15 Ohio Sandwich Counters Serving Bites As Legendary As The State’s Best Pizza
Ohio might be famous for its pizza, but the state’s sandwich scene deserves just as much attention and applause.
From towering corned beef stacks in Cleveland to mouthwatering creations in Columbus and Cincinnati, these sandwich counters have perfected the art of what goes between two slices of bread.
Whether you’re craving classic deli fare or inventive modern combinations, these 15 spots prove that Ohio’s sandwich game is absolutely legendary.
1. Slyman’s Restaurant – Cleveland
Corned beef piled higher than a skyscraper makes this Cleveland institution an absolute must-visit for sandwich lovers everywhere.
Slyman’s has been serving up their legendary creations since 1963, and they haven’t changed their winning formula one bit.
The corned beef here is slow-cooked to tender perfection, hand-sliced thick, and stacked so tall you’ll need both hands and maybe a forklift to tackle it.
Located at 3106 St. Clair Ave NE, Cleveland, OH 44114, this spot attracts everyone from construction workers to celebrities who crave authentic deli excellence.
The meat is juicy, flavorful, and seasoned with just the right amount of spice to keep you coming back for more bites.
Pair your sandwich with crispy fries and a cold drink, and you’ve got yourself a meal that defines Cleveland comfort food at its finest.
2. Katzinger’s Delicatessen – Columbus (German Village)
Walking into Katzinger’s feels like stepping back in time to an old-world European delicatessen where quality reigns supreme.
This German Village gem at 475 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215 has been delighting customers since 1984 with authentic deli traditions and recipes.
Their menu features over 50 sandwich options, from classic pastrami and Reubens to creative combinations that showcase their house-cured meats beautifully.
The bread comes fresh daily from local bakeries, and the pickles are brined in-house using secret family recipes passed down through generations.
Every sandwich is crafted with care, piled high with premium ingredients, and served with a side of genuine Columbus hospitality.
The atmosphere buzzes with energy as regulars swap stories over their favorite sandwiches, creating a community feel that’s genuinely heartwarming.
3. The Brown Bag Delicatessen – Columbus (German Village)
Neighborhood charm meets serious sandwich craftsmanship at this beloved German Village hideaway that locals guard like a precious secret.
Tucked away at 898 Mohawk St, Columbus, OH 43206, The Brown Bag serves up creative combinations that surprise and delight with every bite.
Their signature sandwiches feature locally sourced ingredients, house-made spreads, and flavor combinations that push boundaries while respecting classic deli traditions beautifully.
The cozy atmosphere makes you feel like you’re eating at a friend’s kitchen table rather than a restaurant, which adds warmth to every visit.
Fresh vegetables, premium meats, and artisan breads come together in perfect harmony, creating sandwiches that photograph beautifully and taste even better than they look.
Service is friendly and personalized, with staff who remember your name and your favorite order after just a few visits here.
4. Express Deli – Brook Park
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you—this Brook Park treasure serves sandwiches that’ll knock your socks clean off your feet.
Express Deli at 5185 Smith Rd, Brook Park, OH 44142 has built a loyal following thanks to generous portions and wallet-friendly prices that keep customers smiling.
Their specialty sandwiches combine multiple meats, cheeses, and toppings in creative ways that maximize flavor without overwhelming your taste buds at all.
The bread is always fresh and perfectly toasted when you want it crispy, providing the ideal foundation for their towering meat and veggie combinations.
Staff members work quickly without sacrificing quality, making this spot perfect for grabbing a satisfying lunch when you’re short on time but big on appetite.
Regulars swear by the homemade sides and soups that complement the sandwiches perfectly, turning a quick bite into a complete meal experience.
5. Newfangled Kitchen – Bexley (Columbus Area)
Innovation meets tradition at this Bexley hotspot where sandwiches get a modern makeover without losing their soul or substance.
Newfangled Kitchen at 2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209 reimagines classic combinations with unexpected twists that make your taste buds dance with joy.
Their creative menu changes seasonally, featuring locally sourced ingredients and house-made components that elevate each sandwich to culinary art status here.
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual and upscale, making it ideal for everything from business lunches to weekend brunches with friends.
Each sandwich is thoughtfully constructed with attention to texture, flavor balance, and visual appeal, proving that fast-casual food can be genuinely sophisticated and delicious.
The friendly staff provides excellent recommendations and can customize sandwiches to accommodate dietary preferences without compromising on taste or satisfaction at all.
6. Wario’s Beef & Pork – Columbus (Downtown)
Chicago-style Italian beef finds a worthy home in Columbus at this downtown spot that takes meat sandwiches seriously and deliciously.
Wario’s at 111 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215 specializes in slow-roasted beef and pork that’s sliced thin and piled high on fresh rolls.
The beef is seasoned with Italian spices and cooked until it practically melts in your mouth, creating an unforgettable texture that’s tender yet satisfying.
Order it wet for extra juice, or dry if you prefer less mess, but either way, you’re getting authentic flavors that transport you straight to Chicago.
The giardiniera adds a perfect spicy kick that cuts through the richness of the meat, balancing each bite with tangy, crunchy vegetable goodness.
Downtown workers flock here during lunch rushes, creating a bustling atmosphere that adds energy and excitement to your midday meal break every single time.
7. Mr. Zub’s Deli & Bar – Akron
Akron’s sandwich scene wouldn’t be complete without this neighborhood institution that’s been feeding hungry locals for decades with consistent excellence.
Mr. Zub’s at 795 W Market St, Akron, OH 44303 combines deli counter classics with a full bar, making it perfect for lunch or dinner.
Their sandwiches feature quality Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, stacked generously on fresh bread that’s delivered daily from trusted local bakeries nearby.
The casual, friendly atmosphere makes everyone feel welcome, whether you’re a regular who’s been coming for years or a first-time visitor exploring Akron.
Prices remain reasonable despite the generous portions, proving that quality and value can coexist beautifully in the same delicious sandwich experience here.
The bar area offers craft drink and cocktails that pair wonderfully with your sandwich, turning a simple meal into a relaxing social occasion worth savoring.
8. Diamond Deli – Akron
Sparkling service and gem-quality sandwiches make this Akron deli a true diamond in the rough that shines brighter than its competition.
Located at 378 S Main St, Akron, OH 44311, Diamond Deli has earned its reputation through consistency, quality, and genuine care for every customer.
Fresh ingredients arrive daily, ensuring that every vegetable is crisp, every meat is flavorful, and every sandwich meets their exacting standards of excellence.
The menu offers both traditional favorites and creative specials that showcase the chef’s culinary imagination and willingness to experiment with bold flavors.
Portion sizes are generous without being wasteful, giving you plenty to enjoy without feeling stuffed or guilty about leftovers going to waste later.
The downtown location makes it convenient for office workers, shoppers, and anyone exploring Akron’s revitalized urban core and cultural attractions throughout the city.
9. Izzy’s – Cincinnati (Downtown)
Cincinnati’s answer to New York delis, Izzy’s has been stacking sandwiches sky-high since 1901, making it a true Ohio institution with serious history.
At 800 Elm St, Cincinnati, OH 45202, this downtown landmark serves breakfast and lunch to crowds who appreciate authentic deli traditions done right every time.
Their Reuben is legendary, featuring house-cooked corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on perfectly grilled marble rye bread.
The potato pancakes are another must-try item, crispy on the outside and tender inside, providing the perfect accompaniment to any sandwich order here.
Vintage decor and old-school service create an atmosphere that feels timeless, like you’re eating in a piece of Cincinnati history that’s still very much alive.
Lines often stretch out the door during peak hours, but the wait is always worth it for sandwiches that have been perfected over more than a century.
10. The Thurman Café – Columbus (German Village)
Burgers might not be traditional sandwiches, but Thurman’s creations are so legendary they absolutely deserve a spot on this list without question.
The Thurman Café at 183 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206 has been serving oversized burgers since 1942 to hungry crowds who appreciate quantity and quality.
Their signature Thurmanator features two massive beef patties, bacon, ham, sausage, multiple cheeses, and all the fixings, weighing in at over two pounds total.
Even the regular Thurman Burger is impressive, with generous toppings that require architectural precision to stack without toppling over completely onto your plate.
The cozy tavern atmosphere, complete with vintage memorabilia covering the walls, adds character and charm to every visit here throughout the year.
Expect a wait during dinner hours, but the friendly staff keeps things moving while maintaining quality, ensuring every burger leaves the kitchen perfectly cooked and assembled.
11. The Spot Restaurant – Sidney
Small-town charm meets big-time flavor at this Sidney institution where locals have gathered for great food and conversation for generations past.
The Spot at 201 S Ohio Ave, Sidney, OH 45365 serves up classic American comfort food with a focus on quality ingredients and hometown hospitality.
Their sandwiches range from simple but perfect grilled cheese to elaborate club sandwiches with multiple layers of meat, cheese, and fresh vegetables throughout.
The homemade soups and sides complement the sandwiches beautifully, making this spot perfect for a complete meal that satisfies body and soul alike.
Prices reflect small-town values, meaning you get tremendous value for your money without sacrificing quality or portion size in any way whatsoever here.
The friendly staff treats everyone like family, remembering orders and asking about your day, creating a warm atmosphere that’s increasingly rare in modern dining experiences.
12. Deli Ohio – Canton
Canton’s premier sandwich destination lives up to its straightforward name by delivering authentic deli excellence with every order placed here daily.
Deli Ohio at 328 Walnut Ave NE, Canton, OH 44702 focuses on quality ingredients, proper technique, and customer satisfaction above everything else imaginable.
Their meat selection includes premium brands and house-roasted options, all sliced to order for maximum freshness and flavor in every single bite taken.
The bread selection is impressive, with multiple options from crusty baguettes to soft hoagie rolls, ensuring the perfect foundation for whatever sandwich you choose.
Customization is encouraged, with friendly staff happy to adjust ingredients and portions to match your preferences without any hassle or attitude whatsoever here.
The clean, modern space feels welcoming and comfortable, making it ideal for quick lunches or leisurely meals when you have time to truly savor your food.
13. Buck City Sammies – Columbus
Playful name aside, this Columbus hotspot takes sandwiches seriously, creating innovative combinations that surprise and delight adventurous eaters everywhere around town.
Buck City Sammies at 212 Kelton Ave, Columbus, OH 43205 offers a menu that changes regularly, featuring seasonal ingredients and creative flavor profiles.
Each sandwich is thoughtfully designed to balance textures and tastes, from crunchy vegetables to tender meats and creamy spreads that tie everything together perfectly.
The casual, modern atmosphere attracts a diverse crowd, from families with kids to young professionals grabbing lunch between meetings throughout the busy workday.
Vegetarian and vegan options receive the same attention and creativity as meat-based sandwiches, ensuring everyone finds something delicious to enjoy here always.
The staff’s enthusiasm for their products is contagious, making recommendations with genuine excitement that enhances the overall dining experience significantly every single visit without fail.
14. Cravings Café – Columbus
Sometimes a craving hits, and this German Village cafe knows exactly how to satisfy it with sandwiches that hit all the right notes perfectly.
Cravings Café at 1149 Fair Ave, Columbus, OH 43206 combines cafe culture with serious sandwich craft, creating a menu that appeals to diverse tastes.
Their breakfast sandwiches are particularly noteworthy, featuring fresh eggs, quality meats, and creative combinations that make morning meals memorable and satisfying throughout the day.
Lunch options expand the menu with both hot and cold sandwiches, each prepared with attention to detail that shows in every delicious bite taken.
The cozy atmosphere encourages lingering over your meal, making it perfect for catching up with friends or enjoying some quiet time with good food.
Local artwork decorates the walls, coffee is expertly brewed, and the overall vibe feels authentically neighborhood-focused, welcoming everyone who walks through the friendly doors here.
15. Larder Delicatessen & Bakery – Cleveland (Ohio City)
Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood boasts this artisan gem where bread and sandwiches are elevated to an art form worth celebrating and savoring slowly.
Larder at 1455 W 29th St, Cleveland, OH 44113 bakes bread fresh daily, creating the perfect foundation for sandwiches that showcase house-made charcuterie beautifully.
Their commitment to craft extends beyond the bread to every component, from pickled vegetables to cured meats, all prepared in-house with skill and care.
The menu changes with the seasons, taking advantage of local ingredients at their peak freshness and flavor, ensuring variety throughout the entire year here.
The modern, industrial-chic space feels hip without being pretentious, attracting food lovers who appreciate quality without unnecessary fuss or fanfare at all.
Prices reflect the artisan nature of the products, but the quality and flavor justify every penny spent on these exceptional sandwiches that truly stand out.