12 Hidden New York Burger Joints Serving Double Cheeseburgers That Define The City
New York City is famous for its pizza and hot dogs, but the burger scene here is equally legendary.
Tucked away in neighborhoods across Manhattan and Brooklyn, some of the best double cheeseburgers in America are hiding in plain sight.
These aren’t the flashy chains or tourist traps—they’re the real deal, where locals go when they’re craving something juicy, cheesy, and unforgettable.
1. Burger Joint (Midtown Manhattan)
Walking past the velvet curtain in a fancy hotel lobby feels like discovering a secret speakeasy, except instead of cocktails, you’re greeted by the smell of sizzling beef. I stumbled upon this place by accident three years ago, and it’s been my guilty pleasure ever since.
The double cheeseburger here is no-frills perfection—two juicy patties, melted American cheese, and all the classic toppings. The walls are covered in graffiti, giving it a dive bar vibe that’s worlds away from the polished hotel outside.
Cash only, so hit the ATM first. Lines can get long during lunch, but trust me, it’s worth the wait. This burger doesn’t try to be fancy, and that’s exactly why it works.
2. 7th Street Burger (East Village)
Smash burgers have taken over the city, and this tiny East Village spot does them better than anyone else. The patties get pressed thin on a scorching griddle, creating those crispy, caramelized edges that burger fanatics dream about.
Their double cheeseburger is a masterpiece of simplicity. Two smashed patties, gooey cheese, pickles, onions, and a tangy sauce that ties everything together. The buns are soft and lightly toasted, soaking up all those meaty juices without falling apart.
Seating is limited, so grab your burger and head to Tompkins Square Park if the weather’s nice. I once ate three of these in one week during a particularly stressful work project. No regrets whatsoever.
3. Red Hook Tavern (Brooklyn)
Brooklyn knows how to do comfort food right, and this tavern in Red Hook proves it. The neighborhood might be a bit out of the way, but locals guard this place like a treasured secret.
Their double cheeseburger uses locally sourced beef that’s cooked to a perfect medium, with cheese that melts into every crevice. The brioche bun adds a slight sweetness that balances the savory meat beautifully. They also offer bacon as an add-on, which I highly recommend.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with exposed brick walls and friendly bartenders who remember your order. Pair your burger with their craft drink selection for the ultimate Brooklyn experience. Weekend brunch here is packed, so plan accordingly.
4. Gotham Burger Social Club (Lower East Side)
Social clubs usually mean exclusive membership and stuffy rules, but this burger joint welcomes everyone with open arms and open grills. The Lower East Side location fits perfectly with the neighborhood’s edgy, artistic vibe.
What sets their double cheeseburger apart is the custom beef blend—a mix that creates incredible flavor and the perfect fat ratio. The cheese is always melted just right, and they don’t skimp on portions.
I love their creative topping options, but honestly, the classic double cheeseburger needs nothing extra. The meat speaks for itself. Late-night hours make this a perfect post-concert or post-bar stop. Their milkshakes are also ridiculously good if you’re feeling indulgent.
5. Lovely’s Old Fashioned (Hell’s Kitchen)
Sometimes you want a burger that tastes like it came straight from a 1950s diner, and that’s exactly what you’ll find here. Hell’s Kitchen has changed a lot over the years, but this spot keeps the old-school spirit alive.
Their double cheeseburger is gloriously simple—two beef patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and their secret sauce. The patties are thick and cooked on a flat-top griddle that’s probably older than I am.
The retro decor isn’t just for show; it’s authentic, down to the vinyl booths and jukebox in the corner. Service is quick and friendly, with servers who treat regulars like family. Grab a seat at the counter for the full experience.
6. Nowon (East Village)
Korean flavors meet American burger culture in the most delicious way possible. This East Village gem puts a unique spin on the double cheeseburger that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance.
While they’re known for their Korean-inspired creations, their take on the classic double cheeseburger incorporates subtle Asian influences that elevate it without overwhelming the beef. The patties are juicy and well-seasoned, with cheese that complements rather than dominates.
The restaurant itself is small and modern, with minimalist decor that lets the food be the star. I appreciate how they respect burger traditions while adding their own creative flair. Their kimchi fries on the side are absolutely addictive, fair warning.
7. Burger By Day (Chinatown)
Finding a great burger in Chinatown might seem odd, but this place proves that good food transcends neighborhood expectations. The name tells you exactly what they do—burgers during the day, and they do them exceptionally well.
Their double cheeseburger is straightforward and satisfying, with quality beef that’s never frozen. The cheese melts perfectly over two well-seasoned patties, and the bun holds everything together without getting soggy. Simple condiments let the meat shine.
The spot is tiny, with just a few seats, so most people grab their burgers to go. I like eating mine while wandering through the neighborhood’s bustling streets. Prices are reasonable too, which is refreshing in a city where everything costs a fortune.
8. L’Artusi (West Village)
Italian restaurants aren’t usually where you’d hunt for burgers, but L’Artusi breaks all the rules. This West Village favorite is known for pasta, yet their burger has developed a cult following among those in the know.
The double cheeseburger here is a refined take on the classic—high-quality beef with a perfect char, artisanal cheese, and toppings that show Italian influence. It’s not always on the menu, making it feel even more special when you can order it.
The elegant atmosphere contrasts beautifully with the casual nature of burger-eating. I felt fancy devouring mine at their sleek bar. Reservations are tough to snag, but showing up early for a bar seat usually works.
9. Diner (Brooklyn)
Housed in an actual converted dining car, this Williamsburg institution has been serving burgers since before the neighborhood became trendy. The retro vibe isn’t manufactured—this place has genuine history in its bones.
Their double cheeseburger stays true to diner classics while using quality ingredients that make all the difference. The beef is juicy, the cheese is melted to gooey perfection, and everything tastes like it was made with care.
The narrow space and counter seating create an intimate, communal dining experience. I’ve had some great conversations with strangers while eating burgers here. Open late, it’s perfect for satisfying those midnight cravings when nothing else will do.
10. Ruby Café (SoHo)
Australian cafe culture meets New York burger obsession at this charming SoHo spot. While they’re famous for brunch and coffee, their burger game is seriously underrated and deserves way more attention.
The double cheeseburger combines American classics with a subtle Aussie twist—think beetroot as an optional topping. The patties are thick and flavorful, with cheese that cascades down the sides in the most appealing way possible.
The laid-back atmosphere makes it feel like a neighborhood hangout despite being in tourist-heavy SoHo. Staff are genuinely friendly, not just New York-polite. I always leave feeling satisfied and slightly guilty about how many calories I just consumed, but mostly satisfied.
11. Emily (West Village)
Pizza restaurants making incredible burgers might sound strange, but Emily’s famous Emmy Burger has won awards and stolen hearts across the city. The West Village location buzzes with energy from morning until night.
Their signature burger can be ordered as a double, and you absolutely should. The pretzel bun is a game-changer, adding a unique texture and flavor that regular buns can’t match. The cheese, sauce, and toppings create perfect harmony with the beef.
Reservations are essential because this place stays packed. I’ve converted several burger skeptics by bringing them here. The combination of excellent pizza and outstanding burgers means everyone in your group leaves happy, which is rare in this opinionated city.
12. Corner Bistro (Greenwich Village)
Some places become institutions not through marketing but through decades of consistently great burgers. Corner Bistro has been slinging their famous Bistro Burger since 1961, and the formula hasn’t needed changing.
The double cheeseburger here is massive, messy, and absolutely glorious. Thick patties, melted cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and raw onion all pile onto a soft bun that somehow holds together. Eating it requires both hands and zero dignity.
The dark, divey atmosphere feels authentically New York—no pretense, no fuss, just good food and cold drink. Prices remain shockingly reasonable for the Village. Cash only, and expect to wait, but every minute is worth it for this legendary burger experience.