13 Amish Grocery Stores In Ohio Where Homemade Food Truly Stands Out
I pulled off a two-lane road in Ohio for “just one quick stop,” and my car basically voted to stay. If you like grocery runs with personality, Amish Country is your new favorite errand.
Inside these markets, the air smells like warm bread and good decisions, and the shelves are stacked with hand-rolled noodles, glossy jams, and cheeses that deserve their own fan club. I’ve learned to bring a cooler, a shopping list, and the humility to admit I will ignore both.
Some places win you over with a perfect pie slice, others with a deli sandwich that makes your lunch feel fancy without trying. Here are 13 Amish grocery stores where homemade food steals the show, and your pantry gets a serious upgrade.
1. Ashery Country Store, Fredericksburg
Walking into this beloved spot feels like entering your grandmother’s pantry, if your grandmother happened to be an expert at everything homemade. The shelves practically groan under the weight of bulk foods, spices you’ve never heard of, and enough baking supplies to keep you experimenting for months.
What really catches your eye are the baked goods that come out fresh throughout the day. The cinnamon rolls are legendary around these parts, with swirls so generous you’ll need extra napkins.
Their selection of locally made jams and jellies spans every flavor imaginable, from classic strawberry to unique combinations like peach-raspberry that’ll transform your morning toast.
The cheese section deserves its own visit. You’ll find everything from sharp cheddar that bites back to creamy spreads perfect for crackers.
The staff knows their inventory inside and out, so don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations.
Bulk noodles, fresh produce from nearby farms, and homemade candies round out the experience. This place proves that simple ingredients and traditional methods create something truly special.
Address: 8922 State Route 241, Fredericksburg, Ohio
2. Troyer Market, Millersburg
Located right in the heart of Amish Country, this market brings together everything you’d expect from an authentic community gathering spot. The moment you step inside, the aroma of fresh-baked bread wraps around you like a warm hug on a chilly morning.
Their bakery section operates like a well-oiled machine, churning out pies that would make any home baker weep with envy. The apple crumb pie, in particular, has achieved near-mythical status among regular visitors.
But don’t sleep on their dinner rolls, which practically melt in your mouth.
Beyond the baked goods, you’ll discover a treasure trove of bulk foods that’ll have you rethinking your pantry organization. Grains, flours, dried fruits, and nuts are all available at prices that make stocking up irresistible.
The meat counter offers locally raised options that taste worlds apart from typical grocery store fare.
Seasonal items rotate throughout the year, so there’s always something new to try. Spring brings fresh asparagus and rhubarb, while fall showcases pumpkins and apple cider that tastes like liquid autumn.
Address: 5201 County Road 77, Millersburg, Ohio
3. Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek
Cheese lovers, prepare to lose track of time. This establishment has turned cheese-making into an art form, with varieties that range from familiar favorites to adventurous flavors you won’t find anywhere else.
The sampling counter alone could keep you busy for an hour.
Their specialty cheeses include everything from baby Swiss with its delicate holes to sharp cheddar aged for years until it develops those satisfying crystals. The spreads are downright addictive, especially the bacon-horseradish variety that transforms any cracker into a gourmet experience.
But cheese is just the beginning. The market section stocks homemade noodles that cook up tender and satisfying, plus sauces and seasonings that’ll elevate your weeknight dinners.
Their selection of locally produced honey comes in flavors influenced by whatever flowers the bees visited, creating subtle differences you can actually taste.
The staff genuinely enjoys helping customers find exactly what they need. They’ll explain the difference between various aging processes or suggest pairings that’ll impress your dinner guests.
Fresh fudge near the register makes for dangerous browsing while you wait in line.
Address: 2641 State Route 39, Walnut Creek, Ohio
4. Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Berlin
This sister location brings the same commitment to quality that made the original famous, with its own unique character. Positioned conveniently for travelers exploring the region, it serves as both a destination and a perfect stop during your Amish Country adventure.
The cheese selection mirrors the Walnut Creek location but with some exclusive varieties that make visiting both locations worthwhile. Their Swiss cheese is particularly noteworthy, with a nutty flavor that develops during careful aging.
The pepper jack has just enough kick to keep things interesting without overwhelming your palate.
Fresh produce from local farms fills the bins during growing season, offering tomatoes that actually taste like tomatoes and corn so sweet you could eat it raw. The bulk foods section helps you stock up on baking essentials, snacks, and cooking staples at prices that respect your budget.
Their deli counter prepares sandwiches using their own cheeses and freshly sliced meats, creating lunch options that beat any fast-food stop by miles. The homemade potato chips are dangerously crispy and perfectly salted, making them impossible to stop eating once you start.
Address: 4727 US 62, Berlin, Ohio
5. Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery, Millersburg
Farm-fresh takes on new meaning when you visit this working farm that also happens to produce some of the area’s best baked goods. The connection between field and table couldn’t be more direct, with ingredients often traveling mere yards from where they grew to where they’re transformed into delicious treats.
Their bakery operates on a scale that ensures everything stays fresh while offering enough variety to satisfy any craving. The cinnamon bread deserves special mention, with swirls of spice and sugar that caramelize slightly during baking.
Cookies range from classic chocolate chip to seasonal specialties that change with the harvest.
The farm aspect means you’ll find eggs with deep orange yolks, milk that tastes remarkably rich, and seasonal produce picked at peak ripeness. During summer, their sweet corn draws people from surrounding counties, while fall brings pumpkins and squash in every size and shape imaginable.
Homemade noodles hang in the market area, dried to perfection and ready to transform your soup or casserole. Their selection of jams includes unique combinations you won’t see elsewhere, all made in small batches that ensure quality control.
Address: 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, Ohio
6. Dutch Valley Market, Sugarcreek
Sugarcreek’s charm extends right into this market, where traditional values meet practical shopping needs. The layout makes browsing easy, with clear sections that help you find what you need while encouraging discovery of items you didn’t know you wanted.
Their meat department stands out for quality and variety, offering cuts prepared by butchers who learned their trade through years of apprenticeship. The beef comes from locally raised cattle, resulting in flavor and tenderness that justify the slightly higher prices.
Smoked meats prepared on-site fill the air with enticing aromas that make your mouth water.
The bulk section seems to stretch forever, with bins of grains, beans, dried fruits, nuts, and candy that let you buy exactly the amount you need. Their selection of baking supplies includes specialty flours and unusual ingredients that adventurous cooks appreciate.
Spices come in quantities that make sense for home kitchens rather than restaurant-sized containers.
Fresh baked goods appear throughout the day, with bread still warm from the oven and pastries that showcase seasonal fruits. Their fruit pies feature lattice tops that reveal bubbling filling underneath, signaling the care put into every item.
Address: 1411 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, Ohio
7. Miller’s Bakery, Millersburg
Sometimes the best things come in small packages, and this bakery proves that point deliciously. The focus here stays laser-sharp on baked goods, allowing them to perfect every recipe until it reaches near-perfection.
Their reputation spreads through word of mouth from satisfied customers who become regular visitors.
The donuts deserve their own paragraph. Light, fluffy, and generously sized, they come in varieties from simple glazed to filled with cream or fruit.
Getting there early ensures the best selection, though they bake in batches throughout the morning to keep up with demand.
Their bread selection covers everyday needs and special occasions alike. Whole wheat loaves provide hearty texture and nutty flavor, while white bread achieves that perfect balance of soft interior and slightly crispy crust.
Specialty breads rotate seasonally, incorporating ingredients like pumpkin or cranberries depending on the time of year.
Cookies sell by the dozen or individually, making them perfect for treating yourself or bringing something sweet to share. The peanut butter cookies achieve that ideal combination of chewy center and slightly crisp edges that cookie enthusiasts seek.
Address: 4280 Township Road 356, Millersburg, Ohio
8. Heini’s Cheese Chalet & Bunker Hill Cheese, Millersburg
Cheese-making happens right before your eyes at this combination production facility and retail shop. Watching the process unfold adds appreciation for the skill and patience required to transform simple milk into complex, flavorful cheese.
The viewing windows let you observe without interfering with the careful work.
Their signature cheeses have won awards and loyal fans throughout Ohio and beyond. The Swiss varieties showcase different aging periods, from mild and creamy to sharp and crystalline.
Each stage of aging develops new flavor notes, giving you options depending on your preference and intended use.
Beyond traditional varieties, they experiment with flavored cheeses that incorporate everything from garden herbs to spicy peppers. The garlic-dill cheese spread has converted many skeptics into believers, while the smoked cheddar adds depth to any sandwich or burger.
The shop also stocks complementary items like crackers, mustards, and preserves that pair beautifully with their cheeses. Gift boxes make excellent presents for food lovers, especially when you can customize the selection based on the recipient’s tastes.
Their fudge counter tempts you with creamy squares in flavors ranging from classic chocolate to maple walnut.
Address: 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, Ohio
9. Amish Door Market, Wilmot
Part of a larger complex that includes dining and shopping, this market serves as a one-stop destination for experiencing Amish craftsmanship and culinary traditions. The convenience of having multiple options in one location makes it popular with tour groups and families planning a full day of exploration.
The grocery section stocks an impressive array of homemade items, from noodles hanging in bundles to jars of preserves lined up in rainbow colors. Their selection of baking mixes takes the guesswork out of creating traditional Amish recipes at home, with everything pre-measured and ready to combine with a few fresh ingredients.
Bulk foods fill numerous bins, offering everything from breakfast cereals to soup mixes to trail mixes perfect for snacking. The prices encourage stocking up, especially on items you use regularly.
Their candy section appeals to kids and adults alike, with old-fashioned varieties that spark nostalgia alongside modern favorites.
Fresh produce during growing season comes from nearby farms, ensuring peak flavor and supporting local agriculture. The meat counter offers quality cuts and specialty items like ring bologna that make excellent additions to any gathering.
Address: 1210 Winesburg St, Wilmot, Ohio
10. Kauffman’s Country Bakery, Millersburg
Driving past this bakery without stopping requires superhuman willpower, especially when the aroma of fresh bread drifts across the parking lot. The display cases inside showcase the morning’s work, with rows of pastries, cookies, and breads that represent generations of baking knowledge passed down through families.
Their cinnamon rolls have achieved legendary status for good reason. Each one weighs nearly a pound, with layers of buttery dough spiraled around generous amounts of cinnamon sugar.
The cream cheese frosting gets applied with a heavy hand, exactly as it should be. Plan to share one unless you’re particularly hungry.
Pies rotate with the seasons, taking advantage of whatever fruits are at their peak. Summer brings berry pies bursting with flavor, while fall showcases apple and pumpkin varieties that define comfort food.
The crusts achieve that elusive combination of flaky and tender that home bakers strive for.
Beyond sweets, they bake sandwich breads, dinner rolls, and specialty loaves that make everyday meals feel special. Their whole grain options provide nutrition without sacrificing taste, proving that healthy can also be delicious when done right.
Address: 4357 US-62, Millersburg, Ohio
11. Broad Run Cheesehouse, Dover
Tucked away on a scenic route, this cheesehouse rewards those who venture slightly off the beaten path. The building itself reflects traditional craftsmanship, with attention to detail that extends from the construction to the products sold inside.
Finding it feels like discovering a secret that locals have been keeping to themselves.
The cheese selection focuses on quality over quantity, with each variety chosen for excellence rather than just filling shelf space. Their aged cheddars develop complex flavors that unfold on your palate, starting mild and building to a pleasant sharpness.
The Swiss cheese features those characteristic holes while maintaining a smooth, creamy texture.
They also produce specialty items like cheese curds that squeak when you bite them, a sign of absolute freshness that cheese enthusiasts appreciate. The flavored varieties incorporate ingredients like jalapenos or herbs, creating options for every preference and use.
Beyond cheese, the market section offers homemade noodles, local honey, and preserves that complement their dairy products perfectly. The staff takes pride in explaining their production methods and helping customers select items that match their needs.
Sample trays let you taste before committing to larger purchases.
Address: 6011 Old Rt 39 NW, Dover, Ohio
12. Rothenbuhler Cheese Chalet, Middlefield
The Swiss heritage shines through at this unique establishment, where Old World cheese-making traditions meet Ohio hospitality. The building’s architecture hints at what you’ll find inside, with attention to authentic methods that produce consistently excellent results.
This isn’t just a store but a celebration of cultural traditions kept alive through food.
Their Swiss cheese varieties range from baby Swiss with delicate flavor to aged versions that pack more punch. The production process visible through viewing windows shows the care involved in creating each wheel.
Watching cheese-makers work their craft adds context and appreciation for the final product.
The retail section extends beyond cheese to include other Swiss specialties and Amish-made goods. Chocolates, cookies, and candies provide sweet options, while their selection of sausages and cured meats offers savory alternatives.
Gift baskets can be customized to include your choice of products, making them perfect for any occasion.
Their fudge counter produces creamy squares in numerous flavors, from traditional chocolate to creative combinations that surprise and delight. The maple walnut achieves perfect balance between sweet and nutty, while the peanut butter fudge melts on your tongue.
Address: 15815 Nauvoo Rd, Middlefield, Ohio
13. Yoder’s Hometown Market, Dover
Convenience meets tradition at this well-organized market that serves both local residents and visitors exploring the area. The layout makes shopping efficient without feeling rushed, with wide aisles and clear signage that helps you navigate the extensive inventory.
It’s the kind of place where you can grab quick essentials or spend an hour browsing specialty items.
Their deli counter prepares fresh sandwiches and salads daily, using quality ingredients that elevate simple lunch fare into something memorable. The chicken salad balances creamy dressing with tender meat and crunchy celery, while their ham and cheese uses thick slices of both components.
Side salads feature seasonal vegetables at peak freshness.
The bakery section operates throughout the day, ensuring fresh options whether you shop morning or afternoon. Bread varieties cover every need, from soft sandwich loaves to hearty whole grains perfect for toast.
Their cookies and pastries disappear quickly, especially the frosted sugar cookies decorated for current holidays or seasons.
Bulk foods, fresh produce, quality meats, and specialty items round out the offerings. Their selection of Amish-made products includes noodles, jams, honey, and candies that make excellent gifts or pantry staples for your own kitchen.
Address: 1020 N Tuscarawas Ave, Dover, Ohio