13 Ohio Seafood Restaurants That Serve The Best Catch Of The Day
Ohio might be landlocked, but that hasn’t stopped it from becoming a surprising hotspot for incredible seafood.
From Cleveland to Columbus, talented chefs are bringing ocean-fresh flavors straight to the heartland, serving everything from buttery lobster to perfectly seared fish.
Whether you’re craving a classic fish fry or an elegant seafood tower, these restaurants prove you don’t need to be near the coast to enjoy the best catch of the day.
1. Pier W
Perched on the shores of Lake Erie like a captain surveying the waves, Pier W has been Cleveland’s go-to destination for spectacular views and even better seafood since 1965.
The floor-to-ceiling windows offer diners a front-row seat to stunning sunsets while they feast on fresh catches prepared with culinary precision.
Every dish arrives beautifully plated, from delicate Dover sole to succulent sea scallops that practically melt on your tongue.
Located at 12700 Lake Ave in Lakewood, this waterfront gem combines old-school elegance with modern flavors, making every meal feel like a special occasion worth celebrating with your favorite people.
2. Blue Point Grille
Downtown Cleveland’s Blue Point Grille treats seafood like an art form, and honestly, after one bite of their butter-poached lobster, you’ll understand why locals consider it a masterpiece.
The restaurant’s commitment to freshness is legendary—their seafood arrives daily, ensuring every forkful tastes like it just jumped from the ocean onto your plate.
Their raw bar sparkles with pristine oysters and clams that seafood lovers dream about long after leaving.
Find this culinary treasure at 700 W St Clair Ave, where the sleek atmosphere perfectly complements the refined menu that keeps Cleveland’s seafood standards impressively high.
3. Red Crab – Juicy Seafood
Roll up your sleeves and prepare for a hands-on feast at Red Crab, where messy eating isn’t just accepted—it’s practically mandatory and totally part of the fun!
This Cleveland spot specializes in Cajun-style seafood boils that arrive in bags bursting with shrimp, crab legs, sausage, potatoes, and corn, all swimming in your choice of finger-licking sauces.
The casual vibe encourages diners to crack shells, slurp juices, and enjoy every gloriously messy moment without worrying about fancy table manners.
Head to 4754 Ridge Rd for an experience that proves sometimes the best meals require bibs and plenty of napkins!
4. Kingfish
Akron’s Kingfish reigns supreme when it comes to creative seafood preparations that make landlocked diners forget they’re hundreds of miles from any ocean.
Chef-driven dishes showcase seasonal catches prepared with unexpected twists that keep your taste buds guessing in the best possible way.
The cozy yet contemporary space at 115 Montrose W Ave feels equally perfect for date nights or catching up with old friends over phenomenally fresh fish.
Their constantly evolving menu means there’s always something new to try, though regulars swear by returning favorites that never disappoint even after the hundredth visit.
5. Club Oceano Seafood & Bar
Transport yourself to a coastal paradise without leaving Beavercreek at Club Oceano, where Caribbean vibes meet Ohio hospitality in the most delicious way imaginable.
The menu reads like a tropical vacation, featuring grilled fish preparations, zesty shrimp dishes, and seafood combinations that bring island flavors straight to your table.
Bright colors and beachy decor create an atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a mini getaway, even on ordinary Tuesdays.
Located at 4429 Cedar Park Dr, this lively spot proves that Ohio can absolutely deliver authentic coastal cuisine with personality and flair.
6. Kai’s Crab Boil
Columbus’s Kai’s Crab Boil turns dinner into an interactive experience where cracking shells and getting your hands dirty is absolutely encouraged and expected.
Generous portions of crab legs, crawfish, shrimp, and all the fixings arrive steaming hot, seasoned to perfection with spice levels ranging from mild to mouth-tingling.
The laid-back atmosphere makes it impossible not to relax and enjoy the communal experience of sharing a seafood feast with friends and family.
Visit 839 Bethel Rd to discover why this spot has become a Columbus favorite for anyone craving bold flavors and unforgettable seafood adventures.
7. Mitchell’s Ocean Club
Sophistication meets the sea at Mitchell’s Ocean Club, where Columbus diners come to celebrate life’s special moments with impeccably prepared seafood and refined service.
The extensive menu features everything from classic preparations to innovative creations that showcase the chef’s creativity and respect for premium ingredients.
Gleaming raw bars display the day’s freshest offerings while the elegant dining room sets the perfect stage for memorable meals.
Located at 4002 Easton Station, this upscale destination delivers restaurant experiences that feel luxurious without being stuffy, making every guest feel genuinely welcomed and valued throughout their visit.
8. Watts Restaurant
Small-town charm meets big-city flavors at Watts Restaurant in Utica, where unexpected culinary excellence has put this tiny village firmly on Ohio’s seafood map.
Despite its modest location, Watts consistently delivers restaurant-quality seafood that rivals anything found in major metropolitan areas, surprising first-time visitors who weren’t expecting such sophistication.
The intimate setting creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere where every diner receives attentive service and beautifully prepared dishes that exceed expectations.
Make the trip to 77 S Main St and discover why food lovers willingly drive from across Ohio to experience this hidden gem’s remarkable seafood offerings.
9. Miamar Grill
Latin-inspired seafood preparations take center stage at Miamar Grill, where traditional recipes meet fresh ingredients to create flavor explosions that keep Westerville residents coming back repeatedly.
Grilled fish topped with vibrant sauces, seafood tacos bursting with freshness, and creative ceviches showcase how different cultures approach cooking ocean treasures with distinctive delicious results.
The friendly staff treats every guest like family, making recommendations and ensuring everyone leaves satisfied and already planning their next visit.
Stop by 732 N State St to experience how Miamar Grill brings coastal Latin flavors inland with authentic passion and culinary skill.
10. Frank’s Fish & Seafood Market
Part market, part restaurant, Frank’s Fish & Seafood Market delivers the ultimate freshness guarantee since they literally sell the same fish they cook just steps away.
Diners can browse the impressive seafood selection before ordering, ensuring complete transparency about exactly what’s going onto their plates minutes later.
The no-frills approach focuses entirely on quality and flavor rather than fancy atmospherics, letting the seafood speak for itself through simple, expert preparations.
Located at 5251 Trabue Rd in Columbus, Frank’s proves that sometimes the best restaurants are the ones that keep things straightforward and let fresh ingredients shine.
11. Real Seafood Company (Toledo)
Toledo’s Real Seafood Company anchors the downtown waterfront with a commitment to serving genuinely fresh catches in an atmosphere that celebrates both the river and refined dining.
Their thoughtfully curated menu changes with seasonal availability, ensuring diners always enjoy seafood at its absolute peak flavor and quality.
Floor-to-ceiling windows frame beautiful water views that complement every course, making meals here feel special regardless of the occasion.
Find this riverside treasure at 22 Main St, where Toledo residents and visitors alike gather to enjoy exceptional seafood alongside stunning scenery that enhances every delicious bite.
12. Jolly Roger’s Seafood House
Ahoy, mateys! Jolly Roger’s Seafood House in Port Clinton embraces its pirate theme wholeheartedly while serving up serious seafood that keeps Lake Erie visitors and locals returning season after season.
Fresh Lake Erie perch takes pride of place on a menu that celebrates local catches alongside ocean favorites, all prepared with care and served with a smile.
The fun, family-friendly atmosphere makes everyone feel welcome, from picky kids to adventurous eaters seeking their next favorite seafood dish.
Set sail for 1715 E Perry St to experience Port Clinton’s most entertaining seafood destination where great food meets playful pirate fun.
13. Salty Mary’s Oyster Bar & Tavern
Westlake’s Salty Mary’s brings authentic oyster bar culture to suburban Ohio with a raw bar that would make coastal purists nod approvingly at its freshness and variety.
Beyond the impressive oyster selection, the menu explores seafood preparations from fried classics to creative contemporary dishes that showcase the kitchen’s versatility and skill.
The casual tavern vibe encourages lingering over meals, making it equally perfect for quick bites or leisurely dining experiences with good company.
Visit 25600 Center Ridge Rd to discover why Salty Mary’s has become the neighborhood gathering spot where everyone knows great seafood awaits every single visit.