7 New Costco Baked Goods That Taste Like They Come From A Bakery
Last weekend, I did my usual Costco run, expecting the same old staples,but I stopped in my tracks when I passed the bakery section.
I nearly gasped. Costco has seriously stepped up its dessert game, and the new lineup is anything but ordinary. These baked treats aren’t just “good for store-bought”, they’re genuinely delicious, even rivaling some of my favorite local bakeries.
Naturally, I took one for the team and taste-tested every new item (tough job, I know). After savoring each bite, I’ve rounded up the seven standout bakery items that will completely change how you view warehouse store desserts.
1. Brown Butter Magic Cookies
One bite of these brown butter sugar cookies transported me straight to my grandmother’s kitchen! Remember those special treats that made childhood magical? These cookies nail that nostalgic feeling.
The exterior offers a satisfying crunch before giving way to a melt-in-your-mouth center that’s pure bliss. At $7.99 for 21 cookies, they’re practically stealing my money with each sweet, buttery morsel.
The secret weapon is definitely the brown butter, it adds a nutty, caramelized dimension that elevates these beyond ordinary sugar cookies. I’ve started keeping a stash in my freezer for cookie emergencies (yes, that’s a real thing).
2. Fancy French Palmiers
“Freaking amazing” doesn’t begin to cover these butter sugar palmiers! I skeptically grabbed a package during my last Costco trip, doubtful that mass-produced pastries could capture the magic of a Parisian boulangerie.
Boy, was I wrong! Each bite delivers that distinctive crackly crunch followed by whisper-thin layers of buttery, caramelized goodness. The edges curl perfectly into that classic heart shape that makes palmiers so instantly recognizable.
These delicate beauties pair perfectly with afternoon coffee or tea. I’ve served them to guests who refused to believe they weren’t from an upscale bakery – my little Costco secret stays safe!
3. Cinnamon Dream Loaf
The aroma of this butter cinnamon sugar loaf hit me before I even got it home! My car smelled like a bakery, and I nearly pulled over just to tear into it right there.
For $9.99, this loaf delivers pure comfort in every slice. The tender, moist interior crumb practically melts on your tongue while the generous cinnamon-sugar topping provides a delightful crunch. My morning routine now revolves around toasting a slice until the sugar begins to caramelize just slightly.
What truly impresses me is the versatility, it works for breakfast, dessert, or that awkward time between lunch and dinner when only something sweet will do. I’ve even used it for next-level French toast!
4. Summer Peach Celebration Cake
Who needs a special occasion when this peaches & cream bar cake exists? I initially balked at the $18.99 price tag but quickly realized it’s worth every penny after serving it at an impromptu gathering.
Light, airy cake layers cradle fresh peach slices and pillowy whipped cream that isn’t overly sweet. The balance is absolutely perfect, just enough sweetness to satisfy without overwhelming the delicate peach flavor.
My friends now request this cake specifically when visiting. The most impressive part? It maintains its freshness and texture for days in the refrigerator. Though in my household, it rarely lasts beyond 24 hours before every crumb disappears!
5. Zesty Blueberry Loaf
Sunshine in cake form! That’s how I describe this lemon blueberry loaf that brightened my morning routine last week. The vibrant citrus notes dance perfectly with bursts of sweet-tart blueberries.
Unlike many store-bought loaves that disappoint with dryness, this one stays gloriously moist day after day. The texture strikes that perfect balance between cake and quick bread, substantial enough to slice cleanly but light enough to enjoy any time of day.
I’ve found it pairs beautifully with morning coffee or afternoon tea. My neighbor, a self-proclaimed lemon dessert connoisseur, demanded to know which boutique bakery I’d discovered, her jaw dropped when I revealed the Costco truth!
6. Old-Fashioned Cherry Pie
Grandma would be jealous of Kirkland’s cherry pie! No joke, this seasonal treasure has converted me from pie-skeptic to pie-enthusiast in one fork-tender bite.
The filling strikes that perfect sweet-tart balance with plump, juicy cherries that actually taste like fruit rather than candy. But the true star? That impossibly flaky, buttery crust that shatters just right when your fork breaks through.
A warm slice topped with vanilla ice cream has become my Friday night ritual. I’ve even passed it off as homemade at a potluck (forgive me!). The generous size means you’ll have plenty for sharing, though you might find yourself reluctant to do so once you taste it.
7. Bite-Sized Cupcake Perfection
Size isn’t everything! These mini cupcakes prove that good things come in small packages. I grabbed a pack on a whim, expecting ordinary grocery store fare, but was blown away by their bakery-quality taste.
Available in both chocolate and vanilla varieties, each two-bite wonder is crowned with a swirl of silky buttercream that’s not tooth-achingly sweet. The cake itself maintains remarkable moisture, no easy feat for something so small! At $8.99 for a dozen, they’re perfect for portion control (if you have more willpower than me).
I’ve started keeping these on hand for unexpected guests or midnight cravings. The best part? They defrost quickly from frozen without losing quality, making them my secret weapon for last-minute entertaining.