13 Pennsylvania Pizza Buffets Serving Classic ’80s-Style Pizza
Pennsylvania has pizza buffets that take you straight back to the ’80s, with gooey slices, crispy crusts, and endless toppings that never go out of style.
These spots capture the magic of classic pizza nights, where everyone could grab a plate piled high with their favorites.
Locals keep coming back for the nostalgic flavors and lively buffet experience. Each visit is a delicious trip down memory lane, celebrating the timeless appeal of pizza.
1. Infinito’s Pizza Buffet
Walking into Infinito’s feels like stepping through a time portal to 1985. The neon signs and checkered floors set the stage for pizza perfection.
Kids still collect game tokens while parents load up on unlimited slices topped with mountains of pepperoni and bubbling cheese.
The pizza sauce has that signature sweetness old-school pizza lovers remember, and their garlic knots are legendary among locals.
2. Cicis Pizza (Lancaster)
Families flock to this Lancaster mainstay where the macaroni and cheese pizza remains the crown jewel of their expansive buffet. Retro video games line the walls, creating the perfect backdrop for pizza indulgence.
The dessert pizza, covered in cinnamon and icing, transports taste buds straight back to childhood birthday parties.
Their pizza crust achieves that perfect balance between crispy exterior and soft, doughy interior that defined ’80s pizza perfection.
3. Lelulo’s Pizzeria (Plum)
Neighborhood legends don’t come more authentic than Lelulo’s. Their pizza recipe hasn’t changed since 1981, and locals wouldn’t have it any other way.
The buffet setup encourages second and third trips with its variety of square-cut Sicilian slices and traditional rounds. Cheese pulls stretch dramatically from pan to plate, just like in those vintage pizza commercials. The wood-paneled walls and faded sports pennants complete the throwback experience.
4. Colarusso’s Café (Clarks Summit)
Tucked away in Clarks Summit, Colarusso’s weekend pizza buffet has attained near-mythical status. The owners still use the same dough mixer from 1983!
Patrons rave about their signature white pizza loaded with ricotta and mozzarella that tastes exactly like it did decades ago.
The jukebox in the corner still works, pumping out ’80s hits while families pile their plates high with slices that transport them back in time.
5. Burgh’s Pizza & Wing Pub (Bridgeville)
Pizza royalty exists in Bridgeville where Burgh’s lunchtime buffet draws crowds from across Pittsburgh suburbs. The owners proudly display their original pizza paddles from 1986.
Their signature thick crust somehow supports mountains of toppings without getting soggy – a lost art in modern pizzerias.
Sports memorabilia covers every inch of wall space, creating a time capsule of Pittsburgh sports history while you devour slice after delicious slice.
6. Monte Cello’s (Wexford)
Local families have celebrated birthdays at Monte Cello’s since Reagan was president. Their Tuesday night buffet remains a Pittsburgh tradition where the pizza tastes exactly like childhood memories.
The secret lies in their 80-year-old deck ovens that give each pie that distinctive charred bottom.
Kids still collect pizza tokens for the arcade games while parents reminisce over slices that taste remarkably unchanged by time or trends.
7. Alexander’s Pizza & Subs (Mount Pleasant)
Small-town charm meets pizza perfection at Alexander’s weekend buffet. The original pizza recipes came from the owner’s grandmother who opened shop in 1979.
Their pepperoni cups and curls exactly how fans of old-school pizza remember – slightly charred edges that crisp up and hold tiny pools of savory oil.
The wood-paneled dining room with its red vinyl booths hasn’t been updated in decades, and loyal customers wouldn’t change a thing.
8. Your Place Restaurant & Sports Pub (Lancaster/Harrisburg)
Sports fans gather at Your Place where the Wednesday pizza buffet has reached legendary status. The original location opened in 1981 and still uses the same recipes.
Locals know to arrive early for the stromboli – a buffet item that disappears faster than you can say “extra cheese.”
The pizza sauce has that distinctive sweetness that defined ’80s pizza, paired perfectly with their slightly thicker than average crust.
9. Berwick Original Italian Pizza (Berwick)
Pizza legends are born in small towns like Berwick, where this family-owned gem has served their lunchtime buffet since 1984.
The original pizza ovens still produce that distinctive crispy-yet-chewy crust. Old-timers swear the cheese blend hasn’t changed in nearly four decades.
The dining room features wood-grain Formica tables and vintage Coca-Cola memorabilia that creates an authentic time capsule experience to accompany your unlimited pizza adventure.
10. Roma Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria (Perry Hwy, Pittsburgh)
Sunday afternoons at Roma’s buffet feel like stepping into a family gathering from 1988. The owners still use the same dough recipe brought over from Italy in the early ’80s.
Their square-cut party style pizza defines Pittsburgh pizza traditions with its fluffy yet crisp base.
The dining room features red-checkered tablecloths and photos of Italian landscapes that haven’t been updated since the Reagan administration – creating the perfect nostalgic pizza experience.
11. Giannilli’s II Restaurant & Lounge (Greensburg)
Friday nights at Giannilli’s II bring pizza aficionados from across Westmoreland County. Their buffet features the famous thick-crust pizza that’s been a local favorite since 1983.
The secret weapon is their homemade Italian sausage that tops many buffet varieties.
The restaurant interior remains gloriously unchanged – brass railings, stained glass lamp shades, and wood paneling create that perfect ’80s pizza parlor atmosphere that modern chains try desperately to replicate.
12. Giannilli’s Homestyle Italian Restaurant (Greensburg)
The original Giannilli’s location keeps pizza traditions alive with their Thursday night buffet extravaganza. Three generations of family members still work the kitchen using recipes that haven’t changed since 1979.
Pizza lovers drive from Pittsburgh just for their signature Sicilian slices with the perfectly crispy cheese edges.
The restaurant’s vintage atmosphere includes the original booths and light fixtures from opening day, creating an authentic throwback dining experience.
13. Juliano’s Restaurant & Pizzeria (McKees Rocks/Robinson)
Pizza history lives on at Juliano’s where the lunch buffet has satisfied hungry Pittsburghers since 1978. The original pizza recipes came from the owner’s grandfather who immigrated from Naples.
Their crust achieves that perfect ’80s texture – not too thick or thin, with just the right amount of chew and crunch.
The paneled walls feature faded photos of local sports heroes and Italian landscapes, completing the authentic vintage pizza parlor experience that keeps loyal customers coming back decade after decade.