Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Dreams Come True At This No-Frills Restaurant In Wisconsin
There’s a certain magic to Wisconsin hospitality, a feeling of warmth and genuine welcome that permeates its most beloved establishments.
Nestled within this charming state is The Fox & Hounds Restaurant & Tavern, a place that has mastered the art of comfort food and elevated it to an art form. While their savory offerings are legendary, there’s one particular dessert that has earned a cult following, a sweet masterpiece that has locals and visitors alike raving: their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie.
Forget everything you thought you knew about this classic combination; The Fox & Hounds is serving up a rendition that is nothing short of a dream come true.
A Rustic Tavern With Historic Charm
The Fox & Hounds boasts a charming rustic atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. Wood-paneled walls and country-style decor create a warm, welcoming environment perfect for family gatherings or date nights.
Originally built decades ago, the restaurant maintains its historic character while providing modern comforts. Many guests comment on the cozy fireplace that adds a special touch during Wisconsin’s chilly months.
The friendly staff completes the experience, treating first-timers like regulars and remembering returning customers by name. This combination of ambiance and hospitality keeps people coming back year after year.
The Legendary Pie That Started It All
Their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie isn’t just dessert – it’s an institution. The perfect balance of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter creates a flavor combination that’s simply irresistible.
The secret lies in the contrasting textures: a crunchy chocolate crust, velvety peanut butter filling, and a cloud-like whipped cream topping. Each bite delivers a harmonious blend of sweet and slightly salty notes that dance across your taste buds.
What makes this pie truly special is the restaurant’s commitment to consistency. Whether you tried it twenty years ago or yesterday, that first heavenly bite brings the same joy every time.
A Recipe Guarded Like Treasure
Despite countless requests, The Fox & Hounds keeps their pie recipe under lock and key. Many have tried to recreate this masterpiece at home, but something always seems to be missing.
I once spent an entire weekend attempting to reverse-engineer this dessert after having it at a friend’s birthday dinner. Three attempts and many dirty dishes later, I admitted defeat. The restaurant’s version had something magical my kitchen experiments couldn’t capture.
Some locals joke that the secret ingredient might be the restaurant’s history itself. Decades of perfecting the recipe in that same kitchen, serving generations of satisfied customers.
More Than Just One Amazing Dessert
While the Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie steals the spotlight, The Fox & Hounds offers a full menu of delicious comfort food. Their hearty steaks and fresh seafood options have earned praise from diners and food critics alike.
The restaurant takes pride in sourcing quality ingredients, many from local Wisconsin farms. This farm-to-table approach shines through in dishes like their famous Friday fish fry and prime rib specials.
Vegetarians aren’t forgotten either, with several thoughtfully crafted meat-free options that go beyond typical side dishes. From appetizers to entrees, every menu item receives the same care and attention as their famous pie.
A Destination Worth The Drive
Located in Hubertus, Wisconsin, The Fox & Hounds might require a bit of a journey for those not in the immediate area. Trust me – every mile is worth it.
The restaurant sits amid beautiful countryside scenery, making the drive itself part of the experience. Many visitors combine their dining trip with outdoor activities in the area, creating a perfect day out.
I still remember my first visit five years ago. After hearing about this pie for months, I finally made the 45-minute drive from Milwaukee. As I took my first bite of that legendary dessert, all I could think was, “I’d happily drive twice as far for this.”
Special Occasion Spot
For generations of Wisconsin families, The Fox & Hounds has been the backdrop for life’s biggest celebrations. Birthdays, anniversaries, promotions – all made more memorable with a slice of their famous pie.
The restaurant offers semi-private dining areas that can accommodate larger groups without sacrificing the intimate atmosphere. Regulars know to book well in advance for holiday gatherings, as tables fill up quickly.
What sets their special occasion service apart is attention to detail. The staff goes above and beyond to acknowledge birthdays or anniversaries with small touches that make guests feel truly celebrated.
A Slice To Go? Yes, Please!
Can’t finish your pie after a filling meal? No problem! The Fox & Hounds happily packages slices to go, ensuring you can enjoy that chocolate-peanut butter goodness later.
Many customers actually plan ahead and order whole pies to take home. During holidays, especially Thanksgiving and Christmas, pre-orders for these pies stack up weeks in advance. The restaurant limits daily whole-pie sales to ensure fresh quality.
Their takeout packaging deserves special mention – carefully designed to keep that perfect pie texture intact during transport. Even after refrigeration, the pie maintains its delicious consistency, though most slices don’t survive long enough to need storing!