11 Ohio Seafood Buffets Where You Can Eat All You Want Without Breaking The Bank
Who doesn’t love the thrill of piling a plate high with crab legs, shrimp, and sushi without watching the bill? After traveling across Ohio hunting for standout seafood deals, I’ve uncovered sleeper hits.
These all you can eat buffets deliver bright flavor at prices that won’t sink your wallet, with trays of peel and eat shrimp, buttery scallops, miso bowls, and chefs slicing rolls to order.
From Columbus to Cleveland, Dayton to Toledo, these spots prove you don’t need a coastline to feast well. Grab a bib, crack a claw, bring friends—second helpings are expected, and dessert will tempt you.
1. The Feast Buffet — A Columbus Newcomer Making Waves
Fresh to the Columbus dining scene, The Feast Buffet has quickly become my go-to Friday night spot. The moment you walk in, the aroma of sizzling hibachi and freshly prepared seafood wraps around you like a warm hug.
Their sushi station deserves special praise – the dragon rolls practically dance with flavor! I’ve watched families leave with satisfied smiles and wallets that aren’t completely emptied.
Located on Bethel Road, this 2025 newcomer offers an impressive selection that rivals coastal restaurants. The seafood stays remarkably fresh, and the hibachi chefs add a touch of entertainment to your dining experience. Who knew landlocked Ohio could deliver such oceanic delights?
2. Tokyo Grill Sushi & Hibachi Buffet — Polaris’ Hidden Pearl
Stumbled upon this gem during a shopping trip at Polaris and couldn’t believe my taste buds! The crab legs here snap with freshness that transported me straight to the ocean despite being in the heart of Ohio.
What makes Tokyo Grill special isn’t just their extensive sushi selection – it’s how they balance quality and quantity. The lunch special at $17.99 feels like highway robbery considering what’s offered.
My favorite strategy: start with the nigiri, move to the hot seafood section, and finish with a custom hibachi creation. The staff remembers regular customers, making each visit feel personal. For seafood lovers on a budget, this place is nothing short of miraculous.
3. The City Buffet — Soldano Boulevard’s Seafood Sanctuary
Tucked away on Soldano Boulevard, The City Buffet might look unassuming from outside, but don’t let that fool you! My first visit happened by accident when my usual spot was closed, and now I’m a regular.
Their seafood section outshines many pricier establishments. The salt and pepper shrimp made me close my eyes in pure bliss – crispy, perfectly seasoned, and abundant enough that I didn’t feel guilty loading up my plate three times.
Families gather here on weekends, creating a lively atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. The grill station lets you customize your seafood exactly how you like it. For the price point, the variety and quality feel like a delicious secret that Columbus locals are keeping to themselves.
4. Super Seafood Buffet — Northland’s Nautical Feast
Sometimes a place delivers exactly what its name promises, and Super Seafood Buffet hits the bullseye! During my last visit, I watched a young boy’s eyes widen at the mountain of crab legs – mirroring my own excitement.
The sushi selection rotates regularly, keeping return visits interesting. I’ve developed a particular fondness for their coconut shrimp, which strikes the perfect balance between sweet and savory.
Located in the Northland area, this unpretentious spot has become a monthly tradition for my friend group. We’ve calculated that ordering these seafood items à la carte would cost triple what we pay here. The restaurant’s straightforward approach – focusing on fresh seafood rather than fancy décor – keeps prices reasonable without sacrificing quality.
5. Supreme Buffet & Hibachi — West Broad’s Wallet-Friendly Wonder
Supreme Buffet saved my daughter’s birthday dinner when our reservation fell through elsewhere. Walking in without expectations, we were blown away by both the variety and affordability!
Their seafood section punches well above its weight class. The butterfly shrimp practically melted in my mouth, while the baked fish maintained flakiness despite sitting on the buffet line.
What truly sets Supreme apart is how they manage to keep prices low while not skimping on quality. The hibachi station adds entertainment value as chefs flip spatulas and create onion volcanoes. Located near the West Broad area, this place proves you don’t need ocean views to enjoy excellent seafood at prices that feel like a happy accident.
6. Kumo Japanese Seafood Buffet — Parma’s Oceanic Treasure
Visiting family in Cleveland led me to Kumo, and now I schedule trips around dining here! The snow crab legs alone justify the drive – plentiful, meaty, and perfectly steamed.
Unlike some buffets that excel in quantity but falter in quality, Kumo maintains impressive standards across their entire seafood selection. Their dynamite mussels feature a spicy mayo topping that I’ve unsuccessfully tried to recreate at home.
Located on Snow Road in Parma, Kumo strikes the perfect balance between Japanese and Chinese culinary traditions. The restaurant’s clean, modern atmosphere elevates the dining experience without inflating the price. My Cleveland relatives laugh at how I plan visits based on my seafood cravings rather than family events!
7. Sakura Buffet — Parma Heights’ Seafood Sensation
Sakura Buffet saved my anniversary dinner after I forgot to make reservations elsewhere! My wife still talks about their coconut shrimp – crispy, sweet, and available without the usual fancy restaurant markup.
The sushi selection here impresses even my friend who lived in Japan for three years. Fresh fish, properly seasoned rice, and creative combinations keep the experience interesting visit after visit.
Located on Pearl Road in Parma Heights, Sakura maintains a family-friendly atmosphere without sacrificing adult enjoyment. The staff remembers regulars, adding a personal touch that makes dining here feel special. My wallet stays happy while my seafood cravings get thoroughly satisfied – a combination that’s increasingly rare in today’s dining landscape.
8. Royal Buffet — Sheffield’s Crown Jewel of Seafood
Royal Buffet became my highway oasis during a blizzard last winter, and now I deliberately take the longer route home just to stop here! Their seafood selection transformed what could have been a travel disaster into a delicious discovery.
The crab rangoon here deserves its own fan club – crispy outside, creamy inside, with chunks of real crab rather than the mystery filling found elsewhere. Their sushi selection rotates regularly, ensuring even weekly visitors find new options.
Located in Sheffield/Elyria area, Royal Buffet (sometimes called Royal Grill Sushi Buffet) offers a seafood spread that feels luxurious despite the reasonable price point. The restaurant’s spacious layout means you never feel crowded, even during peak hours. Who knew a snowstorm detour would lead to my favorite seafood spot?
9. Hong Kong Buffet — Toledo’s Longstanding Seafood Legend
Hong Kong Buffet has been my grandpa’s birthday choice for 15 years straight – that’s how good their seafood selection remains! The salt and pepper shrimp here has ruined me for all other versions.
What makes this Glendale Avenue staple special is their consistency. While other buffets fluctuate in quality, Hong Kong maintains its standards year after year.
Their seafood stations feature everything from classic crab legs to more adventurous options like squid salad. The restaurant’s longevity in Toledo speaks volumes about their ability to balance affordability with quality. Watching three generations of my family pile plates with seafood treasures creates memories as rich as their lobster sauce. Sometimes the classics endure for good reason!
10. Ocean Garden Buffet — Sylvania’s Seafood Paradise
Accidentally discovered Ocean Garden during a wrong turn in Sylvania, and now I deliberately “get lost” whenever I’m near Toledo! Their name delivers exactly what it promises – a garden of oceanic delights at prices that feel like happy hour all day.
The seafood selection here changes with market availability, ensuring everything stays fresh. Their garlic butter mussels have me plotting how to smuggle the recipe out of the kitchen.
Located on Monroe Street, Ocean Garden Buffet maintains a relaxed atmosphere that welcomes both date nights and family outings. The staff takes pride in their offerings, regularly refreshing stations even during slow periods. My friends initially questioned driving 30 minutes for a buffet until they tasted the crab legs – now they’re the ones suggesting Ocean Garden trips!
11. New Happy Buffet — Youngstown’s Seafood Celebration
New Happy Buffet became my road trip salvation during a Youngstown business trip gone long. Exhausted and hungry, I wandered in expecting typical buffet fare – instead, I found seafood nirvana!
Their seafood selection defies the modest exterior and pricing. The butterfly shrimp arrives perfectly crisp, while their baked fish maintains flakiness despite the buffet setting.
Located on Belmont Avenue, this unassuming spot delivers consistent quality without unnecessary frills. The restaurant’s straightforward approach focuses on what matters – delicious food at prices that don’t require a second mortgage. After discovering their seafood section, I’ve rescheduled Youngstown meetings around lunch hours just to justify a visit. Sometimes the simplest places deliver the most satisfying experiences!