I Hit The Backroads Of Michigan To Try 7 Coney Dog Counters (And 3 Blew Me Away)
Michigan is the birthplace of the coney dog, a culinary icon that has sparked fierce debates and unwavering loyalty across the state.
I spent weeks zigzagging through cities and small towns, sampling coney dogs at ten legendary spots to see which ones truly earned their reputation.
Some left me speechless with their perfect balance of flavors, while others were just okay.
1. Lafayette Coney Island (Detroit)
Walking into Lafayette felt like stepping into a time capsule where nothing has changed since 1924, and honestly, that is exactly what makes it magical. The narrow counter was packed with locals who clearly knew what they were ordering before they even sat down. I grabbed a stool and watched the cooks work with lightning speed, assembling coney dogs like artists with a well-practiced routine.
My first bite was a revelation. The chili had this slightly spicy, meaty richness that coated every inch of the snappy natural-casing hot dog. Mustard and raw onions added the perfect tangy crunch. The bun was steamed just enough to be soft without falling apart.
Lafayette is not just a restaurant; it is a Detroit institution that has perfected its craft over nearly a century.
2. American Coney Island (Detroit)
Right next door to Lafayette sits its famous rival, American Coney Island, and the sibling rivalry is real. Founded by a brother who split from Lafayette, American has its own loyal following and slightly different vibe. The dining room is bigger, the booths are red, and the menu offers more variety beyond just coney dogs.
The coney here tasted different from Lafayette, with a sweeter, thicker chili that clung to the hot dog like a warm blanket. Some folks swear by American, claiming the chili has more depth and complexity. I found it delicious but less punchy than Lafayette. The hot dog itself was perfectly grilled, and the onions were diced finer.
Choosing between these two is like picking a favorite child, and Detroiters have been doing it for generations.
3. Duly’s Place Coney Island (Detroit)
Tucked away in a quieter Detroit neighborhood, Duly’s Place does not have the same flashy reputation as Lafayette or American, but it absolutely deserves more love. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the owner, who treated me like an old friend even though it was my first visit. The atmosphere was cozy, unpretentious, and refreshingly welcoming.
The coney dog here surprised me with its bold, garlicky chili that had a hint of smokiness I had not tasted anywhere else. The hot dog was plump and juicy, and the bun was perfectly toasted on the edges. Every bite felt like a hug from someone who genuinely cares about good food.
Duly’s is proof that you do not need fame to serve an unforgettable coney dog.
4. Kerby’s Koney Island (Metro Detroit)
Kerby’s has been a metro Detroit staple since 1949, and it is the kind of place where families gather for breakfast, lunch, and late-night cravings. The menu is huge, offering everything from Greek salads to breakfast skillets, but I was there for one thing only. The coney dog arrived hot and messy, just the way it should be.
What stood out to me was the consistency. The chili was well-seasoned without being too salty, and the hot dog had a satisfying snap with every bite. The onions were fresh and crunchy, adding a nice contrast to the rich chili. It was not the most adventurous coney I tried, but it was solid and reliable.
Kerby’s is the kind of spot you can count on, no matter what time of day you visit.
5. National Coney Island (Multiple Locations)
National Coney Island is the chain that brought Detroit-style coneys to the suburbs, and while some purists scoff at the idea of a coney chain, I have to admit they do a pretty decent job. With locations all over Michigan, National makes it easy to grab a coney no matter where you are. The restaurants are clean, bright, and family-friendly.
The coney dog here was good but played it safe. The chili was mild and slightly sweet, which might appeal to folks who prefer less spice. The hot dog was standard, and the bun was soft but not particularly memorable. I appreciated the convenience and consistency, but it lacked the soul and character of the smaller, independent spots.
National is perfect for a quick, reliable coney fix when you are on the go.
6. George’s Coney Island (Westland)
George’s Coney Island in Westland is one of Michigan’s most beloved hidden gems— the kind of place locals fiercely protect like a secret family recipe. The diner is small, cozy, and filled with regulars who know the staff by name. I slid into a booth and ordered a coney, curious to see if the hype was real. Spoiler alert: it absolutely was.
The chili here had a unique, slightly tangy flavor that set it apart from everywhere else I had been in Michigan. It was meaty, flavorful, and had just the right amount of spice to make my taste buds dance. The hot dog was grilled to perfection, and the bun was lightly buttered and toasted. Every element worked together in perfect harmony.
George’s is the kind of Michigan spot that makes you want to become a regular yourself.
7. Senate Coney Island (Detroit)
Senate Coney Island has been serving Detroit since 1946, and it still feels like a portal to mid-century America. The neon sign outside glows like a beacon, and inside, the counter and stools are straight out of a classic diner movie. I sat down and ordered a coney, excited to try another piece of Detroit history.
The coney dog was fantastic. The chili was rich and hearty, with a deep, savory flavor that reminded me of homemade comfort food. The hot dog had a great snap, and the mustard and onions were perfectly proportioned. What really impressed me was how fresh everything tasted, despite the retro setting.
Senate is a must-visit for anyone who loves coney dogs and appreciates a good dose of nostalgia with their meal.