9 New York Pizza Places That Create Scary Good Halloween Pies
Halloween in New York City doesn’t just take over haunted houses and costume parties—it even finds its way into our beloved pizza shops. Every October, creative pizzerias across the five boroughs roll out spooky specials that put a festive twist on the city’s most iconic food.
Think jet-black crusts, pumpkin-spiced sauces, ghost-shaped mozzarella, and toppings arranged to look downright eerie.
It’s the kind of culinary creativity that proves New Yorkers can turn even a slice into a seasonal celebration. After years of chasing down these limited-time pies, I’ve found nine spots where Halloween spirit and pizza perfection collide.
1. Stretch Pizza’s Midnight Magic
My jaw literally dropped when I first laid eyes on Stretch Pizza’s “Dark Web” creation! This Flatiron and Williamsburg hotspot transforms butternut squash and smoked gouda into something wickedly delicious.
The black sesame seeds scattered across the top create an eerie night sky effect against the orange squash base. Crisp apple bits and toasted pumpkin seeds add unexpected crunch and sweetness.
What makes this pie extra special? It’s only available until Halloween, so I make it an annual tradition to grab one before they vanish like ghosts at dawn. The perfect balance of seasonal flavors without going overboard on the pumpkin spice!
2. Creep Crust’s Haunted Slices
Stumbling upon this East Village pop-up felt like discovering a secret Halloween portal! Creep Crust operates right next to Beetle House, creating the ultimate spooky food corridor on 6th Street.
Their signature “Happy Halloween Black Pizza” stopped me in my tracks with its jet-black crust and vibrant orange vodka sauce. The contrast is Instagram gold, but the flavor is what keeps me coming back.
Open Wednesday through Sunday, this fully Halloween-themed spot serves more than just pizza. Fair warning though – I couldn’t stop taking pictures before eating, much to my hungry friends’ dismay!
3. Vinnie’s Pizzeria’s Monster Mashups
Remember that viral candy corn pizza that broke the internet? That was Vinnie’s doing! This Williamsburg and Greenpoint institution never misses a chance to get weird with holiday-themed slices.
Every Halloween, I refresh their Instagram obsessively waiting for their special announcement. Last year they created a “Ghostbusters Slimer” slice that glowed under blacklight thanks to some clever food-safe ingredients.
The best part about Vinnie’s Halloween creations? They’re not just gimmicks – they actually taste fantastic! Their pizza artists somehow balance the perfect NY slice fundamentals with outrageous seasonal creativity. I’ve started a tradition of grabbing whatever spooky special they offer for my annual Halloween movie marathon.
4. Industry Kitchen’s Ink-Infused Crusts
Perched along the Seaport with stunning Brooklyn Bridge views, Industry Kitchen serves pizzas that look like they emerged from the depths of the ocean. Their squid ink crust creates a canvas as dark as a moonless night.
While famous year-round for their over-the-top 24K gold-topped pizza (yes, real gold!), Halloween brings out their most creative offerings. The contrast between the midnight-black base and colorful toppings creates an otherworldly eating experience.
My friends were skeptical about squid ink flavor, but I promise it adds just a hint of brininess that enhances everything else. The restaurant leans into the spooky aesthetic during October, making it perfect for pre-Halloween dinner dates with dramatic flair!
5. Don Antonio’s Pumpkin Patch Pizza
Master pizzaiola Giorgia Caporuscio transforms Don Antonio’s Hell’s Kitchen spot into pumpkin paradise each October. Her signature Halloween creation combines velvety butternut cream with smoky mozzarella that melts like a dream.
Colorful bell peppers and zucchini ribbons dance across the top, creating a festive autumn mosaic. The first time I tried it, I couldn’t believe vegetables could taste this indulgent!
What sets this pizza apart is the authentic Italian technique behind the seasonal ingredients. The wood-fired crust develops perfect leopard spotting that adds subtle smokiness. Don Antonio doesn’t go for gimmicky decorations – they let the gorgeous orange-hued pizza speak for itself. Pure autumn comfort in every bite.
6. Prince Street Pizza’s Sweet Screams
Prince Street Pizza – home of those famous crispy-edged square slices – has a sweet secret during Halloween season. Their limited-edition dessert pizzas feature cocoa-infused crusts that would make Willy Wonka jealous!
Last October, I dragged three friends to stand in their infamous line just to try their chocolate-drizzled “Spooky Pie.” Worth every minute of waiting! The contrast between the slightly bitter cocoa crust and sweet toppings creates a perfect balance.
While savory pizzas remain their claim to fame, these Halloween dessert collaborations showcase their playful side. The staff even gets into the spirit with costumes on Halloween weekend. Pro tip: Order both a classic pepperoni and a dessert slice for the ultimate Prince Street experience!
7. Screamer’s Pizzeria’s Vegan Vampire Slayer
Who says plant-based pizza can’t be sinfully good? Screamer’s Pizzeria in Greenpoint and Crown Heights proves otherwise with their aptly-named “Vampire” slice that keeps me coming back year-round.
Garlic oil forms the base – enough to ward off any actual bloodsuckers! Their house-made vegan pepperoni and caramelized onions create a symphony of flavors that convinced even my most carnivorous friend that plant-based pizza can be magical.
While available throughout the year, this slice feels especially appropriate as Halloween approaches. The staff always gets extra creative with holiday specials too. I love that their spooky-themed food doesn’t rely on artificial colors or gimmicks – just naturally delicious ingredients arranged with a macabre twist!
8. Unregular Pizza’s Pumpkin Burrata Surprise
Tucked near Union Square, Unregular Pizza lives up to its name with unconventional creations that push boundaries. Their Halloween special – a pumpkin-shaped burrata centerpiece – literally made me gasp the first time I saw it!
Priced at exactly $10.31 (get it? October 31st!), this clever pie features a creamy burrata cheese ball artfully shaped and colored to resemble a mini pumpkin. The attention to detail amazes me every time.
Beyond the visual wow-factor, the flavor combination of their slightly charred crust with the cool, creamy cheese creates perfect textural contrast. While they switch up seasonal specials throughout the year, their Halloween offerings consistently show the most creativity. I’ve started planning my October pizza crawl around their annual reveal!
9. Beetle House’s Nightmare Next Door
Okay, I’m cheating slightly because Beetle House isn’t technically a pizzeria – it’s a year-round Tim Burton-inspired Halloween restaurant that happens to share a wall with Creep Crust. Together, they form the ultimate spooky food experience in the East Village!
After devouring black-crusted pizza next door, I always pop into Beetle House for macabre atmosphere. Think Nightmare Before Christmas meets Sweeney Todd, with food and drinks named after horror movies.
The staff coordinates special Halloween week events across both establishments, creating a mini haunted food district on 6th Street. For pizza lovers seeking the complete spooky dining experience, this one-two punch can’t be beat. I recommend making reservations – both spots fill up quickly throughout October!