12 Can’t-Miss Hidden Restaurants in Port St. Lucie, Florida
Port St. Lucie is full of hidden restaurants that turn everyday dining into a delightful discovery.
Tucked away from the main streets, these spots serve dishes that surprise and impress, from fresh seafood to comforting classics and inventive flavors.
Locals know the best-kept secrets, returning for meals that satisfy cravings and spark curiosity.
Visiting these hidden gems is a tasty adventure, proving that some of the most memorable meals come from places you might not expect.
1. Kyle G’s Oyster & Wine Bar
Seafood heaven awaits at this upscale hideaway tucked along Hutchinson Island. The ocean views alone are worth the short drive from Port St. Lucie proper!
Fresh-shucked oysters arrive glistening on ice, while the wine selection could impress even the pickiest sommelier.
Their signature seafood tower makes for an Instagram-worthy moment that tastes even better than it looks.
2. Meating Street Steakhouse
Carnivores rejoice! This family-owned steakhouse flies under the tourist radar while serving up some of the juiciest cuts in St. Lucie County.
The name might make you chuckle, but their dry-aged ribeye is serious business.
Locals pack the place on weekends, so reservations are a must. Their secret weapon? A 1,500-degree broiler that creates the perfect sear on every steak.
3. Pastaio Handmade Pizza & Pasta
Mama mia! Authentic Italian cuisine hides in this unassuming strip mall spot where everything’s made from scratch.
The owner learned his craft in Naples before bringing his dough-spinning skills to Florida.
Watch through the open kitchen as they stretch pizza dough by hand and pull fresh pasta from their imported machine. Their carbonara might be the closest thing to Rome you’ll find without a passport!
4. Amore Italian Chophouse
Romance and red sauce! This hybrid Italian steakhouse creates magic by combining two beloved cuisines under one roof.
Hidden in a quiet neighborhood, its unassuming exterior gives zero hints about the culinary fireworks inside.
Their veal chop parmesan breaks all the rules in the best possible way. Come hungry because portions here are Florida-sized, and the complimentary garlic knots are absolutely addictive.
5. Oak & Ember Steakhouse
Suburban luxury awaits at this Becker Road gem where locals celebrate special occasions. The bartenders craft cocktails with theatrical flair, often using smoke and fire elements that match the restaurant’s name.
Splurge on their tomahawk steak, which arrives at your table still sizzling from the oak-fired grill.
Their truffle mac and cheese side dish has developed its own cult following among Port St. Lucie foodies.
6. Think Greek
Blue and white decor transports you straight to Santorini at this family-run taverna. The owner, Yanni, often roams between tables sharing stories from his childhood in Athens.
Gyro lovers, prepare for perfection! Their vertical rotisserie spins slowly, creating meat that’s crispy outside and tender inside.
Save room for the baklava, made daily by Yanni’s mother using a closely guarded family recipe from the old country.
7. Babalu’s Cuban Café
Salsa music and savory aromas greet you at this vibrant spot where Miami-quality Cuban food hides in plain sight. Vintage photos of Havana line the walls, creating an atmosphere as authentic as the food.
Their Cuban sandwich gets pressed for exactly seven minutes, creating the perfect crispy exterior. The café con leche packs enough caffeine to jumpstart your heart, while the homemade flan provides the perfect sweet ending.
8. Pho Deli
Steamy bowls of happiness emerge from this unassuming Vietnamese spot where the broth simmers for 24 hours before serving.
Family photos and Vietnamese art create a homey atmosphere that welcomes noodle novices and experts alike. Regular customers know to request extra culantro herb and bone marrow in their pho.
Their bánh mì sandwiches feature perfectly crispy bread that shatters delightfully with each bite, revealing layers of savory fillings within.
9. Casa Amigos Authentic Mexican Restaurant
Forget Taco Tuesday chains! This family-owned fiesta spot serves the real deal, from hand-pressed tortillas to slow-simmered mole that takes two days to prepare.
Weekends bring mariachi performances that elevate the already lively atmosphere.
Their tableside guacamole preparation has become legendary among locals, with avocados smashed to your preferred consistency right before your eyes.
10. Taqueria El Rey
Taco paradise exists in this humble roadside stand where Spanish is the primary language and the menu fits on a single chalkboard.
Don’t let the plastic chairs fool you – this place serves royalty-worthy Mexican street food. Each taco comes wrapped in two corn tortillas with simple toppings: cilantro, onion, and lime.
Their weekend-only menudo soup cures whatever ailed you the night before. Cash only, but ATM fees are worth it!
11. Ninja Thai Asian Fusion
Sneaky good Thai food hides in this strip mall gem where the chef-owner trained in Bangkok before bringing her culinary ninja skills to Florida. The modest exterior belies the flavor explosions waiting inside.
Their pad thai achieves that perfect balance of sweet, sour, salty, and umami that marks authentic Thai cuisine.
Brave souls can attempt the “Thai hot” spice level, but be warned – tissues for inevitable tears are provided!
12. Yum Yum Hot Pot
Interactive dining reaches new heights at this bubbling cauldron of fun where you become the chef! Each table features built-in induction burners where broths simmer continuously throughout your meal.
First-timers receive friendly guidance on cooking times for different ingredients. The all-you-can-eat option lets you sample everything from paper-thin beef slices to bouncy fish balls.
Pro tip: their homemade dipping sauces elevate everything you cook!