These Illinois Pie Shops Are So Good, They Put Family Recipes To Shame
Nothing quite compares to the comfort of a warm slice of pie, especially when it comes from a shop that has perfected the art of flaky crusts and luscious fillings.
Illinois is home to some of the most incredible pie destinations in the Midwest, where bakers craft their creations with passion, precision, and a whole lot of butter.
These establishments don’t just serve dessert—they serve up memories, tradition, and flavors so divine they might just eclipse even your grandmother’s secret recipe. Get ready to discover twelve pie shops across the Prairie State that are absolutely worth the trip.
1. Hoosier Mama Pie Company – Chicago
Stepping into Hoosier Mama Pie Company feels like visiting a friend’s kitchen where the oven never stops working and the smell of butter pastry fills every corner. Located at 1618 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, this beloved bakery has been serving up handmade pies since 2009, and locals can’t seem to get enough.
Owner Paula Haney brings her Indiana roots to every creation, using seasonal ingredients and traditional techniques that make each bite taste like a hug from your favorite aunt.
The menu rotates with the seasons, offering everything from classic apple crumb to inventive flavors like salted maple. Each pie is made from scratch daily, with crusts so buttery and flaky they practically melt on your tongue.
Whether you grab a whole pie for Sunday dinner or just a single slice with a cup of coffee, you’re in for a treat that’s both nostalgic and utterly unforgettable.
Hoosier Mama has earned its reputation as one of Chicago’s top pie destinations, and once you taste their work, you’ll understand why people line up out the door.
2. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits – Chicago
Over at 2051 N California Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits has turned the humble pie into an art form that’s equal parts whimsical and downright delicious. This Logan Square gem opened its doors in 2012 and quickly became a neighborhood favorite thanks to its playful approach to classic comfort food.
The bright, cheerful space invites you to linger over a slice of their famous chess pie or a towering biscuit sandwich that could feed a small army.
What sets Bang Bang apart is their commitment to bold, creative flavors that still honor traditional baking methods. Think salted caramel apple pie with a hint of bourbon or a tangy lemon chess that makes your taste buds do a happy dance.
Their biscuits, fluffy as clouds and golden brown, are the perfect companion to any pie, especially when slathered with house-made jam.
The friendly staff and cozy vibe make every visit feel like a celebration, whether you’re stopping by for breakfast or grabbing dessert to go.
3. Justice of the Pies – Chicago
Currently operating out of its South Side storefront at 8655 S Blackstone Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, Justice of the Pies serves up more than just dessert—it serves up hope, community, and second chances. Founded by Maya-Camille Broussard, this bakery has become a beacon of empowerment, offering job training and opportunities to individuals re-entering the workforce.
But don’t let the mission overshadow the main event: these pies are phenomenal, with flavors that honor both Southern tradition and creative innovation.
Maya-Camille’s recipes are inspired by her father’s love of baking, and each pie tells a story of family, resilience, and deliciousness. From the rich, velvety sweet potato pie to the show-stopping peach cobbler pie, every creation is made with care and premium ingredients.
The crust alone is worth the visit—buttery, tender, and perfectly golden.
Justice of the Pies has been featured on national television and in major publications, but the real reward is tasting the passion baked into every slice. The bakery operates limited retail days, so checking hours before visiting is recommended.
4. The Happy Apple Pie Shop – Oak Park
Tucked away at 226 Harrison St, Oak Park, IL 60304, The Happy Apple Pie Shop lives up to its cheerful name with every slice it serves. This charming little bakery specializes in handcrafted pies that taste like they came straight from a farmhouse kitchen, complete with love, attention, and a generous sprinkle of cinnamon.
The moment you walk through the door, the aroma of baked apples and buttery crust wraps around you like a warm blanket.
Owner and baker extraordinaire creates each pie using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, ensuring freshness and flavor in every bite. The classic apple pie is a standout, with perfectly spiced filling and a lattice crust that’s almost too pretty to eat—almost.
Seasonal offerings like pumpkin, cherry, and mixed berry keep the menu exciting year-round.
The cozy, welcoming atmosphere makes The Happy Apple a favorite spot for families, couples, and anyone with a serious sweet tooth. Grab a slice to enjoy on the spot or take a whole pie home to share.
5. The Treehouse Pie Company – Sycamore
Way out in Sycamore at 265 W Peace Rd, Unit 102, Sycamore, IL 60178, The Treehouse Pie Company has carved out a reputation for pies so good, they’re worth the drive from anywhere in the state. This family-owned bakery prides itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients and time-honored recipes that have been passed down through generations.
Every pie is handmade with precision and care, resulting in desserts that taste like pure nostalgia.
The Treehouse offers an impressive variety, from fruit pies bursting with juicy berries to decadent cream pies topped with fluffy meringue. Their pecan pie is legendary, with a filling that’s sweet but not cloying and a crust that shatters perfectly with each forkful.
Seasonal specials keep regulars coming back to see what’s new, and the friendly staff always make you feel like part of the family.
Whether you’re a Sycamore local or just passing through, stopping at The Treehouse Pie Company is an absolute must for any pie lover.
6. Banana Cherry Bakery – Rockford
At 1310 S Alpine Rd, Rockford, IL 61108, Banana Cherry Bakery has been delighting customers with a wide assortment of baked goods, including pies that add a playful twist to traditional desserts. While the bakery is known more broadly for its variety of sweets, its pies remain a popular part of the rotating selection.
The name itself hints at the creativity inside, where bananas and cherries are just the beginning of a wild and wonderful pie adventure.
Banana Cherry’s menu features everything from classic fruit pies to inventive custard creations that push the boundaries of what pie can be. Their banana cream pie is a customer favorite, with layers of fresh banana, silky custard, and a cloud of whipped cream that practically floats off the plate.
The cherry pie, made with tart Montmorency cherries, strikes the perfect balance between sweet and tangy.
The bakery’s vibrant, welcoming atmosphere makes it a popular spot for birthday celebrations, family gatherings, and anyone looking to add a little sweetness to their day.
7. Busy Corner – Goodfield
Head to 302 S Eureka St, Goodfield, IL 61742, and you’ll find Busy Corner, a beloved local institution that’s been serving up homestyle comfort food and desserts for decades. While not a dedicated pie shop, Busy Corner is especially well known for its freshly made pies, which have earned a loyal following.
The down-home atmosphere and friendly service make every visit feel like coming home, even if it’s your first time walking through the door.
Busy Corner specializes in traditional pies made the old-fashioned way, with real ingredients and no shortcuts. Their fruit pies are packed with filling and topped with a crust that’s golden, flaky, and utterly irresistible.
The cream pies are equally impressive, with smooth, rich fillings and meringue piled high enough to make you smile before you even take a bite.
Locals have been making the pilgrimage to Busy Corner for years, and once you taste their pies, you’ll understand why this little spot has such a devoted following.
8. Trefzger’s Bakery – Peoria Heights
Since 1861, Trefzger’s Bakery at 4416 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616 has been a pillar of the community, baking pies that have stood the test of time—and taste. This historic bakery has been family-owned for generations, and their commitment to quality and tradition shines through in every dessert they create.
Walking into Trefzger’s is like stepping back in time, with glass cases filled with gorgeous pies, pastries, and cakes that look almost too beautiful to eat.
Trefzger’s pies are legendary in central Illinois, known for their perfectly balanced flavors and picture-perfect presentation. The fruit pies are bursting with fresh, seasonal produce, while the cream pies are velvety smooth and topped with delicate swirls of whipped cream.
Their coconut cream pie is a particular standout, with toasted coconut adding a subtle crunch to every heavenly bite.
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just treating yourself to something sweet, Trefzger’s delivers excellence every single time.
9. Hopscotch Bakery + Market – Champaign
At 802 W John St, Champaign, IL 61820, Hopscotch Bakery + Market has quickly become a favorite among University of Illinois students, locals, and pie enthusiasts from across the region. While known primarily for its artisan breads, pastries, and café offerings, Hopscotch also features seasonal pies that showcase its farm-forward approach.
This modern bakery combines artisanal techniques with a farm-to-table philosophy, sourcing ingredients from local farms whenever possible. The result is a lineup of pies that taste fresh, vibrant, and utterly delicious, with flavors that change with the seasons.
Hopscotch’s pies are works of art, both visually and gastronomically. Their fruit pies feature perfectly caramelized crusts and fillings that highlight the natural sweetness of the produce.
The chocolate chess pie is a decadent dream, rich and fudgy with a hint of espresso that takes it to the next level. Each pie is made in small batches to ensure quality and attention to detail.
The bright, airy space is perfect for grabbing a slice and a cup of coffee, and the friendly staff are always happy to help you choose the perfect pie to take home.
10. Pies by Inge – Monticello
Over at 212 S Independence St, Monticello, IL 61856, Pies by Inge has been quietly perfecting the art of pie-making for years, and those in the know consider it one of Illinois’ best-kept secrets. The business operates on a smaller, more limited basis, with availability and hours that may vary, making advance ordering or checking ahead advisable.
Inge herself brings European baking traditions to the heart of the Midwest, creating pies that are elegant, flavorful, and made with meticulous attention to detail. Every pie that leaves her kitchen is a testament to her passion for quality and craftsmanship.
Pies by Inge offers a rotating selection of classic and seasonal flavors, all made from scratch using the finest ingredients. The apple pie is a masterpiece, with tender chunks of fruit and a hint of cinnamon nestled in a buttery, golden crust.
Her berry pies are equally impressive, bursting with juicy fruit and just the right amount of sweetness.
The small-town charm of Monticello adds to the experience, making a trip to Pies by Inge feel like a special occasion every time you visit.
11. Incredibly Delicious – Springfield
True to its name, Incredibly Delicious at 925 S 7th St, Springfield, IL 62703 serves up pies that live up to the hype and then some. This Springfield staple has built a loyal following thanks to its commitment to homemade goodness and flavors that remind you why pie is America’s favorite dessert.
The cozy bakery feels like a slice of home, where the staff greet you with a smile and the pie cases are always stocked with tempting options.
Incredibly Delicious offers a wide variety of pies, from fruit-filled classics to rich, creamy custards that melt in your mouth. Their pumpkin pie is a fall favorite, spiced to perfection and topped with a dollop of fresh whipped cream.
The strawberry-rhubarb pie is another standout, with a tangy-sweet filling that perfectly balances the buttery crust.
Whether you’re a Springfield local or just passing through the state capital, a stop at Incredibly Delicious is non-negotiable for anyone who appreciates a truly exceptional pie.