7 Garlic Bread Brands To Skip And 7 You Should Grab Instead

Garlic bread elevates any meal from ordinary to something with its buttery, aromatic goodness. But not all garlic breads deserve a spot at your dinner table. Some brands deliver that perfect crunch and flavor explosion, while others fall disappointingly flat.

Let’s explore which garlic bread brands should stay on the shelf and which ones deserve your hard-earned dollars.

1. AVOID: Pepperidge Farm Frozen Garlic Bread

Butter takes center stage while garlic plays hide-and-seek in this bland offering. Despite the trusted name, this bread consistently underwhelms with its soggy texture that no amount of oven time seems to fix.

The 2024 taste tests confirmed what many home cooks already suspected – this bread is all butter, no bite. Save your money for something that actually delivers the garlic punch you’re craving.

2. AVOID: New York Bakery Garlic Knots & Breadsticks

Ghost garlic alert! These knots and breadsticks promise garlic goodness but deliver disappointment. The texture crumbles faster than a sandcastle at high tide, dissolving into a strange paste that leaves you questioning your snack choices.

Both the knot and Texas toast varieties consistently rank at the bottom of taste tests. What’s the point of garlic bread that lacks the star ingredient? Your taste buds deserve better treatment.

3. AVOID: Bridgford Monkey Garlic Bread

Raw bottoms and rancid flavors make this bread a definite pass. The name ‘Monkey Bread’ suggests something fun and pull-apart delicious, but the reality is far from appetizing.

I once served this at a dinner party before testing it, and my guests politely pushed it around their plates. Talk about embarrassment!

The bread fails to meet even the most basic garlic bread standards – crispy exterior, soft interior, and actual garlic flavor.

4. AVOID: Gillian’s Gluten-Free Garlic Bread

Gluten-free shouldn’t mean flavor-free! This bread seems to have forgotten that garlic is supposed to be the star of the show. The texture manages to be acceptable for gluten-free, but the complete absence of garlic makes this more like plain toast.

Those with celiac disease deserve better options. Several competitors have proven that gluten-free garlic bread can still pack a flavorful punch, making this brand’s bland offering even more disappointing.

5. AVOID: Target Market Pantry Garlic Bread

Buttered toast masquerading as garlic bread! The faint whisper of garlic in this loaf requires superhuman taste buds to detect. Target usually nails their store brands, making this miss particularly surprising.

The bread itself has a decent texture, but calling it garlic bread feels like false advertising. My garlic-loving grandmother squinted at me suspiciously when I served this, asking if I’d forgotten the main ingredient.

Save your Target run for other pantry staples.

6. AVOID: Mama Cozzi’s Garlic Texas Toast (Aldi)

Crispy texture can’t compensate for the anemic garlic flavor in this Aldi offering. The bread achieves a satisfying crunch, but each bite leaves you wondering if someone forgot to add the garlic during production.

Butter dominates the flavor profile, overwhelming any hint of garlic that managed to make it into the final product.

While not terrible, it fails to deliver the robust garlic experience that makes Texas toast worth the calories.

7. AVOID: Great Value Frozen Garlic Bread (Walmart)

Middle-of-the-road mediocrity defines this Walmart staple. While not offensive to the palate, it lacks the garlicky punch that transforms a simple side into something memorable. The bread itself maintains adequate structure, but flavor intensity falls short.

When comparing directly with premium brands, the difference becomes glaringly obvious. Consider this acceptable in a pinch, but not worthy of your regular shopping list. Your pasta dishes deserve a more enthusiastic companion.

8. GRAB: Furlani Garlic Texas Toast

Garlic powerhouse with attitude! This bread consistently dominates taste tests with its perfect balance of crunchy exterior and soft interior. The garlic powder distribution achieves flavor uniformity that many competitors miss.

Each bite delivers that satisfying crunch followed by a full-bodied garlic experience. I’ve converted many garlic bread skeptics with this brand alone.

For the price point, nothing else on the market delivers this level of consistent garlic bread perfection.

9. GRAB: Pepperidge Farm Garlic Texas Toast

Food Republic crowned this the frozen garlic bread champion for good reason! Unlike its disappointing loaf counterpart, the Texas toast version strikes gold with its perfectly calibrated garlic-butter ratio.

The exterior achieves that coveted crisp while maintaining a tender interior. Last Super Bowl, I put out three different brands for testing, and this plate emptied first.

Even my picky brother-in-law went back for seconds – the ultimate endorsement in our family!

10. GRAB: New York Bakery Garlic Texas Toast

Caramelization magic happens when this bread hits your oven! While their knots disappoint, the Texas toast variety achieves garlic bread nirvana. The edges develop a beautiful golden-brown color that signals flavor perfection.

The garlic-butter balance hits the sweet spot – present without overwhelming. Each piece maintains structural integrity from plate to mouth without crumbling.

A consistently high-ranking option that deserves your freezer space.

11. GRAB: Nature’s Promise Roasted Garlic Artisan Bread

Sophisticated garlic bread for discerning palates! This Stop & Shop premium option elevates garlic bread from simple side to conversation starter. The base bread quality surpasses typical frozen options, providing an artisanal foundation for the subtle roasted garlic infusion.

Rather than shouting, the garlic whispers throughout each bite. I served this at a dinner party with a homemade lasagna, and guests assumed I’d made the bread from scratch! Sometimes subtlety trumps intensity.

12. GRAB: Julian’s Recipe Traditional Baguette with Garlic

Baguette-style garlic bread that transports you straight to Paris! Tasting Table ranks this as top-tier for good reason – the authentic baguette texture provides the perfect canvas for the garlic spread.

The exterior achieves that quintessential baguette crackle while maintaining a tender interior. The garlic distribution shows attention to detail, with consistent flavor in every bite.

Perfect for those seeking a more sophisticated garlic bread experience without the homemade effort.

13. GRAB: Mama Cozzi’s Texas Toast (side variant)

Butter lovers, rejoice! While light on garlic, this variant makes up for it with exceptional crispiness and rich buttery goodness. The texture achieves that satisfying crunch that makes Texas toast worth the calories.

Sometimes you want buttery crunch without garlic domination. My kids, who normally pick off “green stuff” from their bread, devour this version without complaint.

For households with varying garlic tolerance levels, this middle-ground option keeps everyone happy.

14. GRAB: Great Value Frozen Texas Toast

Budget-friendly reliability in garlic bread form! This Walmart option delivers consistent performance that exceeds expectations for its price point. While not the most intense garlic experience, it provides satisfying texture and enough flavor to complement most meals.

The bread crisps up nicely with proper baking, avoiding the sogginess that plagues many frozen options. For everyday family meals when you’re watching your grocery budget, this dependable choice satisfies without breaking the bank.