11 Missouri Italian Spots Locals Say You Can’t Book Without Planning Ahead
Missouri’s Italian food scene is absolutely buzzing, and these eleven restaurants are so popular that snagging a table feels like winning the lottery.
Locals know the secret: if you want to enjoy authentic pasta, wood-fired pizza, and homemade sauces at these beloved spots, you better plan way ahead.
From St. Louis neighborhoods to Kansas City’s downtown and Springfield’s hidden spots, these Italian eateries have earned their reputation through incredible food and unforgettable dining experiences.
1. Charlie Gitto’s On The Hill
Reservations disappear faster than garlic bread at this legendary St. Louis institution, where generations of families have celebrated life’s biggest moments since 1981.
Charlie Gitto’s serves up toasted ravioli that locals swear is the best in the entire city, alongside generous portions of classic Italian-American favorites that keep people coming back decade after decade.
The atmosphere feels like stepping into a warm Italian embrace, with attentive servers who remember regulars by name and treat first-timers like long-lost family.
Location: 5226 Shaw Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110
2. Zia’s Restaurant
Lines snake around the block at this cash-only treasure where the Riggio family has been serving soul-warming Italian comfort food since 1989.
Their famous lasagna arrives at your table steaming hot and layered so perfectly that each bite delivers the ideal ratio of pasta, cheese, and rich meat sauce that dreams are made of.
Weekend waits can stretch beyond an hour, but regulars insist the homemade pasta and impossibly tender meatballs make every minute worthwhile.
Location: 5256 Wilson Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110
3. Anthonino’s Taverna
Book your spot at least two weeks ahead if you want to experience this neighborhood gem where Chef Anthony Scarato transforms simple ingredients into extraordinary culinary magic.
Regulars rave about the seafood specials that change with the seasons, showcasing the freshest catches prepared with traditional Italian techniques and modern creative flair.
The intimate space fills up quickly with devoted fans who appreciate the taverna’s commitment to authentic flavors and warm hospitality that makes everyone feel like honored guests.
Location: 2225 Macklind Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110
4. Trattoria Marcella
Chef Cassy Vires has created something truly special at this bustling trattoria where reservations vanish within hours of becoming available online.
Every pasta dish gets made from scratch daily, and the constantly rotating menu means adventurous eaters discover new favorite dishes with each visit to this culinary playground.
Weekend prime-time slots require serious advance planning, but the incredible gnocchi and perfectly executed Italian classics reward patient diners who plan ahead accordingly.
Location: 3600 Watson Rd, St. Louis, MO 63109
5. Salve Osteria
Smart diners call weeks in advance to secure a table at this beloved osteria where Chef Nate Hereford crafts rustic Italian dishes that transport taste buds straight to Tuscany.
The wood-fired pizzas emerge from the oven with perfectly charred crusts and creative topping combinations that balance tradition with playful innovation that delights adventurous palates.
Small plates designed for sharing encourage lively conversation and communal dining, making every meal feel like a festive Italian family gathering among dear friends.
Location: 3200 S Grand Blvd, St. Louis, MO 63118
6. Napoli 3
St. Charles residents know that spontaneous dinner plans rarely work out at this perpetually packed Italian hotspot where reservations book solid days in advance.
Their signature pasta dishes arrive perfectly al dente, swimming in sauces that taste like they’ve been simmering in an Italian grandmother’s kitchen for hours on end.
The spacious dining room somehow always feels full, testament to the restaurant’s reputation for consistently delivering exceptional Italian fare that keeps locals and visitors returning regularly.
Location: 1450 Beale St Ste 105, St. Charles, MO 63303
7. Louie
Scoring a reservation at this Clayton favorite requires the kind of advance planning usually reserved for destination weddings and international travel adventures.
Chef Ben Welch creates elevated Italian cuisine that respects tradition while embracing modern techniques, resulting in dishes that surprise and delight even the most seasoned Italian food enthusiasts.
The stylish atmosphere attracts business diners and date-night couples alike, all seeking the impeccable service and memorable meals that have made Louie legendary throughout the region.
Location: 706 De Mun Ave, Clayton, MO 63105
8. Cafe Napoli
Thirty years of serving exceptional Italian cuisine has made this Clayton establishment a reservation necessity, especially during weekend dinner service when tables fill completely.
Their veal dishes earn consistent praise from diners who appreciate the tender preparation and rich sauces that showcase classic Italian cooking at its absolute finest.
Regulars recommend booking at least ten days ahead for prime dining times, though the wait proves worthwhile when your perfectly prepared entrée arrives at the table.
Location: 7754 Forsyth Blvd, Clayton, MO 63105
9. Garozzo’s Ristorante
Kansas City’s downtown Italian crown jewel stays perpetually booked thanks to their famous chicken spiedini that has achieved near-mythical status among local food enthusiasts.
Family recipes passed down through generations shine in every dish, from the creamy fettuccine alfredo to the robust marinara sauce that tastes like pure Italian sunshine.
Weeknight reservations fill up fast, while weekend slots require calling well in advance to secure your spot at this beloved Kansas City dining institution.
Location: 526 Harrison St, Kansas City, MO 64106
10. Farina
Crossroads Arts District diners scramble for reservations at this trendy Italian spot where handmade pasta takes center stage in creative preparations that honor Italian tradition.
The open kitchen lets guests watch skilled chefs roll, cut, and shape fresh pasta throughout service, creating an entertaining dinner theater experience alongside exceptional food.
Prime weekend slots disappear immediately upon release, so savvy diners mark their calendars and book exactly when reservations open for their desired dates.
Location: 1901 Baltimore Ave, Kansas City, MO 64108
11. Avanzare Italian Dining
Springfield’s premier Italian destination requires serious advance planning, especially for special occasions when diners seek the refined atmosphere and exceptional service that defines Avanzare.
Each dish showcases premium ingredients prepared with meticulous attention to detail, from perfectly seared steaks to delicate pasta creations that demonstrate true culinary artistry.
The extensive menu offers something wonderful for every palate, making this upscale ristorante the go-to choice for celebrations and romantic evenings throughout southwest Missouri.
Location: 3240 S Fremont Ave, Springfield, MO 65804