14 Beloved Pennsylvania Burger Spots Serving Double Cheeseburgers You’ll Never Forget
Pennsylvania has always held a special place in my heart—not just for its rich history and rolling hills, but for its downright impressive burger culture.
From the steel-town grit of Pittsburgh to the bustling streets of Philadelphia, and all the way up to Harrisburg and Erie, this state knows how to do burgers right. You’ll find everything from paper-thin smash patties with crispy, caramelized edges to towering diner-style creations dripping with melted cheese and secret sauce.
No matter what kind of burger you crave, these Pennsylvania spots deliver big flavor, local pride, and that irresistible, all-American bite every single time.
1. Moonlit Burgers — Pittsburgh (Dormont)
Walking into Moonlit Burgers feels like stepping into your favorite neighborhood spot where everyone knows your name.
Their Classic Moonlit Double isn’t just a menu item; it’s literally the default choice for anyone who appreciates a perfectly crafted burger. Two juicy patties stacked high with gooey cheese create a flavor explosion that makes you wonder why you’d ever order anything else.
The magic here lies in simplicity done right. Fresh ingredients, expert grilling techniques, and a passion for burgers shine through every bite. I remember my first visit, skeptical that any burger could live up to the hype, but one taste proved me completely wrong.
2. Burgatory — Pittsburgh
Burgatory turned the Pittsburgh burger scene upside down with their creative twists and bold flavors.
The house Double Smash stands out as a masterpiece of technique, where thin patties get pressed onto a scorching griddle until the edges turn crispy and caramelized. That contrast between the crunchy exterior and tender, juicy interior makes every bite an adventure.
Beyond the burger itself, the atmosphere buzzes with energy and excitement. Customization options abound, letting you build your dream burger from an impressive array of toppings. My personal favorite adds bacon jam and crispy onion straws for an unforgettable flavor combination.
3. Smash’d Burger — Pittsburgh (Forbes Ave/Oakland)
College students and burger enthusiasts flock to Smash’d Burger in Oakland for one simple reason: their core burgers are double patty builds that don’t mess around.
Located right on Forbes Avenue, this spot understands that sometimes you need serious fuel, especially when you’re powering through study sessions or celebrating after a big game.
What impressed me most was the consistency. Every visit delivers the same quality and flavor, which speaks volumes about their dedication. The smash technique creates those irresistible crispy bits that burger lovers dream about, while the double patties ensure you’re never left wanting more protein.
4. DeLuca’s Diner — Pittsburgh (Strip District)
DeLuca’s Diner brings old-school charm to the Strip District with their straightforward approach to burgers.
Their menu proudly lists a Double Beef, Double Cheese burger that tells you exactly what you’re getting: no fancy names, no gimmicks, just honest-to-goodness deliciousness piled high on a toasted bun.
Sitting at the counter watching the cooks work their magic never gets old. The sizzle of beef hitting the flat top, the aroma of grilled onions, and the sight of cheese melting over those patties creates an experience that engages all your senses. This place reminds me why diners remain an essential part of American food culture.
5. Middle Child Clubhouse — Philadelphia (Fishtown)
Fishtown’s coolest spot, Middle Child Clubhouse, knows that sometimes good things come in pairs.
Their cheeseburger menu features a simple but powerful option: make it a double. That little plus sign opens up a world of beefy, cheesy possibilities that transform a good burger into something extraordinary.
The vibe here perfectly matches the neighborhood’s creative energy. Exposed brick walls, friendly staff, and an attention to detail in every dish make this more than just a meal. I love how they’ve taken classic comfort food and given it a modern edge without losing the soul that makes burgers so universally beloved.
6. HUDA — Philadelphia (Rittenhouse)
HUDA brings sophistication to the burger game in Rittenhouse with their outright Double Cheese Burger that proves fancy neighborhoods deserve great burgers too.
This isn’t your typical greasy spoon creation; instead, it’s a carefully crafted masterpiece that respects both culinary tradition and modern sensibilities.
Quality ingredients make all the difference here. Premium beef cooked to perfection, artisan cheese that melts beautifully, and a bun that holds everything together without falling apart showcase what happens when skilled chefs take burgers seriously. Every element works in harmony, creating a dining experience that justifies the slightly higher price tag and leaves you completely satisfied.
7. Nifty Fifty’s — Philadelphia (Multiple Locations)
Nifty Fifty’s captures the golden age of American diners with their commitment to serving burgers the way they were meant to be enjoyed.
Their menus note that burgers are pictured as doubles, and they deliver on that promise with generous portions that transport you straight back to the 1950s.
Multiple locations across Philadelphia and the suburbs mean you’re never far from a fantastic double cheeseburger. The retro atmosphere, complete with jukeboxes and vinyl booths, adds to the experience. My kids go crazy for the nostalgic vibe, and I appreciate that the quality matches the fun presentation perfectly every single time.
8. DBG (Drury Beer Garden) — Philadelphia (Midtown Village)
Beer gardens and burgers go together like cheese and, well, more cheese. DBG in Midtown Village serves up Double Smash burgers with two patties that complement their beverage selection beautifully.
The outdoor seating creates a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy great food without any pretension or fuss.
What sets DBG apart is their understanding that burgers don’t need to be complicated to be incredible. Simple seasoning, proper technique, and fresh ingredients create something memorable. The smash method delivers those crispy, caramelized edges that add texture and depth to every mouthful, making this a must-visit spot for serious burger enthusiasts.
9. Burger Yum — Harrisburg
Sometimes a restaurant name says it all, and Burger Yum in Harrisburg delivers exactly what it promises.
Their menu explicitly lists a Double Cheeseburger, removing any guesswork and ensuring you get exactly what your hungry stomach craves. No confusion, no disappointment, just pure burger satisfaction from the moment you place your order.
Central Pennsylvania doesn’t always get the credit it deserves for its food scene, but places like Burger Yum prove that great burgers exist everywhere. The friendly service and commitment to quality make this a local favorite. I’ve driven out of my way specifically for their double cheeseburger, and it’s worth every mile.
10. Brickerville House Restaurant — Lititz (Lancaster County)
Lancaster County charm meets serious burger craftsmanship at Brickerville House Restaurant in Lititz.
Their menu includes a Double Cheeseburger that fits perfectly with the area’s reputation for honest, hearty cooking. You won’t find any molecular gastronomy or foam here, just real food made with care and served with a smile.
The restaurant itself feels like stepping into a friend’s home, warm and welcoming with that authentic Pennsylvania hospitality. After exploring the beautiful countryside or visiting local shops, settling in for a double cheeseburger here hits differently. It’s comfort food at its finest, prepared by people who genuinely care about feeding their community well.
11. Denny’s Beer Barrel Pub — Clearfield
Denny’s Beer Barrel Pub has achieved legendary status in the burger world, and for good reason.
This famous burger house in Clearfield serves up everything from reasonable doubles to absolutely massive multi-patty builds that defy logic and gravity. Their menu spans the entire spectrum, ensuring everyone from casual diners to competitive eaters finds their perfect match.
Even if you’re not attempting a record-breaking burger challenge, the standard offerings here impress with their size and flavor. The atmosphere celebrates burger culture in all its glory. Visiting feels like a pilgrimage for anyone who takes their double cheeseburgers seriously and wants to experience true Pennsylvania burger history.
12. Wert’s Café — Allentown
Wert’s Café stands as an iconic burger destination in Allentown, the kind of place locals have been visiting for generations.
Their robust burger menu features specials that change regularly, but the locals consistently go for the hearty doubles that have built this spot’s reputation. Walking through the door feels like joining a tradition that stretches back decades.
What makes Wert’s special isn’t just the food, though the burgers absolutely deliver. It’s the sense of community, the familiar faces, and the knowledge that you’re eating at a place that has perfected its craft over many years. These burgers taste like home, even if it’s your first visit.
13. Smash Shack Burger Bar — Erie
Erie’s burger scene got a serious upgrade when Smash Shack Burger Bar opened its doors.
This smash-style shop offers double and triple options that showcase the technique perfectly, with thin patties pressed hard onto a blazing hot griddle until they develop that signature crust. The delivery menus make it easy to enjoy these beauties at home, though eating in lets you experience them at peak freshness.
Located near the lake, this spot captures the laid-back Erie vibe while taking its burgers very seriously. The double option provides the ideal balance of meat, cheese, and toppings without overwhelming your appetite. Perfect for a post-beach meal or anytime burger cravings strike.
14. Scranton Pizzeria — Scranton
Plot twist: one of Scranton’s best double cheeseburgers comes from a pizzeria.
Scranton Pizzeria proves that you don’t need to specialize exclusively in burgers to make an exceptional one. Their full Double Cheeseburger sandwich appears right on the menu alongside the pizza offerings, giving diners delicious options whether they’re craving Italian or American classics.
This unexpected gem shows that great cooking transcends categories. The same care and quality that goes into their pizza clearly extends to their burger program. I love places that surprise you, and ordering a double cheeseburger at a pizzeria definitely counts as a pleasant surprise worth experiencing firsthand.