6 Best Places To Try North Carolina’s Famous Sweet Potato Pie
Sweet potato pie holds a special place in North Carolina’s culinary heritage. With its smooth, spiced filling and deep Southern roots, this classic treat turns a humble crop into pure comfort on a plate.
Whether you’re visiting a cozy bakery or a celebrated restaurant, these are the spots serving up the most unforgettable sweet potato pies in the Tar Heel State.
1. King’s BBQ – Kinston
Smoke-kissed meats might bring folks through the door, but King’s sweet potato pie keeps them coming back for dessert. Their legendary recipe balances earthy sweetness with warm spices in a flaky, buttery crust.
The family-owned establishment has perfected this Southern classic over the decades. At $24.95 for a whole 9-inch pie, it’s worth every penny, whether you’re dining in or ordering online for a special occasion.
2. Slice Pie Company – Raleigh
Tucked inside Sugar Euphoria at 606 N Person St, this bakery showcases why their sweet potato pie earned that coveted State Fair Blue Ribbon. The secret? Perfect texture—never too dense or too fluffy—with just the right hint of cinnamon and nutmeg.
Even Southern Living magazine couldn’t resist highlighting their exceptional crust. Each bite delivers that homemade quality that mass-produced pies simply can’t match.
3. Nana Morrison’s Soul Food – Charlotte
My grandmother used to say you can taste love in good soul food, and Nana Morrison’s sweet potato pie proves her right. The first time I tried their pie, that familiar aroma of warm spices transported me straight to childhood holiday gatherings.
Locals rave about the silky-smooth filling that strikes the perfect balance between sweet and savory notes. The homestyle crust completes this authentic Southern experience that keeps Charlotte residents coming back.
4. Mama Van’s Sweet Potato Pie – Statewide Delivery
Sometimes the best pies aren’t found in storefronts but through local food services like Safari Eatz, which delivers Mama Van’s exceptional creations statewide. I ordered one for my brother’s birthday after he moved away. He called it “a taste of home in a box.”
At $20 per pound, these pies showcase North Carolina’s famous sweet potatoes in their finest form. The filling’s velvety texture and authentic flavor profile have earned Mama Van’s a devoted following beyond brick-and-mortar limitations.
5. Once in a Blue Moon Bakery & Café – Cary
This charming Cary establishment offers not one but two sweet potato masterpieces. Their classic version ($21.99) delivers everything pie purists crave, that familiar comfort of perfectly spiced filling and tender crust.
For those seeking something extra special, their sweet potato-pecan variation ($24.99) creates magic by combining two Southern classics. My aunt practically swooned when I brought this to Thanksgiving dinner last year!
Both options are baked fresh daily, ensuring peak flavor and texture.
6. Baked Pie Company – Avery Creek
Nestled near Asheville, this pie haven consistently ranks among Western North Carolina’s top dessert destinations on Yelp. Their sweet potato pie stands out with its silky-smooth texture and perfectly balanced spice profile.
The crust deserves special mention, slightly more substantial than most, providing the ideal foundation for the creamy filling. Grab a slice with coffee or take home a whole pie to share.
Either way, you’ll understand why mountain locals consider this their go-to spot for authentic sweet potato pie.