8 Old-School Candies From Ohio’s Past
Remember when a nickel could buy you a sweet treat that would make your taste buds dance with joy?
Growing up in Ohio, I was surrounded by unique candies that defined childhood for generations of Buckeye State kids.
These sugary delights weren’t just treats—they were edible pieces of Ohio’s rich history, created in local kitchens and factories before becoming beloved staples in corner stores across the state.
1. Buckeye Candies: Ohio’s Chocolate-Dipped Treasures
My grandma’s kitchen transformed into a candy factory every Christmas, with the star attraction being her famous buckeye candies. These peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, resembling the nuts from Ohio’s state tree, weren’t just treats—they were edible state pride!
The tradition began in the 1960s when home cooks created this simple yet irresistible candy that perfectly balanced sweet and salty flavors. Unlike store-bought versions, homemade buckeyes had that telltale toothpick mark where loving hands had dipped them.
Every Ohio family seems to have their secret recipe—some add paraffin for shine, others swear by crunchy peanut butter for texture. Whatever the variation, these candies remain the unofficial sweet ambassador of the Buckeye State, appearing at everything from football tailgates to wedding dessert tables.
2. Clark Bars: Youngstown’s Crunchy Chocolate Icon
“Want a Clark Bar?” That question from my baseball coach meant you’d played a great game. These crunchy, peanut butter-filled chocolate bars weren’t just candy—they were edible trophies!
Though originally created in Pittsburgh, Clark Bars found their Ohio home when production moved to Youngstown in 1955. The distinctive red, blue and white wrapper became a fixture in steel town lunch pails and corner stores throughout the industrial Midwest.
The Youngstown factory prided itself on the perfect “snap” when breaking a Clark Bar—if it didn’t make the right sound during quality testing, the batch was rejected! Local steelworkers even referenced this quality standard, calling a well-made steel beam “Clark Bar straight.” When the factory closed in 1984, many Ohioans still traveled to Pennsylvania just to get their authentic Clark Bar fix.
3. Dairy Queen’s Dilly Bars: Findlay’s Frozen Innovation
My first job was at the Findlay Dairy Queen, home of the original Dilly Bar—that perfectly round chocolate-dipped ice cream on a stick with the signature curly-Q design on top. Few people realize this iconic treat was actually invented right here in Ohio!
Back in 1955, the Findlay DQ owners experimented with dipping ice cream pucks into chocolate that hardened instantly, creating portable frozen treats that revolutionized the industry. The name allegedly came from an excited customer who exclaimed “Now, isn’t that a dilly!” upon trying the prototype.
Our Findlay location maintained bragging rights with a faded photo showing the original creation team. We even had special local varieties not found elsewhere—the buckeye version featured peanut butter ice cream with chocolate dip, while the Ohio Orchard used local apple ice cream with caramel coating, both drawing customers from three counties away.
4. Marshmallow Peanuts: Columbus’s Soft Delight
Brightly colored and soft to the touch, Marshmallow Peanuts were a staple in Columbus’s candy scene. These sugary treats offered a unique texture that was both chewy and fluffy. Children and adults alike enjoyed the playful shapes and pastel colors that brought a spark of joy with every bite.
Columbus’s sweet shops thrived with these peanuts, creating a sense of community around sugary indulgence.
Did you know? These candies were often used in parades, tossed from floats to eager spectators, leaving a trail of sticky, sweet memories. Truly, Marshmallow Peanuts were Columbus’s soft delight.
5. Necco Wafers
Necco Wafers are iconic discs of nostalgia that have graced candy shelves since 1847. With their chalky texture and variety of colors, these candies are a delightful reminder of simpler times. Originally produced in New England, they became a staple sweet treat in Ohio candy shops.
Each wafer offers a mild flavor, ranging from clove to chocolate, and carries a unique charm that’s hard to resist. The wafers are perfect for those who enjoy a gentle taste adventure.
Did you know? Necco Wafers were carried by Union soldiers during the Civil War, providing them with a sweet taste of home.
6. Malley’s Chocolates
In the heart of Ohio, Malley’s Chocolates has been a family tradition since 1935. This beloved confectionery started with a small storefront and a dream to create the finest chocolates. Today, it remains a symbol of quality and nostalgia.
Their chocolates are crafted with love, using recipes passed down through generations. The rich aroma of cocoa fills the air, beckoning chocolate enthusiasts of all ages.
Each bite of a Malley’s chocolate is a journey back in time. The smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture and delightful flavors make it a timeless treat cherished by many. Did you know? Malley’s hosts annual chocolate festivals that draw crowds from all over the state.
7. Heggy’s Chocolates
Heggy’s Chocolates, founded in 1923 in Canton, Ohio, is a treasure trove of rich flavors and timeless traditions. The shop exudes an old-world charm with its vintage decor and aromatic allure. Specializing in chocolates and roasted nuts, Heggy’s carries the essence of traditional candy-making.
Each piece of chocolate from Heggy’s is a testament to craftsmanship, reflecting nearly a century of expertise. Favorites like their chocolate-covered nuts and creams are beloved by locals and visitors alike. The store’s enduring popularity lies in its commitment to quality and heritage, making it a must-visit for candy enthusiasts.
Did you know? Heggy’s has been family-owned and operated since its inception, maintaining its authentic approach to confectionery delights. Its lasting legacy is a testament to its dedication to preserving Ohio’s sweet traditions.
8. Chandler’s Cherry Mash
Chandler’s Cherry Mash is a delightful candy that encapsulates the essence of nostalgia. With its bright red cherry center, enveloped in a rich chocolate coating, it captures a blend of fruity sweetness and creamy chocolate.
This candy, a beloved classic from Ohio’s candy shops, was a favorite among children and adults alike. Each bite delivers a burst of cherry flavor, creating a unique taste experience that lingers.
Did you know? The Cherry Mash was often a centerpiece in candy jars, becoming a symbol of Ohio’s sweet offerings and a cherished memory for many.