People Drive From Across Florida Just To Taste The Key Lime Pie At This Beloved Coastal Diner
Florida has no shortage of beautiful beaches and delicious food, but only one place makes people travel hundreds of miles just for a slice of pie.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop sits right in the heart of Key West, serving up the kind of dessert that turns first-time visitors into lifelong fans.
This little bakery at 200 Elizabeth Street has been perfecting the art of Key lime pie for years, and the result is nothing short of magical.
Whether you live in Miami, Tampa, or anywhere in between, once you taste what Kermit’s has to offer, you will understand why so many people make the drive down to the southernmost point of Florida.
A Recipe That Has Stood The Test Of Time
Walking into Kermit’s feels like stepping into a place where tradition meets perfection, and their Key lime pie recipe proves it.
This is not some experimental dessert with fancy twists or unusual ingredients.
Instead, the folks at Kermit’s stick to what works, using authentic Key lime juice, a buttery graham cracker crust, and a filling so smooth it practically melts on your tongue.
Every slice tastes exactly like Key lime pie should, which is why people keep coming back year after year.
The balance between tart and sweet hits just right, never too sugary or too sour.
Some bakeries try to reinvent the wheel, but Kermit’s knows that when you have something this good, you do not mess with it.
Consistency matters, and this shop delivers the same incredible flavor every single time.
Honestly, after tasting this pie, you will wonder why anyone would ever settle for store-bought versions again.
Frozen Key Lime Pie On A Stick
If regular Key lime pie feels too ordinary for you, Kermit’s has a treat that takes things to a whole new level.
Picture this: creamy Key lime pie filling dipped in rich chocolate, all frozen on a stick so you can enjoy it while strolling through Key West. It sounds almost too good to be true, but this invention has become one of the most popular items at the shop.
The combination of tangy lime and smooth chocolate creates a flavor explosion that works surprisingly well.
Plus, the frozen texture makes it the perfect snack for a hot Florida day.
You can grab one and walk around town without worrying about melting pie or messy plates.
Tourists love these because they are portable, delicious, and completely Instagram-worthy.
One bite and you will see why people line up just to get their hands on this frozen masterpiece.
More Than Just Pie
Sure, the pie steals the spotlight, but Kermit’s offers a whole lineup of Key lime goodies that deserve some serious attention.
From Key lime cookies to Key lime taffy, this place has turned one humble fruit into an entire empire of treats.
You can find Key lime fudge, Key lime salsa, Key lime hot sauce, and even Key lime body lotion if you want to smell as good as the pie tastes.
The variety means you can bring home a little piece of Key West no matter what your taste buds prefer.
My cousin once bought a jar of Key lime curd here, and she still talks about how she ate it straight from the jar with a spoon.
These products make fantastic gifts too, especially for friends who could not make the trip with you.
Everything captures that signature tangy-sweet flavor that makes Key lime so special.
Location In The Heart Of Key West
Finding Kermit’s is incredibly easy since it sits right on Elizabeth Street in one of the busiest parts of Key West.
The shop stands out with its bright, cheerful exterior that practically invites you inside.
You can park nearby and walk over, or if you are already exploring the historic district, you will probably stumble upon it by accident.
The location makes it convenient to stop by between other Key West attractions, whether you are heading to the beach or checking out local shops.
Being in the heart of town means you can grab a slice and then continue your adventure without going out of your way.
The neighborhood itself has that classic Key West charm, with colorful buildings and friendly locals everywhere you look.
Honestly, the walk to Kermit’s feels like part of the experience.
Once you arrive, the smell of fresh-baked pies will confirm you have reached the right place.
Open Seven Days A Week
One of the best things about Kermit’s is that you can visit any day of the week without worrying about finding it closed.
The shop opens at 10 in the morning and stays open until 9:30 at night, giving you plenty of time to stop by whenever it fits your schedule.
Whether you want pie for breakfast, an afternoon snack, or a late-night dessert, Kermit’s has you covered.
This flexibility makes planning your visit super easy, especially if you are on vacation and do not want to stick to a rigid itinerary.
No need to rush over first thing in the morning or worry about missing out because you arrived too late.
The extended hours also mean you can avoid the biggest crowds if you prefer a quieter experience.
Personally, I love stopping by in the late afternoon when the heat starts to fade and the shop feels a bit more relaxed.
Affordable Prices for Premium Quality
Great food does not always have to come with a hefty price tag, and Kermit’s proves that point beautifully.
Despite serving some of the best Key lime pie in all of Florida, the shop keeps prices reasonable so everyone can enjoy a slice.
You can grab a piece for just a few dollars, or take home a whole pie without breaking the bank.
This affordability makes it easy to try multiple items or bring treats back for friends and family.
Compared to fancy restaurants that charge double for dessert, Kermit’s offers incredible value without sacrificing quality.
The shop operates on a simple philosophy: make amazing pie and sell it at a fair price.
That approach has earned them a loyal following of locals and tourists alike.
When you get a taste of what they offer, you will realize that quality and affordability can absolutely go hand in hand.
Rave Reviews From Thousands Of Visitors
With nearly 3,000 reviews and a solid 4.6-star rating, Kermit’s has built a reputation that speaks for itself.
People from all over Florida and beyond have shared glowing stories about their experiences at this little bakery.
Many describe the pie as life-changing, while others say it ruined them for any other Key lime dessert.
The consistency of positive feedback shows that Kermit’s delivers the same high quality day after day.
Whether someone visits on a busy Saturday or a quiet Tuesday, they walk away happy.
Reading through the comments, you will notice how often people mention making special trips just to get their pie fix.
Some families even turn it into an annual tradition, stopping by every time they vacation in the Keys.
That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident; it comes from creating something truly special and treating every customer like they matter.
Perfect For Gifts And Souvenirs
Bringing home a souvenir from Key West becomes so much better when that souvenir happens to be delicious.
Kermit’s offers whole pies that travel well, along with a variety of packaged treats that make perfect gifts.
You can pick up a few jars of Key lime spread, some cookies, or even a bottle of Key lime hot sauce for the adventurous eaters in your life.
Everything comes nicely packaged, so you do not have to worry about presentation.
These gifts always go over well because they offer a taste of the Florida Keys that people can enjoy long after their vacation ends.
My neighbor once received a whole pie from a friend who visited Kermit’s, and she could not stop raving about it for weeks.
The shop even ships nationwide if you want to send treats to someone who could not make the trip.
Honestly, food gifts beat tacky keychains any day of the week.
A Family-Friendly Atmosphere
Kermit’s creates an environment where everyone feels welcome, from toddlers to grandparents and everyone in between.
The shop has a relaxed, cheerful vibe that makes it easy to bring the whole family along.
Kids love the frozen treats and colorful displays, while adults appreciate the quality and nostalgia of classic Key lime pie.
The staff treats every visitor with warmth and patience, even when the shop gets busy.
You never feel rushed or unwelcome, which makes the experience that much better.
Families often stop by after spending the day at the beach, turning it into a fun tradition that kids remember for years.
The casual atmosphere means you do not have to worry about fancy dress codes or formal dining etiquette.
Just show up, order what sounds good, and enjoy the moment.
That simplicity is part of what makes Kermit’s so special and keeps people coming back with their loved ones.
A Must-Visit Destination For Pie Lovers
Anyone who considers themselves a dessert enthusiast needs to add Kermit’s to their bucket list immediately.
This is not just another bakery; it has become a landmark that represents everything great about Key West food culture.
People plan entire trips around visiting this place, and for good reason.
The combination of quality, authenticity, and charm makes it impossible to resist.
You will see tourists snapping photos outside, locals picking up their regular orders, and first-timers looking amazed after their first bite.
Every element comes together to create an experience that goes beyond just eating pie.
The memories you make here stick with you long after the last crumb disappears.
Friends will ask about your Key West trip, and you will find yourself telling them all about this incredible little shop on Elizabeth Street.
Missing out on Kermit’s during a Florida Keys visit would be like skipping the beach entirely, just unthinkable.