14 Pennsylvania Pizza Buffets Where Locals Keep Coming Back For More
Pennsylvania is a haven for pizza lovers who know that nothing beats a buffet loaded with cheesy, saucy goodness.
From crispy thin crusts to deep-dish delights, these pizza buffets serve up slices that have locals lining up again and again.
Each visit feels like a mini celebration, with endless options that satisfy every craving and mood.
Friends, families, and pizza enthusiasts swear by these spots, where generous portions and unbeatable flavor make every bite memorable.
If you think you’ve had great pizza, Pennsylvania’s buffets might just change your mind and keep you coming back for more.
1. Lelulo’s Pizzeria — Plum, PA
Stepping inside feels like entering your Italian grandmother’s dining room, complete with checkered tablecloths and the smell of fresh garlic bread wafting through the air.
Located at 2551 Golden Mile Highway in Plum, this family-run spot has been feeding hungry locals since the early 2000s.
The buffet spreads out across a long counter with at least a dozen pizza varieties at any given time, plus pasta dishes that rotate daily.
Their white pizza with ricotta and spinach disappears fastest, so regulars know to grab a slice early.
The building itself is a converted retail space with big windows facing the highway, giving diners a view of passing traffic while they feast.
Families pack the place on Friday nights when the buffet gets restocked every twenty minutes.
The owners often walk around chatting with customers, remembering names and favorite pizza toppings without needing to check notes.
2. Juliano’s Restaurant & Pizzeria — McKees Rocks, PA
Brick walls and vintage Italian posters create an old-school vibe that perfectly matches the traditional recipes served here.
Found at 5476 Steubenville Pike in McKees Rocks, Juliano’s has been a neighborhood staple for decades.
The lunch buffet runs weekdays and attracts construction workers, teachers, and anyone smart enough to know where the good pizza lives.
Sicilian-style square slices reign supreme here, with thick, fluffy crusts that soak up just enough sauce without getting soggy.
The building dates back to the 1950s and still has the original tin ceiling tiles that reflect light from hanging pendant lamps.
Pepperoni cups that curl up into little grease-filled bowls are a Pittsburgh tradition, and Juliano’s does them perfectly.
The salad bar sits next to the pizza buffet, offering fresh vegetables and homemade Italian dressing that customers swear is better than anything store-bought.
3. Pizza Roma (Roma Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria) — Pittsburgh, PA
Murals of the Roman Colosseum cover one entire wall, transporting diners straight to Italy without the jet lag or expensive plane ticket.
Situated at 5840 Forward Avenue in Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood, Pizza Roma combines upscale atmosphere with casual buffet dining.
The lunch crowd includes university professors, medical professionals from nearby hospitals, and students looking for affordable all-you-can-eat options.
Their margherita pizza uses fresh mozzarella that arrives daily, and the basil comes from herbs grown in pots right outside the kitchen door.
The dining room features dark wood booths and white tablecloths that somehow never show pizza sauce stains.
Garlic knots piled high in baskets disappear within minutes of hitting the buffet line.
The restaurant occupies a renovated storefront with tall ceilings and exposed ductwork painted black, giving it a modern industrial touch despite the classical Italian theme.
4. Monte Cello’s Pizza — Wexford, PA
Walking through the entrance, you’re greeted by a massive stone pizza oven that dominates the open kitchen like a delicious volcano.
Located at 10441 Perry Highway in Wexford, this location serves the northern suburbs with enthusiasm and endless cheese.
The buffet runs daily during lunch and dinner hours, featuring specialty pizzas that change based on whatever the chef feels inspired to create.
BBQ chicken pizza loaded with red onions and cilantro is the signature dish that keeps people driving from miles away.
The building has a rustic lodge feel with wooden beams across the ceiling and stone accents that make it feel cozy even when packed with hungry customers.
Dessert pizzas topped with Nutella, strawberries, and powdered sugar appear on the buffet around 7 PM, causing a small stampede.
The salad bar includes pasta salad, coleslaw, and fresh fruit alongside the usual lettuce and tomatoes.
5. Monte Cello’s Hampton — Allison Park, PA
Floor-to-ceiling windows flood the dining room with natural light, making this location feel more open and airy than its Wexford sibling.
You’ll find it at 4716 William Flynn Highway in Allison Park, serving the same great pizzas with a slightly different atmosphere.
The lunch buffet attracts business people on break and parents with young kids who appreciate the spacious layout.
Taco pizza piled high with lettuce, cheese, and crushed tortilla chips is a crowd favorite that sounds weird but tastes incredible.
The interior features contemporary design with sleek metal chairs and polished concrete floors that echo with conversation and laughter.
A separate kids’ buffet station sits lower to the ground, letting little ones serve themselves without needing help.
The dessert selection includes Italian cookies, tiramisu cups, and those addictive cinnamon sticks drizzled with icing that nobody can resist taking three or four of.
6. Alexander’s Pizza & Subs — Mount Pleasant, PA
Neon signs advertising daily specials glow in the windows of this small-town pizza joint that punches way above its weight class.
Located at 166 South Church Street in Mount Pleasant, Alexander’s has been feeding the community since 1990.
The buffet might be smaller than big-city operations, but what it lacks in size it makes up for in quality and heart.
Steak and cheese pizza loaded with shaved ribeye and sautéed peppers is the star of the show here.
The building is a classic Main Street storefront with pressed tin walls and vintage Coca-Cola memorabilia covering every available surface.
Local high school sports teams celebrate victories here, and the walls display decades of team photos and signed jerseys.
The buffet includes wings tossed in various sauces, from mild to nuclear hot, and the ranch dressing is made fresh every morning in five-gallon batches.
7. Burgh’s Pizza & Wing Pub — Bridgeville, PA
Sports memorabilia from every Pittsburgh team imaginable covers the walls, creating a shrine to black and gold that makes locals feel right at home.
Find it at 533 Washington Avenue in Bridgeville, where the lunch buffet draws a devoted following of regulars who have their favorite seats claimed.
The atmosphere leans more casual than family restaurant, with a full counter and multiple TVs always tuned to whatever game is on.
Buffalo chicken pizza topped with blue cheese crumbles and a drizzle of hot sauce is the most requested item on the buffet.
The building is a renovated roadhouse with exposed brick, dark wood paneling, and Edison bulb lighting that creates a warm ambiance.
Wednesday night buffets get extra lively when they add specialty pies like mac and cheese pizza or pierogi pizza that sound surprising but taste amazing.
The wing section of the buffet rivals the pizza selection, with at least eight different flavors available at any time.
8. Spirit — Pittsburgh, PA
Contemporary art pieces and modern sculptures give this place a gallery vibe that feels unexpected for a pizza buffet destination.
Located at 242 51st Street in Pittsburgh’s Lawrenceville neighborhood, Spirit brings an upscale twist to the all-you-can-eat concept.
The space features high ceilings with industrial ductwork, polished concrete floors, and Edison bulb chandeliers that look like art installations.
Fig and prosciutto pizza with arugula and balsamic glaze represents the more sophisticated options available here.
The buffet runs during weekend brunch and includes breakfast pizzas topped with scrambled eggs, bacon, and hollandaise sauce that shouldn’t work but absolutely do.
Local craft beers on tap pair perfectly with the pizza selection, and the bartenders know their stuff.
The building is a converted warehouse with massive windows overlooking the Allegheny River, giving diners a view that rivals anything in downtown Pittsburgh while they pile their plates high.
9. Sir Pizza (Ross Township) — Pittsburgh, PA
Retro 1970s décor remains mostly unchanged since the restaurant first opened, giving the place an authentic time capsule quality that customers love.
You’ll find it at 7604 McKnight Road in Pittsburgh’s Ross Township, still serving the same recipes that made it famous decades ago.
The lunch buffet attracts retirees, construction crews, and anyone seeking nostalgia along with their pepperoni.
Their signature Sir Pizza special combines five meats and three cheeses in a glorious pile of excess that tastes like childhood memories.
The building features wood-paneled walls, orange vinyl booths, and hanging Tiffany-style lamps that were peak design in 1975.
A salad bar with cottage cheese, pickled beets, and three-bean salad reminds you this place hasn’t changed much over the years.
The dessert pizza topped with cherry pie filling and streusel crumbles appears on Fridays and disappears within an hour of the buffet opening.
10. Bellisario Pizza Shop — West Mifflin, PA
Family photos covering one wall tell the story of three generations running this neighborhood gem with pride and plenty of mozzarella.
Located at 1842 Homeville Road in West Mifflin, Bellisario’s serves a community that treats the place like a second home.
The buffet runs during lunch hours on weekdays, drawing crowds from nearby businesses and schools.
Grandma-style pizza with a thick, rectangular crust and sweet tomato sauce is the dish that built this restaurant’s reputation.
The interior is simple and unpretentious, with laminate tables, metal folding chairs, and fluorescent lighting that somehow adds to the charm.
Homemade meatballs the size of tennis balls sit in marinara sauce on the buffet, and regulars pile them onto their plates alongside pizza slices.
The owners still use the same dough recipe from 1962, mixing it fresh every morning before sunrise in a basement kitchen you can see through a window.
11. Caliente Pizza & Drafthouse — Pittsburgh, PA
Colorful murals depicting Mexican and Italian cultural mashups create a visual feast before you even hit the buffet line.
Found at 5507 Walnut Street in Pittsburgh’s Shadyside neighborhood, Caliente brings fusion flavors to the traditional pizza buffet concept.
The space features vibrant colors, mismatched furniture, and an eclectic vibe that appeals to college students and adventurous eaters.
Jalapeño popper pizza loaded with cream cheese, bacon, and fresh jalapeños is the signature creation that keeps people coming back despite the inevitable heartburn.
The building is a narrow storefront with exposed brick walls covered in local artist paintings that rotate monthly.
The craft beer selection rivals any dedicated beer bar in the city, with over thirty taps featuring local and international brews.
Taco Tuesday buffets add Mexican-inspired pizzas topped with chorizo, cilantro, and queso fresco that blur the line between pizza and flatbread in the best possible way.
12. Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Catering — Scranton, PA
Copper pots and pans hanging from the ceiling give this place an Old World Italian kitchen feel that screams authenticity.
Located at 131 North Main Avenue in Scranton, Vincenzo’s has been a family operation since 1985.
The lunch buffet attracts courthouse workers, hospital staff, and locals who know where to find real Italian-American cooking done right.
Red pizza with a thin, crispy crust and minimal toppings lets the quality of the ingredients shine through without unnecessary complications.
The dining room features dark wood wainscoting, white plaster walls, and framed photos of Italian villages that transport diners straight to Tuscany.
Homemade Italian wedding soup sits in a crock pot on the buffet, and regulars always grab a bowl before loading up on pizza.
The building is a converted house with multiple small dining rooms that create intimate spaces even when the restaurant is packed to capacity.
13. Andy’s Pizza — Scranton, PA
Handwritten daily specials on a chalkboard greet customers at the door, changing based on whatever fresh ingredients arrived that morning.
You’ll find Andy’s at 1126 Moosic Street in Peckville, serving a working-class neighborhood with generous portions and fair prices.
The lunch buffet runs Monday through Friday, feeding factory workers, delivery drivers, and smart office employees who escape their cubicles for real food.
White pizza loaded with garlic, olive oil, and ricotta cheese is the number one seller, often requiring multiple batches during peak hours.
The interior is no-frills with linoleum floors, plastic chairs, and paper plates that keep costs down and prices affordable.
A small TV in the corner always plays classic movies or game shows, never sports, giving the place a unique atmosphere.
The owners are usually visible in the open kitchen, hand-tossing dough and shouting friendly jokes at regular customers who give it right back.
14. Joey’s Pizza — Dunmore, PA
Arcade games line one wall, making this place equally popular with kids begging for quarters and adults reliving their childhood memories.
Located at 1214 Oneill Highway in Dunmore, Joey’s combines pizza buffet with family entertainment center vibes.
The lunch and dinner buffets run seven days a week, drawing families, birthday parties, and anyone seeking affordable fun along with unlimited pizza.
Stuffed crust pizza oozing with cheese is the specialty here, requiring careful eating technique to avoid burning your mouth on molten mozzarella.
The building is a standalone structure with a pitched roof, large parking lot, and a neon sign visible from the highway that’s been a landmark for decades.
The game room generates constant beeping and music that somehow doesn’t overwhelm the dining area.
A soft-serve ice cream machine sits at the end of the buffet line, and kids pile their bowls high with chocolate and vanilla swirls topped with every available candy topping.