12 New York Pizza Places That Get Deliciously Creepy For Halloween
Last October, I wandered through the streets of Brooklyn on Halloween night, my stomach growling and my mind set on something perfectly cheesy.
The chill in the air carried the scent of dough and garlic, and when I stumbled upon a pizzeria draped in cobwebs, flickering jack-o’-lanterns grinning from every corner, I knew I’d found my tribe. Inside, ghosts and ghouls shared tables with witches and vampires, all devouring bubbling slices of pizza.
Across New York, pizzerias were going all out—hosting costume contests, serving monster-themed pies, and transforming dinner into a spirited, spooky celebration that made every bite pure Halloween magic.
1. Vinnie’s Pizzeria — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Walking past 148 Bedford Ave, you’ll spot pumpkins grinning from the window and staff sporting witch hats behind the counter. Vinnie’s has built a reputation for wild, inventive pies year-round, but when October rolls in, they crank the creativity up to eleven.
Their seasonal Halloween specials change weekly, featuring everything from black-dough crusts to toppings arranged in skull patterns. I once tried a slice topped with purple cauliflower that looked like it belonged in a mad scientist’s lab.
Follow their Instagram for daily drops of spooky creations. This Williamsburg gem stays open late, so you can grab a creepy slice after trick-or-treating with the kids or bar-hopping in costume with friends.
2. Two Boots Pizza — Multiple NYC Locations
Two Boots doesn’t do boring, especially not in October. With locations in the East Village, West Village, and Upper West Side, you’re never far from one of their legendary Halloween slices.
The Depraved and The Kraken are limited-time monsters that pack bold flavors and even bolder names. I remember biting into The Kraken and tasting a swirl of spicy shrimp and garlic that felt like a flavor explosion from the deep sea.
Check their Facebook for updates on which location has which special. The staff loves Halloween almost as much as they love pizza, and the festive energy is contagious. Swing by any store this month and prepare for a slice that’s equal parts delicious and devilish.
3. Roberta’s — Bushwick, Brooklyn
Roberta’s at 261 Moore St transforms into a full-blown Halloween bash every October 31st. Picture a DJ spinning beats, a costume contest with prizes that actually matter, and wood-fired pies coming out nonstop from their famous oven.
I showed up one year dressed as a giant slice of pepperoni pizza (meta, I know) and ended up winning second place. The vibe is electric, with fairy lights tangled in fake spiderwebs and everyone from hipsters to families dancing between bites.
Their specials menu gets a spooky makeover for the night, featuring pies with charred edges that look delightfully sinister. Reservations fill up fast, so lock in your spot early and prepare for a night you’ll remember long after the sugar crash.
4. Jimmy Max — Staten Island
Jimmy Max on Watchogue Road has turned Halloween into an annual tradition that Staten Islanders circle on their calendars. Their Halloween party is legendary, complete with games, music, and enough pizza to feed an army of zombies.
What sets them apart is their preorder program for Halloween night. You can call ahead and reserve party-sized pies customized with spooky designs, from ghost-shaped pepperoni to green pesto swirls that look like witch potions.
Their 2025 Facebook posts are already buzzing with sneak peeks of this year’s menu. I love how they make families feel welcome while still keeping things fun for adults. Stop by or place your preorder now before slots vanish faster than candy on November first.
5. Primo Pizzeria — Staten Island
Primo Pizzeria on Richmond Road has cracked the code on making pizza both delicious and downright spooky. Their Pepperoni Pizza Skulls are the star of every Halloween party they cater, and trust me, they’re as tasty as they are Instagram-worthy.
Each skull is hand-shaped with dough, then loaded with sauce, cheese, and pepperoni arranged to form creepy faces. I ordered a tray for my nephew’s Halloween birthday last year, and the kids went absolutely wild.
Their Instagram reels show the whole process, from shaping the dough to pulling them out of the oven with perfectly melted cheese. Primo makes it easy to elevate your Halloween party without breaking a sweat. Order ahead and watch your guests freak out (in the best way) when you unveil these edible masterpieces.
6. Santora’s Pizza Pub & Grill — Williamsville
Up in Williamsville near Buffalo, Santora’s on Transit Road throws a kids’ Halloween party that feels like stepping into a storybook. This October, they’re hosting a costume parade where little ones can strut their stuff through the restaurant while parents snap photos and munch on pizza.
The energy is pure joy, with staff members dressed as pirates and princesses cheering on every tiny superhero and monster. I heard from a friend who attended last year that her daughter still talks about winning a prize for her homemade dragon costume.
Check Eventbrite and their Facebook for exact dates and times. Santora’s proves that Halloween pizza parties don’t have to be scary to be memorable. Bring the whole family and watch your kids light up brighter than any jack-o-lantern.
7. Cam’s Pizzeria — Rochester
Cam’s Pizzeria across Rochester has a weekly tradition that gets wonderfully weird in October. Their Crazy Slice of the Week goes full Halloween mode, featuring toppings you’d never expect on pizza—like Halloween Oreos.
Yes, you read that right. Cookies on pizza. And somehow, it works. The sweet-and-savory combo is oddly addictive, especially when paired with their signature sauce and gooey cheese.
Each location puts its own spin on the spooky slice, so visiting multiple shops becomes a fun scavenger hunt. I love scrolling through their Instagram to see what bizarre creation they’ve cooked up next. If you’re in the Rochester area and feeling adventurous, grab a Crazy Slice and embrace the delicious madness of Halloween pizza innovation.
8. Prince Street Pizza — Nolita/SoHo, Manhattan
Prince Street Pizza at 27 Prince St is famous for their legendary square slices, but this October they’re pushing Halloween party catering like never before. Whether you’re hosting a rooftop bash or an office costume contest, they’ve got you covered with party-sized trays and custom orders.
I catered a friend’s Halloween gathering with their pepperoni squares last year, and people are still asking where I got the pizza. The thick, crispy crust and generous toppings make every bite feel like a celebration.
Their Instagram is packed with catering options and seasonal posts to inspire your party planning. Prince Street makes it easy to look like a party-planning genius without lifting a finger. Place your order early and let the pizza do the talking while you enjoy the spooky festivities.
9. John’s of Bleecker Street — Greenwich Village, Manhattan
John’s of Bleecker Street at 278 Bleecker St is a New York institution, and on Halloween night, they’re right in the heart of the action. The famous Village Halloween Parade snakes past their door, bringing thousands of costumed revelers to the neighborhood.
Because of the parade, John’s posts operational notices about delivery limits and adjusted hours, proving they’re fully engaged with the Halloween madness. I once grabbed a slice there after watching the parade and felt like I was part of New York history.
Their brick-oven pies are timeless, and the atmosphere on Halloween is electric. If you’re planning to catch the parade, make John’s your dinner stop. Just order early or dine in, because delivery gets tricky when the streets fill with zombies and superheroes.
10. Borrelli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria — East Meadow, Long Island
Borrelli’s on Hempstead Turnpike in East Meadow throws a Halloween party that feels more like a nightclub than a pizzeria. With a live DJ spinning tracks, an open bar flowing, and a costume contest with serious prizes, this is where Long Island comes to celebrate in style.
I’ve heard stories of guests showing up in elaborate costumes that could win Hollywood makeup awards. The pizza keeps coming all night, from classic margheritas to creative seasonal specials that match the spooky theme.
Check their website for tickets and event details. Borrelli’s proves that pizza parties can be sophisticated and fun at the same time. Grab your best costume, round up your crew, and get ready for a Halloween night that blends great food with unforgettable energy.
11. Emmy Squared Pizza — Multiple NYC Locations
Emmy Squared has locations scattered across New York City, and this October they’re teasing a seasonal feature called The Big Spooky. Their Detroit-style square pies are already a cult favorite, with crispy, caramelized edges that crunch with every bite.
Adding a Halloween twist takes things to another level. While they’re keeping some details under wraps, their Instagram hints at bold toppings and a spooky presentation that’ll make your feed pop.
I’m a sucker for their creative seasonal releases, and The Big Spooky sounds like it’ll deliver both flavor and fun. Follow their social media for the official drop date and menu details. Emmy Squared knows how to keep things fresh, and their Halloween offering is shaping up to be a must-try for pizza lovers who crave something different.
12. Kesté Pizza & Vino — Financial District, Manhattan
Kesté at 77 Fulton St is rolling out a Mystery Pizza promotion that’s only available for Halloween. The spooky branding and secretive menu have everyone guessing what toppings might appear on this limited-time creation.
Kesté is known for authentic Neapolitan pizza with a perfectly charred crust and fresh ingredients, so whatever they’re hiding under that mystery label is bound to be delicious. I love the element of surprise, especially when it comes from a pizzeria with this much credibility.
Check their ordering platform for availability and details. The Mystery Pizza adds a playful twist to their traditional menu and gives adventurous eaters something to talk about. Swing by before Halloween ends and solve the tasty mystery for yourself. You might just discover your new favorite slice in the process.