10 Florida Pizza Places That Locals Swear Serve The Best Slices Under The Sun

Florida isn’t just about beaches and theme parks. The Sunshine State has quietly become a pizza lover’s paradise, with pies that rival anything you’d find up north.

From crispy Neapolitan crusts to thick, cheesy New York slices, these local spots have perfected the art of pizza making. Whether you’re a tourist or a longtime resident, these ten pizzerias deserve a spot on your must-visit list.

1. La LeGGenda Pizzeria, Miami Beach

Authentic Neapolitan pizza doesn’t get much better than what you’ll find at this Miami Beach gem. The owners imported their massive oven straight from Italy, and it shows in every bite.

Each pie comes out with a perfectly charred crust that’s crispy on the outside but soft and chewy inside. The San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella taste like they were plucked from a Napoli garden this morning.

Locals line up here because the quality never wavers, and the prices won’t empty your wallet either.

2. ‘O Munaciello, Miami (MiMo & Coral Way)

Named after a Neapolitan folklore character, this spot brings serious Italian tradition to Miami’s streets. Two locations mean more people can experience the magic without driving across town.

The dough ferments for days, creating complex flavors that mass-produced pizza joints can’t touch. Toppings range from classic margherita to creative combinations that respect Italian roots while embracing Florida’s fresh ingredients.

You’ll hear Italian spoken at nearby tables, which tells you everything about how genuine this place really is.

3. La Natural, Miami (Little River)

Health-conscious pizza lovers finally have their champion. La Natural proves that wholesome ingredients and mouthwatering flavor can absolutely coexist on the same plate.

Their sourdough crust gets made with organic flour and wild yeast, then topped with vegetables from local farms and hormone-free meats. The result tastes surprisingly indulgent despite being better for you than typical pizza.

Even my picky cousin who claims to hate healthy food devoured three slices last month and asked when we could return.

4. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza, Miami

Extraordinary isn’t just part of the name here. It’s a promise they keep with every unconventional pizza that leaves their kitchen.

The menu reads like a culinary adventure, with combinations you’d never imagine but somehow work perfectly together. Think truffle cream, burrata, and unexpected ingredient pairings that make your taste buds do a happy dance.

Multiple Miami locations have opened because word spread fast about these inventive pies that push boundaries while respecting pizza fundamentals.

5. Pizza Craft, Fort Lauderdale

Craft is the perfect word for what happens inside this Fort Lauderdale favorite. Every pizza gets treated like an art project worthy of a museum.

The wood-fired oven cranks out pies with blistered crusts and smoky undertones that gas ovens simply cannot replicate. Fresh ingredients arrive daily, ensuring your toppings taste as vibrant as they look.

Families pack this place on weekends, and the patio seating makes it easy to enjoy Florida’s weather alongside your meal.

6. Jay Luigi’s, St. Petersburg

New York transplants weep with joy when they bite into Jay Luigi’s pizza. This St. Petersburg institution nails the authentic Big Apple style that’s hard to find down south.

Giant slices fold perfectly in half, just like they should, with grease dripping down in that weirdly satisfying way.

The sauce has the right tang, the cheese stretches for miles, and the crust hits that sweet spot between crispy and floppy. Grab a slice and understand why locals refuse to eat anywhere else.

7. Bro’s Pizza, Largo

Sometimes you want pizza that feels like a warm hug from an old friend. Bro’s delivers exactly that kind of comfort with every order.

The crust comes thick and doughy, loaded with enough cheese and toppings to satisfy even the hungriest appetite. Nothing fancy happens here, just honest pizza made by people who clearly care about feeding their community well.

Prices stay reasonable, portions stay generous, and the friendly staff remembers your name after a couple visits.

8. Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza, Tampa

Eddie and Sam clearly grew up eating real New York pizza because they’ve recreated it flawlessly in Tampa. The recipe stays true to East Coast traditions that many Florida shops get wrong.

Thin crust crackles when you bite it, never turning soggy even when loaded with toppings. The cheese-to-sauce ratio hits perfection, and the garlic knots could convert sworn garlic haters.

Multiple Tampa locations prove that quality and expansion can happen simultaneously when you refuse to cut corners.

9. Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza, Clearwater

Coal ovens create a distinct flavor that gas and wood just can’t match. Cristino’s uses this old-school method to produce pizzas with character and soul.

The intense heat chars the crust in all the right spots, adding smoky depth to every slice. Traditional Italian recipes guide the menu, but the execution feels personal rather than corporate.

Clearwater residents guard this secret jealously, though the cat’s probably out of the bag now that lines stretch out the door most evenings.

10. Prato, Winter Park

Winter Park’s Prato elevates pizza into something special without losing sight of what makes it comforting. The atmosphere feels more refined than your typical pizza joint, but the food stays approachable.

Seasonal ingredients shine on creative pies that change throughout the year, keeping regulars excited to see what’s new. The crust achieves that rare balance of substantial yet airy.

Date night or family dinner, this place handles both occasions with equal grace and consistently outstanding food.