolls without a long trek.

Grandma’s slice is the one to know. It’s a thinner, crispier take on Sicilian pizza, finished with fresh basil.

The setting is small and modest, with booth seats. Unlike a counter shop, this one offers table service, so someone brings the food to you.

Italian favorites fill out the menu beyond pizza. Lasagna, buffalo calamari, and garlic rolls are all worth a look.

Save a little room, because cannoli are on the dessert list. A cannoli after a market stroll feels like a very good decision.

Portions run generous, so sharing is smart. Reservations are accepted, which helps when you’re wrangling a bigger group.

Families get high chairs and a kids’ menu. It’s a relaxed spot made for slowing down.

Hours run 10 AM to 10 PM Monday through Saturday. On Sunday, the doors open at 11 AM and close at 9 PM.

Address: 313 S New St, Bethlehem, PA 18015

5. Pizza Fiesta (Downtown)

Pizza Fiesta (Downtown)
© Pizza Fiesta (Downtown)

Ever needed a slice at 1:30 in the morning? Pizza Fiesta’s downtown shop stays open until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.

You’ll find it at 14 Smithfield St in downtown Pittsburgh. Market Square, home of the annual Peoples Gas Holiday Market, is about a five-minute walk away.

Pizza by the slice is the main event here. The crust has a good crunch with a little New York-style flop when you fold it.

Toppings go beyond the basics. Buffalo chicken, Hawaiian, and steak ranchero pizzas all show up on the menu.

Not in a pizza mood? Hoagies, wings, popcorn chicken, and French fries are also on offer.

Dessert brings an Oreo cheesecake to the counter. That’s a sweet way to cap off a chilly lap around the square.

Service is fast and counter-based, so you won’t lose much shopping time. The spot also draws a college crowd.

Hours run 10 AM to 1 AM Sunday through Thursday. That gives you a backup plan if the market lights keep you out late.

Takeout and delivery are both available too. Catering is offered for bigger holiday gatherings.

Address: 14 Smithfield St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

6. Sauce Boss

Sauce Boss
© Sauce Boss

Location doesn’t get much handier than this. Sauce Boss sits right next to Harrisburg’s historic Broad Street Market, which hosts festive holiday vendor pop-ups.

The Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex is just over a mile away too. That’s where the huge Pennsylvania Christmas + Gift Show sets up.

The pizza leans NYC-style, with thin slices you can fold. Single slices are available, perfect for a quick stop between errands.

Wings are a strong pick here, seasoned well and cooked fresh. Pizza and wings together make a pretty convincing holiday lunch.

For something bigger, try the Boss Slammer with steak, shrimp, and provolone cheese. Truffle fries round things out, and they’re vegan.

The vibe is laid-back and unpretentious. Staff are known for being accommodating, which matters when your group can’t agree on toppings.

Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are allowed outside. Kids get their own menu as well.

Hours take a little planning, especially if you’re visiting on a weekend. Published schedules differ, so check directly with the restaurant for its current opening and closing times.

Parking options include nearby street spaces and lots, making it convenient to combine your pizza stop with a visit to Broad Street Market.

Address: 910 N 6th St, Harrisburg, PA 17102

7. Pizzeria 211

Pizzeria 211
© Pizzeria 211

Can’t choose between a floppy New York slice and a crispy Detroit-style square? Pizzeria 211 in Lancaster makes both.

After building a following at Southern Market, the restaurant moved into its own storefront on West Lemon Street in July 2026. Downtown holiday events and artisan stands around Lancaster Central Market add to the seasonal fun.

Hand-tossed pies come with a light, crispy crust and a nice mix of fresh toppings. The Detroit-style pizza brings a thicker, crunchy crust with plenty of cheese.

Slices are a great option for wandering shoppers, but timing matters. Individual slices are served from opening until 3 p.m., while whole pizzas and the rest of the menu remain available throughout the day.

Want more? The restaurant also serves cheesesteaks made with sliced ribeye, caramelized onions, and Cooper Sharp cheese on freshly delivered rolls.

The new dining room has seating for up to 40 guests, making it a comfortable place to rest after exploring Lancaster.

Takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup are available too. That gives hungry shoppers several ways to grab their next meal.

Mind the schedule, because the shop is closed Monday and Tuesday. It’s open 11 AM to 9 PM Wednesday through Saturday and noon to 8 PM Sunday.

Address: 601 W Lemon St, Lancaster, PA 17603

8. Zags Pizza and Grille

Zags Pizza and Grille
© Zags Pizza and Grille

A drive-through pizza place is a gift when your arms are full of shopping bags. Zags Pizza and Grille offers exactly that in Lancaster.

It sits about a mile from Lancaster Central Market and the downtown holiday vendor markets. That’s a quick hop once you’re done browsing.

Cheese slices here have earned serious praise. Simple can be the best choice after a long, cold day.

The menu covers pizza, hearty subs, and pasta dishes. Vegetarians get a full menu of their own.

Planning a group dinner after the market? Reservations are accepted, which isn’t common at counter-service pizza spots.

Football season lands right in the middle of the holidays too. Zags is a good spot for watching sports, so nobody misses kickoff.

The space is family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly, with high chairs for little ones. Free Wi-Fi helps if you need to check the market schedule.

Parking is usually easy, with an on-site lot and street spaces. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs too.

Doors open at 11 AM daily and close at 10 PM Thursday through Saturday. Other nights end at 9 PM, leaving time for one last Pennsylvania slice.

Address: 1018 N Christian St, Lancaster, PA 17602

9. Mamma Lucia’s Pizzeria

Mamma Lucia's Pizzeria
© Mamma Lucia Pizzeria

A thick Sicilian slice sounds like a pretty good reward after wandering through Pittsburgh’s holiday market.

Mamma Lucia’s Pizzeria makes that easy, with its downtown location just a short walk from Market Square.

The Peoples Gas Holiday Market fills the square with festive vendor stalls, giving shoppers plenty of reasons to work up an appetite.

Mamma Lucia’s keeps things simple. Pizza dough is made fresh daily, and you can grab individual slices instead of committing to an entire pie.

The Sicilian-style pizza is a standout, especially if you prefer a thicker crust. Traditional thin-crust slices are available too.

Hungry for something beyond pizza? Hoagies, homemade lasagna, spaghetti, and loaded fries give the menu plenty of variety.

The restaurant has been a downtown favorite for decades. Longtime owner Bruce Rahimzadeh eventually passed the business to his daughter Farrah and her husband Dan.

Timing matters during the holidays. Doors open at 9 a.m.

Monday through Friday and 11 a.m. Saturday, but the shop closes Sundays.

Grab your slice before the evening market crowds arrive. Address: 535 Smithfield St, Suite 105, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

10. Stoke Coal Fire Pizza & Bar

Stoke Coal Fire Pizza & Bar
© Colonial Pizza & Spaghetti House

Few pizza stops put you closer to holiday shopping than Stoke Coal Fire Pizza & Bar.

This Easton restaurant sits beside Centre Square, where the annual Easton Winter Village transforms downtown into a festive gathering place.

From November 27 through December 20, 2026, the square fills with vendor huts, seasonal entertainment, and the city’s famous Peace Candle.

After wandering between stalls, stepping inside for coal-fired pizza sounds like an excellent plan.

Stoke’s oven produces thin, crispy crusts with a little char around the edges. It’s the kind of pizza that feels especially satisfying on a cold afternoon.

The menu offers creative combinations, including the Fig & Pig with prosciutto and fig spread, plus the Funghi Bianco with mushrooms and truffle oil.

Wings are another house specialty. They come with caramelized onions, banana peppers, gorgonzola, and citrus seasoning.

Inside, exposed brick walls and local artwork give the dining room a warm, lively personality.

The restaurant opens daily at 11:30 a.m., making it convenient for lunch or dinner between holiday activities. Address: 1 Lehns Ct, Easton, PA 18042