This South Carolina Seafood Spot Ranked No. 21 On North America’s 50 Best Restaurants List
A dessert called Not Fried Chicken looks exactly like a drumstick. It’s actually waffle ice cream, caramelized white chocolate, and corn flakes, and it comes from a seafood restaurant.
That same small dining room just landed at No. 21 on North America’s 50 Best Restaurants list. It’s the second year in a row this South Carolina spot made the cut, after placing No. 19 the year before.
The menu changes every single day. It depends on what local fishers bring in and what nearby farmers are growing.
I like how that keeps every visit a little bit of a mystery.
The room only holds around 40 seats. Cobalt drapes open at 5 p.m., and the kitchen works right out in the open.
So how does a place this small keep landing on lists this big?
A Tiny Dining Room Just Beat Out Some Very Big Cities

Chubby Fish earned No. 21 on North America’s 50 Best Restaurants list, announced on May 28, 2026. That’s a serious honor for a room with roughly 40 seats.
The ranking wasn’t a one-time lucky break either. In 2025, the restaurant placed No. 19, so this marks two straight years on the list.
The team shared that they felt honored to stand beside restaurants they admire. They were also proud to see Charleston show up next to much larger food cities.
The list covers the United States, Canada, and the Caribbean, with Cuba and the Dominican Republic joining Mexico in the separate Latin America ranking.
Chubby Fish is also listed in the MICHELIN Guide. Chef James London was a 2024 James Beard Award finalist for Best Chef: Southeast, and Chubby Fish was an Outstanding Restaurant semifinalist in 2025 and 2026.
Food & Wine, The New York Times, Bon Appétit, Eater, and Robb Report have all given it attention too. That’s a stack of praise that would make any fish feel a little chubby with pride.
Still, the awards only tell part of the story. The real reasons start in the kitchen.
The Chef Came Home And Brought Big Ideas With Him

James London grew up in South Carolina, and that local root matters here. He’s the chef and owner, and his path back home took a few interesting turns.
He attended the College of Charleston before heading to New York. There, he trained at The French Culinary Institute and sharpened his skills.
Next came kitchen work in New York and San Francisco. Those cities gave him plenty of fresh ideas to carry back to the Lowcountry.
James London opened Chubby Fish on June 22, 2018, with his wife, Yoanna Tang, and business partner Geoffrey Shyatt. London and Tang still run the restaurant together.
London is known for speaking up about sustainable fishing and smart sourcing. In plain terms, he cares about where the fish comes from and how it’s caught.
I believe that care shows in the restaurant’s whole approach. A chef who works directly with local fishers tends to treat each catch with real respect.
It’s a nice reminder that big-city training doesn’t have to keep someone away forever. Sometimes the best move is heading home and cooking for your neighbors.
Tomorrow’s Menu Depends On Today’s Catch

Dock-to-table is the whole idea at Chubby Fish. The restaurant works with local fishers to figure out what lands on your plate.
That’s why the menu changes daily. Whatever swam into the nets recently could become tonight’s crudo or curry.
Local farmers supply seasonal ingredients too. So the vegetables shift with the calendar, just like the seafood does.
Here’s a practical tip. Don’t fall in love with one dish from a friend’s photo and expect it to be waiting for you.
Past menus have featured fish like wahoo, amberjack, sheepshead, and yellowfin tuna. Whole fish options have shown up as well, but nothing is guaranteed on any given night.
Honestly, that unpredictability is part of the fun. You get to try something you may never have ordered at a regular seafood chain.
The cooking leans fresh and creative, with Lowcountry seafood handled through inventive techniques. It feels local and adventurous at the same time.
So go in curious. Ask your server what came in that day, and let the ocean help you choose.
Start Cold With Oysters, Crudos, And A Very Small Sandwich

Caviar on a tater roll with crème fraiche sounds fancy and fun at once. That’s the Caviar Sammich, and it’s one of the raw bar’s best-known bites.
The oyster lineup often travels the coast. Past offerings have come from South Carolina, North Carolina, Massachusetts, and Maine.
That’s a neat chance to compare flavors side by side. Oysters from different waters can taste surprisingly different.
Crudos are the other big draw here. Wahoo Crudo, Yellowfin Tuna Crudo, and Bluefin Tuna Crudo have all appeared on the menu.
Amberjack Ceviche has made an appearance as well. Raw fish dishes like these show off just how fresh the catch really is.
A smart strategy is ordering a few raw bar items for the table. Sharing lets everyone sample more without filling up too early.
The Caviar Sammich is small, though, so don’t plan on splitting one four ways. Get your own and skip the polite arguments.
Starting cold also sets up the rest of the meal nicely. After that, the warm plates feel even more exciting.
Small Plates Pack Some Seriously Bold Flavors

Grilled oysters topped with crab fat curry might be the most Chubby Fish idea ever. It mixes Lowcountry seafood with big, warm spices in one bite.
Chili Garlic Shrimp has been another standout on the small plates list. It’s simple in name but loaded with punch.
Then there’s Bone Marrow with shrimp tempura and spicy mayonnaise. That combo sounds wild, and it’s exactly the kind of dish people remember.
Fried Fish Collar has appeared too, prepared like fried chicken. The collar is a cut many home cooks never see, so it’s a fun one to try.
Vegetables get their moment as well. Cauliflower Cacio e Pepe and Fish Tempura have both shown up on past menus.
Octopus has made the list on certain nights. Again, the lineup changes, so treat these as examples rather than promises.
My advice is to build a meal from several small plates. You’ll taste more of the kitchen’s creativity that way.
Bigger plates are coming next, but small plates are where many surprises hide. Pace yourself and share freely.
Big Plates Bring The Curry And The Comfort

Smoked fish and curry make a surprisingly cozy pair. Chubby Fish has served versions like Smoked Sheepshead Curry and Smoked Wahoo Curry.
Curry pops up a lot on these large plates. It’s become something of a signature move for the kitchen.
Not into curry tonight? Past menus have offered a Fried Oyster Roll and Tagliatelle with clams.
Grilled fish and whole fish options have also rotated through. A whole fish is great for sharing and looks impressive when it hits the table.
Large plates here work best as part of a team effort. Many groups mix them with raw bar items and small plates.
This approach lets everyone try a little of everything. It also keeps the table buzzing with passing plates and quick taste tests.
Because the catch changes daily, the fish in your curry might differ from last week’s. That keeps things interesting even for repeat visitors.
A good rule is one or two large plates for a small group. Fill in the rest with lighter bites, and save some room for dessert.
Save Room, Because Dessert Is Playing Tricks

Pastry chef Cynthia Wong created Not Fried Chicken for Life Raft Treats, the ice cream company she founded. Chubby Fish serves the drumstick-shaped dessert, complete with a chocolate-covered pretzel for the bone.
The star trick is Not Fried Chicken. It’s waffle ice cream with caramelized white chocolate and corn flakes, built to look like a crispy drumstick.
Yes, a seafood restaurant serves fake fried chicken for dessert. That sense of humor makes the meal end on a smile.
Another past favorite is The Tammy. It brings together tamarind caramel, ice cream, and chocolate.
Tamarind has a tangy, slightly sweet flavor. It’s a clever way to wrap up a menu packed with bold spices.
Desserts may shift like the rest of the menu. Still, it’s worth asking what sweet options are available on your night.
Here’s a handy tip for groups. Order one or two desserts and pass them around so everyone gets a spoonful.
I can’t imagine skipping this course after seeing that ice cream drumstick. It’s the kind of plate that ends up in every phone’s camera roll.
Blue Drapes, A Ship’s Wheel, And A Front-Row Kitchen View

Floor-to-ceiling cobalt velour drapes open at 5 p.m. It’s a dramatic little curtain call before dinner begins.
Look up and you’ll spot a chandelier made from a wooden ship’s wheel. Pale blue glassware adds more nautical charm to the tables.
Tall ceilings help the compact room feel more open. There’s a communal table too, so you might share space with new faces.
The open kitchen is a highlight of the room. Diners can watch the culinary team cook, plate, and hustle in real time.
Seats at the counter put you closest to that action. It’s like dinner with a live cooking show included.
The mood feels buzzy, warm, and full of energy. Many describe the hospitality as making guests feel welcomed into the owners’ home.
A smart and elegant outfit is suggested for the evening. You don’t need a tux, but maybe leave the beach flip-flops at the hotel.
With only about 38 to 40 seats, the space stays intimate. Every table feels close to the heart of the action.
Grab A Reservation At Noon Or Try Your Luck As A Walk-In

Lines used to form outside long before opening time. Chubby Fish was famous for being walk-in only.
That changed in late 2026 with a full reservation system on OpenTable. New reservations drop daily, Tuesday through Saturday, at noon.
Each release covers availability two weeks out. Set a reminder on your phone, because these seats in South Carolina go quickly.
Walk-ins still have a shot, though. The restaurant holds some tables for them, plus patio seating when the weather cooperates.
You’ll find Chubby Fish at 252 Coming Street, Charleston, SC 29403. It sits in the historic Elliotborough neighborhood.
Rainbow Row and the Historic Charleston City Market are about a twenty-minute walk away. That makes it easy to pair sightseeing with dinner.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday starting at 5 p.m., and it’s closed Sundays and Mondays. Plan around those days so you don’t show up to locked doors.
Ranked No. 21 in North America, this spot is a strong reason to visit Charleston. Good luck ignoring that grilled oyster craving now.
