The Best Pizza Spots In Indian River County, Florida
Pizza lovers in Indian River County have plenty of choices when it comes to finding the perfect slice.
From authentic New York-style pies to Italian family recipes passed down through generations, this Florida county is home to some seriously good pizza joints.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting the area, these nine spots serve up the most mouthwatering pizzas around.
1. Vincent’s Ristorante e Pizzeria
Family-owned Vincent’s brings a true taste of Italy to Vero Beach with their brick oven masterpieces. Their dough is made fresh daily, creating that perfect chewy-yet-crispy crust that pizza aficionados crave.
The margherita pizza showcases simple ingredients at their finest – San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
Their friendly staff makes you feel like part of the famiglia the moment you walk through the door.
2. Giorgio’s New York Pizzeria
Craving an authentic New York slice? Giorgio’s has you covered with their oversized, foldable pizza that transports you straight to the Big Apple.
The thin crust achieves that magical balance – sturdy enough to hold generous toppings yet pliable enough to fold in half.
Their sauce has just the right tangy sweetness, complementing the gooey, stretchy mozzarella. The pepperoni cups into perfect little flavor pools when baked, creating a slice worth traveling for.
3. Nino’s Cafe
Nino’s Cafe serves up slices of heaven with their hand-tossed pizzas that have locals coming back weekly. The first time I visited, I ordered their specialty pie with spinach, feta, and sun-dried tomatoes – it was so good I dreamed about it that night!
Their secret weapon is the garlic-infused olive oil brushed on the crust before baking. The dining room’s cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for family dinners or casual date nights when you want quality pizza without any fuss.
4. Cap’s Pizza
Hidden gem alert! Cap’s Pizza might not look fancy from the outside, but their pizza game is seriously strong. The slightly sweet sauce and generous cheese-to-crust ratio make for a perfectly balanced bite every time.
Locals rave about their Supreme pizza loaded with fresh veggies and quality meats. Cap’s also offers a unique honey-drizzled crust option that adds an unexpected but delightful sweet finish to their savory pies.
5. Pizzoodles
The clever name hints at what makes this place special – fantastic pizza AND homemade noodles under one roof.
Their signature white pizza with ricotta, mozzarella, and roasted garlic will change how you think about tomato-less pies forever.
I still remember my first visit three years ago when the owner personally recommended their thin-crust pizza.
The crisp bottom and tender chew created a textural masterpiece that’s hard to find outside of Italy.
6. Massimo’s Pizza Beachside
Location, location, location! Massimo’s combines great pizza with a beachside setting that makes the experience unforgettable.
Their thin-crust pizzas emerge perfectly cooked from the oven with bubbling cheese and a well-charred crust.
The seafood pizza topped with fresh local catches is a must-try specialty that perfectly captures Florida’s coastal vibe.
After surfing nearby, nothing beats grabbing a slice and relaxing on their outdoor patio.
7. Pizza Mia
Small in size but mighty in flavor, Pizza Mia serves up some of the most creative topping combinations in the county. Their Buffalo chicken pizza with homemade ranch drizzle has developed something of a cult following among locals.
The crust strikes that perfect balance between crispy and chewy. What makes Pizza Mia special is their willingness to experiment – their monthly special always features unexpected ingredient pairings that somehow work beautifully together.
8. Big Apple Pizza & Pasta
True to its name, Big Apple serves enormous 18-inch pies that could feed a small army. The giant slices require the classic New York fold technique to eat without wearing more sauce than you consume.
Their pizza sauce has a secret blend of herbs that gives it a distinctive flavor you won’t find elsewhere in town.
The walls decorated with NYC memorabilia and the sounds of Sinatra playing softly create an authentic Big Apple atmosphere right in the heart of Florida.
9. Giuseppe’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Family recipes passed down through four generations make Giuseppe’s a standout in Sebastian. Their old-world Italian pizza features a slightly thicker crust that still maintains a satisfying crunch when you bite into it.
The homemade sausage topping comes from a secret family recipe that Giuseppe’s grandfather brought from Sicily.
My grandmother, who rarely compliments restaurants, declared their margherita pizza “almost as good as mine” – which is the highest praise possible from an Italian nonna!