10 New Jersey Supper Clubs That Fill Up Fast Every Weekend
New Jersey has become home to some of the most exciting supper clubs on the East Coast, where incredible food meets unforgettable entertainment.
These special venues focus on chef-driven dining and memorable ambiance, and many of them also offer live music or special events that people talk about for weeks.
Getting a reservation at these hotspots can feel like winning the lottery because they book up incredibly fast.
Whether you’re celebrating something special or just want a memorable night out, these supper clubs offer experiences you won’t find anywhere else.
1. That Supper Club – Park Ridge
Tucked away in the charming town of Park Ridge sits a gem that transforms ordinary weekends into extraordinary experiences.
That Supper Club brings back the golden era of intimate, multi-course dining, where guests enjoy phenomenal, carefully crafted tasting menus in a cozy, BYOB setting.
The atmosphere buzzes with excitement as diners settle into comfortable seating arrangements that offer perfect views of both their plates and the open kitchen action.
Located at 7 Hawthorne Ave, Park Ridge, NJ 07656, this venue has mastered the art of creating memorable evenings.
The menu features dishes prepared with care and creativity, satisfying even the pickiest eaters with flavors that dance across your taste buds.
What makes this place truly special is how seamlessly the multi-course tasting menu flows from one dish to the next, turning dinner into a leisurely culinary experience that encourages conversation and connection at the table.
The staff treats every guest like family, ensuring your water glass stays full and your needs are met before you even ask.
Reservations disappear faster than ice cream on a summer day, so planning ahead is absolutely essential.
Families love bringing relatives here for milestone celebrations, while couples find it perfect for date nights that feel extra romantic.
The combination of exceptional service, delicious food, and top-notch entertainment creates an experience worth every penny and every minute spent securing that coveted reservation.
2. Tim McLoone’s Supper Club – Asbury Park
Right on the legendary Asbury Park boardwalk, a supper club legend has been making waves for years.
Tim McLoone’s Supper Club at 1200 Ocean Ave, Asbury Park, NJ 07712, combines the best of Jersey Shore vibes with sophisticated entertainment.
The oceanfront location means you can watch waves crash while enjoying dishes that showcase fresh, seasonal ingredients prepared by skilled chefs who clearly love what they do.
This isn’t just another restaurant by the beach.
The venue pulses with energy from the moment doors open, drawing crowds who know they’re about to experience something remarkable.
Live performances range from tribute bands to original acts, all delivering shows that keep audiences engaged from start to finish.
The acoustics have been carefully designed so every note reaches your ears with crystal clarity, whether you’re sitting near the stage or across the room.
Servers navigate the busy space with impressive grace, delivering meals that look almost too pretty to eat.
Almost, but not quite, because the aromas wafting from each plate make resisting impossible.
Weekend reservations require serious advance planning since locals and tourists alike compete for tables.
The combination of beachside location, fantastic food, and entertainment that actually entertains makes this spot worth the effort required to snag a reservation.
3. MoonShine Modern Supper Club – Millburn
Millburn’s downtown district hides a sophisticated secret that locals guard jealously.
MoonShine Modern Supper Club at 55 Main St, Millburn, NJ 07041, brings contemporary flair to the classic supper club concept.
Walking through the doors feels like stepping into a space where old-school glamour meets modern sensibilities, creating an atmosphere that feels both familiar and fresh.
The interior design catches your eye immediately with thoughtful touches that make the space feel intimate despite accommodating substantial crowds.
Lighting creates mood without making it difficult to see your dinner companions or your beautifully plated meal.
Chefs here aren’t afraid to experiment, offering dishes that surprise and delight with unexpected flavor combinations that somehow work perfectly together.
Each course tells a story, taking diners on a culinary journey that complements the evening’s entertainment.
MoonShine regularly hosts nightlife events and occasional live entertainment, but even on quieter evenings the lively bar and dining room create a buzzing, social atmosphere.
Service staff demonstrate genuine enthusiasm for their work, offering recommendations with confidence and ensuring timing between courses flows smoothly.
Securing weekend reservations requires calling well in advance, as word has spread about this Millburn treasure.
The modern approach to a classic concept attracts diverse crowds who all leave smiling and planning their next visit.
4. Blue Basil Supper Club – Cedar Knolls
Some of the best experiences happen in the most unexpected places, like someone’s beautifully transformed home.
Blue Basil Supper Club operates from a private residence in Cedar Knolls, NJ, with the exact address revealed only upon reservation confirmation.
This unique approach creates an air of mystery and exclusivity that makes securing a spot feel like joining a special secret society.
The intimate setting means guest lists stay small, ensuring everyone receives personalized attention throughout the evening.
Hosts pour their hearts into every detail, from table decorations to menu planning, creating experiences that feel like being invited to the world’s fanciest dinner party.
Meals showcase creativity and skill, with dishes that often incorporate global influences and seasonal ingredients sourced from local suppliers.
Each course arrives at the perfect moment, neither rushed nor delayed, allowing conversations to flow naturally between bites.
Blue Basil centers the experience on its multi-course tasting menu, warm conversation, and the feeling of sharing a gourmet dinner party in a host’s home, with occasional special themed evenings.
The residential setting adds warmth and character impossible to replicate in traditional restaurant spaces.
Guests rave about feeling like treasured friends rather than customers, with hosts remembering preferences and making everyone feel genuinely welcome.
Limited seating means these events sell out almost immediately after being announced.
Following their social media becomes essential for anyone hoping to snag a reservation to this one-of-a-kind supper club experience.
5. Supper Club 1923 at The Flanders Hotel – Ocean City
History comes alive at this stunning Ocean City landmark where elegance never goes out of style.
Supper Club 1923 at The Flanders Hotel, located at 719 E 11th St, Ocean City, NJ 08226, transports guests back to an era of glamour and sophistication.
The historic hotel provides the perfect backdrop for evenings that feel both timeless and special, with architectural details that remind visitors of the building’s fascinating past.
Named for the hotel’s founding year, this supper club honors tradition while serving cuisine that feels decidedly current.
Chefs balance classic techniques with modern presentations, creating plates that photograph beautifully but taste even better.
The dining room itself deserves mention, with high ceilings, elegant fixtures, and an ambiance that makes everyone feel a bit fancier.
Servers dress impeccably and move with practiced efficiency, maintaining the upscale atmosphere while remaining approachable and friendly.
While the focus here is on refined dining in a historic setting, the hotel and restaurant also host special events and occasional live entertainment that complement the sophisticated atmosphere rather than dominate it.
The acoustics benefit from the room’s original architecture, designed long before modern sound systems existed.
Ocean City families consider dining here a tradition, booking tables for special occasions months in advance.
Visitors from other areas quickly understand why locals treasure this spot so deeply.
The combination of historic charm, exceptional food, and quality entertainment creates experiences that feel significant and memorable long after the evening ends.
6. The Restaurant at BOC Supper Club (Haute Feast x Barnegat Oyster Collective) – Barnegat
When two culinary powerhouses join forces, magic happens on every plate that leaves the kitchen.
The Restaurant at BOC Supper Club, found at 483 E Bay Ave, Barnegat, NJ 08005, represents a collaboration between Haute Feast and Barnegat Oyster Collective.
This partnership brings together expertise in upscale dining and fresh seafood, resulting in menus that celebrate the bounty of local waters.
Oysters take center stage here, as you’d expect from a collective dedicated to these briny delicacies.
Preparations range from classic raw presentations to creative preparations that showcase the chef’s imagination and skill.
Beyond the impressive oyster offerings, the full menu demonstrates commitment to quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation.
Seafood shines throughout, though options for different preferences ensure everyone finds something exciting to try.
The waterfront location adds atmosphere that money can’t buy, with views that change beautifully as daylight fades into evening.
Inside, the space balances casual coastal vibes with upscale touches that signal this isn’t your typical seafood shack.
The experience leans into its waterfront ambiance and chef-driven menus rather than nightly stage shows, though special events and occasional live-music evenings can add an extra layer of energy to the supper club vibe.
Staff members demonstrate deep knowledge about both the food and the local waters that provide it.
Reservations fill quickly as word spreads about this unique collaboration.
Seafood lovers and supper club enthusiasts alike consider this spot essential visiting, making advance planning absolutely necessary for weekend dining.
7. Dockside Dinner Club at Dockside Kitchen – Ocean City
Few things beat enjoying fantastic food while boats bob gently in the water just beyond your table.
Dockside Dinner Club at Dockside Kitchen, positioned at 228 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, maximizes its waterfront location to create dining experiences that engage all your senses.
The bay views provide constantly changing scenery as boats come and go, birds fly past, and the water reflects the changing light.
Kitchen staff clearly understand that fresh ingredients make the biggest difference, sourcing locally whenever possible to ensure peak flavor and quality.
Menus change with the seasons, reflecting what’s available and at its absolute best during different times of year.
The dinner club format means evenings unfold at a leisurely pace, allowing guests to truly relax and disconnect from daily stresses.
Courses arrive with perfect timing, giving you space to enjoy conversations and scenery between plates.
Dockside Kitchen runs the Dinner Club as a seasonal, membership- or day-pass–based experience, occasionally adding live music or special themed nights that enhance the laid-back waterfront atmosphere without turning it into a full concert venue.
The outdoor seating becomes especially popular during warmer months, though the indoor space offers equally appealing views through large windows.
Staff members treat regulars and first-timers with equal warmth, sharing recommendations and ensuring every need gets met promptly.
Weekend spots disappear fast as locals and vacationers alike recognize the special combination of location, food, and atmosphere.
Planning ahead becomes essential for anyone hoping to secure a table during peak season or popular weekend dates.
8. Good Folk Supper Club – Various NJ Shore towns
Chasing this supper club around different locations adds an element of adventure to already exciting dining experiences.
Good Folk Supper Club operates as a pop-up throughout various Monmouth and Ocean County locations, with addresses changing depending on each event.
This nomadic approach keeps things fresh and interesting, introducing guests to new venues and neighborhoods they might not otherwise explore.
The name perfectly captures the vibe, with organizers creating welcoming environments where strangers become friends over shared meals.
Community building happens naturally when good food brings people together in thoughtfully chosen spaces.
Menus showcase creativity and seasonal awareness, with chefs often collaborating with local farms and suppliers to highlight regional ingredients.
Each pop-up event feels unique, offering dishes and themes that change based on location, season, and inspiration.
Depending on the specific event, Good Folk may incorporate local musicians or other performances, but the heart of the experience is its charitable, pop-up supper format and the chance to share a one-night-only meal in a unique setting.
The rotating locations mean different acoustics and atmospheres for each gathering, keeping repeat attendees engaged and curious.
Following their social media becomes crucial since event announcements happen there first, with tickets often selling out within hours.
The pop-up format creates urgency and excitement, with each event feeling like a special occasion worth clearing your calendar for.
Guests appreciate the sense of discovery that comes with each new location, never quite knowing what surprises await.
This innovative approach to supper club dining has built a loyal following of food lovers across the Jersey Shore.
9. Graze at Night Dinner Club – Ho-Ho-Kus
Sometimes the best meals happen in small spaces where every guest receives undivided attention.
Graze at Night Dinner Club, located at 611 N Maple Ave, Ho-Ho-Kus, NJ 07423, operates on a smaller scale that allows for truly personalized dining experiences.
The intimate setting means chefs can focus on details that might get overlooked in larger operations, resulting in food that consistently exceeds expectations.
Grazing menus encourage sharing and sampling, letting tables experience a wider variety of flavors throughout the evening.
This approach promotes conversation and interaction, as dishes get passed around and everyone offers opinions on different preparations.
The kitchen embraces seasonal changes enthusiastically, completely reimagining menus as ingredients come in and out of peak availability.
Regulars never get bored because return visits always bring new discoveries and favorite dishes prepared with current seasonal touches.
Although Graze at Night is primarily a chef-driven, reservation-only dinner club, some evenings may feature subtle musical or thematic elements that enhance the cozy, intimate feel rather than dominate the experience.
The cozy atmosphere makes everyone feel like they’re attending an exclusive gathering rather than just another restaurant meal.
Staff members develop relationships with regular guests, remembering preferences and making newcomers feel immediately welcomed into the fold.
Limited seating means reservations require advance planning, especially for weekend evenings when demand peaks.
The neighborhood location adds to the charm, with Ho-Ho-Kus residents considering this dinner club a treasured local secret they’re almost reluctant to share with outsiders.
10. Maricel’s Kitchen Supper Club – East Brunswick
Walking into Maricel’s Kitchen feels like being welcomed into someone’s home for the best meal of your life.
Located at 111 Main St, East Brunswick, NJ 08816, this supper club brings warmth and hospitality to every evening.
The name suggests personal connection, and the experience delivers on that promise with food that tastes like it was prepared with love by someone who genuinely cares about your enjoyment.
Menus often reflect cultural influences and family recipes, offering dishes you won’t find at typical restaurants.
This authenticity creates memorable meals that feel special and meaningful, connecting diners to culinary traditions and stories behind each preparation.
The atmosphere balances casual comfort with special occasion energy, making it perfect for everything from family celebrations to friendly gatherings.
Decorations and ambiance choices create warmth without feeling overly formal or stuffy.
Maricel’s Kitchen centers on chef-led classes, special dinners, and occasional themed events, with the focus firmly on heartfelt food and hospitality.
Music and conversation fill the space with positive energy that gets feet tapping and faces smiling.
Service style emphasizes genuine care over rigid formality, with staff members checking in frequently to ensure satisfaction without hovering annoyingly.
The East Brunswick location makes it accessible to wide areas of central New Jersey, drawing crowds from multiple counties.
Weekend reservations book solid weeks in advance as word spreads about the exceptional food and heartfelt hospitality.
Guests consistently leave planning their return visits, eager to experience more of what makes this supper club so wonderfully special.