Top 10 Most Delicious Chocolate Ice Creams
When the craving for something cold, creamy, and deeply chocolatey strikes, nothing satisfies quite like chocolate ice cream. Fortunately, the world of chocolate ice cream offers endless possibilities for dessert lovers.
I’ve sampled countless scoops to bring you this definitive ranking of the most mouthwatering chocolate ice creams that will transport your taste buds to cocoa heaven.
1. Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate
Bold and unapologetically intense, Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate delivers a punch that true cocoa enthusiasts crave. The fudge-like consistency stays firm on your spoon yet dissolves into silky decadence once it hits your mouth.
What sets it apart are those subtle fruity undertones complementing the deep chocolate base. While less creamy than some competitors, its sophisticated flavor profile makes it worth every penny of its boutique price tag.
Think of it as the wine connoisseur’s chocolate ice cream.
2. Häagen-Dazs Chocolate Ice Cream
Velvety richness defines this premium classic. With just five simple ingredients, Häagen-Dazs creates magic in every spoonful – the dense, custard-like texture melts perfectly on your tongue.
The balanced chocolate flavor hits that sweet spot between milk and dark chocolate without overwhelming your palate.
I’ve yet to find another supermarket brand that matches its luxurious mouthfeel, though some chocolate purists might wish for a more intense cocoa punch.
3. Van Leeuwen Chocolate
Imagine frozen chocolate ganache – that’s the luxurious experience Van Leeuwen delivers. Each spoonful feels like diving into chocolate velvet, with a texture so dense it borders on brownie batter territory.
I still remember my first taste three summers ago in Brooklyn; it was a revelation that changed my chocolate standards forever.
The price point makes it an occasional splurge, but the complex flavor profile featuring those subtle cocoa bean fruity notes justifies every dollar spent on this artisanal masterpiece.
4. Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Therapy
Chocolate overload in the best possible way! This pint packs chocolate ice cream, chocolate cookies, and swirls of chocolate pudding into one indulgent package. The contrasting textures create an adventure in every bite.
The sticky pudding ribbons add unexpected moisture that keeps you coming back for more. Perfect for those nights when only serious chocolate immersion will do.
While purists might find the mix-ins distract from the base, chocolate maximalists will rejoice at this triple-threat concoction.
5. Tillamook Chocolate Ice Cream
Creamy doesn’t begin to describe Tillamook’s velvety contribution to the chocolate universe. The extra egg yolks create an almost mousse-like texture that scoops beautifully even straight from the freezer.
Last Christmas, I served this at a family gathering and watched as everyone fell silent – the universal signal of ice cream excellence. While the chocolate flavor leans toward the milder side, the exceptional creaminess more than compensates.
It’s the perfect blank canvas for toppings or simply divine on its own.
6. Alden’s Organic Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Organic ingredients shine in this standout creation. The base strikes that elusive balance between sweetness and bittersweet chocolate depth, while tiny chocolate flecks add textural intrigue without disrupting the smooth experience.
What you won’t find are artificial additives or that chemical aftertaste that plagues lesser brands. The clean ingredient list creates pure chocolate bliss that feels almost virtuous.
Each spoonful delivers consistent quality that has earned this brand a permanent spot in my freezer rotation.
7. Turkey Hill Belgian Style Chocolate
Pennsylvania farm-fresh milk meets authentic Belgian chocolate in this surprisingly sophisticated supermarket find. The result? A distinctively European flavor profile featuring deeper cocoa notes and less sweetness than typical American offerings.
The velvety texture holds up beautifully in milkshakes – I’ve become somewhat famous among friends for my Turkey Hill chocolate malt creations.
Some might detect subtle coffee undertones in the finish, adding complexity without overwhelming the primary chocolate character.
8. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Chocolate
Store brands rarely impress chocolate connoisseurs, making this Whole Foods creation such a delightful surprise. The fudgy, dark chocolate profile delivers unexpected depth with a creaminess that rivals premium brands.
Let it soften for ten minutes to experience its full flavor potential. The balanced sweetness lets the organic cocoa take center stage without any chalky texture that sometimes plagues health-conscious options.
For chocolate lovers watching their budget but unwilling to compromise on quality, this hidden gem deserves discovery.
9. Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate
Cult following doesn’t begin to describe the devotion Blue Bell inspires. This Texan treasure features a custard-like consistency that coats your spoon and refuses to drip – perfect for slow savoring on scorching summer days.
The flavor leans sweet with a classic milk chocolate profile that triggers childhood nostalgia. Limited distribution across 22 states has created a mystique around this brand.
During a road trip through the South last year, I detoured an hour just to grab a half-gallon – that’s the power of Blue Bell’s legendary status.
10. Breyers Chocolate Ice Cream
Accessibility meets reliability in this grocery store staple. Breyers delivers a straightforward milk chocolate experience with no pretension – just honest chocolate flavor that’s been pleasing families for generations.
The simpler ingredient list (milk, cream, sugar, cocoa) creates a clean taste, though the texture runs slightly airier than premium competitors. Makes an excellent sundae foundation where toppings take center stage.
While it won’t blow away serious chocolate aficionados, its affordable price point and wide availability earn it a spot in the chocolate ice cream pantheon.