14 Surprisingly Delicious Foods You've Probably Never Tried In North Carolina

Barbecue might be North Carolina’s claim to fame, but there’s so much more waiting to be discovered. Venture into mountain towns and coastal spots where locals savor unique dishes you won’t find in guidebooks.

These hidden treasures show off the real variety of Tar Heel flavors.

1. Livermush: The Breakfast of Mountain Champions

Country folks have been starting their day with this savory loaf for generations. Made from pig liver, head parts, cornmeal, and spices, it’s sliced and fried until crispy on the outside while staying tender inside.

I grew up watching my grandpa slather it with mustard between two pieces of white bread. Locals in western NC towns like Shelby consider it practically a food group, often serving it with eggs or grits for a hearty breakfast.

2. Moravian Sugar Cake: Pockets of Joy

This heavenly treat comes from Winston-Salem’s Moravian settlers who brought their baking traditions from Europe. The yeast-raised dough gets topped with brown sugar, butter, and cinnamon that melts into little pockets during baking.

What makes it special is the mashed potato in the dough, creating an incredibly tender texture. Best enjoyed warm from the oven, this sweet bread appears at every holiday gathering in Moravian communities but remains unknown to many visitors.

3. Moravian Chicken Pie: Not Your Average Pot Pie

Unlike regular chicken pot pie, this Moravian specialty contains only chicken and gravy – no vegetables whatsoever. The flaky, buttery crust encases tender chunks of chicken swimming in rich, peppery gravy.

My first taste came at a church fundraiser in Old Salem, and I was shocked by how something so simple could taste so complex.

These pies remain a cornerstone of community dinners and fundraisers throughout the Piedmont region, often made using recipes passed down through generations.

4. Surry County Sonker with “Dip”: The Mountain Cobbler’s Cooler Cousin

Sonker defies easy description – somewhere between a cobbler, pie, and deep-dish pancake. This rustic dessert features fruit (traditionally whatever was in season) baked in a sweet, milky batter.

The magic happens with the addition of “dip” – a sweet, vanilla-infused sauce poured over top. Each family in Surry County seems to have their own version, with fierce debates about proper thickness and fruit combinations.

The annual Sonker Festival in Mount Airy celebrates this humble dessert.

5. Cheerwine Float: The Cherry-Red Soda Sensation

Born in Salisbury in 1917, Cheerwine soda remains a Carolina treasure with its deep cherry flavor and slight bite. When topped with vanilla ice cream, this burgundy-colored beverage transforms into something magical.

I remember my first Cheerwine float at a roadside stand near Charlotte – the creamy ice cream slowly melting into the fizzy cherry depths. The combination creates a sweet-tart symphony that puts root beer floats to shame.

Many visitors leave the state never experiencing this simple but perfect dessert.

6. Muscadine Grape Hull Pie: Wild Grape Wonder

Native muscadine grapes grow wild across North Carolina, their thick skins and sweet-tart flesh unlike any grocery store variety. Resourceful cooks transform these humble fruits into an extraordinary pie filled with intense grape flavor.

The thick hulls cook down with sugar to create a jammy filling, while the pulp and juice form a separate layer. Together with a flaky crust, each bite delivers complex flavor that captures pure southern sunshine.

September brings muscadine season and these special pies to farm stands across the state.

7. Hatteras-Style Clam Chowder: The Clear Contender

Forget creamy New England or tomato-based Manhattan versions – Hatteras chowder keeps things simple with a clear broth that lets the seafood shine. Fresh clams, potatoes, onions, and a touch of bacon create a light yet deeply flavorful soup.

Outer Banks fishermen developed this style to highlight their daily catch without masking it under heavy cream.

I’ve sat at waterfront shacks watching boats return while savoring this brothy delight, the clean flavors perfectly capturing the essence of coastal Carolina.

8. Carolina-Style Burger: The All-In-One Flavor Bomb

Carolina burger artists pile their patties high with a specific combination: chili (no beans), tangy coleslaw, yellow mustard, and diced onions. The result is a messy masterpiece where each element plays a crucial role in the flavor symphony.

The chili provides savory depth, the slaw adds crunch and coolness, mustard brings tang, and onions contribute sharpness.

Small-town drive-ins across the state serve these beauties wrapped in paper that barely contains the delicious chaos. Napkins are non-negotiable when tackling this regional treasure.

9. Bright Leaf “Red” Hot Dogs: The Neon Wieners

These vibrant red hot dogs have been a staple at Carolina cookouts since 1941. Their distinctive color comes from food dye, while the flavor packs a uniquely tangy punch that regular hot dogs can’t match.

Growing up, summer meant Bright Leaf dogs topped with chili and slaw at my uncle’s backyard gatherings. The satisfying snap of the casing gives way to a juicy interior that generations of North Carolinians consider the only proper hot dog.

Visitors often do a double-take at their vivid appearance before becoming instant converts.

10. Chicken and Pastry: Comfort in a Bowl

Not quite chicken and dumplings, this eastern North Carolina specialty features flat, rectangular strips of pastry instead of fluffy dough balls. The pastry strips simmer slowly in rich chicken broth until they develop a unique texture – tender yet slightly chewy.

The simple combination of chicken, pastry, and broth creates a dish greater than the sum of its parts. Church suppers and family gatherings throughout the eastern part of the state always feature massive pots of this humble but deeply satisfying meal.

11. Eastern North Carolina Fish Stew: The Coastal Catch

This rustic one-pot meal combines rockfish or other white fish with potatoes, onions, and bacon in a tomato-tinged broth. What makes it truly unusual is the addition of whole eggs cracked into the simmering stew to poach during the final cooking stage.

Traditionally prepared in large outdoor pots for community gatherings, fish stew brings folks together around communal tables. I watched a master stew maker layer ingredients in a huge pot at a riverside gathering, insisting that stirring would ruin it.

The eggs absorb the broth’s flavor while adding rich texture to this remarkable coastal tradition.

12. Lumbee Collard Sandwich: Green Goodness Between Cornbread

The Lumbee Tribe of Robeson County created this ingenious sandwich that turns humble ingredients into something spectacular. Slow-cooked collard greens get nestled between two pieces of crispy fried cornbread rather than standard bread.

The cornbread provides a perfect crunch against the tender greens, while pot likker (the nutrient-rich cooking liquid) soaks in just enough to enhance flavor without soggy disaster.

Found primarily at community gatherings and small restaurants in Robeson County, this handheld meal demonstrates how truly creative southern cooking can be.

13. Crystal Coast Shrimp Burger: Seafood Patty Paradise

Along the Crystal Coast, particularly in Morehead City, seafood shacks serve an unusual creation: a soft bun piled with crispy fried shrimp. This generous pile gets served on a soft bun with tartar sauce, lettuce, and tomato.

Unlike a crab cake, the shrimp burger features distinct pieces of sweet shellfish that keep their texture.

My first bite at El’s Drive-In revealed why locals line up for this regional specialty – the fresh-caught flavor combined with that perfect crispy-tender contrast creates an unforgettable sandwich experience.

14. Lexington-Style Red Slaw: The Tangy BBQ Companion

Forget mayonnaise-based coleslaw – Lexington barbecue joints serve their cabbage with a vibrant red dressing made from ketchup, vinegar, and pepper. This zingy side dish perfectly complements the region’s famous pork shoulder barbecue.

The fine-chopped cabbage absorbs the tangy dressing, creating the perfect textural and flavor counterpoint to smoky meat.

While visitors flock to North Carolina for barbecue, many miss trying this essential accompaniment that locals consider mandatory.

The bright color and zippy flavor make ordinary coleslaw seem bland by comparison.

0 Shares