11 Ohio Pie Shops Locals Say Taste Just Like Grandma’s Best Recipes
Nothing quite captures the heart like a slice of homemade pie, especially when it reminds you of Grandma’s kitchen on a Sunday afternoon.
Ohio is packed with pie shops that have mastered the art of old-fashioned baking, bringing back those warm, nostalgic flavors we all crave.
These local treasures have earned rave reviews from folks who swear their crusts are flakier, their fillings are richer, and their love is baked right in.
Get ready to discover where Ohioans go when they need a serious pie fix that feels just like home.
1. Just Pies – Westerville, OH
Walking into this charming spot feels like stepping through your grandmother’s front door on Thanksgiving morning.
The bakers here treat every crust like a work of art, rolling dough by hand and using recipes passed down through generations.
Their apple pie bursts with cinnamon-spiced fruit that’s neither too sweet nor too tart, striking that perfect balance Grandma always nailed.
Locals line up early because these pies sell out fast, especially on weekends.
The flaky, buttery crust practically melts on your tongue, proving that simple ingredients and serious skill create magic.
Address: 736 N State St, Westerville, OH 43082
2. Der Dutchman Bakery – Plain City, OH
Ever wonder what makes Amish baking so legendary?
One bite of their peanut butter cream pie answers that question with a resounding yum.
This bakery stays true to traditional methods, avoiding shortcuts and fancy equipment in favor of time-tested techniques.
Their shoofly pie offers a molasses-rich sweetness that transports you straight back to simpler times.
The crust has that signature tender crumb that only comes from patient, loving hands.
People drive from neighboring counties just to grab a slice and a smile.
Address: 445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
3. Lindsey’s Bakery – Circleville, OH
Circleville is famous for pumpkins, so naturally this bakery knows a thing or two about pumpkin pie perfection.
Their version features a silky-smooth filling spiced with just the right amount of nutmeg and ginger, making every forkful feel like a warm hug.
The graham cracker crust adds a sweet, crunchy twist that Grandma would totally approve of.
Locals swear their cherry pie rivals any homemade version, with plump fruit and a lattice top that looks magazine-worthy.
This spot has been a community favorite for decades, earning its reputation one delicious slice at a time.
Address: 127 W Main St, Circleville, OH 43113
4. Katalina’s Bake Shop – Columbus, OH
Who says Grandma can’t get a little fancy?
This Columbus gem takes classic pie flavors and gives them a creative spin without losing that comforting, home-baked soul.
Their salted caramel apple pie combines traditional fruit filling with a modern flavor twist that makes your taste buds dance.
The crust boasts those beautiful crimped edges that show someone truly cares about presentation.
Each slice arrives at your table looking almost too pretty to eat—almost.
The neighborhood buzz around this place proves that innovation and nostalgia can absolutely coexist deliciously.
Address: 1105 Pennsylvania Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
5. The Elegant Pie – Dayton, OH
Despite the fancy name, this bakery delivers down-home goodness with every slice.
Their pecan pie features a gooey, caramel-like filling studded with toasted nuts that crunch perfectly against the tender crust.
Bakers here source local ingredients whenever possible, ensuring freshness that Grandma would insist upon.
The coconut cream pie tops the charts with billowy meringue that towers impressively without being overly sweet.
Customers rave about the personal touch—staff members remember your name and your favorite flavor.
It’s this combination of quality and care that keeps folks coming back week after week.
Address: 3013 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45410
6. The Pie Peddler – Wilmington, OH
This little shop peddles happiness one flaky crust at a time.
Their blackberry pie bursts with juicy berries that taste like they were picked fresh from a backyard bramble.
The secret lies in their commitment to scratch baking—no mixes, no preservatives, just honest ingredients working together beautifully.
Their lemon meringue achieves that elusive balance between tart and sweet, crowned with golden-tipped meringue that’s lightly torched.
Regulars claim the strawberry rhubarb tastes exactly like the one their grandmother made every June.
That’s the highest compliment any pie shop could possibly receive.
Address: 3443 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45410
7. Mary Ann Donut Kitchen (Famous for pies) – Canton, OH
Don’t let the donut name fool you—this Canton institution bakes pies that could win county fair blue ribbons.
Their banana cream pie features thick, vanilla-scented custard layered with fresh banana slices and real whipped cream.
The crust stays crisp even under all that luscious filling, which is no easy feat.
Old-timers remember coming here as kids, and now they bring their own grandchildren for the same sweet experience.
The apple crumb pie delivers big chunks of fruit topped with a buttery streusel that adds delightful texture.
It’s comfort food at its absolute finest.
Address: 5039 Tuscarawas St W, Canton, OH 44708
8. The Peanut Shoppe & Pie Counter – Akron, OH
Peanuts and pies might sound like an odd pairing, but this Akron landmark makes it work wonderfully.
Their chocolate cream pie gets an extra boost from crushed peanuts mixed into the crust, creating a flavor combination Grandma would call genius.
The key lime pie offers a tropical escape with its tangy filling and graham cracker base that crumbles perfectly.
Locals appreciate the generous slice sizes—no skimpy portions here.
The shop maintains that old-fashioned soda fountain vibe, complete with spinning stools and friendly counter service.
It’s a step back in time that tastes absolutely delicious.
Address: 203 S Main St, Akron, OH 44308
9. Mum’s Apple Pie / Apple Hill Orchard – Mansfield, OH
When your pies come from an actual orchard, you know the apples are seriously fresh.
Mum’s bakes their apple pies using fruit picked right from surrounding trees, ensuring maximum flavor and crispness.
The crust features a hint of cinnamon sugar on top that caramelizes beautifully during baking.
Their Dutch apple pie variation includes a crumb topping so buttery it practically dissolves on your tongue.
Visiting during harvest season means you can pick your own apples, then enjoy a slice while watching the orchard bustle.
It’s the complete farm-to-table pie experience Grandma would adore.
Address: 1175 Lexington-Ontario Rd, Mansfield, OH 44903
10. Henny Penny’s Pies – Youngstown, OH
This Youngstown favorite proves that great pies don’t need gimmicks—just quality ingredients and genuine care.
Their blueberry pie overflows with plump berries that burst with natural sweetness, requiring minimal added sugar.
The crust features that perfect golden-brown color that signals it’s been baked to absolute perfection.
Customers love their mixed berry option, which combines several fruits for a complex, layered flavor profile.
The peach pie arrives during summer months, showcasing juicy fruit that tastes like sunshine in every bite.
Henny Penny’s understands that simplicity done right beats fancy every single time.
Address: 100 Victoria Rd, Youngstown, OH 44515
11. The Pie Factory – Cleveland, OH
Factory might suggest mass production, but this Cleveland spot cranks out handmade pies with serious artisan attention.
Their pumpkin pie features a spice blend that’s been perfected over years, creating warmth without overwhelming the squash flavor.
The sweet potato pie offers a Southern-inspired twist that’s become a local obsession.
Their crust recipe produces layers that shatter delicately under your fork, revealing tender, flaky perfection.
Regulars appreciate the rotating seasonal flavors that keep the menu exciting while maintaining those classic favorites.
It’s proof that tradition and innovation can coexist beautifully in one delicious package.
Address: 1120 E 105th St, Cleveland, OH 44108