8 Best Secret Menu Items At Arby’s Nobody Regrets Getting

Ever found yourself standing at the Arby’s counter, staring at the menu and wondering if there’s more to discover beyond the usual lineup? You’re not alone—and you’re absolutely right to be curious!
Behind that familiar menu board lies a secret world of off-the-menu creations that only the most dedicated Arby’s fans know about. These hidden gems, passed around like culinary folklore, offer bold flavor combinations and over-the-top twists on classic favorites.
I’ve spent years digging into Arby’s not-so-secret secrets, taste-testing and tweaking, and I can confidently say these eight secret menu items are worth every bite—if you’re adventurous enough to order them.
1. The Meat Mountain Sandwich

Holy protein paradise! The Meat Mountain is the Everest of secret sandwiches that started as a promotional poster showing all Arby’s meats stacked together. When customers began asking for it, a legend was born.
I nearly dislocated my jaw trying to bite into this behemoth the first time. It packs chicken tenders, roast turkey, ham, corned beef, brisket, Angus steak, roast beef, bacon, and both Swiss and cheddar cheese between two buns. My buddy Mike thought I was pranking him when I described it.
Pro tip: Bring napkins. Lots of napkins. And maybe a friend to help you finish it – unless you’re planning to hibernate afterward like I did!
2. The Bacon Beef ‘n Cheddar

Bacon makes everything better, and Arby’s secret Bacon Beef ‘n Cheddar proves this universal truth. The classic sandwich gets a magnificent upgrade that’ll make your taste buds throw a party.
Last summer, I ordered this masterpiece on a road trip and the car fell silent as everyone focused on the perfect harmony of flavors. The standard Beef ‘n Cheddar already rocks with its roast beef, cheddar cheese sauce, and red ranch on an onion roll, but adding crispy bacon transforms it into something otherworldly.
Fair warning: once you try this version, you’ll never go back to the regular one. My wallet learned this lesson the hard way!
3. The Arby’s Melt with Bacon

Cheese pulls for days! The regular Arby’s Melt secretly transforms into a flavor bomb when you ask them to add bacon. Sometimes simplicity wins, and this modification proves it brilliantly.
During my college finals week, this sandwich saved my sanity. The standard melt features roast beef and melted cheddar on toasted sourdough bread. When bacon enters the chat, it creates a trinity of tastes that dance together in perfect harmony.
The best part? Most employees won’t bat an eye at this request since they have bacon ready for other sandwiches. Just be prepared for envious glances from other customers when they see what you’re enjoying. My roommate started ordering his own after stealing half of mine three visits in a row!
4. The Loaded Italian Fries

Carb lovers, rejoice! Imagine Arby’s curly fries topped with all the fixings from their Italian sandwich – it’s a Mediterranean dream in fast food form that’ll transport you straight to flavor town.
My first encounter with this secret creation happened by accident when the cashier misunderstood my order. Best mistake ever! These fries come loaded with ham, salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, red onion, banana peppers, and Italian dressing.
The hot fries slightly wilt the lettuce and warm the meats, creating a perfect contrast of temperatures and textures. I’ve converted at least seven friends to this messy masterpiece. Just remember to grab a fork – trying to eat these with your fingers is a rookie move I learned the hard way!
5. The Double-Stacked Roast Beef

Size matters when hunger strikes! The Double-Stacked Roast Beef isn’t officially listed, but savvy Arby’s fans know to ask for this monster that doubles down on their signature meat.
Remember that scene in cartoons where someone’s eyes bug out at something amazing? That was literally my reaction biting into this for the first time. It’s essentially two Classic Roast Beef sandwiches merged into one glorious creation – double the meat between a single set of buns.
The beauty lies in the meat-to-bread ratio that finally feels right. After discovering this hack during a late-night food run, I’ve never ordered a regular roast beef again. My wallet might not thank me, but my stomach certainly does. Sometimes more really is more!
6. The French Dip Max

Dipping enthusiasts, I’ve found your holy grail! The French Dip Max combines Arby’s French Dip with their Beef ‘n Cheddar, creating a sandwich that’s practically begging to be dunked in that savory au jus.
During a rainy afternoon lunch break, I nervously requested this mashup, wondering if they’d think I was crazy. The cashier just winked and said, “Good choice.” This beauty combines roast beef, Swiss cheese, and red ranch sauce with the classic dipping broth on the side.
Each bite delivers a flavor explosion that gets even better when dunked in that warm, savory juice. The contrasting textures of the soft bun, tender meat, and melty cheese create a symphony in your mouth. My coworkers now insist we go to Arby’s on Fridays just for this!
7. The Chicken Bacon Swiss Melt

Chicken sandwich lovers need to know about this secret weapon in the Arby’s arsenal! By combining their Chicken Sandwich with bacon and Swiss cheese, you’ll create a flavor combination that puts other fast food poultry options to shame.
I discovered this gem when eavesdropping on the order of a guy who looked like he knew what he was doing. The crispy chicken filet gets elevated with smoky bacon and melty Swiss cheese, creating something far greater than the sum of its parts.
The slight nuttiness of the Swiss perfectly complements the savory chicken and bacon. My vegetarian sister tried a bite and seriously considered abandoning her principles on the spot! Ask for some Arby’s sauce on the side to take this creation to even greater heights.
8. The Ultimate Curly Fry BLT

Sandwich innovation at its finest! This mind-blowing creation stuffs Arby’s famous curly fries inside a BLT sandwich, creating a carb-loaded masterpiece that satisfies multiple cravings at once.
My brother-in-law, a former Arby’s employee, introduced me to this game-changer during a family barbecue. “You’ll never look at a BLT the same way,” he promised. He wasn’t exaggerating! The standard bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich gets transformed when you ask them to add a layer of those perfectly seasoned curly fries.
The contrast between the cool, crisp vegetables and the warm, spiced potatoes creates a textural wonderland. Add some Arby’s sauce or Horsey sauce depending on your mood. Just prepare for some funny looks when ordering – until they see your delicious result!