15 Cinnamon Roll Brands Ranked Best To Worst

Who doesn’t love waking up to the sweet aroma of cinnamon rolls baking in the oven? These gooey, swirled treats have become a breakfast favorite for families everywhere, offering that perfect blend of sweet cinnamon and creamy icing.

But not all store-bought options are created equal, and choosing the wrong brand can turn your morning delight into a disappointing dud.

1. Pillsbury Grands! Flaky Cinnamon Rolls with Cinnabon Icing

Pillsbury Grands! Flaky Cinnamon Rolls with Cinnabon Icing
© Amazon.com

These bakery-style beauties consistently win taste tests for good reason. The dough puffs up gloriously, creating those irresistible flaky layers that practically shatter when you bite into them.

The Cinnabon-branded icing delivers that perfect cream cheese tang we all crave. My family actually fought over the last roll during our Christmas morning breakfast last year – they’re that good!

2. Immaculate Baking Ready-to-Bake Cinnamon Rolls with Icing

Immaculate Baking Ready-to-Bake Cinnamon Rolls with Icing
© Instacart

Health-conscious cinnamon roll lovers, rejoice! These organic, non-GMO rolls manage to deliver authentic bakery quality without artificial ingredients.

The robust cinnamon flavor permeates every bite, while the dough achieves that perfect balance between fluffy and chewy.

Though slightly pricier than conventional options, the clean ingredient list and bold flavor profile make these worth every penny for discerning breakfast enthusiasts.

3. Annie’s Organic Cinnamon Rolls

Annie's Organic Cinnamon Rolls
© abillion

Annie’s knocks it out of the park with these organic treasures. The dough rises beautifully, creating pillowy-soft rolls with just the right amount of flakiness around the edges.

The cinnamon filling tastes genuinely spicy rather than artificially sweet. I still remember my daughter’s fifth birthday when we made these instead of cake – her little face lit up with each bite, and she declared them “better than birthday cake!”

4. Kroger Ooey Gooey Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls with Buttercream Icing

Kroger Ooey Gooey Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls with Buttercream Icing
© Kroger

Don’t underestimate this grocery store gem! Kroger’s jumbo rolls feature a thick, paste-like cinnamon filling that caramelizes beautifully during baking.

The buttercream icing deserves special mention – rich, creamy, and generous enough to coat every nook and cranny.

These substantial rolls nearly toppled our top three contenders in blind taste tests, proving store brands can compete with the big names when done right.

5. Rhodes Frozen Cinnamon Rolls

Rhodes Frozen Cinnamon Rolls
© Savoring The Good

Rhodes rolls require a bit more patience, but oh, what a reward awaits! These frozen delights need thawing and rising time, making them the closest experience to homemade without the mixing and kneading.

The yeast-raised dough creates an ethereal texture that’s impossibly light. Growing up, my grandmother would prep these the night before special occasions – I’d wake to the intoxicating smell of baking cinnamon and know the day would be magical.

6. Pillsbury Original Cinnamon Rolls with Original Icing

Pillsbury Original Cinnamon Rolls with Original Icing
© Amazon.com

Nostalgia in a tube! These iconic rolls have launched countless childhood memories of Saturday mornings and special treats.

While not as large or flaky as their Grands! counterparts, these classics deliver reliable cinnamon flavor and that signature sweet icing that hardens just enough on top.

The pop of the tube still makes me jump every time, just like when I was eight years old helping my dad make weekend breakfast!

7. Pillsbury Mini Cinni Stix

Pillsbury Mini Cinni Stix
© spoilyourdinner

Sometimes good things come in small packages! These bite-sized cinnamon treats develop wonderfully crisp edges while maintaining a tender center. The cinnamon icing creates perfect little dippable sticks that kids absolutely adore.

The portion-controlled format prevents overindulgence while still satisfying that cinnamon roll craving, though you might find yourself popping “just one more” until the plate is mysteriously empty!

8. Walmart Bakery Cinnamon Rolls

Walmart Bakery Cinnamon Rolls
© Walmart

Fresh-baked convenience gives these supermarket rolls their edge. Found in Walmart’s bakery section, these ready-to-eat treats eliminate preparation entirely.

The generous icing application ensures sweetness in every bite, while the soft dough maintains freshness surprisingly well.

Though not quite reaching the heights of our top contenders, these make an excellent grab-and-go option when time constraints make baking impossible.

9. Aldi Bake House Creations Cinnamon Rolls

Aldi Bake House Creations Cinnamon Rolls
© Aldi Reviewer

Budget-conscious bakers, take note! These Aldi exclusives have cultivated a devoted following among thrifty shoppers. Fans praise the dough quality and generous cinnamon filling, though some batches suffer from consistency issues.

When I moved into my first apartment in college, these affordable rolls became my Sunday morning ritual – I’d splurge on real butter to spread on top and feel like I was living luxuriously on a student budget!

10. Target Simple Truth Organic Cinnamon Rolls

Target Simple Truth Organic Cinnamon Rolls
© Business Insider

These health-conscious rolls offer a solid organic option at a reasonable price point. The clean ingredient list appeals to label-readers everywhere, though the dough doesn’t achieve the impressive rise of conventional alternatives.

The cinnamon flavor comes through authentically, making these a respectable choice for organic households. Perfect for those unwilling to compromise on ingredients but still craving that classic cinnamon roll experience.

11. Pillsbury Pumpkin Spice Rolls (Seasonal)

Pillsbury Pumpkin Spice Rolls (Seasonal)
© Good Morning America

Fall fanatics count down to these limited-edition treats each year! The pumpkin-infused dough delivers subtle seasonal flavor without overwhelming the classic cinnamon experience. The special spiced icing complements the autumnal theme perfectly.

During last year’s family pumpkin carving session, I served these warm from the oven – even my pumpkin-spice-skeptic brother-in-law had to admit they were fantastic.

12. Pillsbury Grands! with Original Icing

Pillsbury Grands! with Original Icing
© Fry’s Food Stores

Reliability earns these rolls their mid-list ranking. The standard Grands! formula delivers consistently good results with the traditional white icing many grew up loving.

While lacking the flakiness of our top-ranked variation, these maintain the generous size and satisfying texture that’s become synonymous with the Grands! name.

Sometimes the classics endure for good reason – these remain a pantry staple for countless American households.

13. Great Value Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese Icing

Great Value Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese Icing
© YouTube

Wallet-friendly pricing makes these Walmart staples tempting for bargain hunters. The cream cheese icing delivers reasonable flavor, providing adequate sweetness to complement the cinnamon filling.

Unfortunately, the dough often disappoints with its slightly cardboard-like quality. In a pinch, these will satisfy a cinnamon roll craving without breaking the bank, but they won’t create the memorable breakfast experience of higher-ranked options.

14. Pillsbury Cinnamon Rolls Original Icing (Budget Version)

Pillsbury Cinnamon Rolls Original Icing (Budget Version)
© Reddit

Crisp edges become the unexpected highlight of these economical rolls. The smaller size and lower price point make these accessible to tight budgets, though the experience differs significantly from premium options.

The texture leans surprisingly biscuit-like rather than delivering the gooey indulgence most cinnamon roll enthusiasts seek.

These remind me of elementary school cafeteria cinnamon rolls – not amazing, but they still somehow trigger warm memories of chocolate milk and lunch trays.

15. Amazon Happy Belly Cinnamon Rolls

Amazon Happy Belly Cinnamon Rolls
© Business Insider

Online convenience can’t salvage these disappointing rolls. Amazon’s house brand entry into the cinnamon roll market falls noticeably flat with its bread-like texture that misses the mark entirely.

The bland cinnamon filling lacks the aromatic punch that defines a proper cinnamon roll experience. Even the icing fails to rescue these forgettable pastries.

One desperate morning when our grocery delivery was delayed, these arrived via Prime – my kids asked if we could have toast instead.