I Hit the Backroads of Virginia to Try 12 Hidden Seafood Shacks (And 7 Were Better Than You’d Believe)
Virginia’s coastline hides some of the best seafood spots you’ve never heard of, tucked away on quiet roads where locals don’t want tourists to find them.
I spent weeks driving through small towns and following hand-painted signs to discover which backroad shacks serve the freshest catches.
Some places looked sketchy from the outside but served mind-blowing crab cakes, while others had fancy facades but disappointing food.
Here are all twelve spots I visited, including the seven that absolutely blew me away.
1. The Great Machipongo Clam Shack – Nassawadox
Pulling up to this place feels like stumbling onto a movie set for a coastal fishing village.
The weathered wooden building sits right off Lankford Highway, and you can smell the salt air mixed with steaming seafood before you even park.
Located at 6468 Lankford Hwy, Nassawadox, VA 23413, this gem specializes in clams so fresh they were probably underwater that morning.
Their clam strips are golden, crispy, and absolutely addictive—like potato chips but way better.
The staff treats everyone like family, remembering regular customers’ usual orders and chatting about the day’s catch.
Portions are generous enough to share, though you probably won’t want to.
Picnic tables outside offer a relaxed roadside setting, though the location is not waterfront despite the coastal vibe.
This spot earns its place among the magnificent seven because it nails the basics while adding that special touch only true seafood lovers understand.
Cash is accepted here, but they also take cards, so you’re covered either way.
The simplicity of their menu proves that when you start with quality ingredients, you don’t need fancy preparations.
2. The Shanty – Cape Charles
Nestled at 33 Marina Rd, Cape Charles, VA 23310, The Shanty combines stunning marina views with seriously good seafood.
Walking in feels like entering your beach-loving friend’s upgraded backyard hangout.
The casual atmosphere doesn’t prepare you for how expertly they prepare their fish.
Their crab cakes contain actual chunks of crab instead of filler—a rarity that deserves applause.
Watching boats drift by while you eat makes the experience feel like a mini-vacation.
The menu changes based on what local fishermen bring in, which means you’re always getting the freshest options available.
Service strikes the perfect balance between attentive and laid-back.
You’ll never feel rushed, even during busy lunch hours.
Their hush puppies deserve a special mention—crispy outside, fluffy inside, with just enough sweetness.
This definitely ranks among the top seven because everything from the setting to the seasoning hits just right.
Parking can get tight during peak season, so arrive early or be prepared to walk a bit.
3. Merroir – Topping
Fancy meeting you here, in the middle of nowhere, at one of Virginia’s most surprisingly sophisticated seafood spots.
Merroir sits at 784 Locklies Creek Rd, Topping, VA 23169, and redefines what a “shack” can be.
The oysters here taste like the Chesapeake Bay decided to show off.
Each variety has distinct flavors that make you understand why oyster enthusiasts get so passionate.
The waterfront deck provides Instagram-worthy sunset views that rival the food for attention.
Their seafood comes directly from their own oyster farm, which explains the unbeatable freshness.
The menu is smaller than other places, but every single item has been perfected.
Staff members know their stuff and can explain the difference between oyster varieties like sommeliers discussing grapes.
This spot made my top seven because it proves that backroad seafood can be both rustic and refined.
Prices run slightly higher than typical shacks, but the quality justifies every penny.
Reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekend visits.
4. The Seafood Shack – Mathews
Blink while driving through Mathews and you’ll miss this unassuming building at 10744 Buckley Hall Rd, Mathews, VA 23109.
The exterior doesn’t win beauty contests, but who cares when the food tastes this good?
Their fried flounder is so light and flaky it practically melts on your tongue.
Locals pack this place during lunch hours, which always signals quality.
The coleslaw has a tangy kick that perfectly complements the fried seafood.
Prices remain remarkably reasonable, especially considering the portion sizes.
You’ll leave with a full belly and money still in your wallet.
The staff moves quickly during rushes but never makes you feel hurried.
Their tartar sauce tastes homemade because it actually is.
This spot didn’t quite make my top seven, but it’s still absolutely worth visiting.
The no-frills approach means they focus entirely on cooking great seafood.
Seating is limited, so takeout might be your best bet during peak times.
Cash and cards both work here, making it convenient for everyone.
5. N N Crab Shack – Heathsville
Hidden at 5057 Jessie Dupont Memorial Hwy, Heathsville, VA 22473, this spot serves crabs that’ll make you question why you ever ate them anywhere else.
The building looks like it’s been here forever, weathered by salt air and summer storms.
Steamed crabs arrive at your table hot, perfectly seasoned, and begging to be cracked open.
Their seasoning blend has just enough spice to make things interesting without overwhelming the sweet crab meat.
Paper-covered tables and mallets create an interactive dining experience that kids especially love.
The casual atmosphere encourages you to relax, get messy, and enjoy yourself.
Their crab soup is thick, hearty, and loaded with vegetables and meat.
Service is friendly in that genuine small-town way that can’t be faked.
This place earned a spot in my top seven because they understand that great crab needs minimal interference.
Bring wet wipes or be prepared to wash up afterward.
The outdoor seating area is perfect for warm evenings.
They sometimes run out of popular items, so calling ahead doesn’t hurt.
6. Crab Shack on the James – Newport News
Perched at 7601 River Rd, Newport News, VA 23607, this spot offers river views that almost distract from the excellent food.
Almost, but not quite.
Their soft-shell crab sandwich is a masterpiece of crispy, tender, and tangy flavors working together.
The deck seating puts you right above the water, where you can watch boats pass while you eat.
Seagulls circle overhead, hoping for scraps, which somehow adds to the authentic coastal experience.
Their shrimp comes in multiple preparations, but the steamed version lets the natural sweetness shine through.
The menu is extensive without being overwhelming, offering something for every seafood preference.
Families love this place because kids can move around a bit without bothering other diners.
Service stays cheerful even during the busiest times.
This one made my top seven because the combination of location, food quality, and atmosphere creates something special.
Sunset dinners here are particularly magical.
Parking is plentiful, which is a nice change from some cramped seafood spots.
7. Seafood Shack – Newport News
Tucked into a strip mall at 11710 Jefferson Ave Suite D, Newport News, VA 23606, this place proves that great seafood doesn’t need waterfront real estate.
The interior is simple and clean, focusing attention entirely on the food.
Their fried shrimp has a perfectly crispy coating that stays crunchy even after sitting for a few minutes.
The fish and chips could compete with any British pub’s version.
Portion sizes are generous enough that you’ll probably have leftovers.
Prices are incredibly fair, making this a great option for families or anyone watching their budget.
The staff clearly takes pride in their work, checking on tables regularly.
Their sides, especially the fries and hush puppies, complement the main dishes perfectly.
This spot didn’t make my top seven, but it’s still a solid choice for quality seafood.
The convenient location makes it easy to grab a quick meal.
Takeout orders are handled efficiently, perfect for beach picnics or eating at home.
The menu offers enough variety to satisfy different tastes and dietary preferences.
8. Captain Chuck-a-Muck’s Ship Store & Grill – Rescue
The name alone makes this place worth visiting, and the address—21088 Marina Rd, Rescue, VA 23424—sounds like the setup for an adventure story.
The nautical theme is strong here, with maritime decorations covering every available surface.
Their crab dip is dangerously addictive, served hot with crackers that never seem like enough.
The grill marks on their fish show proper technique, creating texture and flavor.
This spot functions as both a restaurant and a ship store, which adds to its unique character.
You can grab bait, supplies, and an excellent lunch all in one stop.
The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, with boaters and landlubbers mixing comfortably.
Their burgers deserve mention too, for anyone in your group who doesn’t eat seafood.
This place earned a spot in my top seven for its personality as much as its food.
The quirky charm and quality cooking create a memorable experience.
Service is laid-back but attentive, matching the overall vibe perfectly.
It’s the kind of place you’ll tell friends about.
9. Willoughby Fish House – Norfolk
Located at 1525 Bayville St, Norfolk, VA 23503, this fish house has a loyal following that knows good seafood when they taste it.
The building has character, the kind that comes from years of serving satisfied customers.
Their blackened fish has the perfect crust without being overly spicy.
The seasoning blend enhances rather than masks the fish’s natural flavor.
Their clam chowder is creamy and loaded with clams, not just filler.
Each spoonful delivers the goods.
While the core menu stays fairly consistent, they do offer rotating specials and seasonal catches that keep things interesting.
Regulars know to ask about daily specials, which often feature the best catches.
Service is efficient without feeling rushed, striking a nice balance.
This spot didn’t quite crack my top seven, but it’s still excellent.
The neighborhood location gives it a local favorite vibe that tourists rarely discover.
Parking is available on-site, though it can feel tight during busy hours.
Their commitment to quality over flash shows in every dish.
10. Tidewater Seafood Shack – Norfolk
Sitting at 7483 Tidewater Dr, Norfolk, VA 23505, this shack keeps things straightforward and delicious.
The no-nonsense approach means they concentrate on cooking seafood the right way.
Their oyster po’boy is messy in the best possible way, with crispy oysters and tangy sauce.
You’ll need extra napkins, but you won’t care.
The fried seafood combo platter offers a bit of everything, perfect for indecisive diners.
Portions are substantial, often providing leftovers for later.
The casual atmosphere encourages you to relax and enjoy your meal without pretension.
Staff members are friendly and helpful, answering questions about preparation methods.
This place made my top seven because they nail the classics without trying to reinvent the wheel.
Sometimes simple excellence beats fancy innovation.
The prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality and quantity.
Takeout is popular here, with many locals ordering regularly.
The consistent quality keeps customers coming back week after week.
11. Dockside Seafood & Fishing Center – Virginia Beach
At 3311 Shore Dr, Virginia Beach, VA 23451, this place combines a fishing center with a restaurant, guaranteeing freshness.
The fish literally goes from boat to kitchen to your plate.
Their crab cakes are all meat, no filler, held together with just enough binder.
Each bite delivers pure crab flavor.
The market area lets you buy fresh seafood to cook at home, if you’re so inclined.
Watching the fishing boats come in adds entertainment to your dining experience.
The restaurant area is casual and unpretentious, focusing on food quality.
Their steamed shrimp comes perfectly seasoned and easy to peel.
This spot earned its place in my top seven because the freshness factor is unbeatable.
When seafood is this fresh, simple preparation is all you need.
The staff knows their seafood and can offer cooking tips for your market purchases.
Parking is convenient, and the location is easy to find.
It’s a true working waterfront experience.
12. Bubba’s Seafood Restaurant & Crabhouse – Virginia Beach
Right next door to Dockside at 3323 Shore Dr, Virginia Beach, VA 23451, Bubba’s brings a fun, energetic vibe to seafood dining.
The colorful exterior and nautical decorations set expectations for a good time.
Their steamed crab buckets arrive piled high, inviting you to dig in.
The seasoning has a nice kick that builds gradually.
Their seafood platters offer variety and value, perfect for sharing.
The atmosphere is lively without being overwhelming, creating a festive mood.
Families appreciate the casual vibe where kids can be kids.
Service is attentive and friendly, matching the upbeat atmosphere.
Their hush puppies are addictive little balls of cornmeal happiness.
This place secured a spot in my top seven because it delivers both quality food and a memorable experience.
Sometimes the atmosphere enhances the flavors, making everything taste better.
The convenient location near other attractions makes it easy to include in your beach day.
Portions are generous, ensuring nobody leaves hungry.