12 New York Bagel Orders That Reveal A Lot About Someone
New York bagels are more than a breakfast staple. They’re a personality test in dough and toppings.
The way someone loads cream cheese, picks a flavor, or chooses a toast level can say more about them than a dozen conversations.
From classic lox lovers to adventurous spreads, bagel orders reveal quirks, preferences, and little indulgences. Peeking at someone’s bagel choices is a fun way to discover what makes them tick.
1. Everything Bagel with Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Maximalists who want it all, these folks aren’t afraid to embrace chaos and complexity in their lives. They’re the friends who pack three activities into a Saturday morning before you’ve even had coffee.
Usually early risers with packed schedules, they believe breakfast should be substantial enough to fuel their non-stop energy.
The everything bagel represents their diverse interests, while the classic combo shows they still appreciate tradition.
2. Cinnamon-Raisin Bagel with Lox and Traditional Toppings
Rule-breakers who enjoy watching people squirm, these controversial orderers know exactly what they’re doing.
Combining sweet and savory in the most polarizing way possible reveals someone who enjoys challenging conventions.
Behind their mischievous food choices often lies a creative thinker who sees possibilities where others see fixed boundaries.
They’ll be the first to suggest wild ideas during brainstorming sessions and genuinely don’t understand why everyone’s making such a fuss.
3. Cinnamon-Raisin Bagel with Cream Cheese, Bacon & Jelly
Comfort-seekers with a sweet tooth, these folks prioritize pleasure over convention. Their bagel reflects a personality that embraces contradictions – sweet and salty, healthy and indulgent – without apology.
Friends often describe them as the peacemakers who can get along with anyone. Their unusual combination reveals someone who’s learned to balance life’s contrasting elements.
When faced with tough decisions, they’ll likely find creative middle grounds others miss.
4. Toasted Bagel with Kerrygold Butter, Grey Poupon & Boar’s Head Salami
Brand loyalists with expensive taste, these particular eaters know exactly what they want. Nothing reveals a perfectionist like someone who specifies three premium brands in a single bagel order.
Surprisingly, they’re often quite generous despite their exacting standards. The European-inspired combination suggests someone well-traveled or at least well-read about food culture.
At dinner parties, they’re the friends who bring obscure but delicious wines they discovered from “this little vineyard you’ve probably never heard of.”
5. Everything Bagel with Eggs, Cheese, Hash Browns & Chipotle Mayo
Innovators who push boundaries, these order-creators think outside the breakfast box.
The hash brown addition reveals someone who values efficiency – why have breakfast potatoes on the side when they can go right in the sandwich?
Likely to be problem-solvers in their professional lives, they apply the same creativity to their morning meal.
The chipotle mayo shows they appreciate subtle complexity rather than obvious flavors. When planning group activities, they’re the ones suggesting that new place no one’s tried yet.
6. Egg Bagel with Cream Cheese and Pork Roll
New Jersey transplants who refuse to abandon their roots, these loyal souls stick to what they know works.
The pork roll (never “Taylor ham” to a true South Jerseyan) reveals someone who values regional tradition and authenticity.
Friends count on them for unwavering reliability and strong opinions about breakfast meats. The egg bagel choice shows a subtle appreciation for complementary flavors rather than contrasting ones.
They’re likely to have strong hometown pride and maintain the same friendships for decades.
7. Everything Bagel with Bacon, Egg, Cheese PLUS Cream Cheese
Abundance seekers who believe more is always better, these enthusiastic eaters approach their bagel like they approach life – with gusto and without restraint.
The added cream cheese layer reveals someone who doesn’t just want flavor; they want an experience.
Generous to a fault, they’re the friends who always bring too much food to potlucks. Their approach to breakfast suggests someone who doesn’t worry about messiness or appearances.
When making plans, they’re likely to suggest the all-you-can-eat option or the restaurant with the largest portions.
8. Plain Bagel, Nothing On It
Purists who appreciate simplicity, these minimalists cut through life’s noise to focus on fundamentals. Their unadorned choice reveals someone who values quality so highly they want nothing to mask it.
Often misunderstood as boring, they actually possess refined taste that recognizes excellence in its most basic form.
The plain bagel enthusiast typically extends this philosophy to other areas – their home likely features thoughtfully chosen, well-made items rather than trendy clutter.
When offering opinions, they provide clear, straightforward insights without unnecessary elaboration.
9. Onion Bagel
Bold individuals who aren’t concerned with people-pleasing, these confident types order the most aromatic option without apology.
Their pungent choice reveals someone comfortable standing out and potentially offending sensitive noses nearby.
Natural leaders with strong personalities, they make decisions without excessive concern for others’ approval.
The onion bagel lover typically extends this philosophy to other areas of life – they’ll speak truth in meetings even when it’s uncomfortable.
First dates rarely order this unless they’re supremely confident about their chemistry.
10. Everything Bagel, Untoasted and Uncut
Pragmatic souls who plan ahead, these strategic thinkers are playing the long game with their bagel order. They’re taking it home for later or saving half for an afternoon snack, revealing impressive self-control.
Friends know them as the reliable planners who always have emergency supplies and never run out of toilet paper.
Their approach to bagels suggests someone who values preservation of quality over immediate gratification.
At work, they’re likely to have organized files, color-coded calendars, and lunch prepared the night before.
11. Cinnamon-Raisin Bagel, Toasted with Butter
Nostalgic types with a sentimental streak, these sweet-toothed breakfast lovers are likely reconnecting with childhood comforts. Their choice reveals someone who values tradition and finds security in familiar flavors.
Often the family historians who remember everyone’s birthdays, they appreciate life’s simple pleasures. The classic butter topping (rather than trendy alternatives) suggests someone grounded and unpretentious.
Their homes typically contain cherished heirlooms and photo albums, and they’re the friends who remind the group about anniversaries of shared experiences.
12. Poppy Seed Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
Sophisticated individuals with understated taste, these selective eaters appreciate subtle complexity rather than obvious flavors. Their choice reveals someone who notices fine details others might miss.
Friends value their thoughtful perspectives and nuanced observations about everything from films to friendships.
The classic cream cheese pairing suggests someone who respects tradition while making small, personal adjustments.
In conversations, they’re typically better listeners than talkers, absorbing information before offering precisely worded insights.