13 Ohio Pizza Places That Are Worth The Drive
Ohio might be famous for its buckeyes and roller coasters, but the real treasure hidden across the Buckeye State is its incredible pizza scene.
From wood-fired masterpieces to crispy thin squares that’ll make your taste buds dance, these pizza joints prove that great pies are worth any road trip.
Whether you’re craving a classic New York slice or something totally unique, these 13 spots deliver flavors so good you’ll gladly add extra miles to your odometer.
1. Il Rione – Cleveland
Cleveland pizza lovers have spoken, and they’re all pointing toward the same delicious destination on West 65th Street.
Il Rione serves up authentic Italian pies that transport your taste buds straight to Naples without the passport hassle.
The wood-fired oven works its magic on every pizza, creating that perfect char and chewy crust that makes each bite unforgettable.
Located at 1303 W 65th St, Cleveland, OH 44102, this spot consistently earns the crown as Cleveland’s best pizza.
Local fans rave about the quality ingredients and traditional techniques that make every visit feel special.
2. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza – Columbus
Campus legends are born at 1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, where Adriatico’s has been fueling hungry college students and city dwellers for decades.
This isn’t just any pizza joint—it’s a Columbus institution that practically defines what New York-style pizza should taste like in the Midwest.
The massive slices fold perfectly in half, just like they should, with that ideal balance of crispy bottom and gooey cheese.
Whether you’re pulling an all-nighter or celebrating game day, Adriatico’s delivers the goods every single time with flavors that never disappoint.
3. Terita’s Pizza – Columbus
History tastes delicious at 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, where Terita’s has been perfecting the art of thin square pizzas for generations.
Forget everything you thought you knew about pizza shapes because these crispy squares will change your perspective entirely.
The thin crust gets perfectly crispy on the edges while staying just tender enough in the middle to hold all those tasty toppings.
Food & Wine even gave this spot a shoutout, proving that sometimes the best pizza comes in unexpected packages that honor old-school traditions with every bite.
4. Old Scratch Pizza – Dayton
Dayton’s pizza scene caught fire—literally—when Old Scratch opened its doors at 812 S Patterson Blvd, Dayton, OH 45402.
The wood-fired oven cranks out pies that smell so amazing, you can practically taste them before they hit your table.
Each pizza emerges with those beautiful leopard spots on the crust that pizza aficionados dream about at night.
Tripadvisor reviewers can’t stop gushing about this beloved destination where every pie gets the royal treatment.
The combination of high heat and quality ingredients creates pizza magic that keeps locals coming back week after week.
5. The O On Lane – Columbus
Style meets substance at 352 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, where The O proves that pizza can be both trendy and traditionally delicious.
This isn’t your grandma’s pizza parlor—unless your grandma was seriously cool and loved experimenting with creative flavor combinations.
The menu features pizzas that push boundaries while still respecting the classics that made pizza famous in the first place.
Local foodies flock here for the Instagram-worthy atmosphere and stay for pizzas that taste even better than they photograph, which is really saying something in today’s social media world.
6. Fast Eddie’s Pizza – Bellville
Small towns hide the best secrets, and Bellville’s treasure sits right at 59 Main St, Bellville, OH 44813.
Fast Eddie’s might not have the big-city buzz, but what it lacks in fancy marketing it makes up for with seriously good pizza that’ll make you want to tell everyone you know.
The cozy atmosphere feels like eating at a friend’s house—if your friend happened to be an incredible pizza chef.
This spot is absolutely worth the detour off the highway because some experiences can’t be rushed, and great pizza definitely falls into that category.
7. The Pizza House – Columbus
Sometimes the best pizza doesn’t need fancy tricks or wild toppings—it just needs to be done right, which is exactly what happens at 747 E Lincoln Ave, Columbus, OH 43229.
The Pizza House earned its reputation the old-fashioned way, by consistently serving pies that locals genuinely love and recommend to their friends.
No gimmicks, no pretension, just solid pizza fundamentals executed beautifully every single time.
Columbus residents know that when you’re craving reliable, delicious pizza that hits all the right notes, this classic spot delivers without fail or disappointment.
8. Elliot’s Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap – New Albany
New Albany gets fancy at 266 E Main St, New Albany, OH 43054, where Elliot’s combines craft atmosphere with seriously impressive wood-fired pizzas.
The flames kiss each pizza just right, creating those irresistible bubbles and char marks that separate good pizza from absolutely spectacular pizza.
Everything about this place feels elevated without being stuffy, which is the perfect combination for a memorable meal out.
The wood-fired technique isn’t just for show—it genuinely transforms the flavors and textures in ways that regular ovens simply can’t match or replicate at all.
9. Two Cities Pizza Co. – Mason
Mason became a pizza destination thanks to 202 W Main St, Mason, OH 45040, where Two Cities Pizza Co. serves pies worthy of their sky-high ratings.
The Cincinnati area doesn’t mess around when it comes to food opinions, so earning top marks here means you’re doing something seriously right with your dough and toppings.
Every pizza gets the attention it deserves, from the first stretch of dough to the final sprinkle of herbs.
Reviewers consistently praise this spot for delivering exactly what great pizza should be—flavorful, satisfying, and worth every single calorie consumed.
10. Fireside Pizza – Cincinnati
Cincinnati’s pizza passion burns bright at 773 E McMillan St, Cincinnati, OH 45206, where Fireside has been warming hearts and bellies with classic pies for years.
There’s something wonderfully comforting about a neighborhood pizza place that everyone knows and loves like an old friend.
The menu sticks to what works best—traditional pizzas made with care and quality ingredients that never cut corners.
Locals treat this spot like their personal pizza sanctuary, returning again and again for the familiar flavors that feel like coming home after a long day away.
11. Good Fellaz Pizzeria – Sunbury
Hidden gems shine brightest when you find them, and Sunbury’s treasure glows at 245 N Columbus St, Sunbury, OH 43074.
Good Fellaz built their reputation one loyal customer at a time, proving that word-of-mouth marketing still works when your pizza genuinely deserves the praise.
The local following here isn’t just loyal—they’re downright passionate about spreading the gospel of great pizza to anyone who’ll listen.
This pizzeria proves that you don’t need to be in a big city to make big impressions with flavors that rival anywhere else in Ohio or beyond.
12. Park Street Pizza – Sugarcreek
Amish country serves up more than just cheese and furniture—it’s also home to exceptional pizza at 215 R Dover Rd NW, Sugarcreek, OH 44681.
Park Street Pizza earned strong regional love by doing everything right, from the dough to the sauce to the perfect cheese-to-topping ratio.
The ratings don’t lie, and neither do the satisfied customers who make this spot a regular stop on their travels through Ohio’s beautiful countryside.
Sometimes the best road trips lead to unexpected pizza discoveries that become new traditions worth repeating year after year with family and friends.
13. Hounddog’s Pizza – Columbus
Bigger is definitely better at 2657 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202, where Hounddog’s serves slices so generous they practically qualify as a full meal.
This local favorite earned its reputation by never being stingy with portions, toppings, or flavor—everything here comes supersized with quality to match.
Students and locals alike worship at the altar of Hounddog’s, where creative specialty pizzas push boundaries while classic options satisfy traditional cravings.
One slice might be all you need, but you’ll probably want two because the flavors are simply too good to stop eating once you start.